Reforming the United Nations Security Council: Feasibility or Utopia?
In: International NegotiationSearch for other papers by Kai Schaefer in
Current site
Google Scholar
Reforming the United Nations Security Council has been on the agenda of the General Assembly for over two decades. However, structural reform of the Council remains elusive. This article explains why after so many years nearly all 193 states within the un remain actively seized on the matter of reform, despite no immediate outcome being in sight. In order to analyze Security Council reform efforts and the various obstacles along the way, this article emphasizes states’ motivations during the reform process. With the help of new institutionalist theory, an argument is formed that highlights how certain states are driven by strategic calculations and self-interest, while others are more normatively motivated. Furthermore, the article highlights that despite only lukewarm support for reform from certain states, not a single state can publicly denounce Council reform, because the reform issue itself has become an ingrained norm.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Alvarez Jose International Organizations as Law-makers 2005 New York Oxford University Press
-
Binder Martin & Heupel Monika “The Legitimacy of the UN Security Council: Evidence from Recent General Assembly Debates” International Studies Quarterly 2015 59 238 250
-
Cass Loren “Norm Entrapment and Preference Change: The Evolution of the European Union Position on International Emissions Trading” Global Environmental Politics 2005 5 2 38 60
-
Chapnick Adam “UN Security Council reform and Canadian foreign policy: Then and now” Canadian Foreign Policy Journal 2006 13 1 81 96
-
Druckman Daniel “Turning Points in International Negotiation: A Comparative Analysis” Journal of Conflict Resolution 2001 45 4 519 544
-
Einsiedel Sebastian, Malone David & Ugarte Bruno The UN Security Council in the 21st Century 2015 Boulder, CO Lynne Rienner Publishers
-
Elster Jon Explaining Social Behaviour: More Nuts and Bolts for the Social Sciences 2007 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Fasulo Linda An Insider’s Guide to the UN 2009 New Haven Yale University Press
-
Fearon James D. “Bargaining, Enforcement, and International Cooperation” International Organization 1998 52 2 269 305
-
Finnemore Martha & Sikkink Kathryn “International Norm Dynamics and Political Change” International Organization 1998 52 4 887 917
-
Gowan Richard & Gordon Nora Pathways to Security Council Reform 2014 New York New York University Center on International Cooperation commissioned by the Permanent Mission of Japan to the United Nations.
-
Hall Peter & Taylor Rosemary “Political Science and the Three New Institutionalisms” Political Studies 1996 XLIV 936 957
-
Hosli Madeleine et al. “Squaring the Circle? Collective and Distributive Effects of United Nations Security Council Reform” Rev Int Organ 2011 6 163 187
-
Hurd Ian “Legitimacy, Power, and the Symbolic Life of the UN Security Council” Global Governance 2002 8 1 35 51
-
Hurd Ian “Myths of Membership: The Politics of Legitimation in UN Security Council Reform” Global Governance 2008 14 199 217
-
Hurd Ian After Anarchy – Legitimacy and Power in the United Nations Security Council 2008 Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press
-
Lipson Michael “Peacekeeping: Organized Hypocrisy?” European Journal of International Relations 2007 13 1 5 34 ProQuest Central
-
Luck Edward UN Security Council – Practice and Promise 2006 New York Routledge
-
March James & Olsen Johan “The New Institutionalism: Organizational Factors in Political Life” The American Political Science Review 1984 78 3 734 749
-
March James “The Institutional Dynamics of International Political Orders” International Organization 1998 52 4 943 969
-
March James The Logic of Appropriateness 2009 Arena Center for European Studies, University of Oslo, Working paper, 04/09.
-
Olsen Johan “Change and continuity: an institutional approach to institutions of democratic government” European Political Science Review 2009 1 1 3 32
-
Panke Diana “Lock-in Strategies in International Negotiations: The Deconstruction of Bargaining Power” Journal of International Studies 2015 43 2 375 391
-
Pedrazzi Marco “Italy’s approach to UN Security Council reform” The International Spectator 2000 35 3 49 56
-
Peters Guy Institutional Theory in Political Science. The New Institutionalism 2012 New York The Continuum International Publishing Group
-
Pouliot Vincent Paul T. V., Welch Larson Deborah & Wohlforth William “Setting Status in Stone: The Negotiation of International Instiutional Privileges” Status in World Politics 2014 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Pouliot Vincent International Pecking Orders: The Politics and Practice of Multilateral Diplomacy forthcoming Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Schimmelfennig Frank “The Community Trap: Liberal Norms, Rhetorical Action, and the Eastern Enlargement of the European Union” International Organization 2001 55 1 47 80
-
Swart Lydia Proposals to Reform the UN Security Council: Changing the Composition of the Security Council – Is There a Viable Solution 2015 Center for UN Reform Education
-
Swart Lydia & Von Freiesleben Jonas Governing and Managing Change at the United Nations: Reform of the Security Council from 1945 to September 2013 2013 New York Center for UN Reform Education
-
Thelen Kathleen “Historical Institutionalism in Comparative Politics” Annual Review of Political Science 1999 2 369 404
-
Thompson Alexander “Coercion through IOs: The Security Council and the Logic of Information Transmission” International Organization 2006 60 1 34
-
Voeten Erik “The Political Origins of the UN Security Council’s Ability to Legitimize the Use of Force” International Organization 2005 59 3 527 557
-
Von Freiesleben Jonas A Look at the Transitional Approach to Security Council Reform 2008 New York Center for UN Reform Education
-
Weiss Thomas “Fundamental UN Reform: A Non-starter or Not?” Global Policy 2011 2 2
-
Weiss Thomas, Forsythe David & Coate Roger The United Nations and Changing World Politics. 2007 Boulder, CO Westview Press
-
Welch David Justice and the Genesis of War 1993 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Zartman I. William “Negotiation Pedagogy: International Relations” International Negotiation 2010 15 2 229 246
-
Zartman I. William “Negotiation Theory and the Intifadat” International Negotiation 2015 20 1 109 128
-
4
2005: ST/ADM/SER.B/638; 2015: ST/ADM/SER.B/910.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 3121 | 430 | 46 |
| Full Text Views | 782 | 89 | 17 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 1090 | 180 | 42 |
Reforming the United Nations Security Council: Feasibility or Utopia?
In: International NegotiationSearch for other papers by Kai Schaefer in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Reforming the United Nations Security Council has been on the agenda of the General Assembly for over two decades. However, structural reform of the Council remains elusive. This article explains why after so many years nearly all 193 states within the un remain actively seized on the matter of reform, despite no immediate outcome being in sight. In order to analyze Security Council reform efforts and the various obstacles along the way, this article emphasizes states’ motivations during the reform process. With the help of new institutionalist theory, an argument is formed that highlights how certain states are driven by strategic calculations and self-interest, while others are more normatively motivated. Furthermore, the article highlights that despite only lukewarm support for reform from certain states, not a single state can publicly denounce Council reform, because the reform issue itself has become an ingrained norm.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 3121 | 430 | 46 |
| Full Text Views | 782 | 89 | 17 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 1090 | 180 | 42 |