The Near Eastern Chaoskampf in the River Battle of Iliad 21

in Journal of Ancient Near Eastern Religions
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Abstract

This essay explores the river battle of Iliad 21 in terms of the Near Eastern mythological motif known as the Chaoskampf, wherein an order-promoting storm deity prevails over a water deity associated with chaos. The first section outlines four notable features of the protean Chaoskampf traditions in ancient Near Eastern literature, from Mesopotamia to the Levant to Anatolia. The second section traces these four features into the Iliad’s river battle and explains their presence by proposing cross-traditional mythopoesis, confluent with other cultural exchanges as established in recent decades. Understanding this part of the Iliad as influenced by West Asian traditions will help to explain why it is Hephaistos, not storm god Zeus, who unleashes his fire upon the menacing river god. The role of Hephaistos is examined against the roles of Ugaritic Kothar-wa-Hasis and Hittite-Hurrian Ea in their respective Chaoskampf myths.

The Near Eastern Chaoskampf in the River Battle of Iliad 21

in Journal of Ancient Near Eastern Religions

Sections

References

AnghelinaC. “On the Mythology of Okeanos.” Journal of Ancient Near Eastern Religions 2009 143 50

ArchiAlfonso “Orality, Direct Speech and the Kumarbi Cycle.” Altorientalische Forschungen 2009 36 2 Akademie Verlag 209 229

AutenriethC. Homeric Dictionary 2009 Bristol Bristol Classical Press

BachvarovaM. SuterA. “Sumerian Gala Priests and Eastern Mediterranean Returning Gods: Tragic Lament in Cross-Cultural Perspective.” Lament: Studies in the Ancient Mediterranean World and Beyond 2008 Oxford Oxford University Press 18 52

BartonG. A. “Tiamat.” Journal of the American Oriental Society 1893 15 1 27

BottéroJ. Religion in Ancient Mesopotamia 2001 Chicago University of Chicago Press

BottéroJ. Ancestor of the West 2000 Chicago University of Chicago Press

BremmerJ. Greek Religion and Culture the Bible and the Near East 2008 Leiden Brill

BryceT. CollinsBillie JeanBachvarovaMary R.RutherfordIan C. “Homer at the Interface.” Anatolian Interfaces: Hittites Greeks and their Neighbors 2004 Oxford, UK Oxbow Books 85 92

BryceT. “Anatolian Scribes in Mycenaean Greece.” Historia 1999 XL VIII 3 257 264

BurgessJ. “Achilles’ Heel: The Death of Achilles in Ancient Myth.” Classical Antiquity 1995 14 217 245

BurkertW. The Orientalizing Revolution 1992 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press

CalhounG. M. “Homer’s Gods.” Transactions of the American Philological Association 1939 60 1 28

CalhounG. M. “Homer’s Gods: Prolegomena.” Transactions of the American Philological Association 1937 68 11 25

CollinsB.-J CohenGilanMiller “Hittite Religion and the West.” Pax Hethitica Studies on the Hittites and Their Neighbors in Honour of Itamar Singer 2010 Weisbaden Harrassowitz Verlag 54 64

CollonD. First Impressions: Cylinder Seals in the ancient Near East 2005 London British Museum Press

D’AlessioG. B. “Textual Fluctuations and Cosmic Streams.” Journal of Hellenic Studies 2004 124 16 24

DayJ. “God and Leviathan in Isaiah 27:1.” Biblotheca Sacra 155:423–36; 1985. God’s conflict with the dragon and the sea 1998 Cambridge Cambridge University Press 1 61

Evelyn-WhiteH. G. Hesiod. The Homeric Hymns and Homerica with an English Translation 1914 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press

FishbaneM. Biblical Myth and Rabbinic Mythmaking 2003 New York Oxford University Press

FontenroseJ. Python 1959 1966 Berkeley, CA University of California Press

GadamerH.-G. Philosophical Hermeneutics 1976 Berkeley, CA University of California Press

GreenA. R. W The Storm-God in the Ancient Near East 2003 Winona Lake, Indiana Eisenbrauns

GunterA. C. Greek Art and the Orient 2009 New York Cambridge University Press

GunterA. C. Sancisi-WeerdenburgS.DrijversJ. W. “Models of the Orient in the Art History of the Orientalizing Period.” Achaemenid History V: The Roots of the European Tradition 1990 Leiden Nederlands Institutuut Voor Het Nabije Oosten 131 147

GüterbockH. G. “The Song of Ullikummi. Revised Text of the Hittite Version of aHurrian Myth, Continued.” Journal of Cuneiform Studies 1952 6 1 8 42 (1952)

GüterbockH. G. “The Song of Ullikummi. Revised Text of the Hittite Version of a Hurrian Myth.” Journal of Cuneiform Studies 1951 5 4 135 161 (1951)

GüterbockH. G. “Hittite Version of the Hurrian Kumarbi Myths: Oriental Forerunners of Hesiod,” American Journal of Archaeology 1948 52 1 123 134 (Jan.–Mar. 1948)

HoffnerH. A.Jr Hittite Myths 1990 Atlanta Society for Biblical Literature

JacobsenT. Treasures of Darkness 1976 New Haven, CT Yale University Press

KittsM. Sanctified Violence in Homeric Society 2005 2012 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

KittsM. “Ritual scenes in the Iliad: rote, hallowed, or encrypted as ancient art?” Oral Traditions 2011 26 1

LeafW. The Iliad 1900 London Macmillan Edited with apparatus criticus prolegomena notes and appendices

LemosI. S. VillingA. “The Changing Relationship of the Euboeans and the East” The Greeks in the East 2005 157 London British Museum Research Publication 53 60

López-RuizC. When the Gods were Born: Greek Cosmogonies and the Near East 2010 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press

LoudenB. The Iliad: Structure Myth and Meaning 2006 Baltimore The Johns Hopkins University Press

LoudenB. FoleyJ. M. “The Gods in Epic, or the Divine Economy.” A Companion to Ancient Epic 2005 Hoboken, NJ Wiley-Blackwell Press 90 104

LuckenbillD. D. Ancient Records of Assyria and Babylonia Vol. I 1968 (originally published 1926 University of Chicago)

LuckenbillD. D. Ancient Records of Assyria and Babylonia Vol. II 1968 New York Greenwood Press (originally published 1927 University of Chicago)

MackieC. J Rivers of Fire 2008 Wash, D.C. New Academia Publishing

MalkinI. “Networks and the Emergence of Greek Identity.” Mediterranean Historical Review 2003 18 2 56 74

MondiR. EdmundsL. “Greek Mythic Thought in the Light of the Near East.” Approaches to Greek Myth 1990 Baltimore Johns Hopkins University Press 142 198

MondiR. “Tradition and Innovation in the Hesiodic Titanomachy.” Transactions of the American Philological Association 1986 116 25 48

MorrisS. LaffineurR.HaggR. “Potnia Aswiya: Anatolian Contributions to Greek Religion.” Potnia Deities and Religion in the Aegean Bronze Age 2001 22 Liège Aegeaum 423 434

MorrisS. MorrisI.PowellB. “Homer and the Near East.” A New Companion to Homer 1997 Leiden Brill 599 623

MorrisS. Daidalos and the Origins of Greek Art 1992 Princeton Princeton University Press

NesselrathH.-G “ ‘Where the Lord of the Sea Grants Passage to Sailors through the Deep-Blue Mere No More’: The Greeks and the Western Seas.” Greece & Rome 2005 52 2 153 171

NikoloudisS. CollinsB.J.BachvarovaM.R.RutherfordI.C. “Multiculturalism in the Mycenaean World.” Anatolian Interfaces: Hittites Greeks and their Neighbors 2008 Oxford Oxbow Books 45 56

NoegelS. B. KittsM. “The Ritual Use of Linguistic and Textual Violence in the Hebrew Bible and Ancient Near East.” State Power and Violence 2010 Wiesbaden Harrassowitz 33 46 Ritual Dynamics and the Science of Ritual 3

NoegelS. B. WellmanJ. K.Jr “Dismemberment, Creation, and Ritual: Images of Divine Violence in the Ancient Near East.” Belief and Bloodshed 2007 Lanham, Md Rowman and Littlefield 13 28

OppenheimA. L. “Akkadian pul(u)ḫ(t)u and melammu.” Journal of the American Oriental Society 1943 63 1 31 34

OrtlundE. N Theophany and Chaoskampf 2010 Piscataway, NJ Gorgias Press

PapadopoulosJ. K.RuscilloD. “A Ketos in Early Athens: An Archeology of Whales and Sea Monsters in the Greek World.” American Journal of Archeology 2002 106 2 187 227

Pecchioli-DaddiF.PolvaniA. M. La mitologia ittita 1990 Brescia Paideia Editrice

PonchiaS. “Analogie, Metafore, e Similitudini nelle iscrizioni reali assire: Semantica e Ideologia.” Oriens Antiquus 1987 26 3–4 223 55

PucciP. “Theology and Poetics in the Iliad.” Arethusa 2002 35 1 17 34

PuhvelJ. Homer and Hittite 1991 Innsbruck Innsbrucker Beiträge zur Sprachwissenschaft

SchwemerD. “The Storm God of the Ancient Near East, Part I.” Journal of Ancient Near Eastern Religions 2007 7 2 121 168

SchwemerD. “The Storm God of the Ancient Near East, Part II.” Journal of Ancient Near Eastern Religions 2008 8 1 1 44

SingerI. CollinsB. J.BachvarovaM. R.RutherfordI. C. “Purple-Dyers in Lazpa.” Anatolian Interfaces 2008 Oxford Oxbow Books 85 92

SingerI. Hittite Prayers 2002 Atlanta Society for Biblical Literature

SingerI. OvadiahA. “Cuneiform, Linear, Alphabetic: The Contest between Writing Systems in the Eastern Mediterranean.” Mediterranean Cultural Interaction 2000 Tel Aviv University Howard Gilman International Conferences II 23 32

SmithM. ParkerS. “The Baal Cycle.” Ugaritic Narrative Poetry 1997 Atlanta Society for Biblical Literature 81 180

TambiahS. “A Performative Approach to Ritual.” Proceedings of the British Academy 1981 65 Oxford Oxford University Press 113 169

TurkeltabD. “Perceiving Iliadic Gods,” Harvard Studies in Classical Philology 2007 103 51 82

WalcotP. Hesiod and the Near East 1966 Cardiff, Wales University of Wales Press

WeinfeldM. CanforaL.LiveraniM.ZaccagniniC. “The Common Heritage of Covenantal Traditions in the Ancient World.” I Trattai nel mondo antico forma ideologica funzione 1990 Rome L’Erinna di Bretschneider 175 191

WeinfeldM. “Covenant Making in Anatolia and Mesopotamia.” Journal of Ancient Near Eastern Studies 1983 22 135 139

WeinfeldM. “ ‘Rider of the Clouds’ and ‘Gatherer of the Clouds.’ ” Journal of Ancient Near Eastern Studies 1973 5 421 426

WestM. L. East Face of Helicon: West Asiatic Elements in Greek Poetry and Myth 1997 Oxford Oxford University Press

WestM. L. “Ab ovo: Orpheus, Sanchuniathon, and the Origins of the Ionian World Model.” Classical Quarterly 1994 44 2 289 307

WhitmanC. H. “Fire and Other Elements.” Homer and the Heroic Tradition 1958 Harvard University Press 153 158

Willamowitz-MoellendorffU. Die Ilias und Homer 1916 Berlin Weidmannsche Buchhandlung

WolksteinD.KramerS. N. Inanna Queen of Heaven and Earth 1983 New York Harper Perennial

WyattN. Word of Tree and Whisper of Stone 2007 Piscataway, NJ Gorgias Press

WyattN. Mythic Mind: Essays on Cosmology and Religion in Ugaritic and Old Testament Literature 2005 London/Oakville Equinox

WyattN. DietrichM.RottsieperJ. “Arms and the King.” Und Mose schrieb dieses Lied auf: Festschrift O. Loretz 1998 Münster Ugarit-Verlag 833 882 (Alter Orient und Altes Testament 250)

11

Discussion in Fishbane 2003:39; Wyatt 2005:204–52.

12

See Collon #783 (2005).

15

See KUB VIII 67:10–21 and Kitts 2011.

34

Luckenbill 1926Section 284.

35

Luckenbill 1926: Vol.1:38–39 cited in Ortlund (2010:98).

38

See Whitman (1958).

39

See Leaf (1900) in his introduction to Book 20.

50

Jacobsen 1976:132.

64

See Mackie (2008) for a full discussion. On Achilles’ association with fire as an immortalizing substance see Burgess (1995).

65

Luckenbill 1926: Vol.1:38–39 cited in Ortlund (2010:98).

68

See Archi (2009) on the oral traditional indicators and bilingual implications in the texts for the Hittite Kumarbi cycle.

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 48 48 9
Full Text Views 40 40 19
PDF Downloads 1 1 1
EPUB Downloads 1 1 0