The Ordinary Virtue and Moral Significance of Health Systems: the Case of Taiwan
In: International Journal of Taiwan StudiesSearch for other papers by Ming-Jui Yeh in
Current site
Google Scholar
Abstract
The ordinary virtue of health systems is to secure some form of equitable access to health services for all in pursuit of the ideal of universal health coverage, which would sometimes be considered an integral part of the overall institutional arrangements protecting the human right to health. The history of human-established health systems has come close to an end. In this article, I use the Taiwanese health system as an illustrative case to demonstrate how the roles of a health system vary in different periods across multiple colonial histories. It was not until the 1990s, after Taiwan went through democratisation, that the health system began to display ordinary virtue. I further argue that, beyond the ordinary virtue, the Taiwanese health system has moral significance in (1) integrating divided and conflicting identities and forging a new, forward-looking one; and (2) representing Taiwanese people’s declaration against exclusionary global politics by devoting themselves to a space that protects the right to health and a way of life that cherishes the value of equitable access to health services for all.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Anderson, Michael and Mossialos, Elias (2022) ‘Are we heading for a two tier healthcare system in the UK?’, bmj 376: o618.
-
Andrade, Tonio (2008) How Taiwan Became Chinese: Dutch, Spanish, and Han Colonization in the Seventeenth Century, New York: Columbia University Press.
-
Azevedo, Mario J. (2017) ‘The colonial medical system(s) and the health of Africans’, in Mario J. Azevedo (ed.), Historical Perspectives on the State of Health and Health Systems in Africa, Vol. 1, London: Palgrave Macmillan, 183–214.
-
Bump, Jesse B. (2015) ‘The long road to Universal Health Coverage: Historical analysis of early decisions in Germany, the United Kingdom, and the United States’, Health Systems & Reform 1(1): 28–38.
-
Bump, Jesse B; Friberg, Peter; and Harper, David R. (2021) ‘International collaboration and Covid-19: What are we doing and where are we going?’, bmj 372: n180.
-
Chang, Hsiu-Jung (ed.) (2015) 日治臺灣醫療公衛五十年（修訂版） [Fifty Years of Advancement: A Collection of Taiwan’s Medical and Public Health Records under Japanese Colonial Rule (Revised Version)], Taipei: National Taiwan University Press.
-
Chang, Parris and Lim, Kok-ui (1996) ‘Taiwan’s case for United Nations membership’, uclaJournal of International Law and Foreign Affairs 1(2): 393–430.
-
Chang, Ying-Hwa; Tu, Su-hao; and Liao, Pei-shan (2012) 台灣社會變遷基本調查計畫第六期第二次調查計畫執行報告 [2011 Taiwan Social Change Survey (Round 6, Year 2) Executive Report], Taipei: Institute of Sociology, Academia Sinica.
-
Chang, Zackary Zong Kun (2022) ‘我國勞動基準法制的形成’ [Formation of the Taiwan Labor Standard Regulation, 1927–1984], unpublished ma thesis, Graduate Institute of Labor Research, National Chengchi University, Taipei, Taiwan.
-
Chen, Edward I. te (1972) ‘Formosan political movements under Japanese colonial rule, 1914–1937’, Journal of Asian Studies 31(3): 477–497.
-
Chen, Lung-chu (2016) The U.S.-Taiwan-China Relationship in International Law and Policy, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
-
Chen, Shu-Fen (2000) 戰後之疫: 台灣的公共衛生問題與建制(1945–1954) [Plagues after the War: The Problems and Contributions of Taiwan Public Health (1945–1954)], Taipei County: Dawshiang.
-
Cheng, Tsung-Mei (2015) ‘Reflections on the 20th anniversary of Taiwan’s Single-Payer National Health Insurance System’, Health Affairs 34(3): 502–510.
-
Chiang, Huang-Chih and Hwang, Jau-Yuan (2008) ‘On the statehood of Taiwan: A legal reappraisal’, in Peter C. Y. Chow (ed.), The ‘One China’ Dilemma, New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 57–80.
-
Chiang, Tung-Liang (1997) ‘Taiwan’s 1995 health care reform’, Health Policy 39(3): 225–239.
-
Ching, Leo T. S. (2001) Becoming Japanese: Colonial Taiwan and the Politics of Identity Formation, Berkeley: University of California Press.
-
Chou, Wan-yao (2015) A New Illustrated History of Taiwan, Taipei: SMC Publishing.
-
Ellen, J. Amster (2022) ‘The past, present and future of race and colonialism in medicine’, Canadian Medical Association Journal 194(20): E708.
-
Eskildsen, Robert (2005) ‘Taiwan: A periphery in search of a narrative’, Journal of Asian Studies 64(2): 281–294.
-
Fann, Yen-chiou (1998) ‘新醫學在臺灣的實踐 (1898–1906): 從後藤新平《國家衛生原理》談起’ [The practice of modern medicine in colonial Taiwan (1898–1906): Goto Shinpei’s Theory of State Hygiene], New History 9(3): 49–86.
-
Fu, Li-Yeh (1993) ‘台灣社會保險制度的社會控制本質’ [The social insurance system in Taiwan: A social control explanation], Taiwan: A Radical Quarterly in Social Studies 15: 39–64.
-
Fukuyama, Francis (1989) ‘The end of history?’, The National Interest 16: 3–18.
-
Ghebreyesus, Tedros Adhanom (2017) ‘All roads lead to universal health coverage’, The Lancet Global Health 5(9): e839–e840.
-
Goto, Shinpei ([1900] 2015) ‘後藤民政長官演敘醫學篇’ [Government-General of Taiwan Chief Civil Administrator Goto’s speech addressing the importance of medicine], in Hsiu-Jung Chang (ed.), 日治臺灣醫療公衛五十年（修訂版） [Fifty Years of Advancement: A Collection of Taiwan’s Medical and Public Health Records under Japanese Colonial Rule (Revised Version)], Taipei: National Taiwan University Press, 431–436.
-
Greer, Scott L. (2020) ‘National, European, and global solidarity: covid-19’, Eurohealth 26(2): 104–108.
-
Ho, Ming-sho (2010) ‘Understanding the trajectory of social movements in Taiwan (1980–2010)’, Journal of Current Chinese Affairs 39(3): 3–22.
-
Holliday, Ian (2000) ‘Productivist welfare capitalism: Social policy in East Asia’, Political Studies 48(4): 706–723.
-
Hsu, Feng-Yuan (2018) ‘戰後臺灣霍亂的防治(1945–1947)’ [The study of cholera prevention in Taiwan after World War ii, 1945–1947], Archives Semiannual 17(1): 40–55.
-
Huang, Eric Ting-Lun (2003) ‘Taiwan’s status in a changing world: United Nations representation and membership for Taiwan’, Annual Survey of International & Comparative Law 9: 55–100.
-
Ignatieff, Michael (2017) The Ordinary Virtues: Moral Order in a Divided World, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
-
Kerr, George H. (1965) Formosa Betrayed, Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin.
-
Kuo, Wen-Hua (2002) ‘When state and policies reproduce each other: Making Taiwan a population control policy; making a population control policy for Taiwan’, in Alan K. L. Chan, Gregory K. Clancey, and Hui-Chieh Loy (eds), Historical Perspectives on East Asian Science, Technology and Medicine, Singapore: Singapore University Press; London: World Scientific Publishing, 121–137.
-
Lai, Chin-Hsiang (2015) 傳染病與228 [Infectious Disease and the 228 Incident], Taipei: Wu San-Lien Taiwanese Historical Source Foundation.
-
Lee, Po-Han and Kao, Ying-Chao (2022) ‘Health apartheid during Covid-19: A decolonial critique of racial politics between Taiwan and the who’, International Journal of Taiwan Studies 5(2): 375–402.
-
Lee, Po-Han and Yeh, Ming-Jui (2022) ‘From security to solidarity: The normative foundation of a global pandemic treaty’, Journal of Global Health 12: 03025.
-
Lee, Sang-Yi; Chun, Chang-Bae; Lee, Yong-Gab; and Seo, Nam Kyu (2008) ‘The National Health Insurance System as one type of new typology: The case of South Korea and Taiwan’, Health Policy 85(1): 105–113.
-
Lee, Tzu-wen (1996) ‘The international legal status of the Republic of China on Taiwan’, uclaJournal of International Law and Foreign Affairs 1(2): 351–392.
-
Li, Shu Jung (2022) ‘Working poor in Taiwan: Profile and policy response’, Journal of Asian Public Policy 15(1): 43–59.
-
Liang, Li-Fang (2021) ‘Everyday vulnerability: Work and health experiences of live-in migrant care workers in Taiwan’, in Vincent Horn, Cornelia Schweppe, Anita Böcker, and Maria Bruquetas-Callejo (eds), The Global Old Age Care Industry: Tapping into Migrants for Tackling the Old Age Care Crisis, Singapore: Springer Nature, 219–242.
-
Liao, Ping-hui and Wang, David Der-wei (2006) Taiwan Under Japanese Colonial Rule, 1895–1945, New York: Columbia University Press.
-
Lin, Hsiao-ting (2016) Accidental State: Chiang Kai-shek, the United States, and the Making of Taiwan, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
-
Lin, Hsiao-ting (2021) 蔣經國的台灣時代：中華民國與冷戰下的台灣 [The Chiang Ching-kuo Era: The Republic of China on Taiwan in the Cold War], New Taipei City: Walkers.
-
Liu, Michael Shiyung (2004) ‘Building a strong and healthy empire: The critical period of building colonial medicine in Taiwan’, Japanese Studies 24(3): 301–314.
-
Liu, Michael Shiyung (2009) Prescribing Colonization: The Role of Medical Practices and Policies in Japan-Ruled Taiwan, 1895–1945, New York: Columbia University Press.
-
Lu, Jui-Fen Rachel and Chiang, Tung-Liang (2011) ‘Evolution of Taiwan’s health care system’, Health Economics, Policy and Law 6(1): 85–107.
-
Lu, Jui-Fen Rachel and Chiang, Tung-Liang (2018) ‘Developing an adequate supply of health services: Taiwan’s path to Universal Health Coverage’, Social Science & Medicine 198: 7–13.
-
Lue, Jen-Der (2014) ‘Globalisation, democratisation and the institutional transformation of Taiwan’s welfare regime’, Social Policy and Society 13(2): 275–284.
-
Ministry of Health and Welfare (mohw) (2023) ‘112年7月1日正式實施健保部分負擔調整方案’ [The new National Health Insurance co-payment adjustment program is to be implemented on 1 July 2023], 21 June 2023. Retrieved 24 April 2024 from https://www.mohw.gov.tw/cp-6563-74962-1.html.
-
National Health Insurance Administration (nhia) (2018) 2018–2019全民健康保險年報 [2018–2019 National Health Insurance Annual Report], Taipei: Ministry of Health and Welfare.
-
Papanicolas, Irene; Rajan, Dheepa; Karanikolos, Marina; Soucat, Agnes; and Figueras, Josep (2022) Health System Performance Assessment: A Framework for Policy Analysis (Health Policy Series, No. 57), Geneva: World Health Organization and the European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies.
-
Peng, Huan-Sheng and Chu, Jo-Ying (2017) ‘Japan’s colonial policies—from national assimilation to the Kominka Movement: A comparative study of primary education in Taiwan and Korea (1937–1945)’, Paedagogica Historica 53(4): 441–459.
-
Rabkin, Jeremy (2012) ‘American exceptionalism and the healthcare reform debate’, Harvard Journal of Law & Public Policy 35(1): 153–170.
-
Ray, Lana; Wylie, Lloy; and Corrado, Ann Marie (2022) ‘Shapeshifters, systems thinking and settler colonial logic: Expanding the framework of analysis of Indigenous health equity’, Social Science & Medicine 300: 114422.
-
Roberts, Marc J.; Hsiao, William; Berman, Peter; and Reich, Michael R. (2008) Getting Health Reform Right: A Guide to Improving Performance and Equity, New York: Oxford University Press.
-
Rodwin, Victor G. (1987) ‘American exceptionalism in the health sector: The advantages of “backwardness” in learning from abroad’, Medical Care Review 44(1): 119–154.
-
Saltman, Richard B. (2004) ‘Social health insurance in perspective: The challenge of sustaining stability’, in Richard B. Saltman, Reinhard Busse, and Josep Figueras (eds), Social Health Insurance Systems in Western Europe, New York: Open University Press, 3–20.
-
Saltman, Richard B. (2019) ‘Structural effects of the information revolution on tax-funded European health systems and some potential policy responses’, Israel Journal of Health Policy Research 8(1): 8.
-
Suzuki, Tetsuzo (2011) ‘日治初年臺灣總督府衛生行政制度之形成: 與近代日本衛生行政制度比較考察’ [The formation of the sanitary administrative system of Taiwan Governor-General in early colonial Taiwan: A comparison with modern Japanese sanitary administrative system], Bulletin of Taiwan Historical Research 4: 129–160.
-
Tsai, Duu-Jian and Lee, Meng-Chih (2021) ‘美援對台灣二戰後醫療衛生發展影響’ [The influences of American aids to health care development in post–wwii Taiwan], Taiwan Journal of Public Health 40(6): 600–610.
-
United Nations (UN) (1971) ‘United Nations General Assembly Resolution a/res/2758(xxvi)’, United Nations. Retrieved 22 August 2023 from https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/192054/files/A_RES_2758%28XXVI%29-EN.pdf?ln=en.
-
UN (2019) ‘Political declaration of the high-level meeting on universal health coverage (a/res/74/2)’, United Nations, 10 October. Retrieved 23 August 2023 from https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/3833350/files/A_RES_74_2-EN.pdf?ln=en.
-
UN (2020) ‘Shared responsibility, global solidarity: Responding to the socio-economic impacts of Covid-19’, United Nations, March. Retrieved 22 August 2023 from https://unsdg.un.org/sites/default/files/2020-03/SG-Report-Socio-Economic-Impact-of-Covid19.pdf.
-
World Health Organization (who) (2000) The World Health Report 2000—Health Systems: Improving Performance, Geneva: World Health Organization.
-
who (2014) Making Fair Choices on the Path to Universal Health Coverage: Final Report of thewhoConsultative Group on Equity and Universal Health Coverage, Geneva: World Health Organization Press.
-
who (2015) Anchoring Universal Health Coverage in the Right to Health: What Difference Would It Make?, Policy Brief, Geneva: World Health Organization. Retrieved 23 March 2019 from http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/199548/1/9789241509770_eng.pdf?ua=1.
-
who (2018) ‘Declaration of Astana: Global Conference on Primary Health Care: Astana, Kazakhstan, 25 and 26 October 2018’, World Health Organization, 26 October. Retrieved 7 February 2023 from https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/WHO-HIS-SDS-2018.61.
-
Wong, Joseph (2004) Healthy Democracies: Welfare Politics in Taiwan and South Korea, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
-
Wu, Chyi-In; Fu, Yang-Chih; Lin, Ju-Ping; and Weng, Hui-Ching (2022) 臺灣社會變遷基本調查計畫第八期第二次調查計畫執行報告 [2021 Taiwan Social Change Survey (Round 8, Year 2) Executive Report], Taipei: Institute of Sociology, Academia Sinica.
-
Wu, Hao-Jen (2019) 「野蠻」的復權：臺灣原住民族的轉型正義與現代法秩序的自我救贖 [‘Barbaric’ Revitalisation: The Transitional Justice for Taiwanese Indigenous Peoples and the Self-salvation of Modern Legal Order], Taipei: Springhill Publishing.
-
Wu, Nai-teh (2020) 臺灣最好的時刻，1977–1987: 民族記憶美麗島 [Taiwan’s Finest Hours], Taipei: Springhill Publishing.
-
Wu, Rwei-ren (2014a) ‘Fragment of/f Empires: The peripheral formation of Taiwanese nationalism’, in Shyu-Tu Lee and Jack F. Williams (eds), Taiwan’s Struggle: Voices of the Taiwanese, Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield, 27–34.
-
Wu, Rwei-ren (2014b) ‘Pariah manifesto: The moral significance of the Taiwanese tragedy’, in Shyu-Tu Lee and Jack F. Williams (ed.), Taiwan’s Struggle: Voices of the Taiwanese, Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield, 129–138.
-
Wu, Rwei-ren (2016) ‘The Lilliputian dreams: Preliminary observations of nationalism in Okinawa, Taiwan and Hong Kong’, Nations and Nationalism 22(4): 686–705.
-
Wu, Tsong-Min (2006) ‘臺灣戰後的惡性物價膨脹 (1945–1950)’ [Taiwan’s hyperinflation: 1945–1950], Bulletin of Academia Historica 10: 129–159.
-
Yang, Dominic Meng-Hsuan (2020) The Great Exodus from China: Trauma, Memory, and Identity in Modern Taiwan, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
-
Yang, Tsui-Hua (2008) ‘美援對台灣的衛生計畫與醫療體制之形塑’ [US aid in the formation of health planning and the medical system in Taiwan], Bulletin of the Institute of Modern History Academia Sinica 62: 91–139.
-
Yeh, Chung-Yang; Cheng, Hyunwook; and Shi, Shih-Jiunn (2018) ‘Public–private pension mixes in East Asia: Institutional diversity and policy implications for old-age security’, Ageing & Society 40(3): 604–625.
-
Yeh, Ming-Jui (2019) ‘Exploring users’ perceptions and senses of solidarity in Taiwan’s National Health Insurance’, Public Health Ethics 12(1): 1–14.
-
Yeh, Ming-Jui (2022) ‘Intergenerational contract in ageing democracies: Sustainable welfare systems and the interests of future generations’, Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 25: 531–539.
-
Yeh, Ming-Jui and Chen, Chia-Ming (2020) ‘Solidarity with whom? The boundary problem and the ethical origins of solidarity of the health system in Taiwan’, Health Care Analysis 28(2): 176–192.
-
Yeh, Ming-Jui and Liu, Feng-Yi (2022) ‘“Others’ children are expendable”: Comparing childcare sector with health and long-term sectors in Taiwan’, Children & Society 37(5): 1672–1689.
-
Yeh, Ming-Jui; Yang, Yi-Hua; and Lin, Yi-Ren (2023) ‘Universalists, republicans and rationalists: Exploring health sector solidarity and its boundary through the comparative experience of overseas Taiwanese’, Public Health Ethics 16(1): 35–52.
-
Yeh, Yun-Wen (2006) 台灣醫療發展史:醫政關係 [History of the Medical Development in Taiwan: The Relation between the Medical and Politics], Taipei: Hung Yeh.
-
Zeng, Sian-Wei (2015) ‘戰後初期臺灣的糧食管制 (1945–1949)’ [The food control in early post-war period Taiwan (1945–1949)], Taiwan Historica 66(3): 53–102.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 321 | 280 | 17 |
| Full Text Views | 60 | 51 | 1 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 290 | 274 | 1 |
The Ordinary Virtue and Moral Significance of Health Systems: the Case of Taiwan
In: International Journal of Taiwan StudiesSearch for other papers by Ming-Jui Yeh in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Abstract
The ordinary virtue of health systems is to secure some form of equitable access to health services for all in pursuit of the ideal of universal health coverage, which would sometimes be considered an integral part of the overall institutional arrangements protecting the human right to health. The history of human-established health systems has come close to an end. In this article, I use the Taiwanese health system as an illustrative case to demonstrate how the roles of a health system vary in different periods across multiple colonial histories. It was not until the 1990s, after Taiwan went through democratisation, that the health system began to display ordinary virtue. I further argue that, beyond the ordinary virtue, the Taiwanese health system has moral significance in (1) integrating divided and conflicting identities and forging a new, forward-looking one; and (2) representing Taiwanese people’s declaration against exclusionary global politics by devoting themselves to a space that protects the right to health and a way of life that cherishes the value of equitable access to health services for all.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 321 | 280 | 17 |
| Full Text Views | 60 | 51 | 1 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 290 | 274 | 1 |
