The Battle of Shangganling, Korea, October-November 1952

in Journal of Chinese Military History
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

The six-week-long Battle of Shangganling (known to the Americans as Operation SHOWDOWN), demonstrated the increasing military effectiveness of the Chinese People’s Volunteer Army (cpva) in the Korean War. The cpva intervention in October and November 1950 had deprived the American-led United Nations Command (unc) of an almost certain victory and set the outcome of the Korean War in strategic limbo. After five Chinese-led campaigns and several u.s. Eighth Army counteroffensives, the battle lines stabilized with the cpva still exposed to American firepower from the ground and air. Prolonged negotiations to settle the conflict (begun in July 1951) gave Chinese armies the opportunity to rearm, reform, and establish a competitive tactical method. Both sides deadlocked over the issue of prisoner repatriation in the spring of 1952, leading a frustrated unc to seek to inflict enough damage on Chinese armies while seizing key terrain to make them more likely to accept demands for voluntary repatriation. SHOWDOWN’s failure convinced American leaders that the military power then available in the Korean theater could not settle the war. The Chinese experience at Shangganling produced a similar lesson and further validated the cpva’s doctrine and technique that permitted them to resist the unc’s coercive approach.

The Battle of Shangganling, Korea, October-November 1952

in Journal of Chinese Military History

Sections

References

Associated Press, '“Reds Seize Triangle Hill and Cut off One UN Unit”' (1952) Washington Post October 31 1952..

ClarkMark W., From the Danube to the Yalu, (Harper and Brothers Publishers, New York 1954).

CollinsJ. Lawton, War in Peacetime: The History and Lessons of Korea, (Houghton Mifflin Company, Boston 1969).

DuPing, Zai zhiyuanjun zongbu: Du Ping huiyilu [At the cpvf General hq: Memoirs of Du Ping], (Jiefangjun chubanshe, Beijing 1989).

EckerRichard, Friendly Fire, (Omega Communications, Clarendon Hills, IL 1996).

EckerRichard, '“Showdown on Triangle Hill”' (2002) Veterans of Foreign Wars Magazine: 34-35 (September 2002).

Eighth Army Artillery Officer, 'A Study of the Employment and Effectiveness of the Artillery with the Eighth Army during the Period October 1951—July 1953' (1954) Copy at ahec library.

Korea, (U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C. 1976) frus1950.

Korea and China, (U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C. 1976) frus1951 vol. vii part 1.

Korea, (U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C. 1984) frus1952-1954.

GonsalvesJoseph E., Battle at the 38th Parallel: Surviving the Peace Talks at Panmunjom, (Hellgate Press, Central Point, OR 2001).

HongXuezhiXiaobingLiMillettAllan R.BinYu, '“The CPVAF’s Combat and Logistics”', in Mao’s Generals Remember Korea, (University Press of Kansas, Lawrence 2001) 106-138.

JohnstonPeter R., '“Attack on Triangle Hill”' (2006) 22(no. 10) Military History: 57 (January/February 2006).

MaoZedong, Jianguo yilai Mao Zedong junshi wengao [Mao Zedong’s Military Manuscripts since the Founding of the prc], (Junshi kexue chubanshe and Zhongyang wenxian chubanshe, Beijing 2010).

MosesLloyd R., Whatever it Takes, (University of South Dakota Press, Vermillion 1991).

ParrottLindsey, '“Red Shells Repel 3 Korean Attacks Up ‘Triangle Hill’”' (1952) New York Times November 4 1952..

Richard Peters and Li Xiaobing (eds), Voices from the Korean War: Personal Stories of American Korean and Chinese Soldiers, (University Press of Kentucky, Lexington 2004).

PengDehuaiZhengLongpu, Memoirs of a Chinese Field Marshal: The Autobiographical Notes of Peng Dehuai, (Foreign Language Press, Beijing 1984).

PoatsRutherford, Decision in Korea: An Intimate History of the Korean War, (McBride Company, Inc., New York 1954).

RidgwayMatthew B., The Korean War, (Doubleday, Garden City, NY 1967) Reprint New York: Da Capo Press..

Seventh Infantry Division Public Information Office, Bayonet: The History of the 7th Infantry Division in Korea, (Dai Nippon Printing Co., Ltd, 1953).

WhiteWilliam J., Triangle Hill, (Xilibris Publishing, Bloomington, IN 2011).

YangDezhiXiaobingLiMillettAllan R.BinYu, '“Command Experience in Korea”', in Mao’s Generals Remember Korea, (University Press of Kansas, Lawrence 2001) 147-183.

ZhangSongshan, Tanpai: zhengduo Shangganling jishi [The Showdown: The True Story of the Battle of Shangganling], (Jiangsu renmin chubanshe, Nanjing 1998).

BloodworthDennis, The Chinese Looking Glass, (Farrar, Straus, and Giroux, New York 1966).

CaseySteven, Selling the Korean War: Propaganda Politics and Public Opinion 1950-1953, (Oxford University Press, Oxford 2008).

Zhonglong Chen (ed), Kangmei yuanchao zhanzheng lun [On the War to Resist the United States and Aid Korea], (Junshi wenyi chubanshe, Beijing 2001).

China National Defense University, Zhongguo renmin zhiyuanjun zhanshi jianbian [A Concise History of the cpvf War-Fighting], (Jiefangjun chubanshe, Beijing 1992).

Kangmei yuanchao zhanzheng jishi [A Chronological Record of the War to Resist the u.s. and Aid Korea], (Jiefangjun chubanshe, Beijing 2008) China National Military Museum ed..

JagerSheila Miyoshi, Brothers at War: The Unending Conflict in Korea, (W.W. Norton and Company, New York 2013).

Tingyu Jiang (ed), Jiedu Kangmei yuanchao zhanzheng [Understanding the War to Resist the u.s. and Aid Korea], (Jiefangjun chubanshe, Beijing 2010).

LiHongjie, Zhengyi de zhanzheng weida de jingshen [The Just War and Great Spirit], (Guangdong renmin chubanshe, Guangzhou 2001).

LiQingshan, Zhiyuanjun yuanchao jishi [The cpvf Records of Aiding Korea], (Zhonggong dangshi chubanshe, Beijing 2008).

LiXiaobing, A History of the Modern Chinese Army, (University Press of Kentucky, Lexington 2007).

LuanKechao, Xue yu huo de jiaoliang; kangmei yuanchao jishi [The Contest: Blood vs. Fire. The Records of Resisting America and Aiding Korea], (Huayi chubanshe, Beijing 2008).

MillettAllan R., Their War for Korea, (Brassy’s, Inc., Washington, D.C. 2002).

RussellWilliam, Stalemate and Standoff: The Bloody Outpost War, (E.O. Painter Printing Company, Inc., DeLeon, FL 1993).

SobieskiAnthony J., Fire for Effect!, (Author House, Bloomington, IN 2005).

James T. Stewart (ed), Airpower: The Decisive Force in Korea, (D. Van Nostrand Company, Inc., Princeton, NJ 1957).

Yan Wang (ed), Peng Dehuai zhuan [Biography of Peng Dehuai], (Dangdai zhongguo chubanshe, Beijing 2011).

WerrellKenneth P., Archie Flak AAA and SAM: A Short Operational History of Ground-based Air Defense, (Air University Press, Maxwell Air Force Base, AL 1988).

XuYan, Mao Zedong yu kangmei yuanchao zhanzheng [Mao Zedong and the War to Resist the u.s. and Aid Korea], (Jiefangjun chubanshe, Beijing 2006).

YuBin, '“Chinese People’s Volunteers Forces”', in James A. Matray and Donald W. Boose (eds), The Ashgate Research Companion to the Korean War, (Ashgate Publishing Company, Burlington, VT 2014) 269-282.

ZhangShu Guang, Mao’s Military Romanticism, (University Press of Kansas, Lawrence 1995).

3

Ridgway 1967182-83.

4

Mao 201050-5261-62; Poats 1954 203-4.

5

Letter of Instructions November 12 1951.

7

Poats 1954216; Ridgway 1967 196-97 202-3.

9

Xu 2006222; Peng 1984 480; Luan 2008 294-95. Mao’s new tactic relied on attrition to eliminate unc troops with less risk. This new plan transformed operations from large-scale offensive campaigns to piecemeal attacks targeting a unc battalion company or even platoon-sized outpost in each battle.

12

Wang 2011277-79.

13

China National Military Museum 2008166-67; Du 1989 542-57.

16

Jager 2013242-57; 255-57 links germ propaganda to truce talks while exposing the evidence of fabrication.

21

Moses 1991208213.

22

Ridgway 1967195.

23

Clark 195499.

24

Eighth Army Artillery Officer 195439-40.

25

Until January 1953Eighth Army had one observation battalion which deployed one battery to each u.s. corps. These batteries relied on visual surveillance sound-ranging devices and the newly deployed (September 1952) AN/MPQ-10 radar. Eighth Army Artillery Officer 1954 13-15.

26

Clark 1954100-101.

27

China National Defense University 1992128-30; Zhang 1998 86-94.

29

Casey 2008295-96.

30

Clark 195478-79.

31

Yang 2001171172.

32

Yang 2001172.

34

Yang 2001172; ams 612-13 627.

48

Moses 1991222.

50

Moses 1991223; Command Report 7th Infantry Division Operation SHOWDOWN 36.

51

Moses 1991224; Command Report u.s. ix Corps October 1952 23; Command Report 7th Infantry Division Operation SHOWDOWN 36; ams 616.

53

Russell 1993102; ams 616; kimh 3: 467-469; Command Report u.s. ix Corps October 1952 24. The 2nd Division’s kmag advisor noted that over 1000 artillery and mortar rounds were used to support the Chinese counterattack—ten times the daily enemy average for indirect fire support. Command Report kmag (2nd rok Division) G2/3 Journal Extract October 14 1952.

59

Yang 2001173.

60

Moses 1991224-25.

61

Moses 1991225.

62

Martin 2001.

63

Johnston 200659; Moses Entry October 16 1952.

64

Moses 1991226-28.

67

White 2011123-24; Command Report u.s. ix Corps October 1952 25; Command Report 7th Infantry Division Operation SHOWDOWN 42-43 48.

68

Bloodworth 1966326.

69

Li 2001109-11; Chen 2001 420-22; Peters and Li 2004 173; Gonsalves 2001 79.

70

Millett 2002239-41.

71

Johnston 200660.

72

Peters and Li 2004177; Command Report 7th Infantry Division Operation SHOWDOWN 50; Command Report 7th Infantry Division October 1952 10.

78

Peters and Li 2004179-81.

79

Yang 2001177.

82

Clark 195479; Ecker 2002 35.

84

Yang 2001177-78.

86

Associated Press 1952.

88

Yang 2001179-80.

90

Parrott 1952.

95

Clark 195479.

97

Johnston 200660.

98

Li 2008409-14. Another Chinese participant assessed the 15th Army lost 11400 soldiers on Triangle Hill alone; Peters and Li 2004 184.

101

Yang 2001182.

105

Ecker 1996227; United Nations Command Report No. 56 16-31 October 1952 5.

107

Quoted in Zhang 1995232.

109

Russell 1993103.

Figures

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 71 71 26
Full Text Views 20 20 16
PDF Downloads 2 2 2
EPUB Downloads 2 2 1