The Influence of Narratives on Negotiations and Resolution of the Upper Jordan River Conflict
In: International NegotiationSearch for other papers by Mark Zeitoun in
Current site
Google Scholar
Search for other papers by Michael Talhami in
Current site
Google Scholar
Search for other papers by Karim Eid-Sabbagh in
Current site
Google Scholar
Abstract
This article tests the assertion that narratives constructed around international environmental issues serve to promote or reduce opportunities for their resolution. It does this by interpreting the influence of Lebanese and Israeli environmental narratives on resolution of and indirect negotiations over the Upper Jordan River conflict. Colonial archives, key informant interviews and academic and policy literature serve to identify and critically investigate the narratives. An official Lebanese narrative of adherence to international law is found to contradict the more popular nationalist narrative of Israeli ‘theft’ of the flows. An Israeli water security discourse is found to be built on earlier narratives that have long held water (and the Upper Jordan flows in particular) as both a physically scarce and strategic commodity necessary for continued existence of the Israeli state. Basic discourse, security studies and negotiation theory is developed to gauge the influence of the narratives during the 2002 informal negotiations over the Wazzani pumping station dispute. The more influential Israeli discourse is found to establish the starting point (no discussion on re-allocation of the flows) and process of the informal negotiations. The narratives are found to open or shut windows for resolution of the conflict, by politicizing or securitizing ideas about the flows, respectively. The conflict management approach favored by US and EU mediators is seen to align with the more dominant discourse, at the cost of enduring asymmetry and tensions, and missed opportunities for both resolution of the conflict and promotion of fair water-sharing norms.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Abitbol Eric “Developing Water and Marginalising Israel / Palestinian Peace: A Critical Examination of the Red Sea – Dead Sea Canal Feasibility Process” Journal of Peacebuilding & Development 2010 5 1 35 49
-
Abitbol Eric “Hydropolitical Peacebuilding: Israeli-Palestinian Water Relations and the Transformation of Asymmetric Conflict in the Middle East” 2013 PhD thesis. Department of Peace Studies, School of Social and International Studies. University of Bradford, Bradford.
-
Abu Sitta Salman An Atlas of Palestine 2011 London Palestine Lands Society
-
Acharya Amitav “How Ideas Spread: Whose Norms Matter? Norm Localization and Institutional Change in Asian Regionalism” International Organization 2004 58 239 275
-
Alatout Samer “Towards a Bio-Territorial Conception of Power: Territory, Population, and Environmental Narratives in Palestine and Israel” Political Geography 2006 25 601 621
-
Allan J.A. The Middle East Water Question: Hydropolitics and the Global Economy 2001 London I.B. Tauris
-
Allès Christèle “La question du retour de l’État libanais dans l’ancienne zone occupée par Israël. L’exemple du bassin versant du Hasbani-Wazzani” 2007 Universite lumière Lyon II, Lyon
-
Amery Hussein “The Litani River of Lebanon” Geographical Review 1993 83 3 229 238
-
Amery Hussein Wolf A. & Amery H. “A Popular Theory of Water Diversion from Lebanon: Toward Public Participation for Peace” Water in the Middle East: A Geography of Peace 2000 Austin, TX University of Texas Press
-
Amery Hussein “Water Wars in the Middle East: A Looming Threat” The Geographical Journal 2002 168 4 313 323
-
An Nahar “The Hasbani – crunch time” 1960 Opinion by Ghassan Tueni. 22 January 1960. Beirut, Lebanon
-
Anon 2008 pers.comm-a Anonymous discussion. Litani River Valley. 11 April 2011
-
Anon 2008 pers.comm-b Anonymous discussion with engineers involved in the reconstruction of the Wazzani pumping station. Beirut. December 2008
-
Anon 2010 pers.comm Anonymous interview. Beirut. 30 November 2010
-
Anon 2011 pers.comm-a Anonymous discussion. Beirut. 31 January 2011
-
Anon 2011 pers.comm-b Anonymous interview. Beirut. 11 April 2011
-
Anon 2011 pers.comm-c Anonymous phone interview. 26 August 2011
-
Anon 2011 pers.comm-d Anonymous telephone interview. 17 August 2011
-
AP “Water shortage looms in Israel after prolonged drought, but supply to Jordan continuing” Associated Press 2008 19 March 2008
-
Atoui Mohammad “Israel is Stealing the Water of South Lebanon” Al- Mustaqbal 2002 17 October 2002. Beirut, Lebanon
-
Austin J.L. How to Do Things with Words 1962 Oxford Clarendon Press
-
BBC “Israel warns of war over water” BBC News Middle East Section 2002 10 September 2002
-
Ben-Shahar Haim, Fishelson Gideon & Hirsch Seev Economic Cooperation and Middle East Peace 1989 London George Weidenfeld & Nicolson Limited
-
Blanford Nicholas “Water war reignites between Israel and Lebanon over Hasbani – analysis” The Daily Star 2012 10 July 2012. Beirut, Lebanon
-
Bourdieu Pierre & Passeron Jean-Claude Reproduction in Education, Society and Culture (Second Edition) 2012 London Sage [1970]
-
Buzan B. & de Wilde J. Security – A New Framework for Analysis 1998 London Lynne Rienner Publishers, Inc.
-
Chupp Mark “When Mediation is Not Enough” Conciliation Quarterly 1991 10 3 2 13
-
COGAT Factsheet: Water in the West Bank 2012 [accessed May 2012] The Civil Administration of Judea and Samaria. http://www.cogat.idf.il
-
Comair Fadi Georges Water Management and Hydrodiplomacy of River Basins: Litani, Hasbani-Wazzani, Orontes, Nahr al Kebir 2009 Louaize Notre Dame University
-
Comair Fadi Georges 2011 pers.comm. Discusion with Head of the GDHER, Dr Fadi Comair. GDHER offices, Beirut. 4 January 2011.
-
Cooley John K. “The War over Water” Foreign Policy 1984 54 3 26
-
Cronon William “A Place for Stories: Nature, History and Narrative” The Journal of American History 1992 78 4 1347 1376
-
Daoudy Marwa “A Missed Chance for Peace: Israel and Syria’s Negotiations Over the Golan Heights” Journal of International Affairs 2008 61 2 215 234
-
Daoudy Marwa “Asymmetric Power: Negotiating Water in the Euphrates and Tigris” International Negotiation 2009 14 2 361 391
-
Deconinck Stefan The Wazzani-incident in the Summer of 2002 – a Phoney War? 2006 Waternet. http://www.waternet.be/jordan_river/wazzani.htm
-
Dinar Ariel “Preventive Diplomacy, International Relations, Conflict Resolution and International Water Law: Implications for Success and Failure of the Israeli-Palestinian Water Conflict” International Journal of Global Environmental Issues 2003 3 2 188 225
-
Dinar Ariel & Dinar Shlomi “Negotiations and International Relations: A Framework for Hydropolitics” International Negotiation 2000 5 375 407
-
Dinar Ariel “Power Asymmetry and Negotiations in International River Basins” International Negotiation 2009 14 2 329 360
-
Dinar Ariel & Dinar Ariel “Negotiating in International Watercourses: Diplomacy, Conflict and Cooperation” International Negotiation 2000 5 193 200
-
Dryzek John S. The Politics of the Earth: Evironmental Discourses (Second Edition) 2005 Oxford Oxford University Press
-
EC 2004 EU Rapid Reaction Mechanism, End of programme report. Lebanon/Israel Wazzani springs dispute. Brussels, European Commission
-
Economist “Don’t make the desert bloom” The Economist, Middle East and Africa Section. 2008 June 5
-
el Musa Sharif “The Land-Water Nexus in the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict” Journal of Palestine Studies 1996 25 3 69 78 2008
-
EU Sustainable Water Integrated Management Demonstration Project: Transboundary Master Planning of the Lower Jordan River Basin 2012 European Union, Friends of the Earth Middle East, Stockholm International Water Institute.
-
FAO 2010 [accessed July 2010] Aquastat Database, Food and Agriculture Organization
-
Farajalla Nadim & Makdisi Karim “Lebanon, Hasbani and the Jordan” 2008 Presentation given at American University of Beirut
-
Feitelson Eran “Implications of Shifts in the Israeli Discourse for Israeli-Palestinian Water Negotiations” Political Geography 2002 21 3 293 318
-
Feitelson Eran, Fischhendler Itay & Kay Paul “The Role of a Central Administrator in Managing Water Resources: The Case of the Israeli Water Commissioner” Water Resources Research 2007 43 11
-
Feitelson Eran & Rosenthal Gad “Desalination, Space and Power: The Ramifications of Israel’s Changing Water Geography” Geoforum 2012 43 272 284
-
Feitelson Eran, Tamimi Abdelrahman & Rosenthal Gad “Climate Change and Security in the Israeli-Palestinian Context” Journal of Peace Research 2012 49 1 241 257
-
Fisher Franklin & Huber-Lee Annette Liquid Assets: An Economic Approach for Water Management and Conflict Resolution in the Middle East and Beyond 2005 Washington, DC Resources for the Future
-
Fisher Roger & Ury William Getting to Yes: Negotiating Agreement without Giving in 1999 New York, NY Penguin Books
-
FNA Confidential letter (marked ‘Secret’) from Lieutenant-Colonel PAULET, Chef de la Mission Francaise de délimitation Syro-Palestinienne au Général Commandant en Chef, Haut Commissariat en Syrie et au Grand Liban, 12.10.21 1921 French National Archives in Nantes, Archives des postes diplomatiques, consulaires, culturels et de cooperation: Caisse 1373; Fonds – Syrie-Liban/1er versement; Serie – Bureau Diplomatique, Dossiers de principe/Inventaires no 12 et 15, t.1, 1926–1941; Sujet – Conventions, Relations franco-britanniques dans leurs mandats respectifs.
-
FO Peace Conference (British Delegation) – Eastern Mission (Turkey), Files 76–91 1920 Item No. 318, letter from British Foreign Office to French representative M. Vantissart 9 November 1920 Regards request for control of the Litani and Yarmouk Rivers, UK Foreign Office record FO 608/274
-
FOEME Towards a Living Jordan River: An Environmental Flows Report on the Rehabilitation of the Lower Jordan River 2010 Amman, Bethlehem, Tel Aviv, Friends of the Earth Middle East
-
Frisch Hillel “Water and Israel’s National Security. Efficient Use of Limited Water Resources: Making Israel a Model State” 2002 Ramat Gan, Israel. A Project of the Begin-Sadat Center for Strategic Studies, Bar-Ilan University. http://www.biu.ac.il/Besa/waterarticle6.html
-
Gasteryer Stephen, Jad Isaac, Hilal Jane & Walsh Sean “Water Grabbing in Colonial Perspective: Land and Water in Israel/Palestine” Water Alternatives 2012 5 2 450 468
-
George Alan “ ‘Making the Desert Bloom’: A Myth Examined” Journal of Palestine Studies 1979 8 2 88 100
-
GOI On the Subject of the management of the Water Economy in Israel: Committee’s Report – Abstract 2010 Haifa, Government of Israel National Investigation Committee
-
GOL 2002 Position Report: Service Area of Hasbani Watercourse. Final Copy 09 October 2002, with ‘Rapport de synthese’ and ‘Plan de developpement pour le bassin versant du Hasbani-Wazzani’, in annex. Beirut, Government of Lebanon
-
Hajer Maarten A. The Politics of Environmental Discourse: Ecological Modernization and the Policy Process 1997 Oxford Oxford University Press, Oxford Scholarship Online
-
Hamieh Christine Sylva “Intra-Group Competition in a Deeply Divided Society: The Dynamics of the Hezbollah vs. Amal Competition in Baalbeck-Hermel during 1998–2003” 2007 PhD Thesis. University of York, York
-
Harris Leila M. “Contested Sustainabilities: Assessing Narratives of Environmental Change in Southeastern Turkey” Local Environment 2009 14 8 699 720
-
Hof Frederic C. Mapping Peace between Syria and Israel 2009 Washington, DC United States Institute of Peace Special Report 219
-
ICA Civil Administration Quarterly: Inside the Water Department 2010 Bet El, State of Israel: Civil Administration of Judea & Samaria
-
ICG Old Games, New Rules: Conflict on the Israel-Lebanon Border 2002 Middle East Report Vol 7. Amman/Brussels: International Crisis Group http://www.crisisgroup.org/en/regions/middle-east-north-africa/israel-palestine/007-old-games-new-rules-conflict-on-the-israel-Lebanon-border.aspx
-
IMEP Israel’s Second National Communication on Climate Change (submitted under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change), November 2010 2010 Jerusalem, Ministry of Environmental Protection, Government of Israel. http://www.sviva.gov.il/Enviroment/Static/Binaries/Spokesman/war_2006_madan_1.pdf
-
IMFA “The River Jordan” Israel’s Foreign Relations – Selected Documents, Volumes 1–2: 1947–1974 2000 Tel Aviv Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs in Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs, editor
-
IMFA Cabinet Communique – 13 October 2002 [accessed 4 October 2004] Tel Aviv, Israel, Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs Cabinet Secretariat Archives. http://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/MFAArchive
-
Islam Shafiqul & Susskind Lawrence E. Water Diplomacy: A Negotiated Approach to Managing Complex Water Network 2012 New York, NY RFF Press
-
Jägerskog Anders Why States Cooperate Over Shared Water: The Water Negotiations in the Jordan River Basin 2003 Linköping Linköping University
-
JT “Israel’s Watergate” Jewish Tribune 2012 June 25 2012. Toronto
-
Kaufman Asher “Who Owns the Shebaa Farms? Chronicle of a Territorial Dispute” Middle East Journal 2002 56 4 576 595
-
Kaufman Asher “Between Palestine and Lebanon: Seven Shi’i Villages as a Case Study of Boundaries, Identities, and Conflict” Middle East Journal 2006 60 4 685 706
-
Kehl Jenny R. “Hydropolitical Complexes and Asymmetrical Power: Conflict, Cooperation, and Governance of International River Systems” Journal of World-Systems Research 2011 17 1 218 235
-
Kloosterman Karin “Water Security in the Middle East? From the Desk of Israel’s Water Commission (interview with Uri Shani)” Green Prophet 2010 January 3 2010
-
Lederach John Paul The Little Book of Conflict Transformation 2003 Intercourse, PA Good Books
-
Levinson Dovev “Israel’s Holistic Approach to Water Security: First Stage – Prevention” WaterWorld Magazine 2010 February 20 2010
-
Libiszewski Stephan Water Disputes in the Jordan River Basin Region and their Role in the Resolution of the Arab-Israeli Conflict 1995 Environment and Conflicts Project Occasional Paper No. 13. Berne, Switzerland, ETH Zurich / Swiss Peace Foundation Occational Paper No. 13
-
Lonergan Steve & Brooks David Watershed: The Role of Fresh Water in the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict 1994 Ottawa International Development Research Council
-
Lowi Miriam Water and Power – The Politics of a Scarce Resource in the Jordan River Basin 1993 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Luft Gal “The Wazzani River Dispute: More Tension Along the Israel-Lebanon Border” Peace Watch 2002 [accessed 4 October 2004] 397. 20 September 2002. http://www.washingtoninstitute.org/watch/peacewatch/peacewatch2002/397
-
Makdisi Karim Biswas A.K., Rached E. & Tortajada C. “Towards a Human Rights Approach to Water in Lebanon: Implementation beyond ‘Reform’” Water as a Human Right for the Middle East and North Africa 2008 Ottawa International Development Research Council
-
Maternowski Eileen “Die Wasserverteilungsproblematik zwischen Israel und LibAnon am Beispiel des Hasbani/Wazzani Konflikts” 2006 Universitaet Potsdam, Potsdam, Germany
-
Mazziti Walter 2010 October 24 pers.comm. Discusion with EU Middle East envoy on water issues Walter Mazziti. American University of Beirut, Beirut 2010
-
McCaffrey Stephen The Law of International Watercourses 2007 Oxford Oxford University Press
-
Medzini Arnon The River Jordan: Frontiers and Water 2001 London School of Oriental and African Studies
-
Medzini Arnon & Wolf Aaron “Towards a Middle East at Peace: Hidden Issues in Arab-Israeli Hydropolitics” Water Resources Development 2004 20 2 193 204
-
Mehta Lyla “The Manufacture of Popular Perceptions of Scarcity: Dams and Water-Related Narratives in Gujara, India” World Development 2001 29 12 2025 2041
-
Mekonnen M.M. & Hoekstra A.Y. National Water Footprint Accounts: The Green, Blue and Grey Water Footprint of Production and Consumption – Volume 2: Appendices 2011 Value of Water Research Report Series No. 50. Delft: UNESCO-IHE Institute for Water Education
-
Messerschmid Clemens Scheffran J., Brzoska M., Brauch H. G. & Link P. M. “Nothing New in the Middle East – Reality and Discourss of Climate Change in the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict” Climate Change, Human Security and Violent Conflict: Challenges for Societal Stability 2011 Springer
-
Messerschmid Clemens Turner M. “Hydro-Apartheid and Water Access in Israel-Palestine: Challenging the Myths of Scarcity and Cooperation” The Palestinian People and the Political Economy of De-development New York, NY Routledge (forthcoming)
-
Mirumachi Naho “River Development Institutions and Discourses Of Water Scarcity” 2010 2010 Annual Convention of the International Studies Association New Orleans
-
Nasrallah Hassan “Hezbollah Leader Addresses ‘Victory Rally’ in Lebanon” BBC Monitoring International Reports 2006 23 September 2006. Re-posted on Informed Comment blog, Juan Cole
-
Newman David “The Wazzani and Our Water Problem” The Jerusalem Post 2002 September 18 Jerusalem 2002
-
NIC National Investigation Committee on the Subject of the Management of the Water Economy in Israel 2010 Haifa, Israeli Knesset Abstract, March 2010
-
Phillips David, Attili Shaddad, McCaffrey Stephen & Murray John “The Jordan River Basin: 1. Clarification of the Allocations in the Johnston Plan” Water International 2007 31 5 16 38
-
Qabalan Qabalan “Project to provide Litani River water to the south” The Daily Star 2012 May 4 Beirut 2012
-
Rodríguez Iokiñe & Hernán Darío Correa Correa H. Darío & Rodríguez I. “Lessons, Approaches, and Challenges to Tranforming Socio-Environmental Conflicts in Latin America: The “C&C” Program Experience” Environmental Crossroads in Latin America: Between Managing and Transforming Natural Resource Conflicts 2006 San José University for Peace
-
RoL Ebl El Saqi Proposed Dam: Final Report Master Plan 2008 Beirut, Ministry of Energy and Water, General Directorate of Hydraulic and Electrical Resources (Republic of Lebanon). With Rafik El-Khoury & Partners
-
Salem Elie 2011 pers.comm. email contact 1 March 2011. Beirut. 4 January 2011
-
Schiff Ze’ev Schiff Zeev “Israeli Water Interests in the Occupied Territories” Security for Peace: Israel’s Minimal Security Requirements in Negotiations with the Palestinians 1989 Washington, DC The Washington Institute for Near East Policy
-
Schiff Ze’ev “First light on a shelved report” Ha’aretz Daily 1993 (Hebrew). 8 October 1993. Tel Aviv, Israel
-
Schiff Ze’ev “The Ghajar trap” Ha’aretz Daily 2001 (English). 07 September 2001. Tel Aviv, Israel
-
Schoenfeld Stuart Schoenfeld S. “Introduction” 2005 Palestinian and Israeli Environmental Narratives: Proceedings of a Conference Held in Association with the Middle East Environmental Futures Project Toronto Centre for International and Security Studies, York University
-
Scott James C. Weapons of the Weak: Everyday Forms of Peasant Resistance 1985 London Yale University Press
-
Sedan Gil “U.S., Israel seek to defuse tense Lebanese water plan” J Weekly.com 2002
-
Sengupta Somini “In Israel and Lebanon, Talk of War Over Water” New York Times 2002 October 16 New York, USA 2002
-
Shaʿlah Tāriq “Miyāh Lubnān . . . qad’iyyah siyādiyyah” al-Kifāḥ al-ʿArabī 2002
-
Shuman Ellis “Israel warns Lebanon over Hatzbani water project” Israel Insider 2001
-
Sneh Ephraim Reaction on Coole’s Foreign Affairs Article on Diversion of Water to Israel 1984 Former IDF “Coordinator for Southern Lebanon”, handwritten note (also typed in Hebrew). Reference no 783 of the Associates for Middle East Research (AMER), now held by the Oregon State University Middle East Water Collection Database
-
Sobelman Daniel New Rules of the Game: Israel and Hizbollah after the Withdrawal from Lebanon 2004 Memorandum No. 69. Tel Aviv: Jafee Center for Strategic Studies, Tel Aviv University
-
Spector Bertram I. “Motivating Water Diplomacy: Finding the Situational Incentives to Negotiate” International Negotiation 2000 5 223 236
-
Spector Bertram I. “Resiliency in Negotiation: Bouncing Back from Impasse” International Negotiation 2006 11 2 273 286
-
Stetter Stephan, Herschinger Eva, Teichler Thomas & Albert Matthias “Conflicts about Water: Securitizations in a Global Context” Cooperation and Conflict 2011 46 441 459
-
Stinnett Douglas M. & Tir Jaroslav “The Institutionalization of River Treaties” International Negotiation 2009 14 229 251
-
Stork Joe “Water and Israel’s Occupation Strategy” Middle East Research & Information Project – MERIP Reports 1983 116 19 24
-
Tenne Abraham “The Challenges of Scaling up Desalination” Water Management in Scarcity Regions: The Experience of Israel. 2009 Presentation for World Bank. 8 July 2009. Israel Water Authority
-
Tooze Roger & May Christopher Authority and Markets – Susan Strange’s Writings on International Political Economy 2002 Basingstoke Palgrave MacMillan
-
Trondalen Jon Martin Water and Peace for the People: Possible Solutions to Water Disputes in the Middle East 2008 Paris UNESCO Publishing
-
Waintraub Nicole “Water and the Middle East Peace Process” Potentia 2009 Fall 23 35 2009
-
Warner Jeroen “Discourse Engineering . . . and Some of its Limits” 2010 Presentation given at the Fifth International Workshop on Hydro-Hegemony: Water Security, 8/9 May 2010, University of East Anglia London campus, London Water Research Group
-
Warner Jeroen & Buuren A. van “Multi-Stakeholder Learning and Fighting on the River Scheldt” International Negotiation 2009 14 419 440
-
Wolf Aaron T. “Hydrostrategic Decisionmaking and the Arab-Israeli Conflict” Yale F&ES Bulletin 1998 103 221 273
-
Wolf Aaron T. 2011 pers.comm. Telephone interview. Oregon State University. 01 April 2011
-
Zawahri Neda A. “Third Party Mediation of International River Disputes: Lessons from the Indus River” International Negotiation 2009 14 281 310
-
Zawahri Neda A. & Gerlak Andrea K. “Navigating International River Disputes to Avert Conflict” International Negotiation 2009 14 211 227
-
Zeitoun Mark Power and Water: The Hidden Politics of the Palestinian-Israeli Conflict 2008 London I.B. Tauris
-
Zeitoun Mark, Eid-Sabbagh Karim, Dajani Muna & Talhami Michael Hydro-political Baseline of the Upper Jordan River 2012 Beirut Association of the Friends of Ibrahim Abd el Al
-
Zeitoun Mark, Eid-Sabbagh Karim & Loveless Jeremy “Water as Deliberate and Indiscriminate Tool and Target of War: Lebanon-Israel 2006” (forthcoming) Submitted for publication to Disasters
-
Zeitoun Mark, Eid-Sabbagh Karim, Talhami Michael & Dajani Muna “Hydro-Hegemony in the Upper Jordan Waterscape: Control and Use of the Flows” Water Alternatives 2013 6 1
-
Zeitoun Mark, Messerschmid Clemens & Attili Shaddad “Asymmetric Abstraction and Allocation: The Israeli-Palestinian Water Pumping Record” Ground Water 2009 47 1 146 160
-
Zeitoun Mark, Mirumachi Naho & Warner Jeroen “Transboundary Water Interaction II: Soft Power Underlying Conflict and Cooperation” International Environmental Agreements 2011 11 2 159 178
-
Zisser E. Heller M. “Israel and Lebanon: The Battle for the Wazzani” Tel Aviv Notes – An Update on Political and Strategic Developments in the Middle East, No. 50 2002 Tel Aviv Moshe Dayan Center for Middle Easter and African Studies / Jafee Center for Strategic Studies, Tel Aviv University
| All Time | Past Year | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 1251 | 285 | 15 |
| Full Text Views | 300 | 29 | 1 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 233 | 54 | 2 |
The Influence of Narratives on Negotiations and Resolution of the Upper Jordan River Conflict
In: International NegotiationSearch for other papers by Mark Zeitoun in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Search for other papers by Michael Talhami in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Search for other papers by Karim Eid-Sabbagh in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Abstract
This article tests the assertion that narratives constructed around international environmental issues serve to promote or reduce opportunities for their resolution. It does this by interpreting the influence of Lebanese and Israeli environmental narratives on resolution of and indirect negotiations over the Upper Jordan River conflict. Colonial archives, key informant interviews and academic and policy literature serve to identify and critically investigate the narratives. An official Lebanese narrative of adherence to international law is found to contradict the more popular nationalist narrative of Israeli ‘theft’ of the flows. An Israeli water security discourse is found to be built on earlier narratives that have long held water (and the Upper Jordan flows in particular) as both a physically scarce and strategic commodity necessary for continued existence of the Israeli state. Basic discourse, security studies and negotiation theory is developed to gauge the influence of the narratives during the 2002 informal negotiations over the Wazzani pumping station dispute. The more influential Israeli discourse is found to establish the starting point (no discussion on re-allocation of the flows) and process of the informal negotiations. The narratives are found to open or shut windows for resolution of the conflict, by politicizing or securitizing ideas about the flows, respectively. The conflict management approach favored by US and EU mediators is seen to align with the more dominant discourse, at the cost of enduring asymmetry and tensions, and missed opportunities for both resolution of the conflict and promotion of fair water-sharing norms.
| All Time | Past Year | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 1251 | 285 | 15 |
| Full Text Views | 300 | 29 | 1 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 233 | 54 | 2 |