A bitter conflict between the Spanish and Ottoman empires dominated the second half of the sixteenth century. In this early modern “global” conflict, intelligence played a key role. The Duchy of Milan, home to Simon Sacerdoti (c.1540-1600), a Jew, had fallen to Spain. The fate that usually awaited Jews living on Spanish lands was expulsion—and there were signs to suggest that King Philip ii (1527-1598) might travel down that road. Sacerdoti, the scion of one of Milan’s wealthiest and best-connected Jewish families had access to secret information through various contacts in Italy and North-Africa. Such intelligence was highly valuable to Spanish forces, and Philip ii was personally interested in it. However, this required Sacerdoti to serve an empire—Spain—with a long history of harming the Jews, and to spy on the Ottomans, widely considered as the Jews’ supporters at the time. This article offers a reflection on Simon Sacerdoti’s story. Examining how a Jew became part of the Spanish intelligence agency helps us understand how early modern secret information networks functioned and sheds new light on questions of Jewish identity in a time of uprootedness and competing loyalties.
Carnicer and MarcosEspias de Felipe II: Los servicios secretos del Imperio español13-27. By contrast in England Sir Francis Walsingham ran Queen Elizabeth’s entire intelligence network for her. Béatrice Pérez ed. Ambassadeurs apprentis espions et maîtres comploteurs. Le système de renseignement de l’Espagne au temps modernes (Paris 2010).
Quoted by Gurkan“Espionage in the 16th Century Mediterranean”387. There is some evidence to suggest that Nasi too was courted by Christian forces including Spain and that he himself had made overtures in Spain’s direction although the extent of Nasi’s role as a “double agent” is disputed. Baron dismissed Nasi’s overtures to Spain as made up and impulsive Salo Wittmayer Baron A Social and Religious History of the Jews 2d ed. (New York 1952) xviii 92; Rosenblatt and Gurkan on the other hand see him as a shrewd political operator who would not have had any compunctions about giving information to Spain if it served his interests: Rosenblath “Joseph Nasi Friend of Spain” 257-286; Gurkan “Espionage in the 16th Century Mediterranean” 383.
SegreThe Jews in Piedmont447-453. Joseph ha-Cohen recorded the 1565 expulsion too but got a number of the facts wrong. He dated it to 1566 called the Duke Joseph Filibert instead of Emmanuel Philibert and wrote that the Duke “who was greedy” ordered the Jews to pay 4000 golden coins or leave his lands. The Jews left but few days later they came back with 2000 golden coins after which the duke readmitted them and granted them a new condotta or “covenant” with a yearly tax of 1500 golden coins. Joseph ha-Kohen “Emek ha-Bakha” 170. Apparently when not in Milan or Genoa places Joseph was intimately familiar with the level of accuracy of Emek ha-Bakha decreases.
John Elliott“A Europe of Composite Monarchies,”Past and Present137 (1992): 48-71; Guiseppe de Luca “Trading Money and Empire Building in Spanish Milan (1570-1640)” Polycentric Monarchies 18-125; Alberto Marcos Martin “Polycentric Monarchies: Understanding the Grand Multinational Organizations of the Early Modern Period” Polycentric Monarchies 217-226.