Canada’s Multiple Voices Diplomacy in Climate Change Negotiations: A Focus on Québec

in International Negotiation
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


This article sheds light on the complexity of international climate change negotiations in a federal country, like Canada, where there is no clear attribution of full power over international negotiation concerning this issue. Climate change is a multi-level and multi-stakeholder issue, one that can only be tackled successfully if all actors, at all levels of government, are involved in the process. In recent years, Canadian provinces, especially Québec, have become intensely involved in climate change paradiplomacy. That situation has led to a Canadian paradox where the Government of Québec worked to respect the Kyoto Protocol and act accordingly, while Canada opted out of the Protocol in 2011.

Canada’s Multiple Voices Diplomacy in Climate Change Negotiations: A Focus on Québec

in International Negotiation



afp “Nobel Climate Panel Chief Raps Canada on Carbon Cuts.” Agence France Presse 2007 Online <

ArbourJ.-M. Droit international public 1997 3rd ed. Cowansville Éditions Yvon Blais

AndonovaLiliana B.BetsillMichele M.BulkeleyHarriet “Transnational Climate Governance” Global Environmental Politics 2009 9 2 52 73

BacheIanFlindersMatthew Multi-Level Governance 2004 Oxford Oxford University Press

BadieBertrandSmoutsMarie-Claude Le retournement du monde: Sociologie de la scène internationale 1999 3rd ed. Paris PFNSP et Dalloz.

BakvisHermanBaierGeraldBrownDouglas M. Contested Federalism: Certainty and Ambiguity in the Canadian Federation. 2009 Toronto Oxford University Press.

BoardmanRobert VannijnattenDebora L.BoardmanRobert “Canadian Environmental Policy in the Global Context: Obligations and Opportunities” Canadian Environmental Policy and Politics. Prospects for Leadership and Innovation 2009 3rd ed. Toronto Oxford University Press 137 149

BramleyMatthew “Far from Turning the Corner.” Carbon Finance 2008 June 20 2008.

BramleyMatthewDemerseClare Climate Change Kyoto and the New Federal Government: Concerns and Expectations 2006

BrownDouglas M.FryEarl H. States and Provinces in the International Economy 1993 Berkeley, CA Institute of Governmental Studies Press.

Canadian Press “Copenhague: Charest avertit Harper.” Les 2009 December 16 2009.

CardinalFrançois “L’honnêteté du Canada mise en doute.” La Presse 2007a December 12 2007.

CardinalFrançois “Même la Chine fait la leçon au Canada.” La Presse 2007b December 11 2007.

cbc “Harper’s Letter dismisses Kyoto as “Socialist Scheme”.” cbc News 2007 January 30 2007. Online <

ChalouxAnnieSéguinHugo “États fédérés et mise en oeuvre de traités climatiques internationaux: le cas du Québec.” Revue de droit de l’Université de Sherbrooke 2012 4 608 632

Climate Action Network International “Fossil of the Day Awards – Bonn – June 6, 2011.” 2011 Accessed at:–2011

Climate Group The Climate Group. 2013 Online at <

CyrHugo Canadian Federalism and Treaty Powers. Organis Constituionalism at Work 2009 New York P.I.E. Peter Lang.

DavisRufus WildavskyAaron “The Federal Principle Reconsidered” American Federalism in Perspective 1967 Boston Little Brown.

De MestralArmand Gaudreau-DesBiensJ.-F.GélinasF. “The Provinces and International Relations in Canada” The States and Moods of Federalism: Governance Identity and Methodology 2005 Cowansville Éditions Yvon Blais 319 322

De MestralArmandFox-DecentEvan “Rethinking the Relationship between International and Domestic Law.” McGill Law Journal 2008 53 573

DufaultEvelyne Demi-tour: une approche sociologique des renversements de politique étrangère. Le cas de la politique étrangère environnementale canadienne 2006 PhD Thesis Montréal Sciences politiques Université du Québec à Montréal.

FafardPatrickLeblondPatrick “Closing the Deal: What Role for the Provinces in the Final Stages of the ceta Negotiations?” International Journal 2013 68 4 553 559

GauvinJean-Philippe “Les relations intergouvernementales au Canada: gage de succès ou d’échec?” Options politiques 2012 38 41

Government of Canada Federalism and International Relations Ministry of Foreign Affairs Ottawa. 1968a

Government of Canada Federalism and International Conference on Education Ministry of Foreign Affairs Ottawa. 1968b

Gouvernement du Québec “Le Québec et les changements climatiques: Un défi pour l’avenir. Plan d’action 2006–2012.” Ministère du Développement durable de l’Environnement et des Parcs. 2008

GoldenbergEddie The Way it Works: Inside Canada 2006 Toronto McClelland & Stewart

HaasPeter M.KeohaneRobert O.LevyMarc A. Institutions for the Earth. Sources of Effective International Environmental Protection 1993 Cambridge, MA The MIT Press.

HarringtonJoanna “Redressing the Democratic Deficit in Treaty Law Making: (Re-) Establishing a Role for Parliament.” McGill Law Journal 2005 50 465 509

HarrisonKathryn Passing the Buck. Federalism and Canadian Environmental Policy 1996 Vancouver UBC Press.

HarrisonKathryn “The Road Not Taken: Climate Change Policy in Canada and the United States” Global Environmental Politics 2007 7 4 92 117

HockingBrian Localizing Foreign Policy. Non-central Governments and Multilayered Diplomacy 1993 New York St. Martin’s Press.

HoogheLiesbetMarksGary “Unravelling the Central State, but How? Types of Multi-Level Governance.” American Political Science Review 2003 97 2 233 243

JefferyCharlie “Sub-National Mobilization and European Integration: Does it Make Any Difference?” Journal of Common Market Studies 2000 38 1 1 23

KukuchaChristopher “Canadian Sub-federal governments and ceta: Overarching Themes and Future Trends” International Journal 2013 528 535

KukuchaChristopher The Provinces and Canadian Foreign Trade Policy 2008 Vancouver, UBC Press.

KukuchaChristopher “Dismembering Canada? Stephen Harper and the Foreign Relations of Canadian Provinces.” Review of Constitutional Studies 2009 14 1

KukuchaChristopher “Provincial Pitfalls: Canadian Provinces and the Canada-eu Trade Negotiations” Association Canadienne De Science Politique 2010 82e Congrès Annuel Université Concordia.

LidskogRolfElanderIngemar “Addressing Climate Change Democratically. Multi-Level Governance, Transnational Networks and Governmental Structures” Sustainable Development 2010 18 1 32 41

MacdonaldDouglas VanNijnattenDebora L.BoardmanRobert “The Failure of Canadian Climate Change Policy: Veto Power, Absent Leadership, and Institutional Weakness” Canadian Environmental Policy and Politics. Propects for Leadership and Innovation 2009 Toronto Oxford University Press 152 166

MacdonaldDouglasSmithHeather A. “Promises Made, Promises Broken: Questioning Canada’s Commitments to Climate Change” International Journal 1999 55 1 107 124

MacdonaldDouglasSmithHeather A.VanNijnattenDebora L. “Sustainable Development and Kyoto Implementation in Canada: The Road Not Taken” Policy Options 2005 13 29

MacdonaldDouglasSmithHeather A.VanNijnattenDebora L. “La politique canadienne en matière de changements climatiques et l’influence nord-américaine.” Gouvernance 2010 7 1

MayElizabeth BlakeR.B. “Brian Mulroney and the Environment” Transforming the Nation: Canada and Brian Mulroney 2007 Montreal McGill-Queen’s University Press 381 392

MartinLisa L. Democratic Commitments: Legislatures and International Cooperation 2000 Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press

MeekisonJ. Peter Relations intergouvernementales dans les pays fédérés: Une série d’essais sur la pratique de la gouvernance fédérale 2004 Ottawa Forum des Fédérations.

MichelmannHans Foreign Relations in Federal Countries 2009 Montreal McGill University Press

MilnerHelen V.RosendorffB. Peter “Democratic Politics and International Trade Negotiations. Elections and Divided Governments as Constraints on Trade Liberalization.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 1997 41 117

neg-ecp Climate Change Action Plan 2001 Conference of New England Governors and Eastern Canada Premiers.

OkerekeChukwumerijeBulkeleyHarrietSchroederHeike “Conceptualizing Climate Governance Beyond the International Regime.” Global Environmental Politics 2009 9 1 58 78

OttHermann E.SterkWolfgangWatanabeRie “The Bali Roadmap: New Horizons for Global Climate Policy.” Climate Policy 2008 81 1 91 95

PaquinStéphane Histoire des relations internationales du Québec 2006 Montréal VLB éditeur

PaquinStéphane Paradiplomatie et relations internationales: théorie des stratégies internationales des régions face à la mondialisation 2004 Brussels Presses interuniversitaires européennes-Peter-Lang.

PaquinStéphane “Quelle place pour les provinces canadiennes dans les organisations et les négociations internationales du Canada à la lumière des pratiques au sein d’autres fédérations?” Administration publique du Canada / Canadian Public Administration 2005 48 4 477 505

PaquinStéphane “Federalism and Compliance with International Agreements: Belgium and Canada Compared.” The Hague Journal of Diplomacy 2010 5 173 197

PaquinStéphane “Federalism and the Governance of International Trade Negotiations in Canada: Comparing cusfta with ceta.” International Journal 2013 545 552

PatryAndré Le Québec dans le monde 1980 Montréal Leméac

PiattoniSimona The Theory of Multi-level Governance. Conceptual Empirical and Normative Challenges 2010 New York Oxford University Press.

PutnamRobert “ Diplomacy and Domestic Politics : The Logic of Two-Level Games.” International Organization 1988 42 3 427 460

Québec Éléments de planification québécoise du développement durable 1995 Québec Ministère de l’Environnement et de la Faune

Québec L’Assemblée nationale du Québec appuie à l’unanimité le protocole de Kyoto: Communiqué de presse c010410a 2001 Québec Assemblée nationale du Québec

Québec 2006 Journal des débatsDébats de l’Assemblée nationale Assemblée nationale du Québec [online] < – _Toc150845481>

Québec 2007 Gazette officielle du Québec décret 1074–2007 January 3 2008 140th year no 1 Gouvernement du Québec

RobitailleAntoine “La France défend le Québec à Nairobi. Une sorte de “Vive le Québec vert” vite dénoncé par Ottawa.” Le Devoir 2006 November 17

SavoieDonald J. BickertonJamesGagnonAlain G. “Power at the Apex: Executive Dominance” Canadian Politics 2004 4th ed. New York Broadview Press

ScharpfFritz W. “The Joint-Decision Trap: Lessons from the German Federalism and European Integration.” Public Administration 1988 66 3 239 278

scic News Release – Joint Communiqué First Ministers’ Meeting Ottawa – December 12 1997 1997a Secrétariat des Conférences intergouvernementales canadiennes [online] <

scic Réunion conjointe des sous-ministres de l’environnement et de l’énergie: Communiqué de presse 830–599/00 1997b Regina

ShawMalcolm N. International Law 2008 6th ed. Cambridge Cambridge University Press

SimeonRichard MeekisonJ.P. “Conclusion” Relations intergouvernementales dans les pays fédérés: Une série d’essais sur la pratique de la gouvernance fédérale 2004 Ottawa Forum des Fédération.

SimpsonJeffreyJaccardMarkRiversNic Hot Air. Meeting Canada’s Climate Change Challenge 2008 2nd ed. Toronto McClelland & Stewart

SkogstadGrace BakvisHermanSkogstadGrace “International Trade Policy and Canadian Federalism: A Constructive Tension” Canadian Federalism: Performance Effectiveness and Legitimacy 2012 3rd ed. Toronto Oxford University Press

SmithHeather A. Canadian Federalism and International Environmental Policy Making: The Case of Climate Change 1998 Working Paper, Institute of Intergovernmental Relations

SmithHeather A. “Political Parties and Canadian Climate Change Policy” International Journal 2008 64 1 47 66

StilbornJack “Canadian Intergovernmental Relations and the Kyoto Protocol: What Happened, What Didn’t” cpsa 2003 Conference 2003

StoettPeter SelinHenrikVanDeveerStacy D. “Looking for Leadership: Canada and Climate Change Policy” Changing Climates in North American Politics. Institutions Policymaking and Multilevel Governance 2009 Cambridge, MA The MIT Press

TwomeyAnne MichelmannHans “Commonwealth of Australia” Foreign Relations in Federal Countries 2009 Montreal McGill University Press

undp Human Development Report 2007/2008 2007 New York Human Development Report Office, United Nations

VanDuzerAnthony J. “Could an Intergovernemental Agreement Increase the Credibility of Canadian Treaty Commitments in areas of Provincial Jurisdiction?” International Journal 2013 536 544

VanNijnattenDebora L. VanNijnattenDebora L.BoardmanRobert “The North American Context: Canadian Environmental Policy and the Continental Push” Canadian Environmental Policies and Politics 2009 Don Mills Oxford University Press 92 108

VanNijnattenDebora L.BoardmanRobert Canadian Environmental Policy and Politics 2009 Don Mills Oxford University Press

wci Design for the wci Regional Program 2010 [online] <>

WheareKenneth C. Federal Government 1967 Oxford Oxford University Press

WindfieldMark S.MacdonaldDouglas BakvisHermanSkogstadGrace “The Harmonization Accord and Climate Change Policy: Two Case Studies in Federal-Provincial Environmental Policy” Canadian Federalism: Performance Effectiveness and Legitimacy 2008 2nd edition Toronto Oxford University Press 266 288


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 15 15 7
Full Text Views 86 86 65
PDF Downloads 3 3 1
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0