Issue Salience and Controversy: Any Effect on Chair’s Autonomy in Multilateral Negotiations?

in International Negotiation
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


High issue salience and controversy negatively affect the probability of success of multilateral negotiations. In such a context, Chairpersons acquire an important role in agenda management and brokerage among the bargaining partners. If they perform these functions neutrally and impartially, Chairs increase their effectiveness and emerge as key determinants of negotiation success. However, Chairs as agents often seek some degree of autonomy to pursue their own interests. We expect high issue salience and controversy to create a non-conducive environment for Chairs to follow their own agenda, due to greater principals’ sensitivity, thus leading any such autonomy-seeking attempt to failure. We discuss four case studies of negotiations taken from the un setting, in which Chairs sought autonomy in a highly polarized and controversial bargaining environment. Whereas in the first two cases, the Chairs’ attempts ended in failure confirming our basic hypothesis, in the latter two cases the Chairs were successful.

Issue Salience and Controversy: Any Effect on Chair’s Autonomy in Multilateral Negotiations?

in International Negotiation



BlavoukosSpyrosBourantonisDimitris Chairing Multilateral Negotiations: The Case of the United Nations 2011a London Routledge

BlavoukosSpyrosBourantonisDimitris “Chairs as Policy Entrepreneurs in Multilateral Negotiations.” Review of International Studies 2011b 37 2 653 672

BourantonisDimitris The History and Politics of the un Security Council Reform 2005 London Routledge

BuzanBarry “Negotiating by Consensus: Developments in Technique at the United Nations Conference on the Law of the Sea.” The American Journal of International Law 1981 75 2 324 348

CiobanuDan “Credentials of Delegations and Representation of Member States at the United Nations.” International and Comparative Law Quarterly 1976 25 2 352

ElgströmOle European Union Council Presidencies: A Comparative Perspective 2003 London Routledge

ElsterJohn Ulysses Unbound. Studies in Rationality Precommitment and Constraints 2000 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

FulciPaolo “Italy and the Reform of the un Security Council.” The International Spectator 1999 34 2 7 16

GeorgeA. L.BennettA. Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences 2005 Cambridge, MA MIT Press

GerringJohn Case Study Research: Principles and Practices 2007 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

GrossLeo “On the Degradation of the Constitutional Environment of the United Nations.” American Journal of International Law 1983 77 3 569 584

HurdIan After Anarchy: Legitimacy and Power in the United Nations Security Council 2007 Princeton Princeton University Press

JankowitschOdetteSauvantKarl The Third World without Superpowers: The Collected Documents of the Non-Aligned Countries 1978 New York Oceana Publications

KingdonJohn Agendas Alternatives and Public Policies 1982 New York Longman

KoremenosB.LipsonC.SnidalD. KoremenosB.LipsonC.SnidalD. “The Rational Design of International Institutions,” The Rational Design of International Institutions 2004 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

KiewietRoderickMcCubbinsMathew The Logic of Delegation: Congressional Parties and the Appropriation Process. 1991 Chicago University of Chicago Press

KufuorJohn “The Chair of the African Union.” African Journal of International and Comparative Law 2007 15 2 276 292

LuckEdward WeissThomasDawsSam “Principal Organs,” The Oxford Handbook on the United Nations 2007 Oxford Oxford University Press

MatesLeo Non-Alignment: Theory and Current Policy 1972 London & Belgrade Oceana Publications

McCubbinsMathewWeingastBarry “Administrative Procedures as Instruments of Political Control.” Journal of Law Economics and Organization 1987 3 2 243 277

MetcalfeD. “Leadership in European Union Negotiations: The Presidency of the Council.” International Negotiation 1998 3 3 413 434

MoeTerryHowellWilliam G. “The Presidential Power of Unilateral Action.” Journal of Law Economics and Organization 1999 15 1 132 179

MortimerRobert Third World Coalition in International Politics 1980 New York Praeger

MyrdalAlva The Game of Disarmament: How the United States and Russia Run the Arms Race 1978 New York Pantheon Books

OdellJohn “Chairing a wto Negotiation.” Journal of International Economic Law 2005 8 2 425 448

OxmanBernard “The Third United Nations Conference on the Law of the Sea: The 1976 New York Sessions.” The American Journal of International Law 1977 71 2 248 249

PenkethA. “New Security Council Enlargement Plan Unveiled.” Agence France Presse 1997 March 20

RaiffaHoward The Art and Science of Negotiation 1982 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press

SchellingT. The Strategy of Conflict. 1960 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press

SchimmelfennigFrank “International Socialization in the New Europe: Rational Action in an Institutional Environment.” European Journal of International Relations 2000 6 1 109 139

SimsNicholas Approaches to Disarmament: An Introductory Analysis. 1979 London Quaker Peace & Service

SmithCourtney “Three Perspectives on Global Consensus Building: A Framework for Analysis.” International Journal of Organization Theory and Behavior 2002 5 1&2 115 144

SullivanMichael “Conference at the Crossroads: Future Prospects for the ccd.” International Organization 1975 29 2 392 393

SwingJohn “The Law of the Sea.” Proceedings of the Academy of Political Science 1977 32 4 128 141

TallbergJonas “Delegation to Supranational Institutions: Why, How and with what Consequences” West European Politics 2002 25 1 23 46

TallbergJonas “The Agenda-Shaping Powers of the eu Council Presidency,” Journal of European Public Policy 2003 10 1 1 19

TallbergJonas “The Power of the Presidency: Brokerage, Efficiency and Distribution in eu Negotiations.” Journal of Common Market Studies 2004 42 5 999 1022

TallbergJonas Leadership and Negotiation in the European Union 2006 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

TallbergJonas “The Power of the Chair: Formal Leadership in International Cooperation.” International Studies Quarterly 2010 54 2 241 265

ThatcherMarcStone SweetAlec “Theory and Practice of Delegation to Non-Majoritarian Institutions.” West European Politics 2002 25 1 1 22

TarrowSidney “The Strategy of Paired Comparison: Toward a Theory of Practice.” Comparative Political Studies 2010 43 2 230 59

TouvalSaadiaZartmanI. William The Man in the Middle: International Mediation in Theory and Practice 1985 Boulder, CO Westview Press

WallJamesLynnAnn “Mediation: A Current Review.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 1993 37 1 160 194

YoungOran “The Politics of International Regime Formation: Managing Natural Resources and the Environment.” International Organization 1989 43 3 349 375

ZartmanI. William “Introduction: Bias, Prenegotiation and Leverage in Mediation.” International Negotiation 2008 13 3 305 310

ZartmanI. WilliamTouvalSaadia “International Mediation: Conflict Resolution and Power Politics.” Journal of Social Issues 1985a 41 2 27 45


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 17 17 9
Full Text Views 77 77 54
PDF Downloads 3 3 1
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0