How are we to understand China’s decades-long sovereignty claim over Taiwan? One assumption upheld by many international relations scholars is that state behaviour will change according to a variance of polarity in the international system. Yet while China can flexibly manage its territorial issues elsewhere, its goal of unification with Taiwan has not changed despite multiple structural changes in the international system over the decades. This paper argues that historical and nationalist approaches alone do not explain China’s unswaying obsession with this island. Geopolitics plays a far more prominent role in the minds of Chinese leaders than scholars have previously acknowledged. Since 1949, China has viewed Taiwan as a geopolitical buffer protecting the security of Chinese coastal areas. China’s buffer thinking towards Taiwan was a significant factor in China’s decisions to launch military action against Taiwan in 1954, 1958, and 1996.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
Anonymous (1985) 清實錄 [The Veritable Records of the Qing Dynasty], Vol. 5, Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company.
Apple Daily (2016) ‘違規操作港台敏感事件環時遭中共勒令整改’ [Illegally hypes the sensitive issue about Hong Kong and Taiwan, the Global Times was forced to rectify and reform by the ccp], 13 May.
Bush, Richard (2005) Untying the Knot: Making Peace in the Taiwan Strait, Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.
Buzan Barry and Wæver, Ole (2003) Regions and Powers: The Structure of International Security, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
ccp >Central Literature Editorial Committee (ed.) (1994) ‘答美國記者麥可華萊士’ [Answers to questions of American reporter Michael Wallace], in 鄧小平文選 [The Selected Works of Deng Xiaoping], Beijing: People’s Press, 167–175.
ccp Central Literature Editorial Committee (ed.) (2006) ‘國際形勢和軍事戰略方針’ [The international situation and the guideline of military strategy]’, in 江澤民文選 [The Selected Works of Jiang Zemin], Vol. 1, Beijing: People’s Press, 278–294.
Chang, Gordon and He, Di (1993) ‘The absence of war in the U.S.-China confrontation over Quemoy and Matsu in 1954–1955: Contingency, luck, deterrence’, American Historical Review 98(5): 1507–1511.
Chan, John (2008) ‘Russia and China settle longstanding territorial disputes’, World Socialist Web Site, 14 August. Retrieved 3 May 2021 from https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2008/08/ruch-a14.html.
Chay, John and Ross, Thomas (eds) (1986) Buffer States in World Politics, Boulder, CO, and London: Westview Press.
Chen, Yi (1992) ‘目前國際形勢和我們的外交政策’ [The current interational situation and our foreign policy], in Li-Min Guo (ed.), 中共對台政策資料選輯: 1949–1991 [Selected Works on Mainland China’s Policy Toward Taiwan: 1949–1991], Vol. 1, Taipei: Lifework Press, 151–153.
Christensen, Thomas (1996) Useful Adversaries: Grand Strategy, Domestic Mobilization, and Sino-American Conflict, 1947–1958, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Christensen, Thomas (2001) ‘China’, in Richard Ellings and Aaron Friedberg (eds), Strategic Asia 2001–02: Power and Purpose, Seattle, WA: National Bureau of Asian Research, 26–70.
Cole, Bernard (2001) The Great Wall at Sea: China’s Navy Enters the Twenty-First Century, Annapolis, MD: Naval Institute Press.
cpc News (1922) ‘中國共產黨第二次全國代表大會宣言’ [The Manifesto of the 2nd Party Congress], cpc Party Congress Database, 16–23 July. Retrieved 3 May 2021 from http://cpc.people.com.cn/GB/64162/64168/64554/4428164.html.
Fazal, Tanisha (2007) State Death: The Politics and Geography of Conquest, Occupation, and Annexation, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Fravel, Taylor (2008) Strong Borders, Secure Nation: Cooperation and Conflict in China’s Territorial Disputes, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Garver, John (1997) Face Off: China, the United States, and Taiwan’s Democratization, Seattle and London: University of Washington Press.
George, Alexander and Smoke, Richard (1974) Deterrence in American Foreign Policy: Theory and Practice, New York: Columbia University Press.
Gilpin, Robert (1981) War and Change in World Politics, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Gries, Peter Hays (2004) China’s New Nationalism: Pride, Politics, and Diplomacy, Berkeley: University of California Press.
Guan, Jie (1995) ‘中共對美台新政策’ [The new ccp’s policy on US and Taiwan], 動向[Trend] 7: 20–21.
He, Di (1988) ‘臺海危機和中國對金門馬祖政策的形成’ [The Taiwan Straits Crises and the formation of Chinese policy on Jinmen and Mazu], 美國研究 [American Studies Quarterly] 3: 40–65.
Ho, Songling and Chi, Diantang (2003) ‘中國周邊海域的戰略地位和地緣戰略價值初探’ [A discussion on the value of waters around China in terms of strategic position and geostrategy], 當代亞太 [Journal of Contemporary Asia-Pacific Studies] 10: 47–52.
Hughes, Christopher (2011) ‘Reclassifying Chinese nationalism: The geopolitik turn’, Journal of Contemporary China 20(71): 601–620.
Ji, You (1997) ‘Making sense of war games in the Taiwan Strait’, Journal of Contemporary China 6(15): 287–305.
Le, Cheng and White, Lynn (1993) ‘The army in the succession to Deng Xiaoping: Familiar fealties and technocratic trends’, Asian Survey 33(8): 757–786.
Lin, Hsiao-ting (2016) Accidental State: Chiang Kai-shek, the United States, and the Making of Taiwan, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Liu, Huaqing (2008) ‘海軍戰略與未來海上作戰’ [The naval strategy and future warfare on the sea], in 劉華清軍事文選 [The Selected Military Works of Liu Huaqing], Vol. 1, Beijing: pla Publishing House, 456–488.
Liu, Shaoqi (1992) ‘在中國共產黨八全大會的政治工作報告’ [The report on political work at the 8th National Congress of the ccp], in Li-Min Guo (ed.), 中共對台政策資料選輯: 1949–1991 [Selected Works on Mainland China’s Policy Toward Taiwan: 1949–1991], Vol. 1, Taipei: Lifework Press, 150.
Liu, Xiaoyuan (1996) A Partnership for Disorder: China, the United States, and Their Policies for the Postwar Disposition of the Japanese Empire, 1941–1945, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Lu, Junyuan (1996) ‘地緣戰略中的台灣及其對大國安全的作用’ [Taiwan in the geostrategy and its security function to great powers], 台灣研究 [Taiwan Studies] 1: 33–37.
Luo, Bin (1996) ‘中共耀武耗資三十億’ [The show of force of the ccp costs three billion dollars], 動向 [Trend] 4: 9–11.
Mao, Zedong (1993) ‘空軍要全力以赴務殲入侵之敵’ [The Air Force has to do its best to extinguish the invading enemy], in Mao Zedong (ed.), 毛澤東軍事文集 [The Selected Military Writings of Mao Zedong], Vol. 6, Beijing: Military Science Press & Central Party Literature Press, 373.
Mearsheimer, John (1990) ‘Back to the future: Instability in Europe after the Cold War’, International Security 15(1): 5–56.
Morgenthau, Hans (2006) Politics Among Nations: The Struggle for Power and Peace, New York: McGraw-Hill Education.
Nakamori, Kawasugi (2010a) ‘危機與抉擇:中國台海危機時期的戰略與系統1’ [China’s strategy and system during the Taiwan Straits Crisis I], 海陸空天慣性世界 [naas & International Technology] 85: 2–14.
Nakamori, Kawasugi (2010b) ‘危機與抉擇:中國台海危機時期的戰略與系統2’ [China’s strategy and system during the Taiwan Straits Crisis ii], 海陸空天慣性世界 [naas & International Technology] 86: 2–13.
Nakamori, Kawasugi (2010c) ‘危機與抉擇:中國台海危機時期的戰略與系統3’ [China’s strategy and system during the Taiwan Straits Crisis iii], 海陸空天慣性世界 [naas & International Technology] 87: 2–13.
National Archives Administration of China (ed.) (1991a) ‘論新階段’ [On the New Stage], in 中共中央文獻選集 [Selection of Documents of the ccp Central Committee], Vol. 11, Beijing: ccp Central Party School Press, 557–662.
National Archives Administration of China (ed.) (1991b) ‘中央關於中原軍須求經濟自救與準備突圍給鄭位三等的指示’ [The ccp Central’s instruction to Zheng Weisan and others on that the Zhongyuan Force has to economically save itself and be ready to break through the encirclement], in 中共中央文獻選集 [Selection of Documents of the ccp Central Committee], Vol. 16, Beijing: ccp Central Party School Press, 181–182.
National Archives Administration of China (ed.) (1994) ‘和平共處五原則應推廣到所有國家關系去’ [The five principles of peaceful coexistence should be promoted to the relations with all of states], 毛澤東外交文選 [Selected Works of Mao Zedong on Diplomacy], Beijing: Central Documentary Research Office, 163–176.
Niu, Jun (2004) ‘三次台灣海峽軍事鬥爭決策研究’ [Chinese decision-making on three military actions across the Taiwan Straits], 中國社會科學 [Social Science in China] 5: 37–50.
Office of Party History Work of the ccp Jiangsu Provincial Committee (ed.) (2006) 粟裕年譜 [The Chronological Record of Su Yu], Beijing: Contemporary China Publishing House.
Organski, A. F. K., and Kugler, Jacek (1980) The War Ledger, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Pang, Jia-jung (2010) 情報札記:台灣軍情高官回憶錄 [Intelligence Note: The Memoirs of a Senior Official at Taiwan Military Intelligence Bureau], Hong Kong: Xianggang wenhuayishu chubanshe.
Peng, Dehuai (1988) ‘把我軍建設成優良的現代化的革命軍隊’ [Building our army into an excellent modernised revolution army], in the Editing Group of Peng Dehuai Biography (ed.), 彭德懷軍事文選 [The Selected Military Works of Peng Dehuai], Beijing: Central Party Literature Press.
People’s Daily (1949) ‘中國人民一定要解放台灣’ [Chinese people must liberate Taiwan], 15 March.
People’s Daily (1958) ‘駁斥美國國務卿杜勒斯在聯合國大會上的發言’ [Rebutting US Secretary of State Dulles’ comments at the UN General Assembly], 21 September.
People’s Daily (1993) ‘台獨是一條危險的道路’ [Taiwan independence is a dangerous road], 3 June.
People’s Daily (1995a) ‘我外交部發表聲明提出抗議就美國政府宣布允許李登輝進行所謂私人訪問’ [Our Ministry of Foreign Affairs issued a strong statement opposing US government issuing Lee Teng-Hui visa to conduct so-called private visit], 23 May.
People’s Daily (1995b) ‘美國究竟要把中美關係引向何方’ [Where does the US want to lead the Sino-American relations to]?, 18 June.
People’s Liberation Army Historical Material Series Editorial Oversight Board (ed.) (2009) 總參謀部大事記 [The Chronology of the PLA General Staff Department], Beijing: Lantain chubanshe.
Rigger, Shelley (2011) Why Taiwan Matters: Small Island, Global Power House, Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
Ross, Robert (2000) ‘The 1995–96 Taiwan Strait confrontation: Coercion, credibility, and the use of force’, International Security 25(2): 87–123.
Ross, Robert (2009) ‘China’s naval nationalism: Sources, prospects, and the U.S. response’, International Security 34(2): 46–81.
Shen, Zhihua (2014a) ‘羅申致斯大林電: 毛澤東通知中國決定出兵朝鮮’ [Roshchin’s cable to Stalin: Mao Zedong informs China’s decision of sending troops to North Korea], in Zhihua Shen (ed.), 中蘇關係:俄國檔案館解密文件選編 [Sino-Soviet Relations: The Selected Declassified Documents in Russian Archives], Vol. 3, Shanghai: Orient Publishing Center, 96–97.
Shen, Zhihua (2014b) ‘馬林科夫與周恩來會談紀要: 重新將解放台灣提上議程’ [The summary of meeting record between Malenkov and Zhou Enlai: Putting the liberation of Taiwan back on the schedule], in Zhihua Shen (ed.), 中蘇關係:俄國檔案館解密文件選編 [Sino-Soviet Relations: The Selected Declassified Documents in Russian Archives], Vol. 5, Shanghai: Orient Publishing Center, 101.
Shen, Zhihua (2014c) ‘羅邁進與周恩來談話紀要: 中國關於解決台灣問題的方案’ [The Memorandum of Conversation between Luomaijin and Zhou Enlai: On China’s plan for solving the Taiwan issue], in Zhihua Shen (ed.), 中蘇關係:俄國檔案館解密文件選編 [Sino-Soviet Relations: The Selected Declassified Documents in Russian Archives], Vol. 5, Shanghai: Orient Publishing Center, 346.
Shirk, Susan (2007) China: Fragile Superpower: How China’s Internal Politics Could Derail Its Peaceful Rise, New York: Oxford University Press.
Sidorov, Andrey (2014) ‘Russia’s territorial disputes with China and Japan: A comparative analysis’, Journal of Territorial and Maritime Studies 1(2): 97–114.
Snow, Edgar (1973) Red Star over China, London: Victor Gollancz.
Spykman, Nicholas and Rollins, Abbie (1939) ‘Geographic objectives in foreign policy, I’, American Political Science Review 33(3): 391–410.
Swaine, Michael (2001) ‘Chinese decision-making regarding Taiwan, 1979–2000’, in David Lampton (ed.), The Making of Chinese Foreign and Security Policy in the Era of Reform, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 289–336.
Tsai, Henry Shin-Shan (2009) Maritime Taiwan: Historical Encounters with the East and the West, Armonk, NY, and London: M. E. Sharp.
Tucker, Nancy (2009) Strait Talk: United States-Taiwan Relations and the Crisis with China, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Valeriano, Brandon and Van Benthuysen, John (2012) ‘When states die: Geographic and territorial pathways to state death’, Third World Quarterly 33(7): 1165–1189.
Wachman, Alan (2008) Why Taiwan? Geostrategic Rationales for China’s Territorial Integrity, Singapore: nus Press.
Waltz, Kenneth (1979) Theory of International Politics, Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
Wang, Yan (ed.) (1998) 彭德懷年譜 [The Chronological Record of Peng Dehuai], Beijing: People’s Publishing House.
Weiss, Jessica Chen (2019) ‘How hawkish is the Chinese public? Another look at “rising nationalism” and Chinese foreign policy’, Journal of Contemporary China 28(119): 679–695.
Whiting, Allen (2001) ‘China’s use of force, 1950–96, and Taiwan’, International Security 26(2): 103–131.
Xu, Yan (2010) 金門之戰:1949–1959 [The Jinmen War: 1949–1959], Shenyang: Shengyang renmin chubanshe.
Yang, Kuisong (2003) ‘毛澤東與兩次臺海危機: 20世紀50年代中後期中國對美國政策變動原因及趨向 (續)’ [Mao Zedong and the two Taiwan Strait Crises ii], 史學月刊 [Journal of Historical Science] 12: 48–55.
Ye, Fei (1988) 葉飛回憶錄 [The Memoirs of Ye Fei], Beijing: pla Publishing House.
Yue, Shang (1995) ‘江澤民對槍桿子的軟化’ [The Jiang Core accommodated the military], 動向 [Trend] 12: 13–14.
Zhang, Shuguang (1992) Deterrence and Strategic Culture: Chinese-American Confrontations, 1949–1958, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University.
Zhang, Wenmu (2003) ‘論中國海權’ [On China’s sea power], 世界政治與經濟 [World Economics and Politics] 10: 8–14.
Zhang, Zhen (2003), 張震回憶錄 [The Memoirs of Zhang Zhen], Beijing: pla Publishing House.
Zhang, Zhen (ed.) (2004) ‘對蔣匪所謂反攻大陸的剖視’ [An analysis of Chiang’s military rollback to the Chinese Mainland], in 張震軍事文選 [Selected Military Works of Zhang Zhen], Vol. 1, Beijing: pla Publishing House.
Zhao, Suisheng (2013) ‘Foreign policy implications of Chinese nationalism revisited: The strident turn’, Journal of Contemporary China 22(82): 535–553.
Zhou, Shuchun and Ding, Qilin (1993) ‘江澤民論中美關係等七大問題’ [Jiang Zemin talks about the seven questions including Sino-American relations], People’s Daily, 9 March.
Zhou, Zhihuai (1998) ‘關於1995–1996 台海危機的思考’ [About the thinking on the Taiwan Strait Crisis of 1995–1996], 台灣研究集刊 [Taiwan Research Quarterly] 2: 1–7.
Zhou, Zhongfei (1996) ‘台灣問題中的美國因素: 從導彈演習看亞太大國關係’ [The American factor in the Taiwan issue: Analysing great power relations in Asia from the missile exercise], 世界經濟研究 [World Economy Studies] 3: 27–30.
Zhu, Tingchang (2001) ‘論台灣的地緣戰略地位’ [On Taiwan’s geostrategic position], 世界政治與經濟論壇 [Forum of World Economics & Politics] 3: 66–69.
All Time | Past Year | Past 30 Days | |
---|---|---|---|
Abstract Views | 344 | 199 | 45 |
Full Text Views | 179 | 176 | 8 |
PDF Views & Downloads | 312 | 300 | 21 |
How are we to understand China’s decades-long sovereignty claim over Taiwan? One assumption upheld by many international relations scholars is that state behaviour will change according to a variance of polarity in the international system. Yet while China can flexibly manage its territorial issues elsewhere, its goal of unification with Taiwan has not changed despite multiple structural changes in the international system over the decades. This paper argues that historical and nationalist approaches alone do not explain China’s unswaying obsession with this island. Geopolitics plays a far more prominent role in the minds of Chinese leaders than scholars have previously acknowledged. Since 1949, China has viewed Taiwan as a geopolitical buffer protecting the security of Chinese coastal areas. China’s buffer thinking towards Taiwan was a significant factor in China’s decisions to launch military action against Taiwan in 1954, 1958, and 1996.
All Time | Past Year | Past 30 Days | |
---|---|---|---|
Abstract Views | 344 | 199 | 45 |
Full Text Views | 179 | 176 | 8 |
PDF Views & Downloads | 312 | 300 | 21 |