International Relations Theory and the Relationship across the Taiwan Strait

in International Journal of Taiwan Studies
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

The purpose of this state-of-the-field article is to take stock of the use of international relations theory in the study of cross-Strait relations since 2000. To what degree have studies of cross-Strait relations made use of international relations theory since 2000, and to what degree has international relations theory provided useful insights for understanding Beijing–Taipei relations? I focus my attention on five topics in particular: the prospects for armed conflict in the Taiwan Strait; alliance/alignment politics and the u.s.–China–Taiwan triangular relationship; interactions between domestic politics (in Taipei and Beijing) and the cross-Strait dyadic relationship; cross-Strait economic integration in the shadow of political conflict; and the role of psychology, emotion, and identity in shaping cross-Strait interactions. For each topic, I survey recent studies that apply rigorous international relations theory to the cross-Strait relationship, and where appropriate I make suggestions for further development.

Sections

References

Abdelal Rawi and Kirshner Jonathan (1999/2000) ‘Strategy, economic relations, and the definition of national interests’, Security Studies 9(1/2): 119156.

Baldwin David A. (1985) Economic Statecraft, Princeton, nj: Princeton University Press.

Benson Brett V. (2012) Constructing International Security: Alliances, Deterrence, and Moral Hazard , New York and Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Benson Brett V. and Niou Emerson M.S. (2001) ‘Comprehending strategic ambiguity: u.s. security commitment to Taiwan’, Unpublished manuscript, Duke University.

Benson Brett V. and Niou Emerson M.S. (2007) ‘Economic integration and peace: A game-theoretic analysis’, Journal of East Asian Studies 7(1): 3559.

Brown Melissa J. (2004) Is Taiwan Chinese? The Impact of Culture, Power, and Migration on Changing Identities, Berkeley, ca: University of California Press.

Bush Richard C. (2013) Uncharted Strait: The Future of China-Taiwan Relations. Washington, dc: Brookings Institution.

Cabestan Jean-Pierre (2009) ‘Taiwan: an internal affair! How China’s domestic politics and foreign policy interact on the Taiwan issue?’, East Asia 26: 120.

Chan Steve (2009) ‘Commerce between rivals: Realism, liberalism, and credible communication across the Taiwan Strait’, International Relations of the Asia-Pacific 9(3): 435467.

Chan Steve (2012) ‘Unbalanced threat or rising integration? Explaining relations across the Taiwan Strait’, in Blanchard Jean-Marc F. and Hickey Dennis V. (eds), New Thinking about the Taiwan Issue: Theoretical Insights into its Origins, Dynamics, and Prospects , London and New York: Routledge, 92115.

Chan Steve (2016) China’s Troubled Waters: Maritime Disputes in Theoretical Perspective , Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Chan Steve ; Hu Richard and Sohn Injoo (2013) ‘Politics of détente: Comparing Korea and Taiwan’, Pacific Review 26(2): 199220.

Chen Ching-chang (2012) ‘Useful adversaries: How to understand the political economy of cross-Strait security’, in Blanchard Jean-Marc F. and Hickey Dennis V. (eds), New Thinking about the Taiwan Issue: Theoretical Insights into its Origins, Dynamics, and Prospects , London and New York: Routledge, 4870.

Chen Dean (2014) ‘An indispensable pillar of Obama’s “Pivot” to Asia: Continuing strategic ambiguity across the Taiwan Strait’, in Chow Peter C.Y. (ed), The us Strategic Pivot to Asia and Cross-Strait Relations: Economic and Security Dynamics, New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 3154.

Chen Lu-huei ; Chen Ying-nan and Wang T.Y. (2013) ‘Interest, identity, and people’s preference on the independence issue in Taiwan’, in Hu Weixing (ed), New Dynamics in Cross-Taiwan Strait Relations: How Far Can the Rapprochement Go? New York: Routledge, 153168.

Christensen Thomas J. (1999) ‘China, the u.s.-Japan alliance, and the security dilemma in East Asia’, International Security 23(4): 4980.

Christensen Thomas J. (2001) ‘Posing problems without catching up: China’s rise and challenges for u.s. security policy’, International Security 25(4): 540.

Christensen Thomas J. (2002) ‘The contemporary security dilemma: Deterring a Taiwan conflict’, The Washington Quarterly 25(4): 721.

Christensen Thomas J. (2001/2002) ‘China’, in Ellings Richard J. and Friedberg Aaron L. (eds), Strategic Asia, 2001–02: Power and Purpose. Seattle, wa: National Bureau of Asian Research, 2770.

Christensen Thomas J. (2006) ‘Windows and war: Trend analysis and Beijing’s use of force’, in Johnston Alastair Iain and Ross Robert S. (eds), New Directions in the Study of China’s Foreign Policy, Stanford, ca: Stanford University Press, 5085.

Chu Ming-chin Monique (2015) ‘Rethinking globalization-security linkages with references to the semiconductor industry across the Taiwan Strait’, in Chu Ming-chin Monique and Kastner Scott L. (eds), Globalization and Security Relations across the Taiwan Strait: In the Shadow of China, London and New York: Routledge, 183208.

Chu Yun-han (1997) ‘The political economy of Taiwan’s mainland policy’, Journal of Contemporary China 6(15): 229257.

Dittmer Lowell (1981) ‘The strategic triangle: An elementary game-theoretical analysis’, World Politics 33(4): 484515.

Dittmer Lowell (2005) ‘Bush, China, and Taiwan: A triangular analysis’, Journal of Chinese Political Science 10(2): 2142.

Dittmer Lowell (2014) ‘Taiwan’s narrowing Strait: A triangular analysis of Taiwan’s security since 2008’, in Chow Peter C.Y. (ed), The us Strategic Pivot to Asia and Cross-Strait Relations: Economic and Security Dynamics, New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 1530.

Fearon James D. (1994) ‘Domestic political audiences and the escalation of international disputes’, American Political Science Review 88(3): 577592.

Fearon James D. (1995) ‘Rationalist explanations for war’, International Organization 49(3): 379414.

Feder Don (2002, May 29) ‘It must be clear: u.s. supports Taiwan’, The Boston Herald, 23.

Fravel M. Taylor (2008) Strong Borders Secure Nation: Cooperation and Conflict in China’s Territorial Disputes, Princeton, nj: Princeton University Press.

Fuller Douglas B. (2008) ‘The cross-Strait economic relationship’s impact on development in Taiwan and China: Adversaries and partners’, Asian Survey 48(2): 239264.

Gartzke Erik (1999) ‘War is in the error term’, International Organization 53(3): 567587.

Gartzke Erik and Li Quan (2003) ‘How globalization can reduce international conflict’, in Gleditsch Nils Petter , Schneider Gerald , and Barbieri Katherine (eds), Globalization and Armed Conflict, Lanham, md: Rowman & Littlefield, 123140.

Gartzke Erik and Zhang J. Jack (2015) ‘Trade and war’, in Martin Lisa L. (ed), The Oxford Handbook of the Political Economy of International Trade, New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press, 419438.

Glaser Charles L. (2015) ‘A u.s.-China grand bargain?: The hard choice between military competition and accommodation’, International Security 39(4): 4990.

Hall Todd H. (2011) ‘We will not swallow this bitter fruit: Theorizing a diplomacy of anger’, Security Studies 20(4): 521555.

He Kai and Feng Huiyun (2009) ‘Leadership, regime security, and China’s policy toward Taiwan: Prospect theory and Taiwan crises’, Pacific Review 22(4): 501521.

He Yinan (2014) ‘Identity politics and foreign policy: Taiwan’s relations with China and Japan, 1895–2012’, Political Science Quarterly 129(3): 469500.

Hirschman Albert O. (1945) National Power and the Structure of Foreign Trade, Berkeley, ca: University of California Press.

Hsu S. Philip (2010) ‘Reappraising the debate and practice of us strategic ambiguity/clarity in cross-Strait relations’, Pacific Review 23(2): 139162.

Huang Shuling (2010) ‘Re-mediating identities in the imagined homeland: Taiwanese migrants in China’, PhD thesis, University of Maryland.

Huth Paul K. (1988) ‘Extended deterrence and the outbreak of war’, American Political Science Review 82(2): 423443.

Jacoby Jeff (1996, March 14) ‘Ambiguity invites Taiwan aggression’, The Boston Globe, 19.

Jervis Robert (1978) ‘Cooperation under the security dilemma’, World Politics 30(2): 167214.

Kahler Miles and Kastner Scott L. (2006) ‘Strategic uses of economic interdependence: Engagement policies on the Korean Peninsula and across the Taiwan Strait’, Journal of Peace Research 43(5): 523541.

Kahneman Daniel and Tversky Amos (1979) ‘Prospect theory: An analysis of decision under risk’, Econometrica 47(2): 263292.

Kastner Scott L. (2009) Political Conflict and Economic Interdependence across the Taiwan Strait and Beyond , Stanford, ca: Stanford University Press.

Kastner Scott L. (2015/2016) ‘Is the Taiwan Strait still a flashpoint? Rethinking the prospects for armed conflict between China and Taiwan’, International Security 40(3): 5492.

Kastner Scott L. and Pearson Margaret M. (2016) ‘Winning hearts and minds? On the sources and efficacy of economic engagement policies in us-China and China-Taiwan relations’, in Lobell Steven and Ripsman Norrin (eds), The Political Economy of Regional Peacemaking, Ann Arbor, mi: University of Michigan Press, 144168.

Keng Shu ; Chen Lu-huei and Huang Kuan-po (2006) ‘Sense, sensitivity, and sophistication in shaping the future of cross-Strait relations’, Issues and Studies 42(4): 2366.

Keng Shu and Schubert Gunter (2010) ‘Agents of Taiwan-China unification? The political roles of Taiwanese business people in the process of cross-Strait integration’, Asian Survey 50(2): 287310.

Lake David A. (2010/2011) ‘Two cheers for bargaining theory: Assessing rationalist explanations of the Iraq War’, International Security 35(3): 752.

Lee Chun-yi (2012) Taiwanese Business of Chinese Security Asset? A Changing Pattern of Interaction between Taiwanese Businesses and Chinese Governments, London and New York: Routledge.

Leng Tse-kang (1996) The Taiwan-China Connection: Democracy and Development across the Taiwan Straits, Boulder, co: Westview Press.

Levy Jack S. (1997) ‘Prospect theory, rational choice, and international relations’, International Studies Quarterly 41(1): 87112.

Li Peng (2013) ‘The nature of the Economic Cooperation Framework Agreement and its implications for peaceful development of cross-Strait relations’, in Hu Weixing (ed), New Dynamics in Cross-Taiwan Strait Relations: How Far can the Rapprochement Go? , New York: Routledge, 4759.

Li Yitan (2014) ‘Constructing peace in the Taiwan Strait: A constructivist analysis of the changing dynamics of identities and nationalisms’, Journal of Contemporary China 23(85): 119142.

Li Yitan ; James Patrick and Drury A. Cooper (2009) ‘Diversionary dragons, or “talking tough in Taipei”: Cross-Strait relations in the new millennium’, Journal of East Asian Studies 9(3): 369398.

Lin Gang (2007) ‘ u.s. strategies for maintaining peace across the Taiwan Strait’, Issues and Studies 43(2): 217236.

Lin Syaru Shirly (2016) Taiwan’s China Dilemma: Contested Identities and Multiple Interests in Taiwan’s Cross-Strait Economic Policy, Stanford, ca: Stanford University Press.

Lynch Daniel A. (2004) ‘Taiwan’s self-conscious nation-building project’, Asian Survey 44(4): 513533.

McDonald Patrick J. (2009) The Invisible Hand of Peace: Capitalism, the War Machine, and International Relations Theory , New York and Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Nicholls Natsuko H. ; Huth Paul K. , and Appel Benjamin J. (2010) ‘When is domestic political unrest related to international conflict? Diversionary theory and Japanese foreign policy, 1890–1941’, International Studies Quarterly 54: 915937.

Pan Chengxin (2012) ‘Normative convergence and cross-Strait divergence: Westphalian sovereignty as an ideational source of the Taiwan conflict’, in Blanchard Jean-Marc F. and Hickey Dennis V. (eds), New Thinking about the Taiwan Issue: Theoretical Insights into its Origins, Dynamics, and Prospects , London and New York: Routledge, 2847.

Pan Zhongqi (2003) ‘ u.s. policy of strategic ambiguity: A dilemma of deterrence’, Journal of Contemporary China 12(35): 387407.

Powell Robert (2002) ‘Bargaining theory and international conflict’, Annual Review of Political Science 5(June): 130.

Putnam Robert D. (1988) ‘Diplomacy and domestic politics: The logic of two-level games’, International Organization 42(3): 427460.

Reed William (2003) ‘Information, power, and war’, American Political Science Review 97(4): 633641.

Reiter Dan (1995) ‘Exploding the Powder Keg Myth: Preemptive wars almost never happen’, International Security 20(2): 534.

Reiter Dan (2003) ‘Exploring the bargaining model of war’, Perspectives on Politics 1(1): 2747.

Rigger Shelley (1999) ‘Competing conceptions of Taiwan identity: The irresolvable conflict in cross-Strait relations’, in Zhao Suisheng (ed), Across the Taiwan Strait: Mainland China, Taiwan, and the 19951996 Crisis, New York and London: Routledge, 229240.

Romberg Alan D. (2003) Rein in at the Brink of the Precipice: American Policy toward Taiwan and u.s.-prc Relations , Washington, dc: Henry L. Stimson Center.

Ross Robert S. (2000) ‘The 1995–96 Taiwan Strait confrontation: Coercion, credibility, and the use of force’, International Security 25(2): 87123.

Ross Robert S. (2002) ‘Navigating the Taiwan Strait: Deterrence, escalation dominance, and u.s.-China relations’, International Security 27(2): 4785.

Ross Robert S. (2006) ‘Comparative deterrence: The Taiwan Strait and the Korean Peninsula’, in Johnston Alastair Iain and Ross Robert S. (eds), New Directions in the Study of China’s Foreign Policy, Stanford, ca: Stanford University Press, 1349.

Saunders Phillip C. and Kastner Scott L. (2009) ‘Bridge over troubled water? Envisioning a China-Taiwan peace agreement’, International Security 33(1): 87114.

Schelling Thomas C. (1960) The Strategy of Conflict, Cambridge, ma: Harvard University Press.

Schelling Thomas C. (1966) Arms and Influence, New Haven, ct: Yale University Press.

Schubert Gunter (2004) ‘Taiwan’s political parties and national identity: The rise of an overarching consensus’, Asian Survey 44(4): 534554.

Schubert Gunter (2010) ‘The political thinking of the mainland taishang: Some preliminary observations from the field’, Journal of Current Chinese Affairs 39(1): 73110.

Schubert Gunter ; Lin Rui-hua and Tseng Yu-chen (2016) ‘Taishang studies: A rising or declining research field?’, China Perspectives 1: 2936.

Schultz Kenneth A. (2001) Democracy and Coercive Diplomacy, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Shirk Susan L. (2007) China, Fragile Superpower: How China’s Internal Politics Could Derail its Peaceful Rise , New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Sullivan Jonathan (2011) ‘Understanding and measuring “Taiwan independence” in presidential discourse’, Journal of East Asian Studies 11(1): 137144.

Sutter Robert (2011) Taiwan’s Future: Narrowing Straits, nbr Analysis 96(May): Seattle, wa: National Bureau of Asian Research.

Tanner Murray Scot (2007) Chinese Economic Coercion against Taiwan: A Tricky Weapon to Use, Santa Monica, ca: rand Corporation.

Tian John Q. (2006) Government, Business, and the Politics of Interdependence and Conflict across the Taiwan Strait, New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

Tomz Michael (2007) ‘Domestic audience costs in international relations: An experimental approach’, International Organization 61(4): 821840.

Tung Chen-yuan (2003) ‘Cross-Strait economic relations: China’s leverage and Taiwan’s vulnerability’, Issues and Studies 39(3): 137175.

Van Evera Stephen (1999) Causes of War: Power and the Roots of Conflict, Ithaca, ny: Cornell University Press.

Wang T.Y. ; Cheng Su-feng ; Yu Ching-hsin and Chen Lu-huei (2012) ‘Structural realism and liberal pluralism: An assessment of Ma Ying-jeou’s cross-Strait policy’, in Blanchard Jean-Marc F. and Hickey Dennis V. (eds), New Thinking about the Taiwan Issue: Theoretical Insights into its Origins, Dynamics, and Prospects , London and New York: Routledge, 137152.

Wang Vincent W. (2008) ‘The impact of Taiwan’s 2008 elections on cross-Strait relations: A game theoretical analysis’, Asian Perspective 32(2): 145172.

Weeks Jessica L. (2008) ‘Autocratic audience costs: Regime type and signaling resolve’, International Organization 62(1): 3564.

Wei Chi-hung (2015) ‘Producing and reproducing the 1992 consensus: The sociolinguistic construction of the political economy of China-Taiwan relations’, Asian Security 11(1): 7288.

Wei Chi-hung and Lai Christina J. (2017) ‘Identities, rationality and Taiwan’s China policy: The dynamics of cross-Strait exchanges’, Asian Studies Review 41(1): 136154.

Weiss Jessica Chen (2014) Powerful Patriots: Nationalist Protest in China’s Foreign Relations, New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Wong Seanon S. (2005) ‘Economic statecraft across the Strait: Business influence in Taiwan’s mainland policy’, Asian Perspective 29(2): 4172.

Wong Stan Hok-wui and Wu Nicole (2016) ‘Can Beijing buy Taiwan? An empirical assessment of Beijing’s agricultural trade concessions to Taiwan’, Journal of Contemporary China 25(99): 353371.

Wu Yu-shan (1995) ‘Economic reform, cross-Straits relations, and the politics of issue linkage’, in Cheng Tun-jen , Huang Chi , and Wu Samuel S.G. (eds), Inherited Rivalry: Conflict across the Taiwan Straits, Boulder, co: Lynne Rienner Publishers, 111133.

Wu Yu-shan (2000) ‘Theorizing on relations across the Taiwan Strait: Nine contending approaches’, Journal of Contemporary China 9(25): 407428.

Wu Yu-shan (2005) ‘From romantic triangle to marriage? Washington-Beijing-Taipei relations in historical perspective’, Issues and Studies 41(1): 113159.

Wu Yu-shan (2015) ‘Under the shadow of a rising China: Convergence toward hedging and the peculiar case of Taiwan’, in Chu Ming-chin Monique and Kastner Scott L. (eds), Globalization and Security Relations across the Taiwan Strait: In the Shadow of China, London and New York: Routledge, 2441.

Yu Yi-wen ; Yu Ko-chia , and Lin Tse-chun (2016) ‘Political economy of cross-Strait relations: Is Beijing’s patronage policy on Taiwanese businesses sustainable?’, Journal of Contemporary China 25(99): 372388.

Zhang Baohui (2011) ‘Taiwan’s new grand strategy’, Journal of Contemporary China 20(69): 269285.

Zhang Baohui (2013) ‘Peaceful unification vs. divided rule: Assessing political relations across the Taiwan Strait’, in Hu Weixing (ed), New Dynamics in Cross-Taiwan Strait Relations: How Far can the Rapprochement Go? , New York: Routledge, 115129.

Zhang Qingmin (2006) ‘Two steps forward, one step back: Domestic politics and prc’s “dual-track” Taiwan policy’, in Hua Shiping (ed), Reflections on the Triangular Relations of Beijing-Taipei-Washington since 1995: Status Quo at the Taiwan Straits?, New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 3563.

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 57 57 36
Full Text Views 24 24 17
PDF Downloads 5 5 3
EPUB Downloads 3 3 2