Do you want to stay informed about this journal? Click the buttons to subscribe to our alerts.
Big Army Groups, Standardization, and Assaulting Fortified Positions: Chinese “Ways of War” and the Transition from Guerrilla to Conventional War in China’s Northeast, 1945-1948
In: Journal of Chinese Military HistoryAbstract
Western military historians often describe the Chinese “way of war” as emphasizing a gradualist military strategy, tending to avoid battle except when victory was assured, and preferring to use subterfuge, maneuver, or psychological means to defeat the enemy without actually fighting. The roots of this understanding of the Chinese way of war lie in selective readings of Sunzi’s Art of War and Mao Zedong’s writings on guerrilla warfare. The record of Chinese Communist operations in China’s Northeast (Manchuria) from 1945 through 1948 instead suggests a Chinese approach to war that is characterized not only by close attention to strategy and maneuver, but also by a preference for offensive operations leading to the ultimate destruction of the enemy in battles of annihilation. In the Northeast theater of China’s civil war we also see that the Communist forces had to go through a process of transformation before they were able to carry out large-scale maneuvers, deploy overwhelming firepower, and conduct large-scale operations or campaigns of annihilation. In order to gain victory, the Chinese Communist forces in the Northeast under Lin Biao’s command had to make the transition from guerrilla to conventional warfare, including the ability to attack cities. This transformation was achieved through a combination of factors: critical assessment of battlefield performance, incorporation of new weapons and equipment, and techniques of staff work. This suggests that any workable understanding of Chinese ways of war must go beyond cultural determinism to take account of the Chinese military’s flexibility and capacity for learning.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Zhonggong zhongyang dangshi ziliao zhengji weiyuanhui & Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun dang’anguan Dongbei renmin jiefangjun silingbu zhenzhong riji Field Diary of the Northeast People’s Liberation Army Headquarters 1987 Beijing Zhonggong dangshi ziliao chubanshe 2 vols.
-
Zhonggong zhongyang dang’anguan Zhonggong zhongyang wenjian xuanji di shiwuce 1991 Selected Documents of the Communist Party Center, vol. 15 Beijing Zhonggong zhongyang dangxiao chubanshe
-
Kongjun “Liu Yalou junshi wenji” bianjizu Liu Yalou junshi wenji Military Writings of Liu Yalou 2010 Beijing Lantian chubanshe
-
Li Zuopeng 2011 Li Zuopeng huiyilu Memoirs of Li Zuopeng Hong Kong Xianggang beixing chubanshe 2 vols.
-
Liao Zhengwu Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun lishi ziliao congshu weiyuanhui “Bian zhandou, bian banxiao, bian fazhan” Fighting, Running a School, and Expanding All at Once Paobing huiyi shiliao Historical Memoirs: Artillery 1998 Beijing Jiefangjun chubanshe 201 204
-
“Lin Biao de liuge zhanshu yuanze” Lin Biao’s Six Principles of Tactics Qing cha de boke. http://wangxudong99999.blog.163.com/blog/static/322717422008819114323162/ accessed 7 January 2011
-
“Lin Biao zongsiling jiejian jizhe” Commander Lin Biao meets with reporters Mudanjiang ribao 18 June 1946 2
-
Mao Tse-tung Selected Military Writings of Mao Tse-tung 1967 2nd ed Beijing Foreign Languages Press
-
Mao Tse-tung Griffith Samuel B. On Guerrilla Warfare 2000 New York Praeger, 1961 Reprint, Champaign, IL: University of Illinois Press. [First Chinese publication was in 1937.]
-
Sawyer Ralph D. The Seven Military Classics of Ancient China 1993 Boulder, CO Westview Press
-
U.S. Department of State Foreign Relations of the United States, Diplomatic Papers 1945 1967-69 Washington, D.C. Government Printing Office 9 vols.
-
Wang Tianxin “Dongbeiju sannian zongjie (huiyi jilugao)” Summary of the Northeast Bureau’s Three Years (Draft Meeting Notes) Undated document in possession of the author. Internal evidence suggests that the document is from 1948
-
“Xin houbeijun kaishi jixun” New Reserve Army Begins Training Dongbei ribao 16 May 1948 1
-
“Zhankai junshi lianbing yundong” Carry Out the Military Training Movement Dongbei ribao 18 May 1948 1
-
Citino Robert M. The German Way of War: From the Thirty Years’ War to the Third Reich 2005 Lawrence, KS University Press of Kansas
-
Dai Yingcong “The Qing State, Merchants, and the Military Labor Force in the Jinchuan Campaigns” Late Imperial China 2001 December 22 2 35 90
-
Dong Dianwen Tingjin dongbei Advancing into the Northeast Shenyang Liaoning renmin chubanshe
-
Duan Zijun Shenyang junqu silingbu tongxin bu tongxinbingshi bianxie weiyuanhui “Yi dongbei tongxin lianluochu chuchuangshi de gongzuo” Recalling the Work of the Early Days of the Northeast Communications Liaison Office Liaoshen juezhan zhong de tongxinbing The Signal Corps in the Liao-Shen Campaign 1994 Shenyang Baishan chubanshe 1 12
-
Ebon Martin Lin Piao: The Life and Writings of China’s New Ruler 1970 New York Stein and Day
-
Echevarria Antulio J. II “Toward an American Way of War” 2004 Carlisle, PA Strategic Studies Institute
-
Fairbank John King Kierman Frank A. & Fairbank John King “Introduction: Varieties of the Chinese Military Experience” Chinese Ways in Warfare 1974 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press 1 26
-
Honeycutt Fred. L. Jr. & Anthony F. Patt Military Rifles of Japan 1996 5th edition Palm Beach Gardens, FL Julin Books
-
Hostetler Laura Qing Colonial Enterprise: Ethnography and Cartography in Early Modern China 2001 Chicago University of Chicago Press
-
Keegan John A History of Warfare 1997 New York Alfred A. Knopf
-
Lew Christopher R. The Third Chinese Revolutionary Civil War, 1945-49: An Analysis of Communist Strategy and Leadership 2009 London Routledge
-
Li Xiaobing A History of the Modern Chinese Army 2007 Lexington, KY The University Press of Kentucky
-
Liu Tong “Jiefang zhanzheng zhong dongbei yezhanjun wuqi laiyuan tantao—jian yu Yang Kuisong xiansheng shangque” An Inquiry into the Sources of the Northeast Field Army’s Weapons during the War of Liberation—A Discussion with Mr. Yang Kuisong Dang de wenxian Party Documents 2000 no. 4 76 80
-
Tong Liu Dongbei jiefang zhanzheng jishi, 1945-1948 Record of the War of Liberation in the Northeast, 1945-1948 2004 Beijing Renmin chubanshe
-
Lorge Peter “The Many Ways of Chinese Warfare” Historically Speaking 2010 11 5 24 25 (November 2010)
-
May Timothy The Mongol Art of War 2007 Yardley, PA Westholme Publishing
-
McCollum Duncan O. Japanese Rifles of World War II 1996 Latham, NY Excalibur Publications
-
Murawiec Laurent “Chinese Grand Strategy and the Chinese Way of War” 2005 accessed 25 April 2011 Testimony presented to the U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission, 15 September 2005, http://www.uscc.gov/hearings/2005hearings/written_testimonies/05_09_15wrts/murawiec.pdf
-
Pangelinan James G. “From Red Cliffs to Chosin: The Chinese Way of War” 2010 Fort Leavenworth School of Advanced Military Studies, United States Army Command and General Staff College
-
Perdue Peter China Marches West: The Qing Conquest of Central Eurasia 2005 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press
-
Poole H. John Phantom Soldier: The Enemy’s Answer to U.S. Firepower 2001 Chevy Chase, MD Posterity Press
-
Rigg Robert Red China’s Fighting Hordes 1951 Westport, CT Greenwood Press
-
Ryan Mark A., Finkelstein David M. & McDevitt Michael A. Chinese Warfighting: The PLA Experience Since 1949 2003 Armonk, NY M.E. Sharpe
-
Skaff Jonathan Karam Di Cosmo Nicola “Tang Military Culture and Its Inner Asian Influences” Military Culture in Imperial China 2009 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press 165 191
-
Spence Jonathan D. Emperor of China: Self-Portrait of K’ang-hsi 1975 New York Vintage Books
-
Tanner Harold M. Elleman Bruce A. & Kotkin Stephen “Railways in Communist Strategy and Operations on Manchuria, 1945-48” Manchurian Railways and the Opening of China: An International History 2010 Armonk, NY M.E. Sharpe 149 170
-
Theobald Ulrich “The Second Jinchuan Campaign (1771-1776): Economic, Social and Political Aspects of an Important Qing Period Border War” 2010 Doctoral dissertation, Eberhard Karls Universität Tübingen
-
“Type 38 rifle” Absolute Astronomy http://www.absoluteastronomy.com/topics/Type_38_rifle accessed 4 April 2010
-
“Type 38 Rifle” Wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Type_38_rifle accessed 4 April 2010
-
Waldron Arthur “The Art of Shi” The New Republic 1997 June 23 36 41
-
Weigley Russell F. The American Way of War: A History of United States Military Strategy and Policy 1973 Bloomington IN Indiana University Press
-
Westad Odd Arne Decisive Encounters: The Chinese Civil War, 1946-1950 2003 Stanford Stanford University Press
-
Wetzel Carroll Robbins Jr. “From the Jaws of Defeat: Lin Piao and the Fourth Field Army in Manchuria” 1972 Ph.D. dissertation, George Washington University
-
Yang Guoqing & Ren Bai Luo Ronghuan zai dongbei jiefang zhanzheng zhong Luo Ronghuan in the War of Liberation in the Northeast 1986 Beijing Jiefangjun chubanshe
-
Yang Kuisong Mao Zedong yu Mosike de enen yuanyuan Mao Zedong and Moscow: Gratitude and Resentment 1999 Nanchang Jiangxi renmin chubanshe
-
Yang Kuisong “Guanyu jiefang zhanzheng zhong de Sulian junshi yuanzhu wenti—jian tan zhixue taidu bing da Liu Tong xiansheng” On the Question of Soviet Military Aid during the War of Liberation—Together with a Discussion of the Approach toward Research and a Response to Mr. Liu Tong Jindaishi yanjiu Modern History 2001 no. 1 285 306
-
Yuan Wei Shanhaiguan zhi zhan The Battle of Shanhaiguan 1989 Beijing Junshi kexue chubanshe
-
Zhang Zhenglong Xuebai, xuehong: Guo Gong dongbei da juezhan lishi zhenxiang White Snow, Red Blood: The Real History of the Nationalists’ and the Communists’ Battle for the Northeast 1991 Hong Kong Dadi chubanshe
-
Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun disishisanjun silingbu Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun disishisanjun disanci guonei geming zhanzhengshi (chugao) The Chinese People’s Liberation Army, Forty-third Army, Battle History of the Third Chinese Revolution (Draft) 1956 Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun disishisanjun silingbu
-
Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun disishiyijun silingbu Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun disishiyijun disanci guonei geming zhanzhengshi (chugao) Chinese People’s Liberation Army, Forty-first Army, Battle History of the Third Chinese Revolution (Draft) 1956 Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun disishiyijun silingbu
-
Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun disi yezhanjun zhanshi bianxiezu Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun disi yezhanjun zhanshi Campaign History of the Chinese People’s Liberation Army Fourth Field Army 1998 Beijing Jiefangjun chubanshe
-
1
Fairbank 1974, 25.
-
2
In Sawyer 1993, 161.
-
5
Keegan 1997, 202.
-
6
Murawiec 2005, 2-3.
-
7
Fairbank 1974, 25.
-
8
Fairbank 1974, 11.
-
9
Fairbank 1974, 11.
-
11
Waldron 1997, 39.
-
12
Ryan et al. 2003, 9-10. Pangelinan 2010, 78-86.
-
19
Mao Zedong, quoted in Zhang 1991, 101; Chen Yi, “Zongxu” [General Introduction], in Dong 1998, 3.
-
20
Zhang 1991, 184; Li 2011, vol. 1, 182.
-
22
Liu 2004, 613-21; Zhonggong zhongyang dangshi ziliao zhengji weiyuanhui 1987, vol. 2, 738-39.
-
23
Liu 2004, 641.
-
27
Li 2007, 72.
-
28
Mao 2000, 42.
-
29
Mao 2000, 42.
-
30
Mao 2000, 113.
-
31
Li Yunchang, quoted in Liu 2004, 65.
-
41
Zhang 1991, 128.
-
42
Lin Biao, quoted in Liu 2004, 472-73.
-
44
Zhang 1991, 274.
-
45
Liu 2004, 468.
-
46
Zhang 1991, 274.
-
47
Yang 1999, 184.
-
48
Liu 2000, 79.
-
49
Yang 2001, 285-306.
-
50
Yang 2001, 295-98.
-
51
Wetzel 1972, 174-75; The Chargé in China (Robertson) to the Secretary of State, Chungking, 9 October 1945, in U.S. Department of State 1967-69, vol. 7, 578-79.
-
54
Yang and Bai 1986; Duan 1994, 8-9.
-
56
Yang 2001, 293-94.
-
57
Duan 1994, 10-12.
-
58
Tanner 2010, 158.
-
59
Lin Biao, quoted in Zhang 1991, 328.
-
62
Ebon 1970, 168.
-
63
Ebon 1970, 170.
-
64
Liao 1998, 202.
-
68
Liu 2004, 607.
-
76
Lorge 2010, 24.
-
77
Citino 2005, xiv; Weigley 1973; May 2007.
-
78
For example, see Citino 2005, xiv.
-
79
Lorge 2010, 24. Lorge’s comments were directed toward the use of “culture” to explain “ways of war.” I have stretched his critique to include geographic determinist approaches.
-
81
Echevarria 2004, 2.
-
82
Echevarria 2004, 2.
-
83
Skaff 2009, 166.
-
84
May 2007, 113-14.
-
85
Perdue 2005; Dai 2001, 35-90; Hostetler 2001; Theobald 2010, 12.
-
86
Skaff 2009, 170. Skaff’s reference is to David A. Graff, “Early T’ang Generalship and the Textual Tradition” (Ph.D. diss., Princeton University, 1995), 553-54.
-
87
The Kangxi Emperor, in Spence 1975, 22.
-
88
Ryan et al. 2003, 9.
| All Time | Past Year | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 425 | 107 | 18 |
| Full Text Views | 151 | 11 | 2 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 141 | 31 | 8 |
Big Army Groups, Standardization, and Assaulting Fortified Positions: Chinese “Ways of War” and the Transition from Guerrilla to Conventional War in China’s Northeast, 1945-1948
In: Journal of Chinese Military HistoryAbstract
Western military historians often describe the Chinese “way of war” as emphasizing a gradualist military strategy, tending to avoid battle except when victory was assured, and preferring to use subterfuge, maneuver, or psychological means to defeat the enemy without actually fighting. The roots of this understanding of the Chinese way of war lie in selective readings of Sunzi’s Art of War and Mao Zedong’s writings on guerrilla warfare. The record of Chinese Communist operations in China’s Northeast (Manchuria) from 1945 through 1948 instead suggests a Chinese approach to war that is characterized not only by close attention to strategy and maneuver, but also by a preference for offensive operations leading to the ultimate destruction of the enemy in battles of annihilation. In the Northeast theater of China’s civil war we also see that the Communist forces had to go through a process of transformation before they were able to carry out large-scale maneuvers, deploy overwhelming firepower, and conduct large-scale operations or campaigns of annihilation. In order to gain victory, the Chinese Communist forces in the Northeast under Lin Biao’s command had to make the transition from guerrilla to conventional warfare, including the ability to attack cities. This transformation was achieved through a combination of factors: critical assessment of battlefield performance, incorporation of new weapons and equipment, and techniques of staff work. This suggests that any workable understanding of Chinese ways of war must go beyond cultural determinism to take account of the Chinese military’s flexibility and capacity for learning.
| All Time | Past Year | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 425 | 107 | 18 |
| Full Text Views | 151 | 11 | 2 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 141 | 31 | 8 |