The Role of Kinship in Negotiating Territorial Rights

Exploring Claims for Winter Pasture Ownership in Mongolia

in Inner Asia
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


This paper explores the role of kinship in herder claims for winter shelter ownership in rural Mongolia, where pastureland is currently designated as state-owned property in the national constitution. Drawing on ethnographic research conducted amongst mobile pastoralist households, this article demonstrates how contemporary winter pasture rights take shape within a locus of political relations structured by custodial land-use practices. It highlights the ways that herders negotiate for territorial rights through appeals to established regional families and are how these appeals are mediated by local government administration. From this analysis, I argue that concepts of kinship in the political economy of pastoralism should be re-examined in light of current debates around land-tenure legislation in Mongolia.

The Role of Kinship in Negotiating Territorial Rights

Exploring Claims for Winter Pasture Ownership in Mongolia

in Inner Asia



AtwoodC.P. Banner, otog, thousand: appanage communities as the basic unit of traditional Mongolian society Mongolian Studies 2012 34 1 54

BawdenC.R. A document concerning Chinese farmers in Outer Mongolia in the eighteenth century Acta Orientalia Academiae Scientiarum Hungaricae 1982 36 47 55

BawdenC.R. Mongolian–English Dictionary 1997 London Kegan Paul International

ByambajavD. The River Movements’ struggle in Mongolia Social Movement Studies: Journal of Social Cultural and Political Protest 2015 14 1 92 97

cao Mongolia/Oyu Tolgoi-01/Southern Gobi Letter of Complaint 2012 accessed 9 September 2016

ChattyD.ColchesterM. Conservation and Mobile Indigenous Peoples: Displacement Forced Settlement and Sustainable Development 2002 New York (NY) Berghahn Books

EmpsonR. CharleuxI.DelaplaceG.HamayonR.PearceS. Enclosing for growth: including or excluding people from land in north-east Mongolia Representing Power in Modern Inner Asia: Conventions Alternatives and Oppositions 2010 Bellingham (WA) Western Washington University 123 148

EmpsonR. Harnessing Fortune: Personhood Memory and Place in Mongolia 2011 Oxford Oxford University Press

Fernandez-GimenezM. Spatial and social boundaries and the paradox of pastoral land tenure: a case study from post-pocialist Mongolia Human Ecology 2002 30 1 49

Fernandez-GimenezM.BatbuyanB. Law and disorder: local implementation of Mongolia’s Land Law Development and Change 2004 35 1 141 165

HannC. The Postsocialist Agrarian Question: Property Relations and the Rural Condition 2003 Münster LIT

HannamI. SquiresV. International perspectives on legislative and administrative reforms as an aid to better land stewardship Rangeland Stewardship in Central Asia: Balancing Improved Livelihoods Biodiversity Conservation and Land Protection 2012 Dordrecht Springer 407 429

HannamI. HerreraP.M.DaviesJ.BaenaP.M. Legal and policy aspects of rangeland management—Mongolia The Governance of Rangelands: Collective Action for Sustainable Pastoralism 2014 London Routledge 156 167

HumphreyC. HirschE.O’HanlonM. Chiefly and shamanist landscapes in Mongolia The Anthropology of Landscape 1995 Oxford Oxford University Press 135 62

HumphreyC. The Unmaking of Soviet Life: Everyday Economies After Socialism 2002 Ithaca (NY) Cornell University Press

HumphreyC.SneathD. Pastoralism and Institutional Change in Inner Asia: Comparative Perspectives from the MECCIA Research Projects. 1996 London Overseas Development Institute

HumphreyC.SneathD. The End of Nomadism? Society State and the Environment in Inner Asia. 1999 Durham (NC) Duke University Press

IchinkhorlooB.YehE. Ephemeral ‘communities’: spatiality and politics in rangeland interventions in Mongolia Journal of Peasant Studies 2016

JacksonS.L. Imagining the mineral nation: contested nation building in Mongolia Nationalities Papers: The Journal of Nationalism and Ethnicity 2014 43 3 437 56

KamimuraA. YamamuraN.FujitaN.MaekawaA. Pastoral mobility and pastureland possession in Mongolia The Mongolian Ecosystem Network 2013 Tokyo Springer 187 203

KazatoM. Local Value and Rights to Winter Camps Under Land Privatization Policy in Postsocialist Mongolia 2006 Unpublished paper presented at the 11th Biennial Conference of IASCP (International Association for the Study of Common Property) 19–23 June Bali, Indonesia

KervenC.SteimannB.DearC.AshleyL. Researching the future of pastoralism in Central Asia’s mountains: examining development orthodoxies Mountain Research and Development 2012 32 3 368 77

MandelR.HumphreyC. Markets and Moralities: Ethnographies of Postsocialism 2002 Oxford Berg

Mongol Ulsiin Khuuli Gazariin Tuhai. 1994 accessed 7 August 2016

Mongol Ulsiin Khuuli Gazariin Tuhai. 2002 accessed 7 August 2016

Mongol Ulsiin Zasag Zakhirgaa Nutag Devcgeriin Negj Tuunii Udirdlagin Tuhai. 1992 accessed 31 August 2016

Mongol Ulsiin Zasag Zakhirgaa Nutag Devcgeriin Negj Tuunii Udirdlagin Tuhai. 2006 accessed 31 August 2016

MurphyD.J. Ecology of rule: territorial assemblages and environmental governance in rural Mongolia Anthropological Quarterly 2014 83 3 759 92

National Statistical Office Mongolian Statistical Yearbook: 2013. 2013 accessed 13 September 2014

Office of the Compliance Advisor Ombudsman Letter of Complaint (redacted) 2012 accessed 24 August 2016

ParkH. Metaphorical and ideological concepts of post-socialist Mongolian kinship Inner Asia 2003 5 2 143 62

PedersenM.A. BruunO.NarangoaL. Where is the center? The spatial distribution of power in post-socialist rural Mongolia Mongols from Country to City: Floating Boundaries Pastoralism and City Life in the Mongol Lands 2006 Copenhagen Nordic Institute of Asian Studies 82 104

ReevesM. Border Work: Spatial Lives of the State in Rural Central Asia 2014 Ithaca (NY) Cornell University Press

SandersA. Mongolia’s new constitution: blueprint for democracy Asian Survey 1992 32 6 506 20

SneathD. Social relations, networks and social organisation in post-socialist rural Mongolia Nomadic Peoples 1993 33 193 207

SneathD. Notions of rights over land and the history of Mongolian pastoralism Inner Asia 2001 3 1 41 59

SneathD. MandelR.HumphreyC. Mongolia in the ‘Age of the Market’: pastoral land use and the development discourse Markets and Moralities: Ethnographies of Postsocialism 2002 191 Oxford Berg

SneathD. Land use, the environment, and development in post-socialist Mongolia Oxford Development Studies 2003 31 4 441 59

SneathD. Transacting and enacting: corruption, obligation and the use of monies in Mongolia Ethnos 2006 71 1 89 112

SneathD. The Headless State: Aristocratic Orders Kinship Society and Misrepresentations of Nomadic Inner Asia 2007 New York (NY) Columbia University Press

SneathD. Political mobilization and the construction of collective identity in Mongolia Central Asia Survey 2010 29 3 251 67

SneathD. Nationalizing civilisation resources: sacred mountains and cosmopolitical ritual in Mongolia Asian Ethnicity 2014 15 4 458 72

State Great Hural The Constitution of Mongolia 1992 accessed 1 February 2015

SwiftJ. FAO Case Study. Institutionalizing Pastoral Risk Management in Mongolia: Lessons learned. 2007 (Report tcp/mon/0066.) Rome: fao. Available at:

UptonC. Social capital, collective action and group formation: developmental trajectories in post-socialist Mongolia Human Ecology 2008 36 2 175 88

UptonC. Managing Mongolia’s commons: land reforms, social contexts, and institutional change Society & Natural Resources: An International Journal 2012 25 2 156 75

VerderyK. The Vanishing Hectare: Property and Value in Postsocialist Transylvania 2003 Ithaca (NY) Cornell University Press

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 30 30 10
Full Text Views 16 16 12
PDF Downloads 7 7 5
EPUB Downloads 1 1 1