The Perception of the Importance of Chinese Cultural Values (马来西亚和台湾华商对华人文化价值观认同的比较分析)

A Comparison of Chinese Entrepreneurs in Taiwan and Malaysia

in Journal of Chinese Overseas
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


The main objective is to compare the perception of the importance of Chinese cultural values by Chinese entrepreneurs in Malaysia and Taiwan. A questionnaire that included demographic data and a survey of Chinese values was distributed by mail to Chinese entrepreneurs in Malaysia and Taiwan. A total of 95 questionnaires from Malaysia and 70 from Taiwan were returned. The results showed that perceptions of the importance of Chinese values are quite similar among Chinese entrepreneurs in Malaysia and Taiwan, and that some differences might be explained by social context. Overall, Chinese entrepreneurs in Malaysia perceived Chinese values to be more important than did Chinese entrepreneurs in Taiwan.

这个研究报告的主要目的在比较马来西亚和台湾华裔企业家对华人文化价值观重要性的认同。研究是以问卷调查方式进行, 并以邮寄方式分发给在马来西亚和台湾的华裔企业家。 问卷内容包括了一些个人基本资料的测量及华人价值观量表。这项研究一共回收了95 份来自马来西亚华裔企业家及70份来自台湾华裔企业家的问卷。分析结果显示马来西亚和台湾华裔企业家对华人文化价值观的重要性认同相当类似,而一些不同的华人文化价值观的重要性的认同可能和他们所处的社会情况有关。整体而言,马来西亚华裔企业家对华人文化价值观的重要性认同稍高于台湾华裔企业家。

This article is in English.



Associated Chinese Chambers of Commerce and Industry of Malaysia “The Associated Chinese Chambers of Commerce and Industry of Malaysia.” 2011 [June 2014]

BaruchYehudaHoltomBrooks C. “Survey Response Rate Levels and Trends in Organizational Research.” Human Relations 2008 61 8 1139 1160

BedfordOlwen “Crossing Boundaries an Exploration of Business Socializing (Ying Chou for Guanxi) in a Chinese Society.” Psychology of Women Quarterly (in press)

BergerBrigitte The Culture of Entrepreneurship 1991 San Francisco ICS Press

BrindleyThomas. A. “Socio-Psychological Values in the Republic of China (i).” Asian Thought and Society 1989 14 41 98 115

BrownGraham K. “Making Ethnic Citizens: The Politics and Practice of Education in Malaysia.” International Journal of Educational Development 2007 27 3 318 330

CarneyMichaelGedajlovicEricYangXiaohua “Varieties of Asian Capitalism: Toward an Institutional Theory of Asian Enterprise.” Asia Pacific Journal of Management 2009 26 3 361 380

Central Intelligence Agency “The World Fact Book.” 2015 [April 2015]

ChenChao C.ChenXiao PingHuangShengsheng “Chinese Guanxi: An Integrative Review and New Directions for Future Research.” Management and Organization Review 2013 9 1 167 207

Chinese Culture Connection “Chinese Values and the Search for Culture-Free Dimensions of Culture.” Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology 1987 18 2 143 164

ChuWan Wen “Inquiries into the Causes of Taiwan’s Postwar Economic Development.” Taiwan: A Radical Quarterly In Social Studies 2007 12 65 1 33

CollinsAlan “Chinese Educationalists in Malaysia: Defenders of Chinese Identity.” Asian Survey 2006 46 2 298 318

ElasmarMichel G.HunterJohn E. “The Impact of Foreign tv on a Domestic Audience: A Meta-Analysis.” Communication Yearbook 1997 20 47 70

FlaaenAaronGhaniSyed EjazMishraSaurabh “How to Avoid Middle Income Traps? Evidence from Malaysia.” World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 2013 6427 [31 Aug. 2015]

GaoHongzhiKnightJohn G.BallantyneDavid “Guanxi as a Gateway in Chinese‐Western Business Relationships.” Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing 2012 27 6 456 467

GeertzClifford The Interpretation of Cultures: Selected Essays 1973 New York Basic Books

GeorgeGerardZahraShaker A. “Culture and Its Consequences for Entrepreneurship.” Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice 2002 26 4 5 8

GiniAI “Moral Leadership and Business Ethics.” Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies 1997 4 4 64 81

GregoryBrian T.HarrisStanley G.ArmenakisAchilles A.ShookChristopher L. “Organizational Culture and Effectiveness: A Study of Values, Attitudes, and Organizational Outcomes.” Journal of Business Research 2009 62 7 673 679

HastingsJustine S.KaneThomas J.StaigerDouglas O. Parental Preferences and School Competition: Evidence from a Public School Choice Program 2005 Cambridge National Bureau of Economic Research

HofstedeGeert “Asian Management in the 21st Century.” Asia Pacific Journal of Management 2007 24 4 411 420

HofstedeG. Culture’s Consequences: Comparing Values, Behaviours, Institutions and Organizations across Nations 2001 California Sage Publications

HofstedeGeertBondMichael Harris “The Confucius Connection: From Cultural Roots to Economic Growth.” Organizational Dynamics 1988 16 4 4 21

HofstedeGeertPetersonMark F. AshkanasyN. M.WilderomC. P. M.PetersonM. F. “National Values and Organizational Practices.” Handbook of Organizational Culture and Climate 2000 California Sage Publications 401 416

InglehartRonaldCarballoMarita “Does Latin America Exist? (And Is There a Confucian Culture?): A Global Analysis of Cross-Cultural Differences.” Political Science and Politics 1997 30 1 34 47

KhorTeik Huat “Malaysian Chinese and Their Collective Memory: Continuity of Cultural Heritage in a Society on the Periphery of Political Power.” Journal of Malaysian Chinese Studies 2006 9 1 18

KraftCharles H. Christianity with Power: Your Worldview and Your Experience of the Supernatural 1989 Mich Vine Books

LinLiang HungHoYu Ling “Confucian Dynamism, Culture and Ethical Changes in Chinese Societies — a Comparative Study of China, Taiwan, and Hong Kong.” The International Journal of Human Resource Management 2009 20 11 2402 2417

LuLuoRobinGilmourKaoShu-Fang “Cultural Values and Happiness: An East-West Dialogue.” The Journal of Social Psychology 2001 141 4 477 493

LumpkinG. TomDessGregory G. “Clarifying the Entrepreneurial Orientation Construct and Linking It to Performance.” The Academy of Management Review 1996 21 1 135 172

NguyenPhuongMinhThiJinPutaiGrossMiraca UM “Confucian Values in Vietnamese Gifted Adolescents and Their Non-Gifted Peers.” Gifted and Talented International 2013 28 1 227 238

NoorNoraini M. NoorN. M.MontielC. J. “The Future of Malay–Chinese Relations in Malaysia.” Peace Psychology in Asia 2009 New York Springer Publishing Company 161 172

Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (oecd). “Fostering Entrepreneurship and Firm Creation as a Driver of Growth in a Global Economy.” 2004 [April 2015]

PeppasSpero C. “US Core Values: A Chinese Perspective.” International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy 2004 24 6 58 75

PeverelliPeter J.JiwenSong PeverelliPeter J.JiwenSong “Chinese Entrepreneurs in Society.” Chinese Entrepreneurship 2012 US Springer 37 57

QuerDiegoClaverEnriqueRiendaLaura “Doing Business in China and Performance: A Review of Evidence.” Chinese Management Studies 2010 4 1 37 56

RochelleTina L.YimK. H. “Factors Associated with Utilisation of Traditional Chinese Medicine among Hong Kong Chinese.” Psychology, Health & Medicine 2014 19 4 453 462

SchneiderSusan C. “Strategy Formulation: The Impact of National Culture.” Organization Studies 1989 10 2 149 168

SegawaN. “Malaysia’s 1996 Education Act: The Impact of a Multiculturalism-Type Approach on National Integration.” Sojourn: Journal of Social Issues in Southeast Asia 2007 22 1 30 56

ShiCangjin “Protection, Inheritance and Development: An Analysis on Measures and Trends of Malaysia Chinese Associations for Developing the Chinese Culture since 1980s.” Southeast Asian Studies 2006 2 57 62

SiahPoh ChuaOngSook Beng ChristinaTanSwee MeeSimChzia Poaw “Perception on Chinese Values: A Comparison of Chinese Secondary Students Studying at National Secondary Schools and Chinese Independent Schools in Malaysia.” The Social Science Journal 2015 52 1 62 68

SwidlerAnn “Culture in Action: Symbols and Strategies.” American Sociological Review 1986 51 2 273 286

TanBenjamin Lin Boon “Researching Managerial Values: A Cross-Cultural Comparison.” Journal of Business Research 2002 55 10 815 821

TaorminaRobert J.SelvarajahChristopher “Perceptions of Leadership Excellence in ASEAN Nations.” Leadership 2005 1 3 299 322

VandewalleDonDyneLinn VanKostovaTatiana “Psychological Ownership: An Empirical Examination of Its Consequences.” Group & Organization Management 1995 20 2 210 226

Welle-StrandAnneChenPei-FenBallGraeme “The Taiwanese Economic ‘miracle’: Continuing?” East Asia 2011 28 4 329 350

WongAmy Lai Yu.ShawGraham H.NgDavid K. C. “Taiwan Chinese Managers’ Personality: Is Confucian Influence on the Wane?” The International Journal of Human Resource Management 2010 21 7 1108 1123

WoodbineGordon F.FanYing HanScullyGlenna “How Chinese Auditors’ Relativistic Ethical Orientations Influence Their Love of Money.” Electronic Journal of Business Ethics and Organization Studies 2013 18 2 20 29

YacobShakila “Political Culture and Nation Building: Whither Bangsa Malaysia.” Malaysian Journal of Social policy and Society 2006 3 22 42


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 20 20 10
Full Text Views 6 6 6
PDF Downloads 1 1 1
EPUB Downloads 1 1 1