Representation of Islam and Christianity in the Swiss Media

in Journal of Empirical Theology
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Abstract

What is the role of the media in multi-religious societies? Are they aggravating latent tensions between religions or rather helping to promote mutual understanding? These are the key research questions addressed in this paper. The discussion in this paper refers to narration and framing as two theoretical approaches from communication science. The empirical findings of a media content analysis in Switzerland show strong differences between Islam and Christianity: While Christianity and its denominations are mainly presented in positive frames and positive narratives (e.g. “good mother”), the image of Islam is rather negative. Islam receives relatively high media attention, but the focus is not on Islam in Switzerland, but on Islam abroad. A number of qualitative interviews with journalists and representatives of religious organisations show that this negative image is not caused by anti-muslim attitudes, but rather the outcome of journalistic routines. The paper discusses these findings against the background of the research questions and concludes with some recommendations for journalists and representatives of religious organizations.

Sections

References

Abdel AzizAmiraDas Bild des Islam und seiner Akteure in der Deutschschweizer Presse: eine Inhaltsanalyse von Blick, Tages-Anzeiger, NZZ2005ZürichLizentiatsarbeit

AwassOmer, 'The representation of Islam in the American media' (1996) 19(3) Hamdard Islamicus: 87-102.

BaumannMartinStolzJörg, 'Religiöse Vielfalt in der Schweiz: Zahlen, Fakten, Trends', in Martin Baumann and Jörg Stolz (eds), Eine Schweiz — viele Religionen. Risiken und Chancen des Zusammenlebens, (Bielefeld 2007) 39-66.

BilandzicHelenaKinnebrockSusanne, 'Persuasive Wirkung narrativer Unterhaltungsangebote. Theoretische Überlegungen zum Einfluss von Narrativität auf Transportation', in Werner Wirth, Holger Schramm and Volker Gehrau (eds), Unterhaltung durch Medien: Theorie und Messung, (Köln 2006) 102-126.

BirdElisabethDardenneRobert, 'Myth, Chroncicle, and Story. Exploring the Narrative Qualities of News', in James Carey (ed), Media, Myths, and Narratives. Television and the Press, (Newbury Park 1988) 67-86.

ChristiansClifford G.FerréJohn P.FacklerMark P., Good news: social ethics and the press, (New York 1993).

D’HaenensLeenBinkSusan, 'Islam in the Dutch Press. With special attention to the Algemeeen DAgblad' (2005) 29(1) Media, Culture & Society: 135-149.

DahindenUrs, Framing — Eine integrative Theorie der Massenkommunikation, (Konstanz 2006).

DahindenUrsWyssVinzenz, 'Spezialisierung im Journalismus: Allgemeiner Trend? Herausforderungen durch das Thema Religion', in Beatrice Dernbach and Thorsten Quandt (eds), Spezialisierung des Journalismus, (Wiesbaden 2009) 123-135.

DahlgrenPeter, 'Introduction', in Peter Dahlgren and Colin Sparks (eds), Journalism and Popular Culture, (London 1992) 1-23.

EntmanRobert M., 'Framing: Toward Clarification of a Fractured Paradigm' (1993) 43(4) Journal of Communication: 51-58.

GamsonWilliam A.ModiglianiAndre, 'Media discourse and public opinion on nuclear power: a constructionist approach' (1989) 95(1) American Journal of Sociology: 1-37.

HafezKai, Die politische Dimension der Auslandberichterstattung. Das Nahost- und Islambild der deutschen überregionalen Presse, (Baden-Baden 2002).

HussainMustafa, 'Islam, media and minorities in Denmark' (2000) 48(4) Current sociology: 95-116.

JeckerConstanze, Religionen im Fernsehen. Fakten, Analysen, Perspektiven, (Konstanz 2011).

KochCarmen, 'Das Politische dominiert. Wie Schweizer Medien über Religionen berichten' (2009) 42(4) Communicatio Socialis: 365-381.

LuleJack, Daily news, eternal stories. The mythological role of journalism, (New York 2001).

LünenborgMargreth, Journalismus als kultureller Prozess: zur Bedeutung von Journalismus in der Mediengesellschaft: ein Entwurf, (Wiesbaden 2005).

ManningPeter, 'Australians Imagining Islam', in Elizabeth Poole and John E. Richardson (eds), Muslims and the News Media, (London 2006) 128-141.

MeadGeorge Herbert, 'The nature of aesthetic experience' (1925/1926) 36 International Journal of Ethics: 382-393.

PoolE., 'Framing Islam: An analysis of newspaper coverage of Islam in the British press', in K. Hafez (ed), Islam and the West in the mass media. Fragmented images in a globalizing world, (Cresskill, New Jersey 2000) 157-179.

PooleElizabeth, 'The Effects of September 11 and the War in Iraq on British Newspaper Coverage', in Elizabeth Poole and John E. Richardson (eds), Muslims and the News Media, (London 2006) 59-102.

ReichmuthStéphanieDie Darstellung des Islams in der Deutschschweizer Presse : eine Inhaltsanalyse zur Vielfalt der Berichterstattung über den Islam in der Neuen Zürcher Zeitung, im Tagesanzeiger und im Blick2006ZürichLizentiatsarbeit

RichardsonJohn E., 'Who Gets to Speak? A Study of Sources in the Broadsheet Press', in Elizabeth Poole and John E. Richardson (eds), Muslims and the News Media, (London 2006) 103-115.

SchranzMarioImhofKurt, 'Muslime in der Schweiz — Muslime in der öffentlichen Kommunikation' (2002) Medienheft http://www.medienheft.ch/kritik/bibliothek/k19Schranz Imhof.pdf (26.5.2007).

SemetkoHolli A.ValkenburgPatti M., 'Framing European Politics: A Content Analysis of Press and Television News' (2000) 50(2) Journal of Communication: 93-109.

SmartNinian, Dimensions of the Sacred. An Anatomy of the World’s Beliefs, (London 1997).

ThofernDetlef, Darstellung des Islams in DER SPIEGEL. Eine inhaltsanalytische Untersuchung über Themen und Bilder der Berichterstattung von 1950 bis 1989, (Hamburg 1997).

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 11 11 6
Full Text Views 2 2 2
PDF Downloads 2 2 2
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0