Reconquista and Reconciliation in the Dutch Revolt: The Campaign of Governor-General Alexander Farnese (1578-1592)

in Journal of Early Modern History
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Abstract

The campaign in the Low Countries led by governor-general Alexander Farnese from October 1578 onwards resulted in the reconquest of more cities for the King of Spain than had been achieved by any of his predecessors or successors. It serves here as a starting point for a contextual analysis of the relationship between the ruler and the city defiant during the Dutch Revolt, not only to cast new light on the oft-neglected and complex Spanish Habsburg policies, but also to understand the broader context of questions of resistance and reconciliation during the Dutch Revolt. Most capitulation treaties accorded by Farnese show at least four features at odds with the pattern of repression of urban revolts. The governor aimed at keeping the civic patrimony intact, he granted full pardon and oblivion, he conditionally restored urban privileges and he often felt obliged not to insist on immediate reconciliation with the Catholic Church. The divergent reactions to this Habsburg policy indicate that the Dutch Revolt showed striking features of a civil war, in which not only the conditions of revolt but also of reconciliation caused discord.

Reconquista and Reconciliation in the Dutch Revolt: The Campaign of Governor-General Alexander Farnese (1578-1592)

in Journal of Early Modern History

Sections

References

3

Jan Craeybeckx“De val van Antwerpen en de scheuring der Nederlanden, gezien door de grote Noordnederlandse geschiedschrijvers van de eerste generatie,” in 1585: Op gescheiden wegen Acta Colloquii Bruxellensis 22-23 XI 1985ed. Jan Craeybeckx Frank Daelemans Frank Scheelings (Leuven 1988) 121-150; Guido Marnef “Betreurd en/of gevierd: de val van Antwerpen (1585)” Het geheugen van de Lage Landen ed. Jo Tollebeek and Henk Te Velde (Rekkem 2009) 131-137; Violet Soen “¿Más allá de la leyenda negra? Léon van der Essen y la historiografía reciente en torno al castigo de las ciudades rebeldes en los Países Bajos (siglos XIV a XVI)” in El Ejército Español en Flandes 1567-1584 ed. Leon Van der Essen Gustaaf Janssens (Yuste 2008) 45-72.

4

Bart De Groof“Alexander Farnese and the Origins of Modern Belgium,” Bulletin de l’Institut Historique à Rome 63 (1993): 195-221; Leon Van der Essen Alexandre Farnèse et les origines de la Belgique Moderne 1545-1592 (Brussels 1943).

8

Geoffrey Parker“The Etiquette of Atrocity: The Laws of War in Early Modern Europe,” in Empire War and Faith in Early Modern Europeed. Geoffrey Parker (Allen Lane 2002) 144-168; Geoffrey Parker The Army of Flanders and the Spanish Road 1567-1659: The Logistics of Spanish Victory and Defeat in the Low Countries’ Wars (Cambridge 1972); Jean-Marie Charles “Le sac des villes dans les Pays-Bas au seizième siècle: Étude critique des règles de guerre” Revue internationale d’histoire militaire 24 (1965): 288-302.

10

Gustaaf Janssens“Pacification générale ou réconciliation particulière? Problèmes de guerre et de paix aux Pays-Bas au début du gouvernement d’Alexandre Farnèse (1578-1579),” Bulletin de l’Institut Historique de Rome 63 (1993): 251-278; Violet Soen “Les Malcontents au sein des États-Généraux rebelles aux Pays-Bas (1578-1581): Défense du pouvoir de la noblesse ou défense de l’orthodoxie?” in La noblesse et la défense de l’orthodoxie XIII-XVIIIme siècles ed. Ariane Boltanski and Frank Mercier (Rennes 2011) 135-149.

11

Anne-Laure Van Bruaene“Spectacle and Spin for a Spurned Prince: Civic Strategies in the Entry Ceremonies of the Duke of Anjou in Antwerp, Bruges and Ghent (1582),” JEMH 11 (2007): 263-284.

14

Hugo de Schepper“Le voyage difficile de Marguerite de Parme en Franche-Comté et en Flandre 1580-1583,” in Margherita d’Austria (1522-1586: Costruzioni politiche e diplomazia tra corte Farnese e Monarchia spagnolaed. Sabina Mantini (Rome 2003) 127-140.

16

Leon Van der Essen“La mission du président Richardot en Espagne en 1583. Documents inédits tirés des Archives farnésiennes de Naples,” BCRH 97 (1933): 321-336.

19

Simon Adams“The Decision to Intervene: England and the United Provinces, 1584-1585,” in Felipe II (1527-1598): Europa y la Monarquía Católica. Tomo I: El Gobierno de la Monarquíaed. José Martínez Millán (Madrid 1998) 19-32.

20

Geoffrey Parker“The Limits to Revolutions in Military Affairs: Maurice of Nassau, the Battle of Nieuwpoort (1600), and the Legacy,” The Journal of Military History 71 (2007): 331-372; Erik Swart Krijgsvolk: militaire professionalisering en het ontstaan van het Staatse leger 1568-1590 (Amsterdam 2006).

22

Maria Rodríguez-Salgado“ ‘Almost a royal eagle’: Alexander Farnese and the Spanish Monarchy,” Alessandro Farnese and the Low Countries (forthcoming).

24

José Eloy Hortal Muñoz“Alessandro Farnese y la Corte de Felipe II: Luchas y facciones cortesanas en Madrid y Bruselas entre 1585 y 1592” and Alicia Esteban Estríngana, “Veeduría general del ejército de Flandes. Sobre las raíces del descrédito político del príncipe de Parma (1585-1587)” in Alessandro Farnese and the Low Countries (forthcoming).

27

Wouter Ryckbosch“Stedelijk initiatief of hertogelijke repressie? Financiële hervormingen en kredietbeleid te Gent (1453-1495),” Tijdschrift voor Sociale en Economische Geschiedenis 4 (2007): 3-28.

28

ArnadeBeggars212-215.

29

Matthew C. Waxman“Strategic Terror: Philip II and Sixteenth-Century Warfare,” War in History 4 (1997): 339-347; Philip II to Farnese 15/09/1584: AGR PEA 180 fos. 44-45 (original); for a city in Gelre Philip II to Farnese: 7/03/1585: AGR PEA 180 fos. 132-136 (original decryption in the margin) see Lefèvre CPh III 16-19 (35).

34

Penny Roberts“The Languages of Peace during the French Religious Wars,” Cultural and Social History 4 (2007): 293-311; see the VNC-project led by Judith Pollmann at the University of Leiden: Tales of the Revolt Memory Oblivion and Identity in the Low Countries 1566-1700: http://www.hum.leiden.edu/history/talesoftherevolt/.

37

Geert Janssen“Exiles and the Politics of Reintegration in the Dutch Revolt,” Historical Journal 94 (2009): 36-52.

39

Guido Marnef“Reconquering a Rebellious City: Alessandro Farnese and the Siege and Recatholicization of Antwerp,” in Alexander Farnese and the Low Countries (forthcoming) passim.

47

Monique Weis“La Paix d’Augsbourg de 1555: Un modèle pour les Pays-Bas? L’ambassade des princes luthériens allemands auprès de Marguerite de Parme en 1567,” Entre Royaume et Empire: Frontières rivalités et modèles (Neuchâtel 2000) 87-100; Ibidem Les Pays-Bas espagnols et les États du Saint Empire (1559-1579): Priorités et enjeux de la diplomatie en temps de troubles (Brussels 2003).

56

Michel De Waele“Entre concorde et intolérance: Alexandre Farnèse et la Pacification des Pays-Bas,” in De Michel de L’Hospital à l’édit de Nantes. Politique et religion face aux Églisesed. Thierry Wanegfellen (Paris 2002) 51-70.

60

Andrew Spicer“After Iconoclasm: Reconciliation and Resacralisation in the Southern Netherlands, c. 1566-1586,” Sixteenth Century Journal (forthcoming).

62

Monica Stensland“Not as Bad as All That: The Strategies and Effectiveness of Loyalist Propaganda in the Early Years of Alexander Farnese’s Governorship,” Dutch Crossing 31 (2007): 91-112.

72

Alastair Duke“Calvinist Loyalism: Jean Haren, Chimay and the Demise of the Calvinist Republic of Bruges,” in Dissident Identities in the Early Modern Low Countriesed. Alastair Duke Judith Pollmann and Andrew Spicer (Aldershot 2009) 251-272; Herman Vanderlinden “Beleg en val in 1584” Het eind van een rebelse droom” Opstellen over het calvinistisch bewind te Gent (1577-1584) en de terugkeer van de stad onder de gehoorzaamheid van de koning van Spanje (17 september 1584) ed. Johan Decavele (Ghent 1984) 103-112.

76

Stensland“Not as Bad”; Koenraad Swart, “The Black Legend during the Eighty Years War,” Britain and the Netherlandsed. J. S. Bromley and E. H. Kossman (The Hague 1975) V: 36-57.

78

Michel De Waele“Henri IV, politicien monarchomaque? Les contrats de fidélité entre le roi et les Français,” in Le traité de Vervinsed. J.-F. Labourdette J.-P. Poussou en M.-C. Vignal (Paris 2000) 117-134 122.

79

Michel Cassan“La réduction des villes ligueuses à l’obéissance,” Nouvelle Revue du Seizième Siècle 22 (2004): 159-174161 and 166-167.

80

Paul Brood“Het ‘Tractaat van Reductie’ van 1594: Overzicht van de gebeurtenissen en tekst van het Tractaat,” Van beeldenstorm tot reductie van Groningen (Groningen 1994) 11-26.

81

Laura Cruz“Reworking the Grand Narrative: A Review of Recent Books on the Dutch Revolt,” The Low Countries Historical Review 125 (2010): 29-38.

82

Wim Blockmans“Voracious States and Obstructing Cities: An Aspect of State Formation in Preindustrial Europe,” Theory and Society 18 (1989): 733-755.

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 45 45 19
Full Text Views 111 111 70
PDF Downloads 9 9 3
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0