Young Marx’s Treatise on Christian Art and the Bonn Notebooks
In: Historical MaterialismSearch for other papers by Kaan Kangal in
Current site
Google Scholar
Abstract
There are episodes in Marx’s life that go unnoticed or that are considered insignificant in Marxian scholarship. A case in point is that Marx wrote a treatise on Christian art between 1841 and 1842 and a group of excerpts (the Bonn Notebooks) on the history of religious art that resulted from it. The treatise and the accompanying notebooks are either completely absent from Marx biographies and studies on young Marx or they are mentioned only in passing; if the notebooks are considered at all, one portion is usually singled out while the rest is effectively ignored. The present piece traces Marx’s motives for occupying himself with religious art as well as his interests, shifting from Christian, Greek and Egyptian arts to fetishism and idolatry. This study intends to highlight that young Marx was more involved in questions concerning the political culture of aesthetics than we usually think. The Bonn Notebooks provide access to a more vivid image of Marx in this regard than previous scholarship has suggested.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Arndt, Andreas 2012, Karl Marx. Versuch über den Zusammenhang seiner Theorie, Berlin: Akademie Verlag.
-
Assmann, Jan 1998, Moses the Egyptian: The Memory of Egypt in Western Monotheism, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
-
Barck, Karlheinz 1993, Poesie und Imagination. Studien zu ihrer Reflexionsgeschichte zwischen Aufklärung und Moderne, Stuttgart: Metzler.
-
Bauer, Bruno 1841, Posaune des jüngsten Gerichts über Hegel den Atheisten und Antichristen. Ein Ultimatum, Leipzig: Otto Wigand.
-
Bauer, Bruno 1842, Hegel’s Lehre von der Religion und Kunst von dem Standpuncte des Glaubens aus beurtheilt, Leipzig: Otto Wigand.
-
Bauer, Bruno 1975a, ‘Bruno Bauer an Karl Marx. 26. Januar 1842’, in Marx – Engels – Gesamtausgabe (MEGA2), Section 3, Volume 1, Berlin: Dietz.
-
Bauer, Bruno 1975b, ‘Bruno Bauer an Karl Marx. 11. Dezember 1839’, in Marx – Engels – Gesamtausgabe (MEGA2), Section 3, Volume 1, Berlin: Dietz.
-
Bauer, Bruno 1975c, ‘Bruno Bauer an Karl Marx. 28. März 1841’, in Marx – Engels – Gesamtausgabe (MEGA2), Section 3, Volume 1, Berlin: Dietz.
-
Bauer, Bruno 2010a, ‘Bruno Bauer an Arnold Ruge. 6. Dezember 1841’, in Hundt (ed.) 2010.
-
Bauer, Bruno 2010b, ‘Bruno Bauer an Arnold Ruge. 24. Dezember 1841’, in Hundt (ed.) 2010.
-
Bauer, Bruno 2010c, ‘Bruno Bauer an Arnold Ruge. 9. Januar 1842’, in Hundt (ed.) 2010.
-
Bersier, Gabrielle 1999, ‘Goethe’s Parody of “Nazarene” Iconography: The Joseph Story in Wilhelm Meisters Wanderjahre’, Goethe Yearbook, 9: 264–277.
-
Boer, Roland 2012, Criticism of Earth: On Marx, Engels and Theology, Historical Materialism Book Series, Leiden: Brill.
-
Boer, Roland 2018, ‘The Fetish’, in The Edinburgh Critical History of Nineteenth-Century Christian Theology, edited by Daniel Whistler, Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
-
Böhme, Hartmut 2014, Fetishism and Culture: A Different Theory of Modernity, Berlin: de Gruyter.
-
Bunn, Matthew 2014, ‘“Censorship is Official Critique”: Contesting the Limits of Scholarship in the Censorship of the Hallische Jahrbücher’, Central European History, 47: 375–401.
-
Chytry, Josef 1989, The Aesthetic State: A Quest in Modern German Thought, Berkeley: University of California Press.
-
Comay, Rebecca 2014, ‘Defaced Statues: Idealism and Iconoclasm in Hegel’s Aesthetics’, October, 149: 123–142.
-
Cornu, Auguste 1954, Karl Marx und Friedrich Engels. Leben und Werk. Erster Band 1818–1844, Berlin: Aufbau-Verlag.
-
Crimp, Douglas 1987, ‘The End of Art and the Origin of the Museum’, Art Journal, 46, 4: 261–266.
-
Demetz, Peter 1967, Marx, Engels, and the Poets: Origins of Marxist Literary Criticism, Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
-
Dessaux, Nicholas 2016, De Marx Comme Trompettiste, Montreuil: L’échappée.
-
Dieckmann, Liselotte 1955, ‘The Metaphor of Hieroglyphics in German Romanticism’, Comparative Literature, 7, 4: 306–312.
-
[Editorial] 1976, ‘[Comments on Bonn Notebooks]’, in Marx – Engels – Gesamtausgabe (MEGA2), Section 4, Volume 1, Berlin: Dietz.
-
Eßbach, Wolfgang 2019, Religionssoziologie 2. Entfesselter Markt und artifizielle Lebenswelt als Wiege neuer Religionen. Teilband 2, Paderborn: Fink.
-
Gemkow, Heinrich 1967, Karl Marx. Eine Biographie, Berlin: Dietz.
-
Gombrich, Ernst Hans 1951, The Story of Art, New York: Phaidon.
-
Gombrich, Ernst Hans 1984, The Sense of Order: A Study in the Psychology of Decorative Art, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
-
Gossman, Lionel 2003, ‘Unwilling Moderns: The Nazarene Painters of the Nineteenth Century’, Nineteenth-Century Art Worldwide, 2, 3: 16–92.
-
Grewe, Cordula 2004, ‘Beyond Hegel’s End of Art: Schadow’s Mignon and the Religious Project of Late Romanticism’, Modern Intellectual History, 1, 2: 185–217.
-
Hatt, Michael and Charlotte Klonk 2006, Art History: A Critical Introduction to its Methods, Manchester: Manchester University Press.
-
Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich 1975, Aesthetics: Lectures on Fine Art, Volume 2, translated by Thomas Malcolm Knox, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
-
Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich 1986a, ‘Vorlesungen über die Philosophie der Religion II. Vorlesungen über die Beweise vom Dasein Gottes’, in Werke, Volume 17, Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp.
-
Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich 1986b, ‘Vorlesungen über die Philosophie der Geschichte’, in Werke, Volume 12, Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp.
-
Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich 1986c, ‘Vorlesungen über die Ästhetik III’, in Werke, Volume 15, Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp.
-
Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich 2004, Philosophie der Kunst oder Ästhetik nach Hegel. Im Sommer 1826. Mitschrift Friedrich Carl Hermann, Victor von Kehler, Munich: Wilhelm Fink.
-
Heinrich, Michael 2019, Karl Marx and the Birth of Modern Society: The Life of Marx and the Development of His Work, Volume I: 1818–1841, New York: Monthly Review Press.
-
Hinnant, Charles H. 2002, ‘Schiller and the Political Sublime: Two Perspectives’, Criticism, 44, 2: 121–138.
-
Hundt, Martin (ed.) 2010, Der Redaktionsbriefwechsel der Hallischen, Deutschen und Deutsch-Französischen Jahrbücher (1837–1844). Band 1. Der Briefwechsel um die Hallischen Jahrbücher, Berlin: de Gruyter.
-
Iacono, Alfonso Maurizio 2016, The History and Theory of Fetishism, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
-
Kangal, Kaan 2020, ‘Marx’s “Bonn Notebooks” in Context: Reconsidering the Relationship between Bruno Bauer and Karl Marx between 1839 and 1842’, Historical Materialism, 28, 4: 102–138.
-
Kroupa, Jiří 2011, ‘Three Returns to Rumohr’, Art in Translation, 3, 3: 281–324.
-
Lapin, Nikolai I. 1974, Der junge Marx, Berlin: Dietz.
-
Liedman, Sven-Eric 2018, A World to Win: The Life and Works of Karl Marx, London: Verso.
-
Lifshitz, Mikhail 1933, K Voprosu o Vzgliadakh Marksa na Iskusstvo, Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe Izdatel’stvo Khudozhestvennoi Literatury.
-
Lifshitz, Mikhail 1976, The Philosophy of Art of Karl Marx, London: Pluto Press.
-
Lifshitz, Mikhail 2021, The Philosophy of Art of Karl Marx (manuscript), translated by David Riff (forthcoming).
-
Lukács, Georg 2002, ‘Hegel’s Aesthetics’, Graduate Faculty Philosophy Journal, 23, 2: 87–124.
-
Marx, Karl 1975a, ‘To Arnold Ruge. March 5, 1842’, in Marx/Engels Collected Works, Volume 1, Moscow: Progress Publishers.
-
Marx, Karl 1975b, ‘To Arnold Ruge. July 9, 1842’, in Marx/Engels Collected Works, Volume 1, Moscow: Progress Publishers.
-
Marx, Karl 1975c, ‘To Arnold Ruge. March 20, 1842’, in Marx/Engels Collected Works, Volume 1, Moscow: Progress Publishers.
-
Marx, Karl 1975d, ‘To Arnold Ruge. April 27, 1842’, in Marx/Engels Collected Works, Volume 1, Moscow: Progress Publishers.
-
Marx, Karl 1975e, ‘To Arnold Ruge. February 10, 1842’, in Marx/Engels Collected Works, Volume 1, Moscow: Progress Publishers.
-
Marx, Karl 1975f, ‘Contribution to the Critique of Hegel’s Philosophy of Law: Introduction’, in Marx/Engels Collected Works, Volume 3, Moscow: Progress Publishers.
-
Marx, Karl 1975g, ‘Proceedings of the Sixth Rhine Province Assembly. First Article: Debates on Freedom of the Press and Publication of the Proceedings of the Assembly of the Estates’, in Marx/Engels Collected Works, Volume 1, Moscow: Progress Publishers.
-
Marx, Karl 1975h, ‘Letter from Marx to His Father’, in Marx/Engels Collected Works, Volume 1, Moscow: Progress Publishers.
-
Marx, Karl 1975i, ‘Proceedings of the Sixth Rhine Province Assembly. Third Article: Debates on the Law on Thefts of Wood’, in Marx/Engels Collected Works, Volume 1, Moscow: Progress Publishers.
-
Marx, Karl 1975j, ‘The Leading Article in No. 179 of the Kölnische Zeitung’, in Marx/ Engels Collected Works, Volume 1, Moscow: Progress Publishers.
-
Marx, Karl 1975k, ‘Philosophical Manifesto of Historical School of Law’, in Marx/Engels Collected Works, Volume 1, Moscow: Progress Publishers.
-
Marx, Karl 1975l, ‘Difference between the Democritean and Epicurean Philosophy of Nature’, in Marx/Engels Collected Works, Volume 1, Moscow: Progress Publishers.
-
Marx, Karl 1976a, ‘Exzerpte aus Karl Friedrich von Rumohr: Italienische Forschungen’, in Marx – Engels – Gesamtausgabe (MEGA2), Section 4, Volume 1, Berlin: Dietz.
-
Marx, Karl 1976b, ‘Exzerpte aus Johann Jakob Grund: Die Malerey der Griechen’, in Marx – Engels – Gesamtausgabe (MEGA2), Section 4, Volume 1, Berlin: Dietz.
-
Marx, Karl 1976c, ‘Exzerpte aus Charles de Brosses: Ueber den Dienst der Fetischengötter’, in Marx – Engels – Gesamtausgabe (MEGA2), Section 4, Volume 1, Berlin: Dietz.
-
Marx, Karl 1976d, ‘Exzerpte aus Karl August Böttiger: Ideen zur Kunst-Mythologie’, in Marx – Engels – Gesamtausgabe (MEGA2), Section 4, Volume 1, Berlin: Dietz.
-
Marx, Karl 1976e, ‘Exzerpte aus Christoph Meiners: Allgemeine kritische Geschichte der Religionen’, in Marx – Engels – Gesamtausgabe (MEGA2), Section 4, Volume 1, Berlin: Dietz.
-
Marx, Karl 1976f, ‘Exzerpte aus Benjamin Constant: De la religion’, in Marx – Engels – Gesamtausgabe (MEGA2), Section 4, Volume 1, Berlin: Dietz.
-
Marx, Karl 1976g, ‘Exzerpte aus Jean Barbeyrac: Traité de la morale des péres de l’eglise’, in Marx – Engels – Gesamtausgabe (MEGA2), Section 4, Volume 1, Berlin: Dietz.
-
McLellan, David 1970, Marx Before Marxism, London: Macmillan.
-
McLellan, David 1985, Karl Marx: His Life and Thought, London: Macmillan.
-
Moggach, Douglas 2003, The Philosophy and Politics of Bruno Bauer, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
-
Musto, Marcello 2018, Another Marx: Early Manuscripts to the International, London: Bloomsbury.
-
Müller, Ernst 2004, Ästhetische Religiosität und Kunstreligion. In den Philosophien von der Aufklärung bis zum Ausgang des deutschen Idealismus, Berlin: de Gruyter.
-
Müller, Ernst 2010, ‘Bruno Bauers implizite Ästhetik. Zur posthegelianischen Figur der „Auflösung der Religion in der Kunst“ – Mit einem Seitenblick auf Marx’, in Bruno Bauer (1809–1882). Ein „Partisan des Weltgeistes“?, edited by Klaus-M. Kodalle and Tilman Reitz, Würzburg: Königshausen und Neumann.
-
Müller-Tamm, Pia 1991, Rumohrs „Haushalt der Kunst“. Zu einem kunstheoretischen Werk der Goethezeit, Hildesheim: Georg Olms Verlag.
-
Nicholls, Angus 2016, ‘Goethe the Writer’, in The Oxford Handbook of European Romanticism, edited by Paul Hamilton, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
-
Panofsky, Erwin 1955, Meaning in the Visual Arts, New York: Anchor Books.
-
Pietz, William 1985, ‘The Problem of the Fetish, I’, RES: Anthropology and Aesthetics, 9: 5–17.
-
Pietz, William 1996, ‘Fetishism and Materialism: The Limits of Theory in Marx’, in Fetishism as Cultural Discourse, edited by Emily Apter and William Pietz, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
-
Podro, Michael 1991, The Critical Historians of Art, New Haven: Yale University Press.
-
Prange, Regine 2007, ‘Gegen die eigene Welt der Kunst. Zu Carl Friedrich von Rumohrs kunsthistorischer Restitution des klassizistischen Ideals’, in Der Körper der Kunst: Konstruktionen der Totalität im Kunstdiskurs um 1800, edited by Johannes Grave, Hubert Locher and Reinhard Wegner, Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht.
-
Prawer, Siegbert Salomon 1978, Karl Marx and World Literature, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
-
Rjazanov, David B. 1929, ‘Einleitung’, in Marx – Engels – Gesamtausgabe (MEGA1), Section 1, Volume 1.2, Berlin: Marx – Engels – Verlag.
-
Rose, Margaret A. 1978, Reading the Young Marx and Engels: Poetry, Parody and the Censor, London: Rowman and Littlefield.
-
Rose, Margaret A. 1984, Marx’s Lost Aesthetic: Karl Marx and the Visual Arts, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
-
Rose, Margaret A. 1986, ‘Theories of Nature from Hegel to Marx’, British Journal of Aesthetics, 26, 2: 150–160.
-
Rose, Margaret A. 1987, ‘Eduard Joseph d’Alton and the Origin of Prince Albert’s Collection’, The Burlington Magazine, 129, 1013: 532–538.
-
Rosen, Zvi 1977, Bruno Bauer and Karl Marx: The Influence of Bruno Bauer on Marx’s Thought, The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff.
-
Rubel, Maximilien and Margaret Manale 1975, Marx without Myth: A Chronological Study of His Life and Work, Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
-
Schimmenti, Gabriele 2019, ‘„Gemälde der wahren Zustände“. Der frühe Marx im Schatten Hegels’, in Hegel und Italien. Italien und Hegel. Geistige Synergien von Gestern und Heute, edited by Francesca Iannelli, Federico Vercellone and Klaus Vieweg, Milan: Mimesis.
-
Schimmenti, Gabriele 2021, L’arte contesa. L’estetica, la sinistra hegeliana e il giovane Marx, Naples/Salerno: Orthotes.
-
Schmidt, Ernst Günther 1988, Erworbenes Erbe. Studien zur antiken Literatur und ihrer Nachwirkung, Leipzig: Reclam Verlag.
-
Schrörs, Heinrich 1906, Die Bonner Universitätsaula und ihre Wandgemälde, Bonn: P. Hansteins Verlag.
-
Skwirblies, Robert 2017, Altitalienische Malerei als preußisches Kulturgut. Gemäldesammlungen, Kunsthandel und Museumspolitik 1797–1830, Berlin: de Gruyter.
-
Sperber, Jonathan 2013, Karl Marx: A Nineteenth-Century Life, New York: Liveright Publishing Corporation.
-
Stedman Jones, Gareth 2016, Karl Marx: Greatness and Illusion, Cambridge, MA: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
-
Taubert, Inge 1978, ‘Probleme der weltanschaulichen Entwicklung von Karl Marx in der Zeit März 1841 bis März 1843’, Marx – Engels – Jahrbuch, 1: 205–232.
-
Thom, Martina 1986, Dr. Karl Marx. Das Werden der neuen Weltanschauung, Berlin: Dietz.
-
van Leeuwen, Arend Theodoor 1972, Critique of Heaven, New York: Scribner.
-
von Goethe, Johann Wolfang 1980, ‘Commentary on Falconet’, in Goethe on Art, selected, edited and translated by John Cage, Berkeley: University of California Press.
-
von Rumohr, Carl Friedrich 1914, ‘Rumohr an den Kronprinzen. 18. Januar 1828’, Jahrbuch der Preußischen Kunstsammlungen, 35: 1–4.
-
von Schlegel, August Wilhelm 1840, Verzeichniss einer von Eduard d’Alton, weiland Professors der Archäologie und Kunstgeschichte an der Königl. Rheinischen Friedrich- Wilhelms-Universität, hinterlassenen Gemälde-Sammlung, Bonn: Carl Georgi.
-
von Staden, Heinrich 1975, ‘Greek Art and Literature in Marx’s Aesthetics’, Arethusa, 8, 1: 119–144.
-
Welcker, Friedrich Gottlieb 1827, Das akademische Kunstmuseum zu Bonn, Bonn: Weber.
-
Wheen, Francis 2001, Karl Marx: A Life, New York: W.W. Norton.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 1639 | 1639 | 155 |
| Full Text Views | 41 | 41 | 6 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 97 | 97 | 8 |
Young Marx’s Treatise on Christian Art and the Bonn Notebooks
In: Historical MaterialismSearch for other papers by Kaan Kangal in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Abstract
There are episodes in Marx’s life that go unnoticed or that are considered insignificant in Marxian scholarship. A case in point is that Marx wrote a treatise on Christian art between 1841 and 1842 and a group of excerpts (the Bonn Notebooks) on the history of religious art that resulted from it. The treatise and the accompanying notebooks are either completely absent from Marx biographies and studies on young Marx or they are mentioned only in passing; if the notebooks are considered at all, one portion is usually singled out while the rest is effectively ignored. The present piece traces Marx’s motives for occupying himself with religious art as well as his interests, shifting from Christian, Greek and Egyptian arts to fetishism and idolatry. This study intends to highlight that young Marx was more involved in questions concerning the political culture of aesthetics than we usually think. The Bonn Notebooks provide access to a more vivid image of Marx in this regard than previous scholarship has suggested.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 1639 | 1639 | 155 |
| Full Text Views | 41 | 41 | 6 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 97 | 97 | 8 |
