‘Soft’ Coercive Diplomacy versus Informal Resistance: Attempts at Deporting ‘Illegal Vietnamese’ from Reunifying Germany, 1990-1995

in The Hague Journal of Diplomacy
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

During the period of Germany’s reunification in the early 1990s, disagreement between Germany and Vietnam over the return of Vietnamese individuals to Vietnam escalated into a diplomatic dispute that also spilled over into Vietnam’s negotiations with the European Union over a major eu–Vietnam treaty. In mid-1995, however, the German and Vietnamese governments finally agreed on a repatriation arrangement that allowed Germany to begin deporting about 40,000 Vietnamese who were living in Germany illegally.

This article explores the episode in the wider context of diplomatic dispute resolution. While Germany was demanding full cooperation from Vietnam on the issue of returning Vietnamese nationals, the Vietnamese government initially resisted large-scale repatriation for economic and social reasons. Hanoi attempted to frame the discussion within bilateral negotiations, economic costs and human rights, whereas Bonn argued from the perspective of customary international law and applied increasingly coercive diplomacy. German authorities escalated the disagreement and made economic threats with the aim of changing Hanoi’s behaviour.

In order to frame this approach analytically, this article uses a modified form of coercive diplomacy. The analysis proceeds in three stages: first, the article analyses the origins of the dispute, which had its roots in German reunification; second, it evaluates the legal arguments advanced by each side; and third, it investigates Germany’s ‘soft’ coercive diplomacy and Vietnam’s response. The article concludes with an evaluation of Germany’s approach, benchmarking 1995’s diplomatic outcome against results on the ground, namely the number of returnees to Vietnam.

Sections

References

1

Rick Atkinson, ‘Cold War Bell Tolls for Berlin’s “Little Hanoi”: Germany to Send Home 40,000 Illegal Vietnamese Residents under April Agreement’, The Washington Post, 16 June 1995, p. A27.

6

Lauren, Craig and George, Force and Statecraft, pp. 198-219; Robert J. Art and Patrick M. Cronin, The United States and Coercive Diplomacy(Washington, dc: United States Institute of Peace Press, 2003); and Daniel Byman and Matthew C. Waxman, The Dynamics of Coercion: American Foreign Policy and the Limits of Military Might, rand studies in policy analysis (New York, ny: Cambridge University Press, 2001).

7

Lauren, Craig and George, Force and Statecraft, p. 200.

9

Lauren, Craig and George, Force and Statecraft: Diplomatic Challenges of Our Time, p. 201.

10

George, Forceful Persuasion, p. 4.

11

George, Forceful Persuasion, p. 11.

14

George, ‘Coercive Diplomacy’, p. 72.

15

Lauren, Craig and George, Force and Statecraft, pp. 201-203; and George, ‘Coercive Diplomacy’, p. 77.

16

Lauren, Craig and George, Force and Statecraft, pp. 201-203; and George, ‘Coercive Diplomacy’, p. 77.

17

George, Forceful Persuasion, pp. 10-11.

18

George, Forceful Persuasion, pp. 10-11; and Lauren, Craig and George, Force and Statecraft, pp. 201-203.

19

Lauren, Craig and George, Force and Statecraft, p. 203.

23

Fall, The Two Viet-Nams, pp. 175-176 and p. 461.

25

David W.P. Elliott, Changing Worlds: Vietnam’s Transformation from Cold War to Globalization(Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012), p. 77.

30

Hellmut Kapfenberger, Berlin–Bonn–Saigon–Hanoi(Berlin: Wiljo Heinen, 2013), p. 350.

34

Malanczuk, Akehurst’s Modern Introduction to International Law, pp. 163-164.

35

Vitzthum, Völkerrecht, p. 237.

54

J. Klaus Bade, ‘Immigration and Social Peace in United Germany’, Daedalus, vol. 123, no. 1, winter 1994, pp. 85-106 at p. 85.

55

Roger Karapin, ‘Antiminority Riots in Unified Germany: Cultural Conflicts and Mischanneld Political Participation’, Comparative Politics, vol. 34, no. 2, 2002, pp. 147-167 at p. 147.

57

Karapin, ‘Antiminority Riots in Unified Germany’, p. 153.

58

Mary Fulbrook, ‘Aspects of Society and Identity in the New Germany’, Daedalus, vol. 123, no. 1, winter 1994, pp. 211-234 at p. 227.

59

Antje Ellermann, ‘The Limits of Unilateral Migration Control: Deportation and Inter-state Cooperation’, Government and Opposition, vol. 43, no. 2, 2008, pp. 168-189 at p. 173; and ‘Wer will Menschen das antun?’, p. 41.

61

Ellermann, ‘The Limits of Unilateral Migration Control: Deportation and Inter-state Cooperation’, p. 173.

65

Ellermann, ‘The Limits of Unilateral Migration Control’, p. 76.

66

Islam and Schwarz, ‘Foreign Relations — Double Deal’; and Hugh Williamson, ‘Boat People — Tobacco Road’, Far Eastern Economic Review, 1996, p. 21.

68

Ellermann, ‘The Limits of Unilateral Migration Control’, p. 18; and Gregor Noll, Rejected Asylum Seekers: The Problem of Return, New Issues in Refugee Research, Working Paper no. 4 (Lund, Sweden: University of Lund, Centre for Documentation and Research, 1999), p. 15.

74

Ellermann, ‘The Limits of Unilateral Migration Control’, pp. 176-177.

75

Noll, Rejected Asylum Seekers, p. 6.

76

Ellermann, ‘The Limits of Unilateral Migration Control’, pp. 176-177.

77

Elliott, Changing Worlds, pp. 125-155 at p. 125.

80

Noll, Rejected Asylum Seekers, p. 15.

81

Noll, Rejected Asylum Seekers, p. 6.

82

In 1993, the name was changed to ‘Bundesministerium für Wirtschafltiche Zusammenarbeit und Entwicklung’ [Federal Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development].

93

George, ‘Coercive Diplomacy’, p. 74.

102

Malanczuk, Akehurst’s Modern Introduction to International Law, p. 261.

105

Vitzthum, Völkerrecht, p. 255; and Malanczuk, Akehurst’s Modern Introduction to International Law, p. 261.

106

Doehring, ‘Aliens, Expulsion and Deportation’, p. 111.

107

Vitzthum, Völkerrecht, p. 255; and Noll, Rejected Asylum Seekers, pp. 25-26.

109

Doehring, ‘Aliens, Expulsion and Deportation’, p. 110.

110

Malanczuk, Akehurst’s Modern Introduction to International Law, p. 261.

111

Andrew Clapham, Brierly’s Law of Nations: An Introduction to the Role of International Law in International Relations(Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012), pp. 520-523; Malanczuk, Akehurst’s Modern Introduction to International Law, p. 261; Vitzthum, Völkerrecht, p. 255; and Valerie Epps, International Law (Durham, nc: Carolina Academic Press, 3rd edition 2005), p. 324.

112

Doehring, ‘Aliens, Expulsion and Deportation’, p. 110.

113

Noll, Rejected Asylum Seekers, p. 22.

114

Doehring, ‘Aliens, Expulsion and Deportation’, p. 111.

116

Noll, Rejected Asylum Seekers, p. 23.

117

Noll, Rejected Asylum Seekers, pp. 23-24.

131

Kapfenberger, Berlin–Bonn–Saigon–Hanoi, p. 409.

135

Craig R. Whitney, ‘Hanoi to Accept Refugees Now in Germany in Exchange for Aid’, New York Times, available online at http://www.nytimes.com/1995/01/12/world/hanoi-to-accept-refugees-now-in-germany-in-exchange-for-aid.html?gwh=5D187BF1597C66641C1750BBDF6D0105; ‘Vietnam nimmt Rückkehrer auf’, Berliner Zeitung, available online at http://www.berliner-zeitung.de/archiv/vietnam-nimmt-rueckkehrer-auf,10810590,8900164.html; and ‘German Citizenship Changes Proposed’, University of California at Davis, available online at http://migration.ucdavis.edu/mn/more.php?id=564_0_4_0.

137

George, ‘Coercive Diplomacy’, p. 74.

160

Ellermann, ‘The Limits of Unilateral Migration Control’, pp. 174-176.

161

Noll, Rejected Asylum Seekers, p. 16.

162

Ellermann, ‘The Limits of Unilateral Migration Control’, p. 175.

163

Ellermann, ‘The Limits of Unilateral Migration Control’, p. 175.

166

Noll, Rejected Asylum Seekers, p. 43.

169

Kristin Huckshorn, ‘4,000 Vietnamese Face Expulsion From Germany’, The Seattle Times, available online at http://community.seattletimes.nwsource.com/archive/?date=19970105&slug=2517249.

173

Williamson, ‘Boat People — Tobacco Road’; and ‘Three Vietnamese Former Cigarette Smugglers Receive Life Sentence for Murder’, Associated Press International, 24 April 2002, accessed on 3 April 2014 via LexisNexis at http://www.lexisnexis.com/ap/academic/.

175

Kapfenberger, Berlin–Bonn–Saigon–Hanoi, pp. 356 and 392.

177

Keukeleire, The European Union as a Diplomatic Actor, pp. 2-4.

180

G.R. Berridge, Diplomacy, Theory and Practice(Houndmills: Palgrave, 2005), p. 84.

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 5 5 4
Full Text Views 4 4 4
PDF Downloads 0 0 0
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0