Is a One Welfare Approach the Key to Addressing Unintended Harms and Maximising Benefits Associated with Animal Shelters?

in Journal of Applied Animal Ethics Research

Abstract

Animal shelters, pounds and rescue organisations have evolved over time. Today they serve three purposes: to reduce animal welfare harms, to reduce harms to the community associated with free-roaming, stray or unwanted companion animals, and to reduce their associated environmental harms. This discussion explores the evolution of animal shelters, and argues that they are justified on utilitarian grounds. It explores unintended harms of shelters on animal welfare, including humane killing for the purposes of population control and shelter population management, as well as risks associated with confinement including behavioural deterioration and infectious diseases. It also explores harms to non-human animals, including moral distress and compassion fatigue. Finally, it explores potential environmental harms of shelters. The One Welfare concept, utilised in the World Animal Health Organisation (OIE) Global Animal Welfare Strategy, acknowledges the interplay between animal welfare, human well-being and environmental sustainability. It is argued that the One Welfare framework is critical in minimising harms and maximising benefits associated with animal shelters.

  • American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (2017). Pet statistics. ASPCA. Available online: https://www.aspca.org/animal-homelessness/shelter-intake-and-surrender/pet-statistics [Accessed October 19, 2017].

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • American Veterinary Medical Association (2017). Options for integrating eco-friendly features into veterinary practices. AVMA. Available online: https://www.avma.org/PracticeManagement/Facilities/Pages/Options-for-integrating-eco-friendly-features-into-veterinary-practices.aspx [Accessed October 21, 2017].

    • Export Citation
  • Amiot, C., Bastian, B., & Martens, P. (2016). “People and companion animals: it takes two to tango”. BioScience, 66, 552–560.

  • Asilomar Accords (2004). The Asilomar Accords. Available online: https://www.shelteranimalscount.org/docs/default-source/DataResources/2004aaccords5.pdf?sfvrsn=0 [Accessed October 20, 2017].

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Australian Veterinary Association (2017). Re-emergence of feline panleukopenia in Australian cats. Available online: http://www.ava.com.au/node/86283 [Accessed October 31, 2017].

    • Export Citation
  • Batchelor, C.E.M. & McKeegan, D.E.F. (2012). “Survey of the frequency and perceived stressfulness of ethical dilemmas encountered in UK veterinary practice”. Veterinary Record, 170, 19–U55.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Best Friends (2017). No Kill Timeline. Available online: https://bestfriends.org/about/our-story/no-kill-timeline [Accessed October 19, 2017].

  • Bozena, P., Jens Jörn, D., & Marc, A. (2002). “The state of ISO 9000 certification: a study of Swedish organizations”. The TQM Magazine, 14, 297–306.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Burn, C.C. (2017). “Bestial boredom: a biological perspective on animal boredom and suggestions for its scientific investigation”. Animal Behaviour, 130, 141–151.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Carter, J. & Taylor, C.S. (2018). “Socio-economic factors in companion animal relinquishment on the Sunshine Coast, Australia”. Society & Animals.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Chua, D., Rand, J., & Morton, J. (2017). “Surrendered and stray dogs in Australia— estimation of numbers entering municipal pounds, shelters and rescue groups and their outcomes”. Animals, 7, 50.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Clark, C.C., Gruffydd-Jones, T., & Murray, J.K. (2012). “Number of cats and dogs in UK welfare organisations”. Veterinary Record, 170, 493–493.

  • College of Veterinarians of British Columbia (2014). Information on sodium pentobarbital. College of Veterinarians of British Columbia. Available online: https://www.cvbc.ca/CVBC2/General-Topics/Poison/Secondary_Poisoning_from_Euthanasia_Drug.aspx [Accessed October 25, 2017].

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Colonius, T.J. & Earley, R.W. (2013). “One welfare: a call to develop a broader framework of thought and action”. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, 242, 309–310.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Companion Animals Act (NSW) (2017). Companion Animals Act 1998 No 87. NSW Government. Available from: https://www.legislation.nsw.gov.au.

    • Export Citation
  • Coppola, C.L., Enns, R.M., & Grandin, T. (2006). “Noise in the animal shelter environment: building design and the effects of daily noise exposure”. Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science, 9, 1–7.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Crane, M.F., Bayl-Smith, P., & Cartmill, J. (2013). “A recommendation for expanding the definition of moral distress experienced in the workplace”. The Australian and New Zealand Journal of Organisational Psychology, 6, 1–9.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Crane, M.F., Phillips, J.K., & Karin, E. (2015). “Trait perfectionism strengthens the negative effects of moral stressors occurring in veterinary practice”. Australian Veterinary Journal, 93, 354–360.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Dawson, B. & Thompson, N. (2017). “The effect of personality on occupational stress in veterinary surgeons”. Journal of Veterinary Medical Education, 44:1, 72–83.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Dingman, P.A., Levy, J.K., Rockey, L.E., & Crandall, M.M. (2014). “Use of visual and permanent identification for pets by veterinary clinics”. The Veterinary Journal, 201, 46–50.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Driver, J. (2014). “The history of utilitarianism”. In: E.N. Zalta (ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Winter 2014 ed. Stanford, CA: Metaphysics Research Lab, Center for the Study of Language and Information, Stanford University.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Duvin, E.S. (1989). “In the name of mercy”. Animalines, 4.

  • English Oxford Living Dictionaries (2017). Shelter. https://en.oxforddictionaries.com. Available online: https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/shelter [Accessed October 24, 2017].

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Farm Animal Welfare Council (2009). Farm Animal Welfare in Great Britain: Past, Present and Future. London: Department for Environment, Rural & Food Affairs.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Fawcett, A. (2013). “Euthanasia and morally justifiable killing in a veterinary clinical context”. In: J. Johnston & F. Probyn-Rapsey (eds), Animal Death. Sydney: Sydney University Press.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Fraser, D. (2012). “A “practical” ethic for animals”. Journal of Agricultural & Environmental Ethics, 25, 721–746.

  • Hartnack, S., Springer, S., Pittavino, M., & Grimm, H. (2016). “Attitudes of Austrian veterinarians towards euthanasia in small animal practice: impacts of age and gender on views on euthanasia”. BMC Veterinary Research, 12, 26.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Hawes, S., Kerrigan, J., & Morris, K. (2018). “Factors informing outcomes for older cats and dogs in animal shelters”. Animals, 8, 36.

  • Hens, K. (2009). “Ethical responsibilities towards dogs: an inquiry into the dog-human relationship”. Journal of Agricultural & Environmental Ethics, 22, 3–14.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Humane Society of the United States (2013). Euthanasia Reference Manual, 2nd ed. Human Society Veterinary Medical Association.

  • Humane Society of the United States (2016). Eliminating Gas Chambers. HSUS. Available online: https://www.animalsheltering.org/page/eliminating-gas-chambers [Accessed October 24, 2017].

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Hurley, K.F. (2008). “Sick to death: the false tension between providing care and saving lives”. In: Animal Sheltering, Humane Society of the United States. Animal Care Expo 2008, 51–59.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Islam, M.M., Mun, H.-S., Bostami, A.B.M.R., Park, K.-J., & Yang, C.-J. (2016). “Combined active solar and geothermal heating: a renewable and environmentally friendly energy source in pig houses”. Environmental Progress & Sustainable Energy, 35, 1156–1165.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Kahler, S.C. (2015). “Moral stress the top trigger in veterinarians’ compassion fatigue”. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, 246, 16–18.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Kaiser, A.M., McFarland, W., Siemion, R.S., & Raisbeck, M.F. (2010). “Secondary pentobarbital poisoning in two dogs: a cautionary tale”. Journal of Veterinary Diagnostic Investigation, 22, 632–634.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Karsten, C.L., Wagner, D.C., Kass, P.H., & Hurley, K.F. (2017). “An observational study of the relationship between Capacity for Care as an animal shelter management model and cat health, adoption and death in three animal shelters”. The Veterinary Journal, 227, 15–22.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Kiddie, J. & Collins, L. (2015). “Identifying environmental and management factors that may be associated with the quality of life of kennelled dogs (Canis familiaris)”. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 167, 43–55.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Leary, S., Underwood, W., Anthony, R., & Al, E. (2013). AVMA Guidelines for the Euthanasia of Animals, 2013 edition. American Veterinary Medical Association.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Maddie’s Fund (2018). Maddie’s Pet Assistant. Maddie’s Fund. Available online: http://www.maddiesfund.org/mpa.htm [Accessed April 25, 2018].

  • McFarland, B. (2014). Animal Care Expo 2014 special session: Mythbusters—finding the perfect home. HSUS Animal Care Expo. Available online: www.animalsheltering.org [Accessed October 26, 2017].

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • McGreevy, P., Starling, M., Payne, E., & Bennett, P. (in press). “Defining and measuring dogmanship: a new multidisciplinary science to improve understanding of human-dog interactions”. The Veterinary Journal.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Mellor, D.J. (2012). “Animal emotions, behaviour and the promotion of positive welfare states”. New Zealand Veterinary Journal, 60, 1–8.

  • Mellor, D.J. (2016). “Moving beyond the “Five Freedoms” by updating the “Five Provisions” and introducing aligned “Animal Welfare Aims””. Animals: an Open Access Journal from MDPI, 6, 59.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Mill, J.S. (1865). On Liberty. London: Longmans, Green and Company.

  • Miller, L., & Zawistowski, S. (2012). Shelter Medicine for Veterinarians and Staff. Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons.

  • National Research Council (US) (2009). “Use of dogs and cats in research: public perception and evolution of laws and guidelines”. In: Scientific and Humane Issues in the Use of Random Source Dogs and Cats in Research. Washington, DC: National Academies Press (US).

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Newbury, S., Blinn, M.K., Bushby, P.A., Barker Cox, C., Dinnage, J.D., Griffin, B., Hurley, K.F., Isaza, N., Jones, W., Miller, L., O’Quin, J., Patronek, G.J., Smith- Blackmore, M., & Spindel, M. (2010). Guidelines for Standards of Care in Animal Shelters. The Association of Shelter Veterinarians. Available from: www.sheltervet.org.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • OIE (2017a). OIE Global Animal Welfare Strategy. Available online: http://www.oie.int/fileadmin/home/eng/Media_Center/docs/pdf/85SG/AW/EN_OIE_AW_Strategy.pdf.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • OIE (2017b). “Stray dog population control”. In: Terrestrial Animal Health Code. OIE, World Organisation for Animal Health.

  • Ortega-Pacheco, A. & Jiménez-Coello, M. (2011). “Debate for and against euthanasia in the control of dog populations”. In: J. Kuře (ed.), Euthanasia—The “Good Death” Controversy in Humans and Animals. Rijeka: InTech.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Page-Jones, S., & Abbey, G. (2015). “Career identity in the veterinary profession”. Veterinary Record, 176, 433.

  • Palmer, C., Corr, S., & Sandoe, P. (2012). “Inconvenient desires: should we routinely neuter companion animals?” Anthrozoos, 25, S153–S172.

  • Patronek, G.J. & Bradley, J. (2016). “No better than flipping a coin: reconsidering canine behavior evaluations in animal shelters”. Journal of Veterinary Behavior: Clinical Applications and Research, 15, 66–77.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Pesavento, P.A. & Murphy, B.G. (2014). “Common and emerging infectious diseases in the animal shelter”. Veterinary Pathology, 51, 478–491.

  • Pierce, J. (2016a). “Rage against the dying”. In: J. Pierce (ed.), Run, Spot, Run: The Ethics of Keeping Pets. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Pierce, J. (2016b). “The shelter industry”. In: J. Pierce (ed.), Run, Spot, Run: The Ethics of Keeping Pets. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Pittman, A. (2016). Eco-friendly Animal Shelters. One Green Planet. Available online: www.onegreenplanet.org [Accessed October 21, 2017].

  • Radford, A.D., Coyne, K.P., Dawson, S., Porter, C.J., & Gaskell, R.M. (2007). “Feline calicivirus”. Veterinary Research, 38, 319–335.

  • Reeve, C.L., Rogelberg, S.G., Spitzmuller, C., & Digiacomo, N. (2005). “The caring-killing paradox: euthanasia-related strain among animal-shelter workers”. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 35, 119–143.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Rogelberg, S.G., Reeve, C.L., Spitzmuller, C., Digiacomo, N., Clark, O.L., Teeter, L., Walker, A.G., Starling, P.G., & Carter, N.T. (2007). “Impact of euthanasia rates, euthanasia practices, and human resource practices on employee turnover in animal shelters”. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, 230, 713–719.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Rollin, B.E. (2011). “Euthanasia, moral stress, and chronic illness in veterinary medicine”. Veterinary Clinics of North America-Small Animal Practice, 41, 651–659.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Russell, W.M.S., & Burch, R.L. (1959). The Principles of Humane Experimental Technique. London: Methuen.

  • Safe Work Australia (2014). Preventing psychological injury under work health and safety laws: fact sheet, May 2014 ed. Safe Work Australia. Available from: www.safeworkaustralia.gov.au.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Schorr-Evans, E.M., Poland, A., Johnson, W.E., & Pedersen, N.C. (2003). “An epizootic of highly virulent feline calicivirus disease in a hospital setting in New England”. Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery, 5, 217–226.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Scorney, R.L., McLaughlin, D., & Keates, H.L. (2015). “A systematic review of the effects of euthanasia and occupational stress in personnel working with animals in animal shelters, veterinary clinics, and biomedical research facilities”. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, 247, 1121–1130.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Scott Nolen, R. (2013). Study shines spotlight on neutering: Assumptions about a mainstay of companion animal practice are called into question. Available online: https://www.avma.org/news/javmanews/pages/131101a.aspx [Accessed October 24, 2017].

    • Export Citation
  • Serpell, J. (1996). In the Company of Animals: A Study of Human Animal Relationships. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

  • Shelter Animals Count (2018). Shelter Animals Count: The National Database. Shelter Animals Count. Available online: https://shelteranimalscount.org/ [Accessed April 25, 2018].

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Simmons, K. & Hoffman, C. (2016). “Dogs on the move: factors impacting animal shelter and rescue organizations’ decisions to accept dogs from distant locations”. Animals, 6, 11.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Spencer, T., Behar-Horenstein, L., Aufmuth, J., Hardt, N., Applebaum, J., Emanuel, A., & Isaza, N. (2017). “Factors that influence intake to one municipal animal control facility in Florida: a qualitative study”. Animals, 7, 48.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Stavisky, J., Brennan, M.L., Downes, M., & Dean, R. (2012). “Demographics and economic burden of un-owned cats and dogs in the UK: results of a 2010 census”. BMC Veterinary Research, 8, 163.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Stephen, J.M. & Ledger, R.A. (2005). “An audit of behavioral indicators of poor welfare in kenneled dogs in the United Kingdom”. Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science, 8, 79–96.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Tasker, L. (2009). Stray animal control practices (Europe). Food and Agriculture Organisation. Available from: www.fao.org.

    • Export Citation
  • Turner, P., Berry, J., & MacDonald, S. (2012). “Animal shelters and animal welfare: raising the bar”. The Canadian Veterinary Journal, 53, 893–896.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Van Mol, M.M.C., Kompanje, E.J.O., Benoit, D.D., Bakker, J., & Nijkamp, M.D. (2015). “The prevalence of compassion fatigue and burnout among healthcare professionals in intensive care units: a systematic review”. PLOS ONE, 10, e0136955.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Wagner, D.C., Kass, P.H., & Hurley, K.F. (2018). “Cage size, movement in and out of housing during daily care, and other environmental and population health risk factors for feline upper respiratory disease in nine North American animal shelters”. PLOS ONE, 13, e0190140.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Webster, A.J.F. (1994). Animal Welfare: A Cool Eye Towards Eden. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing.

  • Weiss, E. & Gramann, S. (2009). “A comparison of attachment levels of adopters of cats: fee-based adoptions versus free adoptions”. Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science, 12, 360–370.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Weiss, E., Gramann, S., Dolan, E., Scotto, J., & Slater, M. (2014). “Do policy based adoptions increase the care a pet receives? An exploration of a shift to conversation based adoptions at one shelter”. Open Journal of Animal Sciences, 4, 313–322.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Weiss, E., Patronek, G., Slater, M., Garrison, L., & Medicus, K. (2013). “Community partnering as a tool for improving live release rate in animal shelters in the United States”. Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science, 16, 221–238.

    • Rechercher Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • World Society for the Protection of Animals (2008). Methods for the euthanasia of dogs and cats: comparison and recommendations. World Society for the Protection of Animals. Available from: www.icam-coalition.org.

    • Export Citation
  • Yeates, J.W. (2010). “Death is a welfare issue”. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 23, 229–241.

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 144 144 20
Full Text Views 6 6 1
PDF Downloads 7 7 1