A Universal Procedural Framework for War Crimes Tribunals

in International Community Law Review
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Abstract

Notwithstanding the uniformity of war crimes substantive law, applicable procedural rules vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. In the case of ad hoc tribunals, the applicable rules may not be known until the tribunal is established. Consequently, there is uncertainty and incoherence in war crimes procedural law. Furthermore, the quality of applicable rules is dependent on the varying experience, knowledge and intentions of the framers of the procedural rules of each tribunal. This article makes the case for a universal procedural framework that can serve as an instrument for evaluating and creating war crimes procedural rules. Amongst other things, such a framework will bring about certainty and coherence in war crimes procedural law. In devising the model framework, the article adopts the Benthamite approach to the relationship between substantive law and procedural law and also relies on some aspects of the process evaluation theories of Robert Summers and Michael Bayles.

A Universal Procedural Framework for War Crimes Tribunals

in International Community Law Review

Sections

References

6)

Sivakumaransupra note 4 p. 495.

27)

Akandesupra note 11 p. 47.

34)

Akandesupra note 11 pp. 51–52.

37)

Kreßsupra note 28 p. 543.

63)

Warbricksupra note 61 p. 51.

64)

Swartsupra note 62 p. 96.

69)

Sluitersupra note 53 p. 605.

80)

Gibson and Rudysupra note 76 p. 1007.

82)

Gibson and Rudysupra note 76 p. 1020.

90)

ICTY Reportsupra note 86 para. 55.

104)

Kreßsupra note 28 p. 538.

108)

Cassesesupra note 105 p. 158; Marco Roscini “Great Expectations: The Implementation of the Rome Statute in Italy” 5 J Int Criminal Justice (2007) pp. 493–512 at 496; Michael P. Scharf “Introductory Note to the International Criminal Court’s Arrest Warrant for Omar Al Bashir President of the Sudan” 48 ILM (2009) 463.

112)

Boassupra note 110 p. 330.

116)

Boassupra note 110 p. 329.

124)

Bedermansupra note 121 p. 36.

126)

Jacksonsupra note 93.

136)

Damaškasupra note 65 p. 5.

141)

Benthamsupra note 1.

182)

Summerssupra note 172.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 8 8 3
Full Text Views 7 7 7
PDF Downloads 3 3 3
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0