The Psychological Temperament of Anglican Clergy in Ordained Local Ministry (OLM): The Conserving, Serving Pastor?

in Journal of Empirical Theology
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Abstract

This study draws on psychological type theory as originally proposed by Jung (1971) and psychological temperament theory as proposed by Keirsey and Bates (1978) to explore the hypothesis that ordained local ministers (OLMs) within the Church of England reflect a psychological profile more in keeping with the profile of Church of England congregations than with the profile of established professional mobile clergy serving in the Church of England. Data provided by 135 individuals recently ordained as OLMs (79 women and 56 men) supported the hypothesis. Compared with established professional mobile clergy there is a higher proportion of the Epimethean Temperament (SJ) among OLMs. Oswald and Kroeger (1988) characterise SJ religious leaders as ‘the conserving, serving pastor’. The implications of these findings are discussed for the evolving ministry of the Church of England.

The Psychological Temperament of Anglican Clergy in Ordained Local Ministry (OLM): The Conserving, Serving Pastor?

in Journal of Empirical Theology

Sections

References

BigelowE. D.FitzgeraldR.BuskP.GiraultE.AvisJ. Psychological characteristics of Catholic sisters: relationships between the MBTI and other measures Journal of Psychological Type 1988 14 32 36

BurtonL.FrancisL. J.RobbinsM. Psychological type profile of Methodist circuit minister in Britain: similarities with and differences from Anglican clergy Journal of Empirical Theology 2010 23 64 81

CabralG. Psychological types in a Catholic convent: applications to community living and congregational data Journal of Psychological Type 1984 8 16 22

CraigC L.DuncanB.FrancisL.J. Psychological type preferences of Roman Catholic priests in the United Kingdom Journal of Beliefs and Values 2006 27 157 164

CraigC. L.FrancisL. J.BaileyJ.RobbinsM. Psychological types in Church in Wales congregations The Psychologist in Wales 2003 15 18 21

CraigC.FrancisL. J.RobbinsM. Psychological type and sex differences among church leaders in the United Kingdom Journal of Beliefs and Values 2004 25 3 13

CraigC. L.HorsfallT.FrancisL. J. Psychological types of male missionary personnel training in England: A role for thinking type men? Pastoral Psychology 2005 53 475 482

Delis-BulhoesV. Jungian psychological types and Christian belief in active church members Journal of Psychological Type 1990 20 25 33

FrancisL. J.ButlerA.JonesS. H.CraigC. L. Type patterns among active members of the Anglican church: a perspective from England Mental Health Religion and Culture 2007 10 435 443

FrancisL.J.CraigC.L.ButlerA. Psychological types of male evangelical Anglican seminarians in England Journal of Psychological Type 2007 67 11 17

FrancisL. J.CraigC. L.HallG. Psychological type and attitude toward Celtic Christianity among committed churchgoers in the United Kingdom: An empirical study Journal of Contemporary Religion 2008 23 181 191

FrancisL. J.CraigC. L.HorsfallT.RossC. F. J. Psychological types of male and female evangelical lay church leaders in England, compared with United Kingdom population norms Fieldwork in Religion 2005 1 69 83

FrancisL. J.CraigC. L.WhinneyM.TilleyD.SlaterP. Psychological profiling of Anglican clergy in England: Employing Jungian typology to interpret diversity, strengths, and potential weaknesses in ministry International Journal of Practical Theology 2007 11 266 284

FrancisL. J.DuncanB.CraigC. L.LuffmanG. Type patterns among Anglican congregations in England Journal of Adult Theological Education 2004 1 66 77

FrancisL. J.GubbS.RobbinsM. Psychological type profile of Lead Elders within the Newfrontiers network of churches in the United Kingdom Journal of Beliefs and Values 2009 30 61 69

FrancisL. J.HancocksG.SwiftC.RobbinsM. Distinctive call, distinctive profile: The psychological type profile of Church of England full-time hospital chaplains Practical Theology 2009 2 269 284

FrancisL. J.HolmesP. Ordained Local Ministers: The same Anglican orders, but different psychological temperaments? Rural Theology 2011 9 151 160

FrancisL. J.LittlerK.RobbinsM. Psychological type and Offa’s Dyke: Exploring differences in the psychological type profile of Anglican clergy serving in England and Wales Contemporary Wales 2010 23 240 251

FrancisL. J.NashP.NashS.CraigC.L. Psychology and youth ministry: Psychological type preferences of Christian youth workers in the United Kingdom Journal of Youth Ministry 2007 5 2 73 90

FrancisL. J.PayneV. J. The Payne Index of Ministry Styles (PIMS): Ministry styles and psychological type among male Anglican clergy in Wales Research in the Social Scientific Study of Religion 2002 13 125 141

FrancisL. J.PayneV. J.JonesS. H. Psychological types of male Anglican clergy in Wales Journal of Psychological Type 2001 56 19 23

FrancisL. J.PensonA.W.JonesS. H. Psychological types of male and female Bible College students in England Mental Health Religion and Culture 2001 4 23 32

FrancisL. J.RobbinsM. Psychological types of male evangelical church leaders Journal of Belief and Values 2002 23 217 220

FrancisL. J.RobbinsM.CraigC. L. The psychological type profile of Anglican churchgoers in England: Compatible or incompatible with their clergy? International Journal of Practical Theology 2011 15 243 259

FrancisL. J.RobbinsM.DuncanB.WhinneyM. RuelasB.BriseroV. Confirming the psychological type profile of Anglican clergymen in England: A ministry for intuitives Psychology of Intuition 2010 New York Nova Science 211 219

FrancisL.J.RobbinsM.JonesS. H. The psychological type profile of clergywomen in ordained local ministry in the Church of England: pioneers or custodians?

FrancisL. J.RobbinsM.WhinneyM. Women priests in the Church of England: Psychological type profile Religions. 2011

FrancisL. J.RobbinsM.WilliamsA.WilliamsR. All types are called, but some are more likely to respond: The psychological profile of rural Anglican churchgoers in Wales Rural Theology 2007 5 23 30

FrancisL. J.WhinneyM.BurtonL.RobbinsM. Psychological type preferences of male and female Free Church Ministers in England Research in the Social Scientific Study of Religion 2011 22 251 263

GerhardtR. Liberal religion and personality type Research in Psychological Type 1983 6 47 53

GreenfieldM. Typologies of persisting and non-persisting Jewish clergymen Journal of Counselling Psychology 1969 16 368 372

HarbaughG. L. The person in ministry: Psychological type and the seminary Journal of Psychological Type 1984 8 23 32

HolsworthT. E. Type preferences among Roman Catholic seminarians Journal of Psychological Type 1984 8 33 35

IrvineA. R. Isolation and the parish ministry 1989 University of St Andrews Unpublished doctoral dissertation

JonesS. H.VillageA.FrancisL. J. Assessing the impact of Ordained Local Ministry on the performance of Church of England dioceses, 1991-2003 Practical Theology 2011 4 213 225

JungC. G. Psychological types: The collected works volume 6 1971 London Routledge and Kegan Paul

KayW. K.FrancisL. J. Psychological type preferences of female Bible College students in England Journal of Beliefs and Values 2008 29 101 105

KayW. K.FrancisL. J.CraigC. L. Psychological type preferences of male British Assemblies of God Bible College students: Tough minded or tender hearted? Journal of the European Pentecostal Theological Association 2008 28 6 20

KeirseyD.BatesM. Please understand me 1978 Del Mar, California Prometheus Nemesis

MacdaidG. P.McCaulleyM. H.KainzR. I. Myers-Briggs type indicator: Atlas of type tables 1986 Gainesville, Florida Centre for Application of Psychological Type Inc.

MyersI. B.McCaulleyM. H. Manual: A guide to the development and use of the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator 1985 Palo Alto, California Consulting Psychologists Press

OswaldR. M.KroegerO. Personality type and religious leadership 1988 Washington, DC The Alban Institute

RehakM. C. Identifying the congregation’s corporate personality Journal of Psychological Type 1998 44 39 44

RobertsT. Partners and Ministers 1972 London Falcon Books

RobertsT. TorryM.HeskinsJ. A novelty, or back to basics? The Bethnal Green and Bermondsey experiments Ordained Local Ministry: A new shape for ministry in the Church of England 2006 Norwich Canterbury Press 11 17

RobbinsM.FrancisL. J. All are called, but some psychological types are more likely to respond: Profiling churchgoers in Australia Research in the Social Scientific Study of Religion 2011 22 213 229

RossC. F. J. Type patterns among active members of the Anglican church: comparisons with Catholics, Evangelicals and clergy Journal of Psychological Type 1993 26 28 35

RossC. F. J. Type patterns among Catholics: four Anglophone congregations compared with Protestants, Francophone Catholics and priests Journal of Psychological Type 1995 33 33 41

VillageA. Gifts differing? Psychological type among stipendiary and non-stipendiary clergy Research in the Social Scientific Study of Religion 2011 22 230 250

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 57 57 4
Full Text Views 6 6 6
PDF Downloads 1 1 1
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0