‘Silent Citizenship Educators’ in Dutch Catholic Schools: Exploring Teachers’ Moral Beliefs About Citizenship in Relation to Their Conduct of Citizenship Education

in Journal of Empirical Theology
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Abstract

In this article we adopt a virtue ethical approach to study teachers’ moral beliefs about citizenship and their relation to two kinds of teacher behaviour in citizenship education: (1) teachers’ modelling behaviour, and (2) the way they arrange moral classroom discussions. We believe that a virtue ethical approach would appeal especially to religious schools, which is why we conducted our study in Catholic primary schools. Two hunderd and three teachers at 20 Catholic schools were involved. Teachers’ beliefs and behaviours were defined and operationalised from a community-centred perspective, because we expected that perspective to fit the context of a Catholic school. We found that these teachers indeed hold community-centred views on citizenship, the more so if they frequently attend church. Another important finding is that teachers do not necessarily show and share their beliefs about citizenship with their students. From a virtue ethical point of view, however, they should not be afraid to do so. As moral educators, especially in a religious school, teachers are allowed, even obliged, to name, explain and defend their beliefs and values.

‘Silent Citizenship Educators’ in Dutch Catholic Schools: Exploring Teachers’ Moral Beliefs About Citizenship in Relation to Their Conduct of Citizenship Education

in Journal of Empirical Theology

Sections

References

  • AlthofW.BerkowitzM. W. Moral education and character education: their relation and roles in citizenship education Journal of Moral Education 2006 35 4 495 518

  • BolhuisS. Naar zelfstandig leren: wat doen en denken docenten? Towards independent learning: what do teachers do and what do they think? 2000 Leuven / Apeldoorn Garant

  • BruceS. Secularization: in defence of an unfashionable theory 2011 Oxford University Press

  • CampbellE. Moral lessons: the ethical role of teachers Educational Research and Evaluation 2003 9 1 25 50

  • CarrD. On the contribution of literature and the arts to the educational cultivation of moral virtue, feeling and emotion Journal of Moral Education 2005 34 2 137 151

  • CarrD. The moral roots of citizenship: reconciling principle and character in citizenship education Journal of Moral Education 2006 35 4 443 456

  • ClarkC.M.PetersonL.P. WittrockM.C. Teachers’ thought processes Handbook of research on teaching 1986 3rd edition New York MacMillan 255 296

  • DekkerP. DekkerP.de HartJ. Goed burgerschap in enquêtes Good citizenship in questionnaires De goede burger: tien beschouwingen over een morele categorie The good citizen. Ten considerations on a moral category 2005 The Hague Sociaal en Cultureel Planbureau

  • DijkstraA.B. MiedemaS.Bertram-TroostG. Onderwijs en integratie Education and integration Levensbeschouwelijk leren samenleven. Opvoeding identiteit en ontmoeting Learning to live together ideologically. Education identity and encounter 2006 Zoetermeer Meinema 141 153

  • FallonaC. Manner in teaching: a study in observing and interpreting teachers’moral virtues Teaching and Teacher Education 2000 16 681 695

  • FenstermacherG.D. On the concept of manner and its visibility in teacher practice Journal of Curriculum Studies 2001 33 6 639 653

  • GatesB.E. Religion as cuckoo or crucible: beliefs and believing as vital for citizenship and citizenship education Journal of Moral Education 2006 35 4 571 594

  • Inspectie van het Onderwijs [Dutch educational inspectorate] Burgerschap en integratie Citizenship and integration De staat van het onderwijs: onderwijsverslag 2008/2009 The state of education: educational report 2008/2009 2010 Utrecht Inspectie van het Onderwijs 272 289

  • KelchtermansG. Who I am in how I teach is the message: self-understanding, vulnerability and reflection Teachers and Teaching: theory and practice 2009 15 2 257 272

  • KristjánssonK. Emulation and the use of role models in moral education Journal of Moral Education 2006 35 1 37 39

  • OpdenakkerM.DammeJ. van Teacher characteristics and teaching styles as effectiveness enhancing factors of classroom practice Teaching and Teacher Education 2006 22 1 21

  • OsguthorpeR.D. On the reasons we want teachers of good disposition and moral character Journal of Teacher Education 2008 59 4 288 299

  • PukaB. LeicesterM.ModgilC.ModgilS. Inclusive moral education: a critique and integration of competing approaches Education culture and values. Moral education and pluralism 2000 Volume IV London / New York Falmer Press 131 148

  • ReidyD.A. Education for citizenship in a pluralistic liberal democracy The Journal of Value Inquiry 1996 30 25 42

  • RichardsonV.FallonaC. Classroom management as method and manner Journal of Curriculum Studies 2001 33 6 705 728

  • SangerM.G. Talking to teachers and looking at practice in understanding the moral dimensions of teaching Journal of Curriculum Studies 2001 33 6 683 704

  • SchulzW.AinlyJ.FraillonJ.KerrD.LositoB. Initial findings from the IEA International Civic and Citizenship Education Study 2010 Amsterdam IEA

  • SchwartzM. The modelling of moral character for teachers: behaviors, characteristics, and dispositions that may be taught Journal of Research in Character Education 2007 5 1 1 28

  • ShermanN. CarrDSteutelJ Character development and Aristotelian virtue Virtue ethics and moral education 1999 London/New York Routledge 35 38

  • SprodT. Philosophical discussion in moral education: the community of ethical inquiry 2001 London/New York Routledge

  • SteutelJ.CarrD. CarrD.SteutelJ. The virtue approach to moral education: pointers, problems and prospects Virtue ethics and moral education 1999 London/New York Routledge 241 255

  • TongerenP. van Deugdelijk leven: een inleiding in de deugdethiek Living virtuously: an introduction to virtue ethics 2003 Amsterdam SUN

  • VenJ.A. van der Formation of the moral self 1998 Grand Rapids Eerdmans

  • WillemsF.DenessenE.HermansC.VermeerP. Citizenship education in religious schools: an analysis of tolerance in Catholic schools from a virtue ethical point of view Journal of Beliefs and Values 2010 31 2 215 229

  • WillemsF.DenessenE.HermansC.VermeerP. Students’ perceptions and teachers’ self-ratings of modelling civic virtues: an explorative empirical study in Dutch primary education Journal of Moral Education 2012 41 1 99 115

  • WillemsF.DenessenE.HermansC.VermeerP. Indicators of the quality of classroom discussions in the realm of citizenship: A virtue ethical approach forthcoming

  • WolffA. deMiedemaS.Bertram-TroostG. Religie, fundamentalisme en burgerschap Religion fundamentalism and citizenship Levensbeschouwelijk leren samenleven. Opvoeding identiteit en ontmoeting Learning to live together ideologically. Education identity and encounter 2006 Zoetermeer Meinema 155 140

Figures

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 35 35 1
Full Text Views 83 83 2
PDF Downloads 9 9 3
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0