‘My Capitalism Is Bigger than Yours!’

Against Combining ‘How the West Came to Rule’ with ‘The Origins of Capitalism’

in Historical Materialism
No Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



This article reviews Alex Anievas and Kerem Nişancıoğlu’s How the West Came to Rule: The Geopolitical Origins of Capitalism (2015). It argues that the book offers a stimulating and ambitious approach to solving the problems of Eurocentrism and the origins of capitalism in growing critical scholarship in historical sociology and International Relations. However, by focusing on the ‘problem of the international’ and proposing a ‘single unified theory’ based on uneven and combined development, the authors present a history of international relations that trades off methodological openness and legal complexity for a structural and exclusive consequentialism driven by anti-Eurocentrism. By misrepresenting the concept of social-property relations in terms of the internal/external fallacy, and by confusing different types of ‘internalism’ required by early-modern jurisdictional struggles, the book problematically conflates histories of international law and capitalism. These methodological problems are contextualised by examples from the Spanish, French and British empires’ conceptions of sovereignty and jurisdiction and their significant legal actors and processes.

‘My Capitalism Is Bigger than Yours!’

Against Combining ‘How the West Came to Rule’ with ‘The Origins of Capitalism’

in Historical Materialism



AndersonPerry 1974Lineages of the Absolutist StateLondon: NLB.

AnghieAntony 2005Imperialism Sovereignty and the Making of International LawCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

AnievasAlexander and Kerem Nişancıoğlu 2015How the West Came to Rule: The Geopolitical Origins of CapitalismLondon: Pluto Press.

BeikWilliam 1985Absolutism and Society in Seventeenth-Century France: State Power and Provincial Aristocracy in LanguedocCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

BeikWilliam 2005‘Review Article: The Absolutism of Louis XIV as Social Collaboration’Past and Present1881: 195224.

BentonLauren 2008‘From International Law to Imperial Constitutions: The Problem of Quasi-Sovereignty, 1870–1900’Law and History Review263: 595619.

BentonLauren 2010A Search for Sovereignty: Law and Geography in European Empires 1400–1900Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

BentonLauren 2012‘Possessing Empire: Iberian Claims and Interpolity Law’ in Native Claims: Indigenous Law against Empire 1500–1920 edited by Saliha BelmessousOxford: Oxford University Press.

BentonLauren and Richard J. Ross (eds.) 2013Legal Pluralism and Empires 1500–1850New York: New York University Press.

BessonSamantha 2012‘The Extraterritoriality of the European Convention on Human Rights: Why Human Rights Depend on Jurisdiction and What Jurisdiction Amounts to’Leiden Journal of International Law254: 857884.

BhambraGurminder 2011‘Historical Sociology, Modernity, and Postcolonial Critique’American Historical Review1163: 653662.

BowringBill 2008The Degradation of the International Legal Order? The Rehabilitation of Law and the Possibility of PoliticsLondon:Routledge.

BrophySusan Dianne 2017‘An Uneven and Combined Theory of Law: Initiation’Law and Critique282: 167191.

BurrageMichael 1988‘Revolution and the Collective Action of the French, American, and English Legal Professions’Law & Social Inquiry132: 225277.

ÇalıBaşak (ed.) 2010International Law for International RelationsOxford: Oxford University Press.

CallinicosAlex and Camilla Royle 2014‘This Quarter’s Selection’International Socialism142available at: <http://isj.org.uk/this-quarters-selection-spring-2014/>.

Chimni B.S. 1993International Law and World Order: A Critique of Contemporary ApproachesFirst EditionLondon: SAGE Publications.

ChimniB.S. 2007‘The Past, Present and Future of International Law: A Critical Third World Approach’Melbourne Journal of International Law82: 499515.

CutlerA. Claire 2003Private Power and Global Authority: Transnational Merchant Law in the Global Political EconomyCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

CutlerA. Claire and Stephen Gill (eds.) 2014New Constitutionalism and World OrderCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

DewarHelen 2013‘Litigating Empire: The Role of French Courts in Establishing Colonial Sovereignties’ in Benton and Ross (eds.) 2013.

DickasonOlive Patricia 1989‘Concepts of Sovereignty at the Time of the First Contacts’ in Green and Dickason 1989.

DimmockSpencer 2014The Origin of Capitalism in England 1400–1600Historical Materialism Book SeriesLeiden: Brill.

DimmockSpencer 2017‘The Eastern Origins of Capitalism?’Historical Materialismavailable at: <http://www.historicalmaterialism.org/book-review/eastern-origins-capitalism>accessed 1 May 2017.

DorsettShaunnagh and Shaun McVeigh 2012JurisdictionNew York: Routledge.

GadamerHans-Georg 2004Truth and MethodSecond Revised Edition translation revised by Joel Weinsheimer and Donald G. MarshallLondon: Continuum.

GerstenbergerHeide 2007Impersonal Power: History and Theory of the Bourgeois State translated by David FernbachHistorical Materialism Book SeriesLeiden: Brill.

GreenL.C. and Olive Patricia Dickason 1989The Law of Nations and the New WorldEdmonton, AB: The University of Alberta Press.

HallidayFred and Justin Rosenberg 1998‘Interview with Ken Waltz’Review of International Studies243: 371386.

HamiltonBernice 1963Political Thought in Sixteenth-Century Spain: A Study of the Political Ideas of Vitoria De Soto Suárez and MolinaOxford: Clarendon Press.

HankeLewis 1974All Mankind Is One: A Study of the Disputation between Bartolomé de Las Casas and Juan Ginès de Sepúlveda on the Religious and Intellectual Capacity of the American IndiansDeKalb, IL: Northern Illinois University Press.

HerzogTamar 2015Frontiers of Possession: Spain and Portugal in Europe and the AmericasCambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

JahnBeate 2000The Cultural Construction of International Relations: The Invention of the State of NatureBasingstoke: Palgrave.

JahnBeate (ed.) 2006Classical Theory in International RelationsCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

JohnstonW. Ross 1973Sovereignty and Protection: A Study of British Jurisdictional Imperialism in the Late Nineteenth CenturyDurham, NC: Duke University Press.

KayaoğluTuran 2010Legal Imperialism: Sovereignty and Extraterritoriality in Japan the Ottoman Empire and ChinaCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

KeeneEdward 2002Beyond the Anarchical Society: Grotius Colonialism and Order in World PoliticsCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

KnafoSamuel 2010‘Critical Approaches and the Legacy of the Agent/Structure Debate in International Relations’Cambridge Review of International Affairs233: 493516.

KnafoSamuel and Benno Teschke 2017‘The Rules of Reproduction of Capitalism: A Historicist Critique’Working Paper Nº 12 January CGPEThe University of Sussex.

KnoxRobert 2009‘Marxism, International Law, and Political Strategy’Leiden Journal of International Law223: 413436.

KoskenniemiMartti 2001The Gentle Civilizer of Nations: The Rise and Fall of International Law 1870–1960Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

KoskenniemiMartti 2008‘What Should International Lawyers Learn from Karl Marx?’ in Marks (ed.) 2008.

KoskenniemiMartti 2011‘Empire and International Law: The Real Spanish Contribution’University of Toronto Law Journal611: 136.

KoskenniemiMartti 2013‘Histories of International Law: Significance and Problems for a Critical View’Temple International and Comparative Law Journal272: 215240.

LacherHannes 2006Beyond Globalization: Capitalism Territoriality and the International Relations of ModernityLondon: Routledge.

LaFranceXavier 2013Citizens and Wage-Labourers: Capitalism and the Making of a Working-Class in FranceDoctoral thesisYork University.

MarksSusan (ed.) 2008International Law on the Left: Re-examining Marxist LegaciesCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

MartineauAnne-Charlotte 2014‘Overcoming Eurocentrism? Global History and the Oxford Handbook of the History of International Law’European Journal of International Law251: 329336.

MatinKamran 2013‘Redeeming the Universal: Postcolonialism and the Inner Life of Eurocentrism’European Journal of International Relations192: 353377.

MiévilleChina 2005Between Equal Rights: A Marxist Theory of International LawHistorical Materialism Book SeriesLeiden: Brill.

MilanovicMarko 2011Extraterritorial Application of Human Rights Treaties: Law Principles and PolicyOxford: Oxford University Press.

MillerStephen 2008State and Society in Eighteenth-Century France: A Study of Political Power and Social Revolution in LanguedocWashington, DC: The Catholic University of America Press.

MorinMichel 2010‘Des nations libres sans territoire? Les Autochtones et la colonisation de l’Amérique française du XVIe au XVIIIe siècle’Journal of the History of International Law12: 170.

NeocleousMark 2012‘International Law as Primitive Accumulation; or, the Secret of Systematic Colonization’European Journal of International Law234: 941962.

OwensJ.B. 2005‘By My Absolute Royal Authority’: Justice and the Castilian Commonwealth at the Beginning of the First Global AgeRochester, NY/Martlesham: University of Rochester Press/Boydell & Brewer Ltd.

OwensbyBrian P. 2011Empire of Law and Indian Justice in Colonial MexicoStanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

ÖzsuUmut 2012‘Ottoman Empire’ in The Oxford Handbook of the History of International Law edited by Bardo Fassbender and Anne PetersOxford: Oxford University Press.

PagdenAnthony 1990Spanish Imperialism and the Political Imagination: Studies in European and Spanish-American Social and Political Theory 1513–1830New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

PagdenAnthony 1995Lords of all the World: Ideologies of Empire in Spain Britain and France c.1500–c.1800New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

PagdenAnthony 2003‘Human Rights, Natural Rights, and Europe’s Imperial Legacy’Political Theory312: 171199.

PahujaSundya 2011Decolonising International Law: Development Economic Growth and the Politics of UniversalityCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

PalMaïa 2013The Politics of Extraterritoriality: A Historical Sociology of Public International LawDoctoral thesis (PhD)The University of Sussexavailable at: <http://ethos.bl.uk/OrderDetails.do?uin=uk.bl.ethos.574962>.

PalMaïa 2016‘Introduction to “Britain versus France: How Many Sonderwegs?”’Historical Materialism241: 310.

PalMaïa (forthcoming) Jurisdictional Accumulation: An Early Modern History of Law Empires and CapitalCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

ParkerDavid 1989‘Sovereignty, Absolutism, and the Function of the Law in Seventeenth Century France’Past and Present1221: 3674.

ParkerDavid 2003‘Absolutism, Feudalism and Property Rights in the France of Louis XIV’Past and Present1791: 6096.

RajagopalBalakrishnan 2003International Law from Below: Development Social Movements and Third World ResistanceCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

RiouxSébastien 2015‘Mind the (Theoretical) Gap: On the Poverty of International Relations Theorising of Uneven and Combined Development’Global Society294: 481509.

RosenbergJustin 1994The Empire of Civil Society: A Critique of the Realist Theory of International RelationsLondon: Verso.

RosenbergJustin 2013‘Kenneth Waltz and Leon Trotsky: Anarchy in the Mirror of Uneven and Combined Development’International Politics502: 183230.

Studnicki-GizbertDaviken 2007A Nation upon the Ocean Sea: Portugal’s Atlantic Diaspora and the Crisis of the Spanish Empire 1492–1640Oxford: Oxford University Press.

TeschkeBenno 1998‘Geopolitical Relations in the European Middle Ages: History and Theory’International Organization522: 325358.

TeschkeBenno 2003The Myth of 1648: Class Geopolitics and the Making of Modern International RelationsLondon: Verso.

TeschkeBenno 2005‘Bourgeois Revolution, State Formation and the Absence of the International’Historical Materialism132: 326.

TeschkeBenno 2014‘IR Theory, Historical Materialism, and the False Promise of International Historical Sociology’Spectrum: Journal of Global Studies61: 166.

TuckRichard 1999The Rights of War and Peace: Political Thought and the International Legal Order from Grotius to KantOxford: Oxford University Press.

WoodEllen Meiksins 1981‘The Separation of the Economic and the Political in Capitalism’New Left ReviewI127: 6695.

WoodEllen Meiksins 1991The Pristine Culture of Capitalism: A Historical Essay on Old Regimes and Modern StatesLondon: Verso.

WoodEllen Meiksins 1995Democracy against Capitalism: Renewing Historical MaterialismCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

WoodEllen Meiksins 2008Citizens to Lords: A Social History of Western Political Thought from Antiquity to the Middle AgesLondon: Verso.

WoodEllen Meiksins 2012Liberty and Property: A Social History of Western Political Thought from Renaissance to EnlightenmentLondon: Verso.

WoodEllen Meiksins 2014‘Capitalism’s Gravediggers’Jacobin12 Mayavailable at: <https://www.jacobinmag.com/2014/12/capitalisms-gravediggers/>.

WoodEllen Meiksins 2016‘Britain versus France: How Many Sonderwegs?’Historical Materialism241: 1129.


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 172 172 74
Full Text Views 100 100 40
PDF Downloads 34 34 8
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0