Multiple Religious and Secular Definitions of Secular Adolescents in Israel

in Journal of Empirical Theology
No Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Abstract

This study explores the validity of a novel theoretical model for assessing secularity and religiosity that proposes two dimensions — conceptual and inherited — in an effort to further refine the religious/secular dichotomy applied in research to date. These new dimensions describe the manner in which people structure their world, religious or secular world as the case may be, and the significance they ascribe to it. The study, conducted among grade 12 students (N=100) in state (secular) schools in Israel, revealed that only five of the eight types in the theoretical model are manifested empirically: three secular (conceptual, inherited and integrative) and two religious (conceptual and inherited). It posits that the concepts “religious” and “secular” are comprehensive and cannot fully describe the complexity of an individual’s self- and public definition in a modern, pluralistic world.

Multiple Religious and Secular Definitions of Secular Adolescents in Israel

in Journal of Empirical Theology

Sections

References

AdornoT. W.Frenkel-BrunswikE.LevinsonD. J.SanfordR. N. The authoritarian personality 1950 New York Harper and Row

AllportG. W.RossJ. M. “Personal religious orientation and prejudice” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1967 5 432 443

BaumanZ. Liquid modernity 2000 Oxford Blackwell

Beit-HallahmiB.ArgyleM. The psychology of religious behaviour belief and experience 1997 London Routledge

Ben MeirY.KedemP. “A measure of religiosity for the Jewish population of Israel” Megamot 1979 24 3 353 362 Hebrew

BrodieR. E.FowlerR. “Crisis case analysis: religious language in suicide attempts” Emotional First Aid: A Journal of Crisis Intervention 1985 2 2 56 58

ByersB.ZellerR. A. “Social judgments of responsibility in elder self-neglect cases” The Journal of Psychology 1995 129 3 331 344

ChumblerN. R. “An empirical test of a theory of factors affecting life satisfaction: understanding the role of religious experience” Journal of Psychology and Theology 1996 24 220 232

EisenstadtS. N. EisenstadtS. N. “Multiple modernities” Multiple modernities 2000 New Brunswick, NJ Transaction 1 29

EllisonC. G. “Religious involvement and subjective well-being” Journal of Health and Social Behaviour 1991 32 1 80 99

EllisonC. G.GayD. A.GlassT. A. “Does religious commitment contribute to individual life satisfaction?” Social Forces 1989 68 1 100 123

FeaginJ. R. “Prejudice and religious types: a focused study of Southern fundamentalists” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 1964 4 1 3 13

GlockC. Y.StarkR. Religion and society in tension 1965 Chicago Rand McNally

GowersS. G.NorthC. D.ByrumV.WeaverA. B. “Life event precipitants of adolescent anorexia nervosa” Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 1996 37 4 469 477

KimmerlingB. Immigrants settlers natives: the Israeli state and society between culture pluralism and cultural wars 2004 Tel-Aviv Am Oved (Hebrew)

LenskiG. The religious factor: a sociological study of religion’s impact on politics 1961 Garden City, NY Doubleday

LevyS.LevinsohnH.KatzE. RebhunU.WaxmanC. I. “The many faces of Jewishness in Israel” Jews in Israel: contemporary social and cultural patterns 2004 Hanover & London Brandeis University Press / University Press of New England 265 284

LupferM. B.PaolaS. J. D.BrockK. F.ClementL. “Making secular and religious attributions: the availability hypothesis revisited” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 1994 33 2 162 171

RossiP. H.AndersonA. B. RossiP. H.NockS. L. The factorial-survey approach: an introduction Measuring social judgments: the factorial survey approach 1982 Beverly Hills & London Sage 15 67

RossiP. H.NockS. L. Measuring social judgments: the factorial survey approach 1982 Beverly Hills & London Sage

SagiA. SagiA.IlanN. “A critique of the Jewish identity discourse” Jewish culture in the eye of the storm: a jubilee book in honor of Yosef Ahituv 2002 Tel Aviv & Ein Tsurim Hakibbutz Hameuhad and Jacob Herzog Center 248 294 (Hebrew)

TirriK.QuinnB. “Exploring the role of religion and spirituality in the development of purpose: case studies of purposeful youth” British Journal of Religious Education 2010 32 3 201 214

WilsonW. C. “Extrinsic religious values and prejudice” Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology 1960 60 2 286 288

WulffD. M. Psychology of religion: classic and contemporary views 1997 2nd ed. New York Wiley & Sons.

ZiebertzH.-G. ZiebertzH.-G.BucherA.FrancisL.KruggelerM. “Change in religion — problem and challenge” Religious individualization and Christian religious semantics 2001a Berlin Lit Verlag 7 8

ZiebertzH.-G. ZiebertzH.-G.BucherA.FrancisL.KruggelerM. “Religiosity and modernity” Religious individualization and Christian religious semantics Berlin Lit Verlag 9 48

ZiebertzH.-G. Religious education in a plural Western society: problems and challenges 2003 Münster Lit Verlag

Figures

  • View in gallery
    A religious-secular typological model
  • View in gallery
    Respondents’ empathy with vignette types (N=100)
  • View in gallery
    Respondents’ acceptance of vignette types (N=100)
  • View in gallery
    Average rank sums of (nine) heritability parameters according to respondents’ (five) religious/secular types (N=100)
  • View in gallery
    Average rank sums of (seven) conceptuality parameters according to respondents’ (five) religious/secular types (n=100)

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 22 22 9
Full Text Views 38 38 20
PDF Downloads 5 5 0
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0