Learning Through Practice
Lin Biao and the Transition to Conventional Combined Operations in China’s Northeast, 1946-1948
In: Journal of Chinese Military HistorySearch for other papers by Harold M. Tanner in
Current site
Google Scholar
Abstract
American scholars of Chinese history have generally explained the outcome of China’s civil war (1945-1949) by reference to social, economic, and political factors rather than by looking at the conduct of the war itself. Recently, military historians have begun to shift the focus to Communist strategy and operations. However, the question of how the Chinese Communist forces made the transition from guerrilla to conventional warfare has still not received sufficient attention. Using Mao Zedong’s theories of guerrilla warfare and Peter Senge’s model of the “learning organization” to analyze Lin Biao’s conduct of the war against the Nationalists in China’s Northeast (Manchuria), we can better understand how the Northeast People’s Liberation Army transformed itself from a force characterized by “guerrilla-ism” to the powerful army capable of defeating Jiang Jieshi’s best troops. The Communists performed poorly when they first encountered American-trained Nationalist units in the Northeast. Lin Biao and his staff responded to defeat by devising principles of tactics which they applied in a series of campaigns beginning with the “Three Expeditions/Four Defenses” (winter 1946-47). The Communist forces continued to derive lessons from their experience and to incorporate those lessons into programs of education and training. As a result, they made great strides forward in terms of the coordination of infantry, artillery, and armor in order to be able to pull off a conventional combined arms operation on the scale of the Liao-Shen Campaign. The Communist forces would bring these strengths with them when they entered the Korean War in 1950.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Acheson Dean “Letter of Transmittal.” 30 July 1949, in United States Department of State 1967 1949 III-XVII
-
Han Xianchu “Dongbei zhanchang yu Liaoshen juezhan” [The Northeast Battlefield and the Liaoshen Campaign] 1988 vol. 1 Zhonggong zhongyang dangshi ziliao zhengji weiyuanhui 81 141
-
He Changgong He Changgong huiyilu [Memoirs of He Changgong] 1987 Beijing Jiefangjun chubanshe
-
Kongjun “Liu Yalou junshi wenji” bianjizu Liu Yalou junshi wenji [Military Writings of Liu Yalou] 2010 Beijing Lantian chubanshe
-
Li Zuopeng Li Zuopeng huiyilu [Memoirs of Li Zuopeng] 2011 Hong Kong Beixing chubanshe 2 vols
-
Liang Biye “Dongbei jiefang zhanzheng zhong de yi zongdui” [The First Column in the Liberation War in the Northeast] 1988 vol. 1 Zhonggong zhongyang dangshi ziliao zhengji weiyuanhui 266 285
-
Liu Yalou Kongjun “Guanyu zhanqian lianbing wenti” [On the Question of Training Prior to Combat] 1948 156 163 2010
-
Mao Zedong Mao “Problems of Strategy in China’s Revolutionary War.” 1936 vol. 1 179 254 1969
-
Mao Zedong Mao “On Protracted War.” 1938 vol. 2 113 194 1969
-
Mao Zedong Mao “The Present Situation and Our Tasks.” 1947 vol. 4 157 176 1969
-
Mao Tse-tung (Mao Zedong) Selected Works of Mao Tse-tung 1969 Peking Foreign Languages Press 4 volumes
-
Mao Tse-tung (Mao Zedong) Griffith Samuel B. II On Guerrilla Warfare 2000 Urbana University of Illinois Press
-
Qiu Huizuo Qiu Huizuo huiyilu [Memoirs of Qiu Huizuo] 2011 Hong Kong Xinshiji chuban ji meiti youxian gongsi
-
Rea Kenneth W. & Brewer John C. The Forgotten Ambassador: The Reports of John Leighton Stuart, 1946-1949 1981 Boulder, CO Westview Press
-
United States Department of State The China White Paper, August 1949 1967 Stanford. CA Stanford University Press
-
Wu Faxian Suiyue jiannan: Wu Faxian huiyilu [Years of Trial: The Memoirs of Wu Faxian] 2006 Hong Kong Beixing chubanshe 2 vols
-
Xiao Jinguang “Sibao Linjiang zhandou suiyue” [Combat Days in the Four Defenses of Linjiang] 1988 vol. 2 Zhonggong zhongyang dangshi ziliao zhengji weiyuanhui 250 265
-
Zhonggong Tonghua shiwei dangshi yanjiushi Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi de Tonghua 2000 Tonghua n.p
-
Zhonggong zhongyang dang’anguan Zhonggong zhongyang wenjian xuanji [Selected documents of the Chinese Communist Party Center] 1989 Beijing Zhonggong zhongyang dangxiao chubanshe 16 vols 1989- ed
-
Zhonggong zhongyang dangshi ziliao zhengji weiyuanhui Liaoshen juezhan [The Liaoshen Campaign] 1988 Beijing Renmin chubanshe 2 vols Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun Liaoshen zhanyi jinianguan weiyuanhui, eds
-
Zhonggong zhongyang dangshi ziliao zhengji weiyuanhui Zhenzhong riji [Field Diary] 1987 Beijing Zhongong dangshi ziliao chubanshe Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun dang’anguan, eds
-
Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun disanshijiujun silingbu Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun disanshijiujun disanci guonei geming zhanzheng zhanshi [Battle History of the People’s Liberation Army, Thirty-ninth Army in the Third Chinese Revolutionary War] 1956 zhengzhibu, ed
-
Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun disishisanjun silingbu Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun disishijun disanci guonei geming zhanzheng zhanshi (chugao) [Campaign History of the Chinese People’s Liberation Army Forty-third Army in the Third Chinese Revolutionary War (Draft)] 1956
-
Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun disishiyi jun silingbu Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun disishiyi jun disanci guonei geming zhanzhengshi (chugao). [Battle History of the Chinese People’s Liberation Army Forty-first Army during the Third Chinese Revolutionary War (Draft)] 1956 ed
-
Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun dongbei junqu silingbu Dongbei sannian jiefang zhanzheng junshi ziliao [Military Materials on the Three-Year Northeast Liberation War] 1949
-
Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun junshi kexueyuan Zhanshu cankao ziliao, diyiji [Reference Materials on Tactics, vol. 1] 1959 Beijing Zong canmoubu junshi chubanshe ed
-
Appleman Roy E. Disaster in Korea: The Chinese Confront MacArthur 1989 College Station, TX Texas A & M University Press
-
Bjorge Gary J. Moving the Enemy: Operational Art in the Chinese PLA’s Huai Hai Campaign 2004 Fort Leavenworth, KS Combat Studies Institute Press Leavenworth Paper No. 22
-
Chassin Lionel Max The Communist Conquest of China: A History of the Civil War, 1945-1949 1965 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press
-
Chang Gordon Friends and Enemies: The United States, China and the Soviet Union, 1948-1972 1990 Stanford Stanford University Press
-
Cheng Victor Shiu Chiang “Imagining China’s Madrid in Manchuria: The Communist Military Strategy at the Onset of the Chinese Civil War, 1945-1946.” Modern China 2005 31 1 72 114 (2005)
-
Cheng Victor Shiu Chiang “Modern War on an Ancient Battlefield: The Diffusion of American Military Technology and Ideas in the Chinese Civil War, 1946-1949.” Modern China 2009 35 1 38 64 (2009)
-
Daze Wuyuan “Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi Zhongguo gongchandang dui dongbei de guanli yu dui Su maoyi” [The Chinese Communist Party’s Administration of the Northeast and Trade with the Soviet Union during the Liberation War Period] Zhonggong dangshi ziliao 2007 no. 1 178 194 (March 2007) 2007
-
Ding Xiaochun & Fulu Ge Dongbei jiefang zhanzheng dashiji [Major Events of the Liberation War in the Northeast] 1987 Beijing dangshi ziliao chubanshe
-
Eastman Lloyd E. Seeds of Destruction: Nationalist China in War and Revolution, 1937-1949 1984 Stanford Stanford University Press
-
Fairbank John K., Reischauer Edwin O. & Craig Albert M. East Asia: Tradition and Transformation 1989 Revised Edition Boston Houghton Mifflin Company
-
Fehrenbach T. R. This Kind of War: A Study in Unpreparedness 1963 New York Macmillan
-
George Alexander L. The Chinese Communist Army in Action: The Korean War and Its Aftermath 1967 New York Columbia University Press
-
Hess Christian A. “From Colonial Port to Socialist Metropolis: Imperialist Legacies and the Making of ‘New Dalian.’” Urban History 2011 38 3 373 390 (2011)
-
Levine Steven I. Anvil of Victory: The Communist Revolution in Manchuria, 1945-1948 1987 New York Columbia University Press
-
Lew Christopher The Third Chinese Revolutionary Civil War, 1945-49: An Analysis of Communist Strategy and Leadership 2009 London Routledge
-
Liu F. F. A Military History of Modern China, 1924-1949 1956 Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press
-
Liu Tong Dongbei jiefang zhanzheng jishi, 1945-1948 [True Record of the Liberation War in the Northeast, 1945-1948] 1997 Beijing Renmin chubanshe
-
Lu Wenjuan “Dui Sulian geiyu Zhonggong dongbei jiefang zhanzheng junshi yuanzhu qingkuang de kaocha” [Observations on the Situation of Soviet Military Aid to the Chinese Communists in the Northeast Liberation War] Anshan keji daxue xuebao 2007 30 1 80 86 (February 2007)
-
Luo Ronghuan zhuan bianxiezu Luo Ronghuan zhuan [Biography of Luo Ronghuan] 2006 Beijing Dangdai zhongguo chubanshe
-
Lutze Thomas D. China’s Inevitable Revolution: Rethinking America’s Loss to the Communists 2007 New York Palgrave Macmillan
-
Marlowe Ann “The Picture Awaits: The Birth of Modern Counterinsurgency,” World Affairs Journal 2009 accessed 28 January 2013 (Summer 2009), http://www.worldaffairsjournal.org/article/picture-awaits-birth-modern-counterinsurgency
-
Miller Frank Scobell Andrew, Lai David & Kampenhausen Roy “People’s Liberation Army Lessons Learned From Recent Pacific Command Operations And Contingencies.” Chinese Lessons from Other Peoples’ Wars 2011 Carlisle Barracks, PA Strategic Studies Institute 201 235 2011
-
O’Dowd Edward C. Chinese Military Strategy in the Third Indo-China War: The Last Maoist War 2007 London Routledge
-
Paine S. C. M. The Wars for Asia, 1911-1949 2012 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Pepper Suzanne Civil War in China: The Political Struggle, 1945-1949 1978 Berkeley University of California Press
-
Rigg Robert B. Red China’s Fighting Hordes 1952 Harrisburg, PA The Military Service Publishing Company
-
Sanjun daxue Guomin gemingjun zhanyishi diwu bu: kanluan [Campaign History of the National Revolutionary Army, Part Five: Suppressing Rebellion] 1989 Taipei Guofangbu shizhengju
-
Senge Peter M. The Fifth Discipline: The Art and Practice of the Learning Organization 1990 New York Doubleday/Currency
-
Spence Jonathan D. The Search for Modern China 1999 Second edition New York W. W. Norton
-
Tang Hongsan “Guo Gong juezhu dongbei zhanchang junshi lishi wenxian liyong yanjiu” [Research on the Use of Historical Documents on the Nationalist and Communist Fight for the Northeast] Junshi lishi yanjiu 2010 supplemental edition 221 226 2010
-
Tang Tsou America’s Failure in China, 1941-50 1963 Chicago University of Chicago Press
-
Tanner Harold Elleman Bruce & Kotkin Stephen “Railways in Communist Strategy and Operations.” Manchurian Railways and the Opening of China: An International History 2010 Armonk, NY M. E. Sharpe 149 170 2010
-
Tanner Harold M. “Big Army Groups, Standardization, and Assaulting Fortified Positions: Chinese “Ways of War” and the Transition from Guerrilla to Conventional War in China’s Northeast, 1945-1948.” Journal of Chinese Military History 2012 1 2 105 138 (2012)
-
Wang Chaoguang Cong kangzhan shengli dao neizhan baofa qianhou [From the Victory of the War of Resistance to the Outbreak of Civil War] 2000 Beijing Zhonghua shuju
-
Westad Odd Arne Decisive Encounters: The Chinese Civil War, 1946-1950 2003 Stanford, CA Stanford University Press
-
Whitson William W. The Chinese High Command: A History of Communist Military Politics, 1927-71 1973 New York Praeger Publishers
-
Xiang Lanxin Mao’s Generals: Chen Yi and the New Fourth Army 1998 Lanham, MD University Press of America
-
Xu Yan “Jiefang zhanzheng Zhong Sulian geile Zhonggong duoshao wuqi yuanzhu?” [How Many Weapons Did the Soviet Union Give to the Chinese Communists in the Liberation War?] Bingqi zhishi 2009 9A 46 49 (2009)
-
Xue Xiantian & Liu Chengyuan “Sulian yu dongbei geming genjudi” [The Soviet Union and the Revolutionary Base Area in Northeast China] Zhonggong dangshi yanjiu 2005 no. 1 70 78 2005
-
Yang Kuisong “The Soviet Factor and the CCP’s Policy Toward the United States in the 1940s.” Chinese Historians 1992 5 1 17 34 (1992)
-
Yick Joseph K. S. Making Urban Revolution in China: The CCP-GMD Struggle for Beiping-Tianjin, 1945-1949 1995 Armonk, NY M. E. Sharpe
-
Zhang Yong “Jiefang zhanzheng zhong yi suku hui wei zhongxin de xinshi zhengjun yundong” [The New Style of Army Rectification Movement Centering on Speak Bitterness Meetings during the Liberation War] Zhonggong dangshi yanjiu 2010 no. 6 72 80 2010
-
Zhang Zhenglong Xuebai, xuehong: Guo Gong dongbei da juezhan lishi zhenxiang [Snow White, Blood Red: The Real History of the Communists’ and the Nationalists’ Struggle for the Northeast] 1991 Hong Kong Dadi chubanshe
-
Zhao Fengsen & Hao Zhongwen Sibao Linjiang [The Four Defenses of Linjiang] 1987 Changchun Zhonggong Jilin shengwei dangshi gongzuo weiyuanhui
-
Zhengzhi xueyuan diyi junshi jiaoyanshi Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun zhanyi zhanli xuanbian (er) [Selected Exemplary Battles of the Chinese People’s Liberation Army (vol. 2)] 1984 Beijing Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun zhengzhi xueyuan chubanshe ed
-
Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun disi yezhanjun zhanshi bianxiezu Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun disi yezhanjun zhanshi [Campaign History of the People’s Liberation Army Fourth Field Army] 1998 Beijing Jiefangjun chubanshe
-
Zhu Jianhua Dongbei jiefangqu caizheng jingji shigao [Draft Financial and Economic History of the Northeast Liberated Area] 1987 Harbin Heilongjiang renmin chubanshe
-
1
Fairbank, Reischauer, and Craig 1989, 939.
-
2
Acheson 1949, XIV; Chang 1990, 15.
-
3
The classics in this area are Tang 1963, Pepper 1978, and Eastman 1984. See also Lutze 2007 and Yick 1995. With respect to the civil war in the Northeast, Levine 1987 includes one chapter on the military dimension of the struggle, but the bulk of the book is devoted to political, economic, and social issues. My purpose here is not to detract from the significant contributions that these scholars have made, but simply to draw attention to the military aspect of the civil war.
-
5
Fairbank, Reischauer, and Craig 1989, 937-40; Spence 1999, 469-73.
-
6
See Bjorge 2004, Cheng 2005 and 2009, Lew 2009, Westad 2003, and Xiang 1998.
-
7
He 1987, 430.
-
9
For example, see Marlowe 2009.
-
10
Mao 1938, 172.
-
11
Mao 2000, 42.
-
12
Mao 1938, 136-37.
-
13
Mao 1938, 138-39.
-
14
Mao 1938, 174.
-
15
Mao 1938, 182.
-
16
Mao 1947, 161.
-
17
Tang 2010, 225.
-
18
Senge 1990. The idea of using Senge’s model of the “learning organization” as a tool of analysis was suggested by Miller 2011.
-
19
Senge 1990, 10.
-
20
Senge 1990, 5-10.
-
21
Senge 1990, 12.
-
22
Senge 1990, 6-7.
-
23
Senge 1990, 14.
-
29
Qiu 2011, 161.
-
35
Mao 1936, 233-39.
-
36
O’Dowd 2007, 145.
-
37
O’Dowd 2007, 145.
-
38
George 1967, 3; Appleman 1989, 353; Fehrenbach 1963, 119.
-
40
Sanjun daxue 1989, 645; Wang 2000, 675; Ding and Ge 1987, 87.
-
41
Li 2011, vol. 1, 187.
-
42
Sanjun daxue 1989, 644-45, 648.
-
45
Lin Biao, quoted in Liu 1997, 306. See also Lin, “Jizhong juedui youshi bingli jiandi yige tuan de zhanshu zhishi” [Tactical directive on concentrating absolute force advantage to annihilate an enemy regiment] (25 October 1946), in lbjl, doc. # 13.
-
46
Lin Biao, quoted in Liu 1997, 307.
-
49
Li 2011, vol. 1, 190-91; Liu 1997, 315.
-
51
Zhang 1991, 238-39.
-
52
Han 1988, 94; Xiao 1988, 257.
-
54
Zhengzhi xueyuan 1984, 201-2.
-
56
Liu 1997, 336-37.
-
60
Liu 1997, 336.
-
76
Qiu 2011, 162.
-
84
Zhang 2010, 74. The following discussion of “Speak Bitterness” draws on Zhang and on Wu 2006, vol. 2, 401.
-
86
Luo Ronghuan zhuan bianxiezu 2006, 258-59; “Dongzong zhengzhibu guanyu 3 zong kaizhan suku yundong de jingyan xiang junwei zongzheng de baogao” [The Northeast Political Office’s report to the Central Military Commission’s political office concerning the experience of the Third Column’s speak bitterness campaign] (28 September 1947), in zrjddisanji, 6, xia, 742-44.
-
87
Liang 1988, 281.
-
88
Wu 2006, 402-3.
-
89
Qiu 2011, vol. 1, 160-61.
-
90
Zhang 2010, 77.
-
92
Senge 1990, 5-10.
-
93
Wu 2006, vol. 2, 403-4.
-
94
Wu 2006, vol. 2, 403-4.
-
96
Wu 2006, 404; Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun disishiyijun silingbu 1956, 134; “Disanshijiujun zhanshi—Liaoshen zhanyi bufen,” 2.
-
101
Liu 1948, 162.
-
102
Liu 1948, 160; “Shitian junshi lianbing jingyan” [Experiences of ten days of military training], Dongbei ribao, 28 May 1948, 1; “Erxian bingtuan jinzhong jixun” [Second line troops in intense training], Dongbei ribao, 28 May 1948, 1; “Zhankai junshi lianbing yundong,” Dongbei ribao, 18 May 1948, 1.
-
103
Wu 2006, vol. 2, 403; “Shitian junshi lianbing jingyan”, Dongbei ribao, 28 May 1948, 1.
-
104
Liu 1948, 162.
-
121
Westad 2003, 120, 123.
-
122
Paine 2012, 246, 253; Tanner 2010, 158; Westad 2003, 196.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 1645 | 153 | 5 |
| Full Text Views | 402 | 21 | 3 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 366 | 46 | 2 |
Learning Through Practice
Lin Biao and the Transition to Conventional Combined Operations in China’s Northeast, 1946-1948
In: Journal of Chinese Military HistorySearch for other papers by Harold M. Tanner in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Abstract
American scholars of Chinese history have generally explained the outcome of China’s civil war (1945-1949) by reference to social, economic, and political factors rather than by looking at the conduct of the war itself. Recently, military historians have begun to shift the focus to Communist strategy and operations. However, the question of how the Chinese Communist forces made the transition from guerrilla to conventional warfare has still not received sufficient attention. Using Mao Zedong’s theories of guerrilla warfare and Peter Senge’s model of the “learning organization” to analyze Lin Biao’s conduct of the war against the Nationalists in China’s Northeast (Manchuria), we can better understand how the Northeast People’s Liberation Army transformed itself from a force characterized by “guerrilla-ism” to the powerful army capable of defeating Jiang Jieshi’s best troops. The Communists performed poorly when they first encountered American-trained Nationalist units in the Northeast. Lin Biao and his staff responded to defeat by devising principles of tactics which they applied in a series of campaigns beginning with the “Three Expeditions/Four Defenses” (winter 1946-47). The Communist forces continued to derive lessons from their experience and to incorporate those lessons into programs of education and training. As a result, they made great strides forward in terms of the coordination of infantry, artillery, and armor in order to be able to pull off a conventional combined arms operation on the scale of the Liao-Shen Campaign. The Communist forces would bring these strengths with them when they entered the Korean War in 1950.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 1645 | 153 | 5 |
| Full Text Views | 402 | 21 | 3 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 366 | 46 | 2 |
