Cages and Crises: A Marxist Analysis of Mass Incarceration

in Historical Materialism
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Since the mid-1960s, the carceral population in the US has increased around 900%. This article analyses that increase from a Marxist framework. After interrogating the theories of Michelle Alexander and Loïc Wacquant, I lay out a theoretical framework for a Marxist theory of mass incarceration. I then offer a historical analysis of mass incarceration in keeping with this theoretical framework, emphasising the carceral system’s relationship to the class struggle and the large-scale economic dislocations of post-Fordism. Finally, I emphasise how private prison companies, increasingly central to the story of mass incarceration, are influencing current efforts to reform the prison system and shift to ‘alternatives to incarceration’.

Cages and Crises: A Marxist Analysis of Mass Incarceration

in Historical Materialism



  • ACLU 2011Banking on Bondage: Private Prisons and Mass IncarcerationNovember available at: <>.

  • ACLU 2014War Comes Home: The Excessive Militarization of American PoliceNew York: ACLU.

  • ACLU 2018Private Prisons’ available at: <>.

  • AlexanderMichelle 2010The Struggle for Racial Justice Has a Long Way to GoInternational Socialist Review84 available at: <>.

  • AlexanderMichelle 2012The New Jim CrowNew York: The New Press.

  • AminSamir 1976Unequal Development: An Essay on the Social Formations of Peripheral Capitalism translated by Brian PierceNew York: Monthly Review Press.

  • BalbusIsaac D. 1973The Dialectics of Legal Repression: Black Rebels before the American Criminal CourtsNew York: Russell Sage Foundation.

  • BaranPaul A. and Paul Sweezy 1966Monopoly Capital: An Essay on the American Economic and Social OrderNew York: Monthly Review Press.

  • BeckettKatherine and Steve Herbert 2010Banished: The New Social Control in Urban AmericaOxford: Oxford University Press.

  • BergerDan 2013Social Movements and Mass Incarceration: What Is to Be Done?Souls151–2: 318.

  • BergerDan 2016Captive Nation: Black Prison Organizing in the Civil Rights EraChapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.

  • BerndCandice 2018First Step Act Has Sinister Implications for the Poor and MarginalizedTruthout19 December available at: <>.

  • BloomJoshua and Waldo E. MartinJr. 2013Black Against Empire: The History and Politics of the Black Panther PartyBerkeley, CA: University of California Press.

  • BoggsJames 1963The American Revolution: Pages from a Negro Worker’s NotebookNew York: Monthly Review Press.

  • BoydHerb 2017Black Detroit: A People’s History of Self-DeterminationNew York: HarperCollins.

  • BravermanHarry 1974Labor and Monopoly Capital: The Degradation of Work in the Twentieth CenturyNew York: Monthly Review Press.

  • BrecherJeremy 2009The World War II and Post-war Strike WaveLibcom.org17 December available at: <>.

  • CampJordan T. 2016Incarcerating the Crisis: Freedom Struggles and the Rise of the Neoliberal StateBerkeley, CA: University of California Press.

  • CarsonE.A. 2018Prisoners in 2016Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics.

  • CIVIC 2016Private Prison Company CCA Has Stolen the Name of a Nonprofit that Advocates against the Use of Private PrisonsCIVIC: Blog13 December available at: <>.

  • CleggJohn 2016Black Representation after FergusonBrooklyn Rail3 May available at: <>.

  • CleggJohn and Adaner Usmani 2017The Racial Politics of Mass IncarcerationSSRN15 February available at: <>.

  • CohenCathy 1999Boundaries of Blackness: AIDS and the Breakdown of Black PoliticsChicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

  • CohenMichael 2015How For-profit Prisons Have Become the Biggest Lobby No-one Is Talking AboutThe Washington Post available at: <>.

  • CowieJefferson and Nick Salvatore 2008The Long Exception: Rethinking the Place of the New Deal in American HistoryInternational Labor and Working-class History74: 332.

  • DaganDavid and Steven M. Teles 2013Locked In? Conservative Reform and the Future of Mass IncarcerationThe Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science6511: 266276.

  • DauenbaughRachel S. 2014Coleman Young’s Detroit11 April available at: <>.

  • DayEli 2018The Prison Strike Is the Modern-day American Slave RebellionIn These Times11 September available at: <>.

  • DeleuzeGilles 1992Postscript on the Societies of ControlOctober59: 37.

  • Detroit Free Press 1932 ‘Murder Charges Asked after Red Mob Fights Police’ 8 December.

  • Detroit Free Press 1967a ‘LBJ Approves all-out Drive to End Strife’ 25 July.

  • Detroit Free Press 1967b ‘AP Newsman Probe Cause of Race Riots’ 31 July.

  • Detroit Free Press 1971 ‘Militant Loses Runoff in Disputed UAW Vote’ 29 May.

  • Detroit Free Press 1973 ‘A Ruling against Reason’ 13 March.

  • DilulioJohn 1995The Coming of the Super-predatorsThe Weekly Standard27 November available at: <>.

  • DuboisWilliam Edward Burghardt 1998 [1935]Black Reconstruction in AmericaNew York: The Free Press.

  • DunnTimothy J. 1996The Militarization of the US–Mexico Border 1978–1992: Low-intensity Conflict Doctrine Comes HomeAustin, TX: CMAS Books.

  • ElkinsAlex 2015The Origins of Stop-and-FriskJacobinMay available at: <>.

  • EscobarMartha 2009–2010The Roots of Latina Migrants’ CaptivitySocial Justice362: 720.

  • FanonFrantz 1976Black Skin White Masks translated by Charles Lam MarkmannNew York: Grove Press.

  • FedericiSilvia 2014Caliban and the Witch: Women the Body and Primitive AccumulationNew York: Autonomedia.

  • FeldmanDavid B. 2018“Pro-Immigrant” Liberalism and Capitalist Exploitation: Why Corporate Democrats Do Not Support Immigrant JusticeTruthout18 February available at: <>.

  • FelsenthalJulia 2016Ava DuVernay’s 13th Is a Shocking, Necessary Look at the Link Between Slavery and Mass IncarcerationVogue6 October available at: <>.

  • Finally Got the News 1970 directed by Stewart BirdRene Lichtman and Peter Gessner produced in association with the League of Revolutionary Black Workers Detroit, MI: Black Star Productions.

  • FiskeWarren 2016Trump Misleadingly Puts Black Youth Unemployment Rate at 59 PercentPolitiFact Virginia20 June available at: <>.

  • FolsomFranklin 1991Impatient Armies of the Poor: The Story of Collective Action of the Unemployed 1808–1942Niwot, CO: University Press of Colorado.

  • FoucaultMichel 1977Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison translated by A.M. SheridanNew York: Vintage Books.

  • FormanJames 2012Racial Critiques of Mass Incarceration: Beyond the New Jim CrowNew York University Law Review87: 101146.

  • FormanJames 2017Locking Up Our Own: Crime and Punishment in Black AmericaNew York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

  • FosterJonathan Bellamy and Robert McChesney 2012The Endless Crisis: How Monopoly-finance Capital Produces Stagnation and Upheaval from the USA to ChinaNew York: Monthly Review Press.

  • FosterJonathan Bellamy and Robert McChesney 2014Surveillance CapitalismMonthly Review1 July available at: <>.

  • FraserSteve 2009The Good War and the WorkersThe American Prospect20 September available at: <>.

  • GeorgakasDan and Marvin Surkin 1998Detroit: I Do Mind DyingCambridge, MA: South End Press.

  • GilmoreRuth Wilson 2007Golden Gulag: Prisons Surplus Crisis and Opposition in Globalizing CaliforniaBerkeley, CA: University of California Press.

  • GilmoreRuth Wilson 2018Prisons and Class Warfare: Interview with Ruth Wilson GilmoreHistorical Materialism available at: <>.

  • GlabermanMartin 1980Wartime Strikes: The Struggle against the No-strike Pledge in the UAW during World War IIDetroit, MI: Bewick Editions.

  • GoldMatea 2015Charles Koch Compares Work of his Political Network to Civil Rights MovementThe Washington Post available at: <>.

  • Gomez del PradoJose 2010The Privatization of War: Mercenaries, Private Military and Security CompaniesGlobal Research8 November available at: <>.

  • GottschalkMarie 2014Caught: The Prison State and the Lockdown of American PoliticsPrinceton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

  • GottschalkMarie 2016Conservatives against Incarceration?JacobinDecember available at: <>.

  • GrahamStephen 2010Cities Under Siege: The New Military UrbanismLondon: Verso.

  • GreenbergDavid F. (ed.) 1993Crime and Capitalism: Readings in Marxist CriminologyPhiladelphia, PA: Temple University Press.

  • HallStuartChas CritcherTony JeffersonJohn Clarke and Brian Roberts 1978Policing the Crisis: Mugging the State and Law and OrderBasingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

  • HalpernMartin 1997“I’m Fighting for Freedom”: Coleman Young, HUAC, and the Detroit African American CommunityJournal of American Ethnic History171: 1938.

  • HarcourtBernard 2011Reducing Mass IncarcerationOhio State Journal of Criminal Law91: 5188.

  • HarringSidney L. and Gerda W. Ray 1999Policing a Class Society: New York City in the 1990sSocial Justice262: 6381.

  • HarveyDavid 2005A Brief History of NeoliberalismOxford: Oxford University Press.

  • HarveyDavid 2013Rebel Cities: From the Right to the City to the Urban RevolutionLondon: Verso.

  • HendersonMary Anne and Brian Platt 2015Counter-Insurgency in the ClassroomJacobin5 November available at: <>.

  • HenricksonWilma Wood (ed.) 1991Detroit Perspectives: Crossroads and Turning PointsDetroit, MI: Wayne State University Press.

  • HochschildJennifer L. 1995Facing Up to the American Dream: Race Class and the Soul of the NationPrinceton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

  • HollemanHannahRobert W. McChesneyJohn Bellamy Foster and R. Jamil Jonna 2009The Penal State in an Age of CrisisMonthly Review available at: <>.

  • HulingTracy 2002Building a Prison Economy In Rural America’ in Invisible Punishment: The Collateral Consequences of Mass ImprisonmentNew York: The New Press.

  • HumphriesDrew and David Greenberg 1993The Dialectics of Crime Control’ in Greenberg (ed.) 1993.

  • In the Public Interest [IPI] 2016The Banks that Finance Private Prison CompaniesNovember available at: <>.

  • IsaacsCaroline 2016Community Cages: Profitizing Community Corrections and Alternatives to IncarcerationAmerican Friends Service CommitteeAugust available at: <>.

  • JacksonGeorge 1994Soledad Brother: The Letters of George JacksonNew York: Lawrence Hill.

  • JacobsonLouis 2017Donald Trump Is Wrong that “Inner-city Crime Is Reaching Record Levels”PolitiFact8 February available at: <>.

  • JayMark 2017Policing the Poor in DetroitMonthly Review1 January available at: <>.

  • JayMark and Philip Conklin 2017Detroit and the Political Origins of “Broken Windows” PolicingRace and Class592: 2648.

  • JayMark and Virginia Leavell 2017Material Conditions of Detroit’s Great RebellionSocial Justice forthcoming.

  • JeffreyTerrence 20157,231,000 Lost JobsCNS News12 May available at: <>.

  • JohnsonCedric 2017The Panthers Can’t Save Us NowCatalyst11 available at: <>.

  • Justice Center 2017NRRC Facts & Trends’ available at: <>.

  • Justice Policy Institute [JPI] 2012Rethinking the Blues: How We Police in the U.S. and at What CostWashington, DC: Justice Policy Institute.

  • KelleyRobin D.G. 2002Freedom Dreams: The Black Radical ImaginationBoston, MA: Beacon Press.

  • KingMartin Luther 1967Beyond Vietnam4 April available at: <>.

  • KleffnerHeike 1993The Black Panthers: Interviews with Geronimo ji-jagaPratt and Mumia Abu JamalRace and Class351: 926 available at: <>.

  • LevittSteven D. and Kevin M. Murphy 2006How Bad Was Crack Cocaine? The Economics of an Illicit Drug MarketCapital IdeasApril available at: <>.

  • LewisNathaniel 2018a ‘Mass IncarcerationPeople’s Policy ProjectJanuary available at: <>.

  • LewisNathaniel 2018b ‘Locking Up the Lower ClassJacobinJanuary available at: <>.

  • LinebaughPeter 2003The London Hanged: Crime and Civil Society in the Eighteenth CenturyLondon: Verso.

  • LopezGerman 2015Private Prison Companies Are Investing in Alternatives to PrisonVox14 May available at: <>.

  • LuanLivia 2018Profiting from EnforcementMigration Policy Institute2 May available at: <>.

  • LuciaDanny 2010The Unemployed Movements of the 1930sInternational Socialist Review71 available at: <>.

  • MagdoffHarry and Paul M. Sweezy 1981The Deepening Crisis of U.S. CapitalismNew York: Monthly Review Press.

  • MahaffeyMaryann 1991Hunger in Michigan’ in Henrickson (ed.) 1991.

  • MarableManning 1983How Capitalism Underdeveloped Black AmericaBoston, MA: South End Press.

  • MarableManning 2007Race Reform and RebellionJackson, MS: University Press of Mississippi.

  • MarceticBranko 2016The FBI’s Secret WarJacobinAugust available at: <>.

  • MarksCarole 1989Farewell – We’re Good and GoneBloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.

  • MartelleScott 2012Detroit (A Biography)Chicago, IL: Chicago Review Press.

  • MarxKarl 1967 [1894]Capital: A Critique of Political Economy. Volume ThreeNew York: International Publishers.

  • MarxKarl 1992Capital: A Critique of Political Economy. Volume One translated by Ben FowkesHarmondsworth: Penguin.

  • Maryland State Archives 2004Streets of Fire: Governor Spiro Agnew and the Baltimore City Riots, April 1968’ available at: <>.

  • McNallyDavid 2011Global Slump: The Economics and Politics of Crisis and ResistanceOakland, CA: PM Press.

  • MurakawaNaomi 2014The First Civil Right: How Liberals Built Prison AmericaOxford: Oxford University Press.

  • MurrayJoshua and Michael Schwartz 2017Collateral Damage: How Capital’s War on Labor Killed DetroitCatalyst11 available at: <>.

  • NAACP 2018Criminal Justice Fact SheetNAACP available at: <>.

  • NarayanJohn 2017The Wages of Whiteness in the Absence of Wages: Racial Capitalism, Reactionary Intercommunalism and the Rise of TrumpismThird World Quarterly3811: 24822500.

  • NeocleousMark 2000The Fabrication of Social Order: A Critical Theory of Police PowerLondon: Pluto Press.

  • NewtonHuey P. 2002The Huey P. Newton Reader edited by David Hillard and Donald WeiseNew York: Seven Stories Press.

  • PBS 2007Bill Moyers talks with Grace Lee BoggsBill Moyers Journal15 June available at: <>.

  • PetitjeanClément 2014True Communism Is the Foreignness of Tomorrow: Alain Badiou talks in AthensVerso Blog26 March available at: <>.

  • PivenFrancis Fox and Richard Cloward 1979Poor People’s Movements: Why They Succeed How They FailNew York: Vintage Books.

  • PizarroJesenia and Vanja M. K. Stenius 2004Supermax Prisons: Their Rise, Current Practices, and Effect on InmatesThe Prison Journal842: 248264.

  • PlattTony and Paul Takagi 1977Intellectuals for Law and Order: A Critique of the New RealistsSocial Justice8: 116.

  • Prison Policy Initiatives 2013The Prison Index: Taking the Pulse of the Crime Control IndustryApril available at: <>.

  • PRWatch 2016Koch Criminal Justice Reform Trojan Horse: Special Report on Reentry and Following the MoneyPRWatch16 June available at: <>.

  • RahmanAhmad 2009Marching Blind: The Rise and Fall of the Black Panther Party in Detroit’ in Liberated Territory: Untold Local Perspectives on the Black Panther Party edited by Yohuru Williams and Jama LazerowDurham, NC: Duke University Press.

  • Reagan Ronald 1984 ‘Remarks at the Annual Conference of the National Sheriff’s Association in Hartford Connecticut’ available at: <>.

  • ReedAdolph 1999Stirrings in the Jug: Black Politics in the Post-segregation EraMinneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.

  • Reed Adolph 2017 ‘The Kerner Commission and the Irony of Antiracist Politics’ unpublished manuscript.

  • Renshaw III Benjamin H. 1982Prisoners 1925–1981Bureau of Justice Statistics available at: <>.

  • Report of the National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders 1968New York: Bantam Books.

  • Revolutionary Worker 1997The 1967 Detroit Rebellion’ 13 July available at: <>.

  • RobinsonCyril D. 1993The Production of Black Violence in Chicago’ in Greenberg (ed.) 1993.

  • RobinsonWilliam I. 2004A Theory of Global Capitalism: Production Class and State in a Transnational WorldBaltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press.

  • RobinsonWilliam I. 2014Global Capitalism and the Crisis of HumanityNew York: Cambridge University Press.

  • RobinsonWilliam I. 2018Accumulation Crisis and the Global Police StateCritical Sociology <>.

  • RoederOliver 2015Releasing Drug Offenders Won’t End Mass IncarcerationFiveThirtyEight17 July available at: <>.

  • RuscheGeorg 1930Prison Revolts or Social Legislation: On the Events in AmericaFrankfurter Zeitung1 June translated by Heinz D. Osterle and Kevin Anderson.

  • RuscheGeorg and Otto Kirchheimer 2003 [1939]Punishment and Social StructureNew Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.

  • RustinBayard 1965From Protest to Politics: The Future of the Civil Rights MovementFebruary available at: <>.

  • SealeBobby 1968Seize the TimeBaltimore, MD: Black Classic Press.

  • StarkRodney 1972Police Riots: Collective Violence and Law EnforcementBelmont, CA: Focus Books.

  • Stauch Jr. Michael 2015 ‘Wildcat of the Streets: Race Class and the Punitive Turn in 1970s Detroit’ unpublished PhD dissertation available at: <>.

  • SugrueThomas J. 1996The Origins of the Urban Crisis: Race and Inequality in Postwar DetroitPrinceton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

  • SullivanAndrew 2018The Poison We PickNew York Magazine19 February available at: <>.

  • SurowieckiJames 2016Trump Sets Private Prisons FreeThe New Yorker5 December available at: <>.

  • TaylorKeeanga-Yamahtta 2016From #BlackLivesMatter to Black LiberationChicago, IL: Haymarket Books.

  • The Economist 2015How America’s Police Became So Heavily Armed18 May available at: <>.

  • ThompsonHeather Ann 2004Whose Detroit? Politics Labor and Race in a Modern American CityIthaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

  • ThompsonHeather Ann 2013Unmaking the Motor City in the Age of Mass IncarcerationLaw and Society151: 4161.

  • ToscanoAlberto 2008The Open Secret of Real AbstractionRethinking Marxism202: 273287.

  • TrumanHarry 1955MemoirsVolume IGarden City, NY: Doubleday.

  • UsmaniAdaner2017Did Liberals Give Us Mass Incarceration?Catalyst13 available at: <>.

  • VogelRichard 2003Capitalism and Incarceration RevisitedMonthly Review1 September available at: <>.

  • WacquantLoïc 2002From Slavery to Mass IncarcerationNew Left ReviewII13: 4160.

  • WacquantLoïc 2009Punishing the Poor: The Neoliberal Government of Social InsecurityDurham, NC: Duke University Press.

  • WallaceDon and Drew Humphries 1993Urban Crime and Capitalist Accumulation’ in Greenberg (ed.) 1993.

  • WalmsleyRoy 2016World Prison Population List’ available at: <>.

  • WengerMorton G. and Thomas A. Bonomo 1993Crime, the Crisis of Capitalism, and Social Revolution’ in Greenberg (ed.) 1993.

  • WhiteWalter and Thurgood Marshall 1991June, 1943: A City Split in Two’ in Henrickson (ed.) 1991.

  • WilkinsonMike 2015Tracking Progress in Detroit Police Response Times a Fool’s ErrandMichigan Radio10 November available at: <>.

  • WilliamsKristian 2015Our Enemies in Blue: Police and Power in AmericaOakland, CA: AK Press.

  • WilliamsRobert F. 1998Negroes With GunsDetroit, MI: Wayne State University Press.

  • WolfSherry 2006Spies, Lies and War: The Lessons of COINTELPROInternational Socialist Review49 available at: <>.

  • WorknehLilly and Taryn Finley 201627 Important Facts Everyone Should Know about the Black PanthersHuffington Post19 February available at: <>.

  • ŽižekSlavoj 1994Did Marx Invent the Symptom?’ in Mapping Ideology edited by Slavoj ŽižekLondon: Verso.

  • ZumoffJacob 2015The Party and Black Liberation: An Interview with Jacob ZumoffJacobinAugust available at: <>.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 157 157 156
Full Text Views 15 15 15
PDF Downloads 17 17 17
EPUB Downloads 1 1 1