Ontologies of Taiwan Studies, Indigenous Studies, and Anthropology

in International Journal of Taiwan Studies
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Indigenous studies and Taiwan studies have a rather tenuous intellectual relationship. From a Taiwanese perspective, the study of indigenous peoples has been a part of the inward-turning indigenisation (本土化, bentuhua) of Taiwan scholarship; affirmation of a locally-rooted, non-Chinese national identity. The idea that Taiwan is the starting point of the Austronesian diaspora makes Taiwan important to the world in new ways. For indigenous scholars, indigenous studies can also contribute to a pride of their places and cultures, meaningful on their own terms. Applied and action research can also be helpful to indigenous goals of local self-determination. Reflection on the ontological implications of indigeneity suggests that indigenous studies cannot be relegated to a subfield of Taiwan studies. There is thus a need for reflection on the ontology of our studies.

Sections

References

Mona Awi and Simon Scott (2011) ‘Imagining first nations: From Eeyou Istchee (Québec) to the Seediq and Truku of Taiwan’, Issues and Studies 47(3): 2970. 10

Dnaha Bawan (沈明仁) (1998) A People Who Believe in Ancestral Spirits: Seediq People (崇信祖靈的民族:賽德克人, Chong xin zu ling de min zu: sai de ke ren), Taipei: Hai Weng Press.

Bellwood Peter (1979) Man’s Conquest of the Pacific: The Prehistory of Southeast Asia and Oceania , New York: Oxford University Press.

Bellwood Peter (2011) ‘Holocene population history in the Pacific Region as a model for worldwide food producer dispersals’, Current Anthropology 52: S363378.

Blundell David (ed) (2001) Austronesian Taiwan: Linguistics, History, Ethnology, and Prehistory , Taipei: smc Publishing.

Blust Robert (1995) ‘The prehistory of the Austronesian-speaking peoples: A view from language’, Journal of World Prehistory 9(4): 453510.

Blust Robert (2002) ‘The history of faunal terms in Austronesian languages’, Oceanic Linguistics 41(1): 89139.

Borrows John (2010) Drawing Out Law: A Spirit’s Guide, Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

Brown Melissa J. (2001) ‘Reconstructing ethnicity: Recorded and remembered identity in Taiwan’, Ethnology 40(2): 153164.

Brown Melissa J. (2003) ‘The cultural impact of gendered social roles and ethnicity: Changing religious practices in Taiwan’, Journal of Anthropological Research 59(1): 4767.

Brown Melissa J. (2004) Is Taiwan Chinese? The Impact of Culture, Power, and Migration on Changing Identities, Berkeley, ca: University of California Press.

Brown Melissa J. (2010) ‘Changing authentic identities: Evidence from Taiwan and China’, Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 16(3): 459479.

Cauquelin Josiane (1995) ‘The age system among the Puyuma, Austronesians of Taiwan’, L’Homme 35: 159170.

Cauquelin Josiane (2004) The Aborigines of Taiwan, the Puyuma: From Headhunting to the Modern World, London: RoutledgeCurzon.

Chang Mau-kuei (2005) ‘The movement to indigenize the social sciences in Taiwan: Origin and predicaments’, in Makeham John and Hsiau A-Chin (eds), Cultural, Ethnic, and Political Nationalism in Contemporary Taiwan: Bentuhua, New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 221260.

Chen Wen-te (2010) Puyuma Tribe (卑南族, Bei nan zu), Taipei: Sanmin Press.

Chi Chun-chieh (2001) ‘Capitalist expansion and indigenous land rights’, The Asia Pacific Journal of Anthropology 2(2): 135153.

Chi Chun-chieh and Chin Hsang-te (2012) ‘Knowledge, power, and tribal mapping: A critical analysis of the “Return of the Truku People”’, GeoJournal 77: 733740.

Chiang Bien (2010) ‘Disaster, culture, and “subjectivity”: Reflections after the Morakot disaster’ (災難、文化與「主體性」:莫拉克風災後的省思, Zainan, wenhua yu zhutixing: Molake fengzai hou de xingsi), Thought (思想, Si xiang) 14: 1932.

Chiu Fred Yen Liang (2000) ‘Suborientalism and the subimperialist predicament: Aboriginal discourse and the poverty of state-nation imagery’, Positions 8(1): 101149.

Corcuff Stéphane (2010) ‘Étudier Taiwan. Ontologie d’un laboratoire-conservatoire’, Études chinoises, Hors-série [Special Issue]: 235257.

Currie Thomas E. (2013) ‘Cultural evolution branches out: The phylogenetic approach in cross-cultural research’, Cross-Cultural Research 47(2): 102130.

Pawan Dakis (郭明正) (2002) ‘A simplified history of Qingliu’ (Kari Alang Nu Gluban [Seediq], 清流部落簡史, Qingliu buluo jianshi), in Jian Hong-mu , Pelin Iwan , and Pawan Dakis (eds), Life Histories of Qingliu (Ltlutuc Knkingan Sapah Alang Gluban [Seediq], 清流部落生命史, Qingliu buluo shengmingshi), Taipei: Yongwang wenhua shiye, 713.

Pawan Dakis (2011) The Real Truth (真相巴萊, Zhen xiang ba lai), Taipei: Yuanliu Press.

Pawan Dakis (2012) Looking Again at the Truth: the Seediq and the Wushe Incident (又見真相:賽德克族與霧社事件, You jian zhen xiang: Sai de ke yu Wu she shi jian), Taipei: Yuanliu Press.

Deng Shian-yang (鄧相揚) (1998) The Wushe Incident (霧社事件, Wu she shi jian), Taipei: Yushan Press.

Desveaux Emmanuel (1996) ‘Controlling births and age classes: A limited case’, L’Homme 36: 143149.

Diamond Jared (1988) ‘Express train to Polynesia’, Nature 336: 307308.

Diamond Jared (2000) ‘Linguistics: Taiwan’s gift to the world’, Nature 403 (February): 709710.

Donohue Mark and Denham Tim (2010) ‘Farming and language in island Southeast Asia: Reframing Austronesian history’, Current Anthropology 51(2): 223256.

Faure David (ed) (2001) In Search of the Hunters and their Tribes: Studies in the History and Culture of the Taiwan Indigenous People, Taipei: Shung Ye Museum.

Ferrell Raleigh (1969) Taiwan Aboriginal Groups: Problems in Cultural and Linguistic Classification, Taipei: Academia Sinica.

Formoso Bernard (2005) ‘Josiane Cauquelin, The Aborigines of Taiwan. The Puyuma: From Headhunting to the Modern World ’, L’Homme 175–176 (July–September 2005): 540542. Retrieved 10 August 2017 from http://lhomme.revues.org.

Friedman Kerim (2010) ‘Entering the mountains to rule the Aborigines: Taiwanese Aborigine education and the colonial encounter’, in Heylen Ann and Sommers Scott (eds), Becoming Taiwan, from Colonialism to Democracy, Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz, 1932.

Hage Per and Marck Jeff (2003) ‘Matrilineality and the Melanesian origin of Polynesian Y chromosomes’, Current Anthropology 44: S121S127.

Hipwell William (2007) ‘Taiwan aboriginal ecotourism: Tanayiku Natural Ecology Park’, Annals of Tourism Research 34(4): 876897.

Hipwell William (2009) ‘An asset-based approach to indigenous development in Taiwan’, Asia Pacific Viewpoint 50(3): 289306.

Hsieh Shih-chung ; Guo Qian-Ting ; Yang Ling-Hui ; Liu Rui-chao and Li Wei-Cheng (2007) An Investigation into the Traditional Customs of Indigenous Peoples: A 2nd Commissioned Research Report to Compile and Evaluate their Integration into Law. Atayal and Truku Tribes (原住民族傳統習慣之調查、整理及評估納入現行法制第二期委託研究:泰雅族、太魯閣族, Yuanzhu minzu chuantong xiguan zhi diaocha, zhengli ji pinggu naru xianxing fa zhi di er qi weituo yanjiu: taiya zu, tailuge zu), Taipei, Council of Indigenous Peoples.

Hsieh Shih-chung ; Liu Rui-chao and Yang Ling-Hui (2009) Legal Context of Indigenous Female: A Comparison among Three Highland Groups in Taiwan (原住民女性的律法脈絡:三個高地族群的比較, Yuanzhumin nüxing de lüfa mailuo: Sange gaodi zuqun de bijiao), Nantou: Taiwan Academia Historica.

Hsu Mutsu (1991) Culture, Self, and Adaptation: The Psychological Anthropology of Two Malayo-Polynesian Groups in Taiwan, Taipei: Institute of Ethnology, Academia Sinica.

Hu Tai-li (胡台麗) and Liu Pi-chen (劉璧榛) (eds) (2010) Shamans and Ritual Performances of Taiwan Indigenous Peoples (台灣原住民巫師與儀式展演, Taiwan yuanzhumin wushi yu yishi zhanyan), Taipei: Institute of Ethnology, Academia Sinica.

Chang-hsing Huang (黃長興) (1996) ‘Hunting culture of the Eastern Seediq group’ (東賽德克群的狩獵文化, Dong Saideke qun de shou lie wen hua), Compilation of Research Materials from the Institute of Ethnology (民族學研究所資料彙編, Min zu xue yan jiu suo zi liao hui bian) 15. Taipei: Institute of Ethnology, Academica Sinica.

Huang Shiun-wey (黃宣衛) (1996) ‘The politics of conversion: The case of an Aboriginal Formosan village’, Anthropos 91(4–6): 425439.

Huang Shiun-wey (2004a) ‘“Times” and images of Others in an Amis village, Taiwan’, Time & Society 13(2–3): 321337.

Huang Shiun-wey (2004b) ‘Language, social life, and fieldwork: A critical introduction to the cognitive anthropology of Maurice Bloch’, (語言、社會生活與田野工作:評介Maurice Bloch有關認知人類學的一些觀點, Yuyan, shehui shenghuo yu tianye gongzuo: Pingjie Maurice Block you guan renzhi renleixue de yixie guandian) Journal of Archaeology and Anthropology (考古人類學刊, Kaogu renlei xuekan), 62: 122135.

Huang Shiun-wey (2008) Amis Tribe (阿美族, A mei zu), Taipei: Sanmin Press.

Huang Shiun-wey (2013) ‘Cultural construction and a new ethnic group movement: The case of the Sakizaya in Eastern Taiwan’, International Journal of Asian Studies 10(1): 4771.

Shu-min Huang (黃樹民) and Ying-hwa Chang (章英華) (2010) Government Policy and Social Development among Taiwanese Indigenous Peoples (台灣原住民政策變遷與社會發展, Taiwan yuan zhu min zheng ce bian qian yu she hui fa zhan), Taipei: Institute of Ethnology, Academia Sinica.

Ying-kuei Huang (黃應貴) (2006) Bunun Tribe (布農族, Bu nong zu), Taipei: Sanmin Press.

Huang Ying-kuei (2012) The Path Towards “Civilization” (「文明」之路, “Wen ming” zhi lu) Taipei: Institute of Ethnology, Academia Sinica.

Cihung Kaji (旮日羿吉宏) (2011) Records of Taroko Tribal History and Sacrificial Music and Dance (太魯閣族部落史與祭儀樂舞傳記, Tailugezu bu luo shi yu ji yi yue wu zhuan ji), Taipei: Shanhai Press.

Ku Kun-hui (2005) ‘Rights to recognition: Minority/indigenous politics in the emerging Taiwanese nationalism’, Social Analysis 49(2): 99121.

Ku Kun-hui (2008) ‘Ethnographic studies of voting among the Austronesian Paiwan: The role of Paiwan chiefs in the contemporary state system of Taiwan’, Pacific Affairs 81(3): 383406.

Kuan Da-wei (官大偉) (2014a) ‘Spatial order, geographical reproduction and ecological politics: A historical geographical review of the use and protection of Taiwan’s mountainous resources’, Journal of Taiwan Indigenous Peoples (台灣原住民族季刊, Taiwan yuanzhu minzu jikan) 7(1): 159197.

Kuan Da-wei (2014b) ‘Challenges for the realisation of Indigenous land rights in contemporary Taiwan: A regional study of Indigenous reserved land trade between Indigenous and non-indigenous people’, (原住民族土地權的挑戰:從一個當代保留地 交易的區域研究談起, Yuanzhu minzu tudiquan de tiaozhan: Cong yige dangdai baoliudi jiaoyi de chuyu yanjiu tanqi) Journal of Archaeology and Anthropology 80: 752.

Tapas Kumu (2004) Tribal Memories: Oral Histories of the Wushe Incident, 2 vols. (部落記憶:霧社事件的口述歷史, Bu luo ji yi: Wushe shi jian de kou shu li shi, i,ii), Taipei: Hanlu Publishing.

Tapas Kumu (2014) The Truth is Hidden in the Whispers in the General Store: Oral Testimonies of the Wushe Incident (真相藏在雜貨微音中:霧社事件的口述證言, Zhen xiang zang zai za huo wei yin zhong: Wushe shi jian de kou shu zheng yan), Taichung: Chung-Hsing University.

Kuper Adam (2003) ‘The return of the native’, Current Anthropology 44(3): 389402.

Li Yih-yuan (1989) ‘Four hundred years of ethnic relations in Taiwan’, New Asia Academic Bulletin 8: 103115.

Siu-theh Lim (林修澈) (1999) Research on the Definition of Indigenous Identity (原住民身分認定的研究, Yuan zhu min shen fen ren ding de yan jiu), Taipei: Council of Indigenous Peoples.

Lin Ching-hsiu (2011) ‘The circulation of labour and money: Symbolic meanings of monetary kinship practices in contemporary Truku society, Taiwan’, New Proposals: Journal of Marxism and Interdisciplinary Inquiry 5(1): 2744.

Lin Yih-ren (2011) ‘Politicizing nature: The Maqaw National Park controversy in Taiwan’, Capitalism, Nature, Socialism 22(2): 88103.

Liu Jennifer A. (2012) ‘Aboriginal fractions: Enumerating identity in Taiwan’, Medical Anthropology 31(4): 329346.

Liu Pi-chen (2003) ‘Missionnaires hommes vs Mtiu (femmes chamanes): Transformation de l’identité et du pouvoir des femmes chez les Kavalan, Austronésiens de Taiwan’, Histoire et Anthropologie asies 2: 4962.

Liu Pi-chen (2011) ‘Du stigmate à la revendication: mémoire et oubli dans la reconstruction des identités aborigènes de Taiwan’, in Ferhat Samia and Marchand Sandrine (eds), Taiwan, île de mémoires, Lyon: Tigre de papier, 247262.

Maddock Kenneth (2002) ‘Revival, renaissance, and the meaning of modern constructions in Australia’, in Kolig Erich and Mückler Hermann (eds), Politics of Indigeneity in the South Pacific, Hamburg: lit Verlag, 2546.

Makeham John (2005) ‘Introduction’, in Makeham John and Hsiau A-chin (eds), Cultural, Ethnic, and Political Nationalism in Contemporary Taiwan: Bentuhua, New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 114.

Mowna Masaw (廖守臣) (1998) Atayal Social Organisation (泰雅族的社會組織, Taiya Zu de Shehui Zuzhi), Hualien: Ciji University Research Institute in Indigenous Health.

Munsterhjelm Mark (2014) Living Dead in the Pacific: Racism and Sovereignty in Genetics Research on Taiwan Aborigines, Vancouver: ubc Press.

Murray Stephen O. and Hong Keelung (1994) Taiwanese Culture, Taiwanese Society: A Critical Review of Social Science Research Done on Taiwan, New York: University Press of America.

Ong Nga-ping (王雅萍) (2011) ‘Promotion of language nests: Still needs to be better’ (語言巢推動:好還要更好, Yu yan chao tui dong: hao hai yao geng hao), Taipei Indigenous Wilds (台北原野, Taibei yuan ye), Pamphlet series, Vol. 95, Taipei: Municipal Government Indigenous Council.

Peschek Sonja (ed) (2012) Die indigenen Völker Taiwans: Vorträge zur Geschichte und Gesellschaft Taiwans, Frankfurt am Main: Peter Lang.

Purcell Trevor W (1998) ‘Indigenous knowledge and applied anthropology: Questions of definition and direction’, Human Organization 57(3): 258272.

Republic of China Legislative Yuan (2005) Indigenous Peoples Basic Law, Taipei: Council of Indigenous Peoples. Retrieved 24 March 2015 from www.apc.gov.tw.

Rudolph Michael (2003a) Taiwans multi-ethnische Gesellschaft und die Bewegung der Ureinwohner: Assimilation oder kulturelle Revitalisierung? Hamburg: lit Verlag.

Rudolph Michael (2003b) ‘The quest for difference versus the wish to assimilate: Taiwan’s Aborigines and their struggle for cultural survival in times of multiculturalism’, in Katz Paul R. and Rubinstein Murray A. (eds), Religion and the Formation of Taiwanese Identities, New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 123156.

Rudolph Michael (2008) Ritual Performances as Authenticating Practices: Cultural Representations of Taiwan’s Aborigines in Times of Political Change, Berlin: lit Verlag.

Said Edward (1979) Orientalism, New York: Vintage Books.

Shih Fang-long ; Thompson Stuart and Tremlett Paul-François (eds) (2007) Re-writing Culture in Taiwan, London: Routledge.

Simon Scott (2010a) ‘Negotiating power: Elections and the constitution of Indigenous Taiwan’, American Ethnologist 37(4): 726740.

Simon Scott (2010b) ‘Femme économique? : Circulation et rapports sociaux de sexe dans les communautés seediq et taroko de Taïwan’, Anthropologie et Sociétés 34 (2): 103122.

Simon Scott (2011) ‘Class and Indigenous politics: The paradox of Seediq/Taroko women’, New Proposals: Journal of Marxism and Interdisciplinary Inquiry 5(1): 4559.

Simon Scott (2012a) Sadyaq Balae! L’autochtonie formosane dans tous ses états, Québec: Presses de l’Université Laval.

Simon Scott (2012b) ‘Politics and headhunting among the Formosan Sejiq: Ethnohistorical perspectives’, Oceania 82(2): 164185.

Simon Scott (2013) ‘Of boars and men: Indigenous knowledge and co-management in Taiwan’, Human Organization 72(3): 220229.

Simon Scott and Mona Awi (2013a) ‘L’autonomie autochtone a Taiwan. Un cadre légal en construction’, in Bellier Irène (ed), Peuples autochtones dans la mondialisation : les avancées du droit, Paris: L’Harmattan, 147164.

Simon Scott and Mona Awi (2013b) ‘Human rights and Indigenous self-government: The Taiwanese experience’, in Bagchi Subrata Sankar and Das Arnab (eds), Human Rights and the Third World: Issues and Discourses , Lanham, md: Lexington Books, 99122.

Ulon Siyat (劉韶偉) (2004) Rediscovering Truku, Gimi Ka Truku Zhaohui Tailuge (找回太魯閣, Zhao hui tai lu ge), Taipei: Hanlu Publishing.

Smith Linda Tuhiwai (1999) Decolonising Methodologies: Research and Indigenous Peoples, London: Zed Books.

Taiban Sasala (2013) ‘From Rekai to Labelabe: Disaster and relocation on the example of Kucapungane, Taiwan’, Anthropological Notebooks 19(1): 5976.

Tan Chang-kwo (2002) ‘Syncretic objects. Material culture of syncretism among the Paiwan Catholics, Taiwan’, Journal of Material Culture 7(2): 167187.

Tan Shzr Ee (2012) Beyond ‘Innocence’: Amis Aboriginal Song in Taiwan as an Ecosystem, Burlington, vt: Ashgate.

Tang Ching-ping and Tang Shui-Yan (2001) ‘Negotiated autonomy: Transforming self-governing institutions for local common-pool resources in two tribal villages in Taiwan’, Human Ecology 29(1): 4967.

Yudaw Tera (李季順) (2003) Crossing the Rainbow (Muda Hakaw Utux Zouguo caihong, 走過彩虹, Zou guo cai hong), Hualien: Taroko Tribal Cultural Workshop Press.

Tian Kwei-fang (田貴芳) (2014) Taroko People: Centennial Memories of the Elders (太魯閣人:耆老百年回憶, Tai lu ge ren: Qi lao bai nian hui yi). Taipei: Hanlu Publishing.

Trouillot Michel-Rolph (2003) Global Transformations: Anthropology and the Modern World, New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

United Nations General Assembly (2007) Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, New York: United Nations.

Venkatesan Soumhya (2010) ‘Debate: Ontology is just another word for culture, motion tabled at the 2008 meeting of the Group for Debates in Anthropological Theory, University of Manchester’, Critique of Anthropology 30(2): 152200.

Wang Fu-chang (2014) ‘A Reluctant identity: The development of Holo identity in contemporary Taiwan’, Taiwan in Comparative Perspective 5: 79119.

Wang Mei-hsia (王梅霞) (2006) Atayal Tribe (泰雅族, Tai ya zu), Taipei: Sanmin Press.

Wang Mei-hsia (2008) ‘The reinvention of ethnicity and culture: A comparative study on the Atayal and the Truku in Taiwan’, Journal of Archaeology and Anthropology 68: 144.

Wang Mei-hsia (2014) ‘Looking from waya to see the processes of capitalist transition: Economic change in a Seediq Band (從waya看資本主義的轉化過程︰一個賽德克部落的經濟變遷, Cong Waya kan ziben zhu yi de zhuanhua guocheng), Journal of Archaeology and Anthropology 80: 53102.

Yang Shu-yuan (2005) ‘Imagining the state: An ethnographic study’, Ethnography 6(4): 487516.

Yang Shu-yuan (2008) ‘Christianity, identity, and the construction of moral community among the Bunun of Taiwan’, Social Analysis 52(3): 5174.

Yang Shu-yuan (2011) ‘Cultural performance and the reconstruction of tradition among the Bunun of Taiwan’, Oceania 81(3): 316330.

Figures

  • The indigenous research agenda. Linda Tuhiwai Smith, 1999. Reproduced with written permission of the author.

    View in gallery

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 37 37 9
Full Text Views 9 9 7
PDF Downloads 2 2 2
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0