Evaluating the Free Early Childhood Education Policies in Taiwan with the 3A2S Framework

in International Journal of Chinese Education
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


The policy of ‘free’ education for young children has come to be a concern in some parts of the Asia-Pacific region in the recent decades. When the early childhood education (ece) policies of Hong Kong, Macau, Shenzhen and some of the provinces on the Mainland China were being studied, the policies in Taiwan have also received some attention. In this paper, the ece policies of Taiwan have been reviewed with the 3A2S framework which refers to accessibility, affordability, accountability, sustainability, and social justice. In doing so, the most up-to-date data from the national and educational statistics of Taiwan were used for the analysis. This policy review does allow us to see how Taiwan has dealt with ece. While there are indications that some of the elements of the framework have had positive effect, others require additional research and reform in the future.

Evaluating the Free Early Childhood Education Policies in Taiwan with the 3A2S Framework

in International Journal of Chinese Education



CaiYingqi “Social harmony and macroregulation of the funding system of early childhood education.” Chinese Education & Society 2008 41 no. 2 20 32

ChenE. EvaHuiLi RaoN.ZhouJ.SunJ. Early childhood education in Taiwan. Early childhood development in Chinese societies (in press) Springer

ChiuChih-Peng Peter邱志鵬Yung-senWu巫永森 “On the voucher policy of early childhood education in Taiwan.” 2003 Paper presented at 幼兒教育與公共政策: 從比較角度看台灣個案論文集, 國立中正大學公共政策及管理研究中心主辦 [Forum on Early Childhood Education and Public Policy: Examining the Case of Taiwan from a Comparative Perspective, Organized by the National Chung Cheng University Research Center for Public Policy and Management] Chiayi, Taiwan

HoMing‐sho “The politics of preschool education vouchers in Taiwan.” Comparative Education Review 2006 50 no. 1 66 89

HongF. C. Exploration of the historical development and future compulsory education policy of the Taiwan early childhood education. 2000 Unpublished Doctoral dissertation. Institute of Education National Taiwan Normal University.

HsiehMei-Hue謝美慧 “Tai wan you er jiao yu de xian zhuang he qu shi 台湾幼儿教育的现状和趋势 The status quo and trends in Taiwan’s early childhood education.” Yi wan jiao yu臺灣教育 Taiwan Education 2001 606 21 34

HsiehMing-Fang “Teaching practices in Taiwan’s education for young children: Complexity and ambiguity of developmentally appropriate practices and/or developmentally inappropriate practices.” 2004 Contemporary Issues in Early Childhood 5 no. 3 309 329

HsueYuling許玉齡 “you zhi yuan pengjian fang an de sheji yu shishi jianyi 幼稚園評鑑方案的設計與實施建議 [Recommendations for the design and implementation of kindergarten evaluation].” 國教世紀 National Education Century 2003 206 73 78

HuangYi Jing黃以敬Min RongXu許敏溶 “you jiao fa xiu zheng an you zhi yuan kai fang gong ban min ying 幼教法修正案幼稚園開放公辦民營 [Early childhood education law amended to allow for government-utility, privately-operated kindergartens].” 大纪元时报 Enoch Times 2004 October 17 http://www.epochtimes.com

JiangL. L. Taipei county evaluation programe of kindergarten counseling (Vol. 136): Birdsfamily 2002

Laws and Regulations Database of The Republic of China “幼兒園評鑑辦法.” Accessed 2012 http://law.moj.gov.tw/

LiH.WangX. Christine NirmalaRaoZhouJingSunJin “International Perspectives on Early Childhood Education in Chinese Societies,” Early childhood development in Chinese societies (in press) Springer

LiHuiDanWang “Understanding the 15-Year Free Education Policies in China: An Online Study of Four Cases.” International Journal of Chinese Education 2014

LiHuiWongJessie Ming SinWangX. Christine “Affordability, accessibility, and accountability: Perceived impacts of the Pre-primary Education Vouchers in Hong Kong.” 2010 Early Childhood Research Quarterly 25 no. 1 125 138

LiHui “Free early childhood education matters.” omep-Hong Kong Newsletter 2012 12 9 12

LiaoFeng Rui廖鳳瑞 “You jiao yuan suo de kai fang shi jiao yu li nian yu zhi xing yan jiu 幼教園所的開放式教育理念與執行研究 [A study of open style education concepts and practices in kindergartens]” 國家科學委員會研究彙刊: 人文及社會科學 Humanities and Social Sciences 8 1998 576 595

Ting-YuLin林庭玉YangSong-cheng楊淞丞 “You er jiao yu yan jin zhi gui ji 幼兒教育演進之軌跡 The trace of early childhood education.” 社會變遷下的幼兒教育與照顧學術研討會論文集 Academic papers on the effects of social change on early childhood education and care 2007 5 14

LinHsiu FenChingMin Ju “Managing the Taiwan kindergarten evaluation system.” 2011 International Journal of Research Studies in Management 1 no. 1

LinYu‐WeiTsaiMin‐Ling “Culture and the kindergarten curriculum in Taiwan.” 1996 Early Child Development and Care 123 no. 1 157 165

LinYu‐Wei “Current critical issues of early childhood education in Taiwan—Reflections on the social phenomenon and governmental policies.” 2007 April Paper presented at the meeting of the American Educational Research Association Chicago, IL, U.S.A

LinYu‐Wei ChanLorna Kim SangMellorElizabeth Jean “Early childhood services in Taiwan.” International developments in early childhood services. P. Lang 2002.

LuMei-Kuei “Kai fang shi you zhi yuan ke cheng yu xue xi ping liang zhi yan jiu 開放式幼稚園課程與學習評量之研究 [The curriculum and learning evaluation of open style kindergarten education]” 1998 Taipei National Science Council

National Statistics of Taiwan “Annual Change of Consumer Price Indices in Taiwan Area.” Accessed 2014 http://eng.stat.gov.tw/public/data/dgbas03/bs3/english/cpiidxc.xls

National Statistics of Taiwan “Income Distribution in Selected Countries.” Accessed 2012 http://win.dgbas.gov.tw/fies/doc/result/101/a11/Year08.xls

Taiwan Ministry of Education and Ministry of the Interior. “5sui you er mian fei jiaoyu jihua5 歲幼兒免學費教育計畫 [Plan to provide free education to 5-year-old children].” Accessed 2011 http://www.edu.tw/files/list/B0039/5歲幼兒免學費教育計畫【100 學年修正計畫發布版 100824】.pdf.

Taiwan Ministry of Education “fa fang you er jiao yu quan shi shi fang an 發放幼兒教育券實施方案 [Program for the distribution of early childhood education vouchers].” Accessed 2003 http://www.cbi.gov.tw/

Taiwan Ministry of Education “fu chi 5 sui you er jiaoyu jihua 扶持 5 歲幼兒教育計畫 [Plan to support the education of 5-year-old children].” Accessed 2008 http://www.cbi.gov.tw/CBI_2/upload/bd07bd4c-813f-4345-a1c9-d2f0350e85dc.pdf

Taiwan Ministry of Education “jiaoyu tongji zhibiao: pingjun mei qianfang gongli geji xuexiao xiaoshu (102xueniandu) 教育統計指標: 平均每千方公里各級學校校數 (102 學年度).” Accessed 2014 http://stats.moe.gov.tw/files/ebook/indicators/102indicators.xls

Taiwan Ministry of Education “zhong di shouru hu you tong tuo jiao fu zhu shishi jihua 中低收入戶幼童托教補助實施計畫 [Plan for providing financial assistance for early childhood care and education to children from middle and low income families].” Accessed 2011 http://www.edu.tw/files/bulletin/B0055/中低收入戶幼童托教補助實施計畫【1000901發布版】.pdf.

WeiMeihui魏美惠 “Jin dai you er jiao yu si chao 近代幼儿教育思潮 [Current Trends of Philosophies in Early Childhood Education]. 1995 Taipei Hsin-Lee

YangShen-Keng “Dilemmas of Education Reform in Taiwan: Internationalization or Localization?.” 2001 March Paper presented at the meeting of the Comparative and International Education Society Washington D.C., U.S.A


Ming‐sho Ho“The politics of preschool education vouchers in Taiwan.” Comparative Education Review 50 no. 1 (2006): 66-89.


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 27 27 18
Full Text Views 77 77 63
PDF Downloads 5 5 3
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0