Shifting Political Terrains in “The City by the Bay” (“海湾之城” 政治角力转向 )

Mayor Ed Lee and the Two Convergences of San Francisco Politics (李孟贤的胜出与 旧金山政局二大趋同)

in Journal of Chinese Overseas
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


While the unchallenged November 2015 re-election of San Francisco Mayor Ed Lee was a telling moment in contemporary San Francisco politics, it was Mayor Ed Lee’s inaugural November 2011 election that revealed the shifting political terrains across its eleven Board of Supervisor districts that will likely shape the future role that Chinese Americans will play in the governing coalition of the “City by the Bay.” In the November 2011 San Francisco mayoral election, Ed Lee became the first Chinese American to be elected to lead this city. Despite the common explanation that Lee’s historic victory was due to the city’s first time use of the controversial ranked-choice voting (rcv) system, this study argues that while rcv was an important factor in Lee’s election, other significant factors played a more prominent role. In particular, the two convergences taking shape between Chinese Americans/Asian Americans and the moderate governing coalition along the axes of Race/Space and Identity/Ideology were more significant to the outcome of Lee’s election than the rcv process. In addition, the other significant factors that contributed to Ed Lee’s monumental election in 2011 include his previous public-service experience as a moderate coalition builder and the role of Chinese American community elites that advocated for the endorsement of Lee in both public and private settings with key moderate coalition leaders.

尽管李孟贤在 2015 年 11 月的地方选举中毫无悬念地顺利连任足以载入旧金山当代政治史册,追本溯源,其在4年前首次参选改变了旧金山监事会的政治力量对比,塑造了华人参政的未来。2011年11月,李当选为该市有史以来第一位华裔民选市长。李的历史性胜利,通常被认为是由于首次使用有争议的排列选择投票(rcv)制度所致。这项研究认为,尽管 rcv 是李当选的一个重要因素,但其他因素的作用也是不可忽视的,尤其是华裔/亚裔美国人与其他族裔群体围绕种族/空间以及族裔身份认同/意识形态的轴心而形成的温和执政联盟,对于李的竞选胜利比 rcv 起到更为显著的作用。此外,促成李孟贤在 2011 年市长大选胜利的其他显著因素还包括他以前的公共服务业绩,他本人在建构温和执政联盟中的所扮演的领导角色以及华人社区对他在不同场合中的温和政治主张的认同和大力支持。

This article is in English.

Shifting Political Terrains in “The City by the Bay” (“海湾之城” 政治角力转向 )

Mayor Ed Lee and the Two Convergences of San Francisco Politics (李孟贤的胜出与 旧金山政局二大趋同)

in Journal of Chinese Overseas



Asian American Center for Advancing Justice A Community of Contrasts: Asian Americans, Native Hawaiians, and Pacific Islanders in California 2013 <>[July 2015]

BerubeAlan “All Cities Are Not Created Equal.” 2014 February 20 <> [July 2015]

BowlerShaunSeguraGary M. The Future is Ours: Minority Politics Political Behavior and the Multiracial Era of American Politics 2012 Washington, DC CQ Press

BrowningRufusMarshallDale RogersTabbDavid H. Racial Politics in American Cities 2003 Third New York, NY Pearson Press

cbre “CBRE: High Tech Presence in San Francisco.” 2013 August 21 <>[July 2015]

CookCoreyLattermanDavid “Ranked Choice Voting in the 2011 SF Municipal Election Final Report.” University of sf Leo T. McCarthy Center for Public Service 2011 <>[July 2015]

CoteJohn “Sneak peek: Mayor Ed Lee has a housing solution.” 2014a January 17 <>[July 2015]

CoteJohn “Mayor signs law regulating Airbnb—and that could mean a ballot fight.” 2014b October 27 <>[July 2015]

DeLeonRichard Left Coast City: Progressive Politics in sf 1975-1991 1992 Lawrence, KS University of Kansas Press

DeLeonRichard E. BrowningRufus P.MarshallDale RogersTabbDavid H. “San Francisco: The Politics of Race, Land Use, and Ideology.” Racial Politics in American Cities 2003 New York, NY Longman Press 167 198

FaganKevin “Census shows big gains by Asian Americans, Latinos.” SF Gate 2011 March 9 <>[July 2015]

JunnJaneMasuokaNatalie “Asian American Identity: Shared Racial Status and Political Context.” Perspectives on Politics 2008 6 4 729 740

LaiJames S. Asian American Political Action: Suburban Transformations 2011 Boulder, CO Lynne Rienner Publishers

LaiJames S.GeronKim “When Asian Americans Run: The Suburban and Urban Dimensions of Asian American Candidates in California Local Politics.” California Politics & Policy 2006 62 88 June 2006

LattermanDavid “PVI 6.0: Revised San Francisco Progressive Voter Index and Changes in the San Francisco Electorate.” 2015 <>[July 2015]

LeeDavid “Chinese American Voters Education Committee.” Asian Society Northern California 2011 November 15 <>[July 2015]

LeeDavid “Clement Street: A Transect of Change.” BOOM: A Journal of California 2014 Summer 4 2 2014 <> [July 2015]

LiuMichaelGeronKimLaiTracy The Snake Dance of Asian American Activism: Community Vision and Power 2008 Lanham, MD Lexington Books

LoweRuss Personal interview 2012 July 11

LubyOliver “Section 1: Total Receipts, Public Financing & Independent Spending for Candidates & Ballot Measure Committees,” Finance Wrap-Up for sf’s 2011 Election 2012 <>[July 2015]

MasuokaNatalie “Political Attitudes and Ideologies of Multiracial Americans: The Implications of Mixed Race in the U.S.” Political Research Quarterly 2008 61 2 253 267

NakanishiDon T.LaiJames S. 2011-12 National Asian Pacific American Political Almanac 2012 14th Los Angeles, CA UCLA Asian American Studies Center Press

PRNewswire “Northern California Laborers Support Edwin Lee for Interim Mayor of SF,” 2011 January 7 <> [July 2015]

RobertsChris “The Mayor’s Money Machine Runs Unopposed.” SF Weekly 2015 September 23 <>[October 2015]

ShihGerry “Behind-the-Scenes Power Politics: The Making of a Mayor,” New York Times 2011 January 6 <>[July 2015]

ShihGerryElinsonZusha “Mayor’s Political Machine Goes Into High Gear in Quest for Full Term.” The New York Times 2011 October 21 <>[July 2015]

SmithChris “Rose Pak is Winning.” San Francisco Magazine Online 2012 November 26 <>[July 2015]

San Francisco Planning Department “San Francisco Neighborhoods Socio-Economic Profiles.” 2012 <>[July 2015]

SonensheinRaphael Politics in Black and White: Race and Power in Los Angeles 1993 Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press

WongJanelle Democracy’s Promise: Immigrants & American Civic Institutions 2006 Ann Arbor, MI University of Michigan Press

WongJanelleRamakrishnanS. KarthickLeeTaekuJunnJane Asian American Political Participation: Emerging Constituents and Their Political Identities 2011 New York, NY Russell Sage Foundation


Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 12 12 1
Full Text Views 5 5 5
PDF Downloads 2 2 2
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0