The Kerry Peace Initiative in the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict: When Hope and Good Intentions Are Not Enough

in International Negotiation
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



This article examines the factors that contributed to the failure of the last major effort, which was carried out by us Secretary of State John Kerry, to facilitate a Final Status Agreement to resolve the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The analysis is based on an understanding that every effort to resolve this intractable conflict, even if unsuccessful, is worthy of examination, which can yield interesting observations and insights that may inform future attempts to find a solution. As President Trump’s administration makes intensive efforts to broker an Israeli-Palestinian peace agreement, and the us Middle East negotiation delegation shuttles intensively between the parties and between major regional actors to explore the possibility of renewing official negotiations, this seems like an opportune time to review the major factors that affected the outcome of the previous peace talks.

The Kerry Peace Initiative in the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict: When Hope and Good Intentions Are Not Enough

in International Negotiation



AggestamKarin (2002). “Mediating Asymmetrical Conflict.” Mediterranean Politics 71: 6991.

BercovitchJacob (2009). “Mediation and Conflict Resolution,” in J. BercovitchV. Kremenyuk and I. W. Zartman editors The SAGE Handbook of Conflict Resolution. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications340357.

BirnbaumB. and A. Tibon (2014). “The Explosive, Inside Story of How John Kerry Built an Israel-Palestine Peace Plan – and Watched it Crumble.” New Republic.

BromShlomo (2014). “The American Principles Document: The Negotiations with Israel and the Palestinians.” INSSFebruary 9: 515. Accessed at:

BromS.U. Dekel and A. Kurtz (2015). “The Israeli Palestinian arena: Lessons following failed negotiation and military conflict.” INSS 2014–2015. Accessed at:

Channel 2 News (2013). “Celebrations at the Palestinian Authority: An agreement will be signed only when all the prisoners are back.” December 13. Accessed at:

CohenG. and J. Khoury (2013). “Thousands protest in front of Ofer Prison against the prisoners’ release.” HaaretzOctober 28. Accessed at:

CohenYaacov (2013). “Palestinians resume negotiations and internal audit doubts about his success.” The Middle East Media Research InstituteOctober 13. Accessed at:

DekelU.A. Kurtz and G. Sher (2014). “Israel and the political process-Plan A, Plan B and what is in-between.” INSS 2013–2014. Tel Aviv University. Accessed at:

DiehlJackson (2009). “Abbas’s Waiting Game on Peace with Israel.” The Washington PostMay 29.

FriedmanUri (2014). “Martin Indyk Explains the Collapse of the Middle East Peace Process.” The AtlanticJuly 3.

Haaretz (2010). “Netanyahu Offers Settlement Freeze in Return for Recognition as Jewish State, Palestinians Say No.” October 10. Accessed at:

Haaretz (2014). “Obama administration officials are considering releasing Pollard for the extension.” April 1. Accessed at:

HaleviJonathan D. (2014). “The Crisis in the Peace Talks Was Pre-Planned by the Palestinians.” Jerusalem Center for Public AffairsApril 10. Accessed at:

HarelAmos (2013). “Release of prisoners: the double protection of Netanyahu from escalation in the West Bank and the collapse of talks.” HaaretzOctober 13. Accessed at:

International Centre for the Study of Radicalisation and Political Violence (2013). “Kerry’s joint interview with Israeli and Palestinian reporters: A step forward or a step in the wrong direction?” King’s College LondonNovember 12. Accessed at:

KalmanAaron (2013). “Kerry: Israeli ‘prosperity’ prevents sense of urgency about peace.” The Times of IsraelMay 23. Accessed at:

KerryJohn (2013). “Remarks at the American Jewish Committee Global Forum.” US Department of StateJune 3. Washington, DC. Accessed at: https://2009–

KerryJ.T. Livni and S. Erekat (2013). “Remarks on the Middle East Peace Process Talks.” US Department of StateJuly 30. Washington, DC. Accessed at: https://2009–

KershnerIsabel (2009). “Netanyahu Backs Palestinian State, with Caveats.” The New York TimesJune 14.

KhalidiRashid I. (2014). “Chronicles of a Death Foretold.” Journal of Palestinian Studies 433. Accessed at:

KhouryJackie (2014). “Senior official in Abbas’ bureau: Kerry did not present any new initiative to us for negotiation.” HaaretzOctober 16. Accessed at:

KirkM.M. Wiser and J. Gilmore (2016). “Netanyahu at War.” In Public Broadcasting Service FrontlineJanuary 5. Accessed at:

LakshmananI. and N. Gaouette (2013). “Kerry’s Day-and-Night Pursuit Reaps Fragile Mideast Talks.” BloombergJuly 22. Accessed at:–07–21/kerry-s-day-and-night-pursuit-reaps-fragile-mideast-talks.

LandlerMark (2010). “In Middle East Peace Talks, Clinton Faces a Crucial Test.” The New York TimesSeptember 4.

LandlerM. and M. Gordon (2014). “US Is Weighing Release of a Spy for the Israelis.” The New York TimesMarch 31.

LissYehonathan (2013). “Conflict between the torch and storm troopers attacking bent on promoting law against releasing terrorists.” HaaretzOctober 27. Accessed at:

MillerAaron D. (2013). “What makes John Kerry think he can secure peace in Israel?” The Washington PostJuly 25.

MillerAaron D. (2016). “Why US diplomacy can’t fix the Middle East.” The Washington PostJune 3.

MitchellGeorge J. (2015). The Negotiator. New York: Simon and Schuster.

PruittDean G. (2005). “Whither Ripeness Theory?” Working paper No. 25. Washington, DC: George Mason University Press. Accessed at:

PruittDean G. (2007). “Readiness Theory and the Northern Ireland Conflict.” American Behavioral Scientist 5011: 15201541.

RabbaniMouin (2014). “It’s Not Over Until It’s Over.” Journal of Palestinian Studies 433.

RavidBarak (2013a). “The evening of the prisoners’ release: Israel announces the construction of 1,200 units across the Green Line.” HaaretzAugust 11. Accessed at:

RavidBarak (2013b). “All You Wanted to Know about the Resumption of the Israeli-Palestinian Negotiations.” HaaretzAugust 5. Accessed at:

RavidBarak (2013c). “The Palestinians Rejected the American Proposal for Security Arrangements in a Future Agreement.” HaaretzDecember 5. Accessed:

RavidBarak (2014a). “US is Pessimistic about Achieving a Framework Agreement by the End of the Month.” HaaretzMarch 3. Accessed at:

RavidBarak (2014b). “Kerry in a Closed Conversation: Without Peace, Israel is Liable to Become an Apartheid State.” HaaretzApril 28. Accessed at:

RavidBarak (2014c). “Netanyahu’s Flexibility, the Americans’ Mistake,” HaaretzJuly 5. Accessed at:

RavidB. and J. Khoury (2013). “Netanyahu on the prisoners’ release: Important move for the state.” HaaretzJuly 28. Accessed at:

RavidB. and J. Khoury (2014). “Kerry to Meet with Abbas Today in Effort to Prevent Breakdown of Negotiations.” HaaretzMarch 24. Accessed at:

RosenSteven J. (2010). “Interesting George Mitchell Interview.” Middle East ForumJanuary 7.

RudorenJodi (2014). “Palestinians Set to Seek Redress in a World Court.” The New York TimesDecember 31.

RossDennis B. (2015). “Stop Giving Palestinians a Pass.” The New York TimesJanuary 5.

SchiffAmira (2014). “Reaching a Mutual Agreement: Readiness Theory and Coalition Building in the Aceh Peace Process.” Negotiation and Conflict Management Research 71: 5782.

SegalUdi (2013a). “This is how the prisoners deal was struck in return for construction.” Channel 2 NewsOctober 30. Accessed at:

SegalUdi (2013b). “Netanyahu in a letter on the release of the prisoners: Prime Ministers are required to make decisions that go against public opinion.” Channel 2 NewsJuly 27. Accessed at:

SherwoodHarriet (2013). “Kerry: Two years left to reach two-state solution in Middle East peace process.” The GuardianApril 18. Accessed at:

TibonAmir (2014a). “Will He Close a Deal? Kerry to Meet with Netanyahu and Abu Mazen.” Walla NewsMarch 31. Accessed at:

TibonAmir (2014b). “The UN Security Council Rejected the Palestinian Proposal.” Walla NewsDecember 31. Accessed at:

TouvalS. and I. W. Zartman (2001). “International Mediation in the Post-Cold War Era,” in C. A. CrockerF. O. Hampson and P. Aall editors Turbulent Peace: The Challenges of Managing International Conflict. Washington, DC: US Institute of Peace Press.

TzenaShlomo (2013). “Bennett on the prisoner release: Can live with that.” Israel HayomNovember 1. Accessed at:

YaarE. and T. Hermann (2014a). The Peace IndexJanuary. Accessed at:

YaarE. and T. Hermann (2014b). Peace Index ColumnFebruary. Accessed at:

YadlinAmos (2014). “Focus on the Essence, Not on the Process.” Maariv OnlineAugust 6. Accessed at:

ZananyOmer (2015). Annapolis Process (2007–2008): Oasis or Mirage. Tel Aviv: Tami Steinmetz Center for Peace Research, Tel Aviv University.

ZartmanI. William (1999). Negotiations as a Mechanism for Resolution in the Arab-Israeli Conflict. Jerusalem: The Leonard Davis Institute, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem.

ZartmanI. William (2000). “The Hurting Stalemate and Beyond,” in P. C. Stern and D. Druckman editors Conflict Resolution after the Cold War. Washington D.C.: National Academy Press.

ZartmanI. William (2008). “Ripeness Revisited: The Push and Pull of Conflict Management,” in William I. Zartman editor Essays on Theory and Practice. New York: Routledge.

ZartmanI. William (2012). “Process Reasons for Failure,” in Guy Olivier Faure editor Unfinished Business: Why International Negotiations Fail. Athens, GA: University of Georgia Press.

ZartmanI. W. and A. deSoto (2010). Timing Mediation Initiatives. Washington, DC: United States Institute of Peace Press.

ZartmanI. W. and J. Z. Rubin (2000). Power and Negotiation. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.



Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 58 58 14
Full Text Views 106 106 72
PDF Downloads 7 7 3
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0