Extra-Judicial Khulʿ Divorce in India’s Muslim Personal Law

in Islamic Law and Society
No Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Abstract

This essay examines khulʿ divorce as it is interpreted, understood, and practiced in India by Sunni Hanafi Muslims. My research was part of a broadly focused investigation of the impact of India’s Muslim Personal Law upon women’s well-being, begun in 1998 and on-going. I draw upon ethnographic and archival data collected between 1998 and 2001, as well as a recent review of the relevant case law. Widespread stereotypes represent Indian Muslim women as powerless to free themselves from unhappy marriages. However, they do have several legal options. One is to offer the husband a consideration for granting an extra-judicial divorce by khulʿ. This has distinct advantages over filing for divorce in a court of law. But its downside is that the husband must agree to release his wife from the marriage. Many refuse, others drive hard bargains or create other difficulties for the wife that are discussed in the essay.

Extra-Judicial Khulʿ Divorce in India’s Muslim Personal Law

in Islamic Law and Society

Sections

References

1

Agarwal Bina 1994 A Field of One's Own: Gender and Land Rights in South Asia Cambridge Cambridge University Press

2

Agnes Flavia 2011 Family Law Volume II: Marriage Divorce and Matrimonial Litigation New Delhi Oxford University Press

3

Agnes Flavia 2016 Muslim Women's Rights and Media Coverage Economic and Political Weekly 51 22 13 16 http://www.epw.in/node/147051/pdf

4

Baillie Neil B.E. 1875 A Digest of Moohummudan Law on the Subjects to Which it is Usually Applied by British Courts of Justice in India London Smith Elder and Company

5

Basu Srimati 1999 She Comes to Take her Rights: Indian Women Property and Propriety. Albany State University of New York Press

6

Bowen John 2003 Islam Law and Equality in Indonesia: An Anthropology of Public Reasoning Cambridge Cambridge University Press

7

Carroll Lucy 1982 Talaq-i-Tafwid and Stipulations in a Muslim Marriage Contract: Important Means of Protecting the Position of the South Asian Muslim Wife Modern Asian Studies 16 2 277 309

8

Carroll Lucy 1996 Qurʾān 2:229: ‘A Charter Granted to the Wife’? Judicial Khulʿ in Pakistan Islamic Law and Society 3 1 91 126

9

Charrad M.M. 2001 States and Women's Rights: The Making of Postcolonial Tunisia Algeria and Morocco. Berkeley University of California Press

10

Cuno Kenneth 2015 Modernizing Marriage: Family Ideology and Law in Nineteenth- and Early Twentieth-Century Egypt Syracuse Syracuse University Press

11

De Rohit 2009 Mumtaz Bibi's Broken Heart: The Many Lives of the Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act, 1939 Indian Economic and Social History Review 46 1 105 30

12

De Rohit 2010 The Two Husbands of Vera Tiscenko: Apostasy, Conversion and Divorce in Late Colonial India Law and History Review 28 4 1011 41

13

Elliott Katja Zvan 2009 Reforming the Moroccan Personal Status Code: A Revolution for Whom? Mediterranean Politics 14 2 213 227

14

Engineer Asghar Ali 1987 The Shah Bano Controversy. London Sangam Books, Ltd.

15

Esposito John 1982 Women in Muslim Family Law Syracuse Syracuse University Press

16

Fazalbhoy Nasreen 2005 Muslim Women and Inheritance In a Minority: Essays on Muslim Women in India. Zoya Hasan Ritu Menon 69 107 New Delhi Oxford University Press

17

Fyzee Asaf A.A. 1974 Outlines of Mohammadan Law 4th Delhi Oxford University Press

18

Galanter Marc 1981 Justice in Many Rooms: Courts, Private Ordering, and Indigenous Law The Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law 13 19 1 47

19

Gilmartin David 1988 Customary Law and Sharī‘at in British Punjab Sharī‘at and Ambiguity in South Asian Islam. Katherine P. Ewing 43 62 Berkeley University of California Press

20

Griffiths John 1986 What is Legal Pluralism? The Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law 18 24 1 55

21

Hirsch Susan F 1998 Pronouncing and Persevering: Gender and the Discourses of Disputing in an African Islamic Court. Chicago University of Chicago Press

22

Holden Livia 2012 Divorce at the Woman's Initiative in South Asia and in the Diasporas Interpreting Divorce Laws in Islam. Rubya Mehdi Werner Menski Jørgen Choler Nielsen 131 54 Copenhagen DJØF Publishing

23

Hoque Ridwanul and Morshed Mahmud Khan 2007 Judicial Activism and Islamic Family Law: A Socio-Legal Evaluation of Recent Trends in Bangladesh Islamic Law and Society 14 2 204 239

24

Hussain Sabiha 2007 Shariat Courts and Question [sic] of Women's Rights in India Pakistan Journal of Women's Studies: Alam-e-Niswan 14 2 73 102

25

Kirmani Nida 2009 Claiming Their Space: Muslim Women-led Networks and the Women's Movement in India Journal of International Women's Studies 11 1 72 85

26

Kozlowski Gregory 1987 Muslim Women and the Control of Property in North India Indian Economic and Social History Review 24 2 163 181

27

Kugle Scott Alan 2001 Framed, Blamed and Renamed: The Recasting of Islamic Jurisprudence in Colonial South Asia Modern Asian Studies 35 2 257 313

28

Lau Martin 2005 The Role of Islam in the Legal System of Pakistan Leiden Brill

29

Lemons Katherine 2010 At the Margins of Law: Adjudicating Muslim Families in Contemporary Delhi Ph.D. Dissertation Department of Anthropology, University of California Berkeley

30

Lemons Katherine 2014 When Marriage Breaks Down How Do Contracts Matter? Marrying in South Asia: Shifting Concepts Changing Practices in a Globalising World Ravinder Kaur Rajni Palriwala 371 88 New Delhi Orient Black Swan

31

Macnaghten William Hay 1825 Principles and Precedents of Moohummudan Law … with Notes Illustrative and Explanatory and Preliminary Remarks. Calcutta Church Mission Press

32

Mahmood Syed Tahir 1980 The Muslim Law of India Allahabad Law Book Company

33

Marghīnānī ʻAlī ibn Abī Bakr 1791 The Hedaya or Guide: A Commentary on the Mussulman Laws. Charles Hamilton London T. Bensley

34

Masud Muhammad Khalid 1996 Apostasy and Judicial Separation in India Islamic Legal Interpretation: Muftis and Their Fatwas. Muhammad Khalid Masud Brinkley Messick David S. Powers 193 203 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press

35

Merry Sally 1988 Legal Pluralism Law and Society Review 22 5 869 96

36

Minault Gail 1997 Women, Legal Reform, and Muslim Identity Comparative Studies of South Asia Africa and the Middle East 17 2 1 10

37

Mody Perveez 2008 The Intimate State: Love-Marriage and the Law in Delhi London Routledge

38

Mulla Dinshaw Fardunji 1977 Principles of Mahomedan Law. 18th M. Hidayatullah Arshad Hidayatullah Bombay N.M. Tripathi

39

Munir Muhamad 2015 The Law of Khul’ in Islamic Law and the Legal System of Pakistan LUMS Law Journal 2 1 33 63 https://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2441564

40

Nadvi Mujibullah 1988 Fatāwa-i ʿĀlamgīrī. Lahore Markaz-i Taḥqīq-i Diyāl Singh Ṭrasṭ Lāibrerī

41

Peletz Michael 2002 Islamic Modern: Religious Courts and Cultural Politics in Malaysia. Princeton Princeton University Press

42

Powers David S 2002 Law Society and Culture in the Maghrib 1300 1500 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

43

Powers David S 2003 Women and Divorce in the Islamic West: Three Cases Hawwa 1 1 29 45

44

Quick Abdul Hakim 1998 Al-Muʿallaqa: The Muslim Woman between Divorce and Real Marriage Journal of Islamic Law 3 1 27 40

45

Rashid Omar 2017 Those who Misuse Triple Talaq Will Face Social Boycott, Says AIMPLB The Hindu April 17 https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/triple-talaq-aimplb-issues-code-for-divorce/article18072109.ece

46

Redding Jeffrey A 2014 The Case of Ayesha, Muslim ‘Courts’, and the Rule of Law: Some Ethnographic Lessons for Legal Theory Modern Asian Studies 48 4 940 85

47

Schneider Nadja-Christina 2009 Islamic Feminism and Muslim Women's Rights Activism in India: From Transnational Discourse to Local Movement – or Vice Versa? Journal of International Women's Studies 11 1 56 70

48

Serajuddin Alamgir Muhammad 2001 Shari‘a Law and Society: Tradition and Change in South Asia. Oxford Oxford University Press

49

Sezgin Yüksel 2013 Human Rights under State-Enforced Religious Family Laws in Israel Egypt and India. Cambridge Cambridge University Press

50

Shahabuddin Syed 2005 Nikahnama is an Important Step in the Right Direction http://www.milligazette.com/Archives/2005/16-31_May05-Print-Edition/163105 2005

51

Sharafi Mitra 2008 Justice in Many Rooms since Galanter: De-Romanticizing Legal Pluralism through the Cultural Defense Law and Contemporary Problems 71 2 139 46

52

Sharafi Mitra 2014 Law and Identity in Colonial South Asia: Parsi Legal Culture 1772 1947 New York Cambridge University Press

53

Solanki Gopika 2011 Adjudication in Religious Family Laws: Cultural Accommodation Legal Pluralism and Gender Equality in India Cambridge Cambridge University Press

54

Sonneveld Nadia 2012 Khul‘ Divorce in Egypt: Public Debates Judicial Practices and Everyday Life. Cairo and New York American University in Cairo Press and Oxford University Press

55

Stiles Erin 2009 An Islamic Court in Context: An Ethnographic Study of Judicial Reasoning New York Palgrave Macmillan

56

Stiles Erin 2013 The Laws of Marriage: Sexuality, Impotence, and Divorce Suits in Zanzibar's Islamic Courts Journal of Women Living Under Muslim Laws: Sexualities Culture and Society in Muslim Contexts Dossier 32 33 59 78

57

Subramanian Narendra 2014 Nation and Family: Personal Law Cultural Pluralism and Gendered Citizenship in India. Stanford Stanford University Press

58

Subramanian Narendra 2017 Beyond Triple Talaq: India Needs a Debate on How to Reform Muslim, Hindu Law The Wire (India June 27 https://thewire.in/151585/democratising-family-nation-triple-talaq-pluralistic-equality

59

Suneetha A 2012 Towards Understanding Muslim Social Reform: Jamait-ul-Mominath and its Fatwas for Women Negotiating Spaces: Legal Domains Gender Concerns and Community Constructs Flavia Agnes Shoba Venkatesh Ghosh 131 165 New Delhi Oxford University Press

60

Tamanaha Brian Z 1993 The Folly of the ‘Social Scientific’ Concept of Legal Pluralism Journal of Law and Society 20 2 192 217

61

Tschalaer Mengia Hong 2017 Muslim Women's Quest for Justice: Gender Law and Activism in India Cambridge Studies in Law and Society. Cambridge Cambridge University Press

62

Tucker Judith 1985 Women in Nineteenth-Century Egypt. Cambridge Cambridge University Press

63

Tucker Judith 1991 Ties that Bound: Women and Family in Eighteenth- and Nineteenth-Century Nablus Women in Middle Eastern History Nikki R. Keddie Beth Baron 233 53 New Haven Yale University Press

64

Tucker Judith 1998 In the House of the Law: Gender and Islamic Law in Ottoman Syria and Palestine. Berkeley University of California Press

65

Tucker Judith 2008 Women Family and Gender in Islamic Law. Cambridge Cambridge University Press

66

Tyabji Faiz Badruddin 1968 Muslim Law. 4th Bombay N.M. Tripathi

67

Vatuk Sylvia 2001 ‘Where Will She Go? What Will She Do?’ Paternalism Toward Women in the Administration of Muslim Personal Law in Contemporary India Religion and Personal Law in Secular India: A Call to Judgment G.J. Larson 226 238 Bloomington, IN Indiana University Press

68

Vatuk Sylvia 2005 Moving the Courts: Muslim Women and Personal Law The Diversity of Muslim Women's Lives in India Zoya Hasan Ritu Menon 18 58 New Brunswick Rutgers University Press

69

Vatuk Sylvia 2008a Divorce at the Wife's Initiative in Muslim Personal Law: What are the Options and What are Their Implications for Women's Welfare? Redefining Family Law in India: Essays in Honour of B. Sivaramayya Archana Parashar Amita Dhanda 200 235 London and New Delhi Routledge

70

Vatuk Sylvia 2008b Islamic Feminism in India: Indian Muslim Women Activists and the Reform of Muslim Personal Law Islam in India Filippo Osella Caroline Osella Modern Asian Studies 42 2-3 489 518

71

Vatuk Sylvia 2009 A Rallying Cry for Muslim Personal Law: The Shah Bano Case and its Aftermath Islam in South Asia in Practice Barbara Metcalf 352 367 Princeton Princeton University Press

72

Vatuk Sylvia 2013a Islamic Feminism in India: Indian Muslim Women Activists and the Reform of Muslim Personal Law Islamic Reform in South Asia Filippo Osella Caroline Osella 346 382 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

73

Vatuk Sylvia 2013b The Women's Court in India: An Alternative Dispute Resolution Body for Women in Distress The Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law 4 1 76 103

74

Vatuk Sylvia 2014 The Application of Muslim Personal Law in India: A System of Legal Pluralism in Action Adjudicating Family Law in Muslim Courts Elisa Giunchi 48 69 London and New York Routledge

75

Vatuk Sylvia 2015 Maintenance for Divorced Muslim Women after the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act 1986: A View from the Lower Courts Asian Muslim Women: Globalization and Local Realities Huma Ahmed-Ghosh 103 126 Albany State University of New York Press

76

Vatuk Sylvia 2017a Marriage and its Discontents: Women Islam and the Law in India. New Delhi Women Unlimited

77

Vatuk Sylvia 2017b Why the Triple Talaq Verdict Will Not Trigger an Instant Revolution The Economic Times (India) August 27

78

Welchman Lynn 2004 Women's Rights and Islamic Family Law: Perspectives on Reform London Zed Books

79

Welchman Lynn 2007 Women and Family Laws in Arab States: A Comparative Overview of Textual Development and Advocacy. Amsterdam Amsterdam University Press

80

Zantout Mida R 2008 Khulʿ: Between Past and Present Islamic Law and Law of the Muslim World. New York New York University Law School https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1094367

81

Zilfi Madeline C 1997 ‘We Don't Get Along’: Women and Hul Divorce in the Eighteenth Century Women in the Ottoman Empire. Madeline C. Zilfi 264 96 Leiden Brill

82

http://164.100.47.4/billstexts/rsbilltexts/AsIntroduced/muslm%20mar-5816-E.pdf May 27 2018

83

http://doj.gov.in/appointment-of-judges/list-high-court-judges January 28 2017

84

http://doj.gov.in/appointment-of-judges/list-supreme-court-judges September 10 2017

85

http://minorityaffairs.gov.in/sites/upload_files/moma/files/pdfs/sachar_comm.pdf October 10 2016

86

http://www.censusindia.gov.in/2011census/Religion_PCA.html October 15 2016

87

http://www.censusindia.gov.in/2011census/C-01.html October 15 2016

88

http://www.epw.in/node/147051/pdf June 1 2018

89

http://www.lawyerscollective.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/BMMA-WS-filed-on-4.4.2017.pdf July 11 2017

90

http://www.milligazette.com/Archives/2005/16-31_May05-Print-Edition/1631052005 October 10 2016

91

https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/2725467/Shayara-Bano-Writ-Petition-FINAL-VERSION.txt July 11 2017

92

https://barandbench.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/counter-affidavit-in-Sharayo-Bano.pdf July 11 2017

93

https://data.gov.in/catalog/literacy-rate-social-groups-and-major-religious-communities May 22 2016

94

https://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2441564 May 1 2018

95

https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/why-the-triple-talaq-verdict-will-not-trigger-an-instant-revolution/printarticle/60236058.cms September 2 2017

96

https://indiankanoon.org/doc/1458498

97

https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1094367 May 15 2017

98

https://stepfeed.com/arab-countries-ranked-by-divorce-rates-1007 June 1 2018

99

https://thewire.in/151585/democratising-family-nation-triple-talaq-pluralistic-equality July 11 2017

100

https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/triple-talaq-aimplb-issues-code-for-divorce/article18072109.ece August 11 2018

101

A. Yousuf Rowther vs. Sowramma AIR 1971

102

Jiauddin Ahmed vs. Anwar Begum 1978 1 GLR 372

103

K.C. Moyin vs. Nafeesa and Ors AIR 1973

104

Kadar Mian vs. Smt. Jahera Khatun and Anr on 15 April 1998 1999 CriLJ 1440

105

Moonshee Buzul-ul-Raheem vs. Luteefut-oon-Nissa MANU/PR/0004/1861

106

Mst. Arshi Riyaz vs. Jalil Ahmed on 11 September 2012 https://indiankanoon.org/doc/10792107

107

Mohd. Ahmed Khan vs Shah Bano Begum and Ors 1985 SCR (3) 844

108

Mumtaz Ahmad vs. State of Bihar & Anr on 3 July 2013 Patna Criminal Revision No. 1284 of 2010

109

Musammat Saddan vs. Faiz Bakhsh 1920 1 Lahore 402 55 I.C. 184

110

S. Basheria vs. The State of Tamilnadu 2012

111

S. Nazeer Ahamed vs. The Director General of Police on 21 September 2006 https://indiankanoon.org/doc/1584561

112

Shahnaz Bano D/O Aslam Khan (Smt) vs. Babbu Khan S/O Nanhekhan Pathan 1985 (2) BomCR 765

113

Shamim Ara vs. State of U.P. 2002 AIR SCW 4162

114

Shayara Bano vs. Union of India and Ors SC Writ Petition No. 118 of 2016

115

Shazma vs. Ashar Ali Zai and Anr 1997 DLT 267

116

Smt. Firdos Jehan vs. Sh. Mohd. Sufiyan Faridi on 12 November 2013 Delhi District Court Suit No. 71/12

117

Smt. Zahira vs. Shri Aslam on 2 May 2012 Delhi District Court Suit No. 229/11

118

State vs. Abrar Ahmad S/O Mohd Aslam 2010 Delhi District Court Sessions Case No. 05/08

119

Whether It Is to Be Circulated to … vs. Javed Hussain Mansuri on 16 October 2014 C/FA/2979/2013

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 104 104 45
Full Text Views 25 25 15
PDF Downloads 14 14 5
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0