Was White Right? Biblical Interpretation, Theological Stance and Environmental Attitudes among a Sample of uk Churchgoers

in Journal of Empirical Theology
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Lynn White’s controversial hypothesis, that Judaeo-Christian belief led to attitudes towards the environment that have spawned an ecological crisis, has received much attention from sociologists of religion, notably in the United States. Surveys of the general population show negative correlations between biblical literalism and environmentalism, but these seem to be due to the particular nature of religion and politics in the usa. This study uses more nuanced measures of biblical interpretation and theological stance to examine the issue among a sample of 537 committed churchgoers from a range of mainly conservative Protestant denominations in the United Kingdom. Literal interpretation of Genesis was directly negatively correlated with concern for the environment, after allowing for indirect effects through dominion and stewardship theologies. The effect of symbolic interpretation was mediated by sacramental understanding of creation and stewardship. Stewardship was a key belief that mediated the effects of symbolic interpretation and theological stance on concern for the environment. Biblical interpretation, dominion and sacramentalism were uncorrelated with willingness to sacrifice to protect the environment, but stewardship was indirectly positively correlated through its effect on environmental concern.

Sections

References

AjzenI. Attitudes, personality and behaviour 2005 Maidenhead McGraw-Hill Education (Open University)

ArbuckleJ.L. IBM SPSS Amos 20 user’s guide 2011 Chicago, Il IBM Corporation

arda View of the Bible. 2013 Accessed on: 14 August 2013. http://www.thearda.com/quickstats/qs_107.asp

BauckhamR. God and the crisis of freedom 2002 Louisville, KY Westminster John Knox Press

BerryR.J. Environmental stewardship: Critical perspectives—past and present 2006 London T & T Clark

BerryT. The dream of the earth 1988 San Francisco, CA Sierra Club Books

Bouma-PredigerS. The greening of theology: The ecological models of Rosemary Radford Ruether, Joseph Sittler and Jurgan Moltmann 1995 Atlanta, GA Scholars Press

BoydH.H. Christianity and the environment in the American public Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 1999 38 1 36 44

ByrneB.M. Structural equation modeling with AMOS: Basic concepts, applications, and programming 2010 New York Routledge

CronbachL.J. Coefficient alpha and the internal structure of tests Psychometrika 1951 16 3 297 334

DunlapR.E. Trends in public opinion toward environmental issues: 1965-1990 Society & Natural Resources 1991 4 3 285 312

DunlapR.E.GallupG.H.GallupA.M. Of gobal concern Environment: Science and Policy for Sustainable Development 1993 35 9 7 39

DunlapR.E.Van LiereK.D.MertigA.G.JonesR.E. New trends in measuring environmental attitudes: Measuring endorsement of the New Ecological Paradigm: A revised nep scale Journal of Social Issues 2000 56 3 425 442

DunlapR.E.VanliereK.D. The New Environmental Paradigm: A proposed measuring instrument and preliminary results Journal of Environmental Education 1978 9 4 10 19

EckbergD.L.BlockerT.J. Varieties of religious involvement and environmental concerns: Testing the Lynn White thesis Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 1989 28 4 509 517

EckbergD.L.BlockerT.J. Christianity, environmentalism, and the theoretical problem of fundamentalism Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 1996 35 4 343 355

FoxM. Original blessing 1983 Santa Fe, NM Bear & Company

FoxM. Creation spirituality: Liberating gifts for the peoples of the earth 1990 New York HarperCollins

FranssonN.GärlingT. Environmental concern: Conceptual definitions, measurement methods, and research findings Journal of Environmental Psychology 1999 19 4 369 382

GreeleyA. Religion and attitudes toward the environment Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 1993 32 1 19 28

GuthJ.L.GreenJ.C.KellstedtL.A.SmidtC.E. Faith and the environment: Religious beliefs and attitudes on environmental policy American Journal of Political Science 1995 39 2 364 382

HageviM. Religiosity and environmental opinion in Sweden and the USA Statsvetenskaplig Tidskrift 2008 110 3 249 274

HandC.M.LiereK.D.V. Religion, mastery-over-nature, and environmental concern Social Forces 1984 63 2 555 570

HarrisonP. BerryR.J. “Having dominion: Genesis and the mastery of nature.” Environmental stewardship: Critical perspectives—past and present 2006 London T & T Clark 17 31

HaughtJ.F. The promise of nature: Ecology and cosmic purpose 1993 New York Paulist Press

HaughtJ.F. GottliebR.S. “Christianity and ecology.” This sacred earth: Religion, nature environment 1996 London Routledge 270 285

HayesB.C.MarangudakisM. Religion and attitudes towards nature in Britain British Journal of Sociology 2001a 52 1 139 155

HayesB.C.MarangudakisM. Religion and environmental issues among Anglo-American democracies Review of Religious Research 2001b 42 2 159 174

HitzhusenG.E. Judeo-Christian theology and the environment: Moving beyond scepticism to new sources for environmental education in the United States Environmental Education Research 2007 13 1 55 74

HuntR.A. Mythological-symbolic religious commitment. The lam scales Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 1972 11 1 42 52

JavorB. WildmannJ. “Religious identities and environmental attitudes in Hungary.” Religions and churches in a common Europe 2012 Bremen EHV

JoransonP.N.ButiganK. Cry of the environment: Rebuilding the Christian creation tradition 1984 Santa Fe, NM Bear & Company

KanagyC.L.NelsenH.M. Religion and environmental concern: Challenging the dominant assumptions Review of Religious Research 1995 37 1 33 45

KanagyC.L.WillitsF.K. A “greening” of religion? Some evidence from a Pennsylvania sample Social Science Quarterly 1993 74 3 674 683

KinsleyD.R. Ecology and religion: Ecological spirituality in cross-cultural perspective 1995 Englewood Cliffs, NJ Prentice Hall

KlineP. The handbook of psychological testing 2000 London & New York Routledge

KollmussA.AgyemanJ. Mind the gap: Why do people act environmentally and what are the barriers to pro-environmental behavior? Environmental Education Research 2002 8 3 239 260

KvaløyB.FinseraasH.ListhaugO. The publics’ concern for global warming: A cross-national study of 47 countries Journal of Peace Research 2012 49 1 11 22

LomanS.E.FrancisL.J. The Loman Index of biblical interpretation: Distinguishing between literal, symbolic and rejecting modes among 11 to 14 year olds British Journal of Religious Education 2006 28 2 131 140

McAndrewS. ParkA.CurticeJ.ThomsonK.PhillipsM.CleryE.ButtS. “Religious faith and contemporary attitudes.” British social attitudes: The 26th report 2010 London SAGE Publications 87 112

MitchellR.C.CarsonR.T. Using surveys to value public goods: The contingent valuation method 1989 Washington DC Resources for the Future

NorthcottM.S. The evolution of green Christianity Journal for the Study of Religion, Nature and Culture 2011 5 3 354 363

PalmerC. BallI.GoodallM.PalmerC.ReaderJ. “Stewardship: A case study in environmental ethics.” The earth beneath: A critical guide to green theology 1992 London SPCK 67 86

PoythressN.G. Literal, antiliteral, and mythological religious orientations Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 1975 14 3 271 284

ReutherR.R. “Ecofeminism: the challenge to theology.” Christianity and ecology 2000 Cambridge, Mass Harvard University Press 97 112

SchultzP.W.ZeleznyL.DalrympleN.J. A multinational perspective on the relation between Judeo-Christian religious beliefs and attitudes of environmental concern Environment and Behavior 2000 32 4 576 591

ShaikoR.G. Religion, politics, and environmental concern: A powerful mix of passions Social Science Quarterly 1987 68 2 244 262

SherkatD.E.EllisonC.G. Structuring the religion-environment connection: Identifying religious influences on environmental concern and activism Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 2007 46 1 71 85

TaylorE. ParkA.CleryE.CurticeJ.PhillipsM.UttingD. “Concern about climate change: A paler shade of green?” British social attitudes 28 2012 London SAGE

ThompsonS.C.G.BartonM.A. Ecocentric and anthropocentric attitudes toward the environment Journal of Environmental Psychology 1994 14 2 149 157

van der LansJ. Interpretation of religious language and cognitive style: A pilot study with the lam-scale The International Journal for the Psychology of Religion 1990 1 2 107 23

VillageA. The relationship of psychological type to interpretations of Genesis among churchgoers in England Psychology of Religion and Spirituality 2014 6 1 72 82

WCC Justice, diakonia and responsibility for creation 2013 Accessed on: 8 August 2013 http://www.oikoumene.org/en/what-we-do/justice-diakonia-and-responsibility-for-creation

WhiteL.Jr. The historical roots of our ecologic crisis Science 1967 155 3767 1203 1207

WolkomirM.FutrealM.WoodrumE.HobanT. Denominational subcultures of environmentalism Review of Religious Research 1997a 38 4 325 343

WolkomirM.FutrealM.WoodrumE.HobanT. Substantive religious belief and environmentalism Social Science Quarterly 1997b 78 1 96 108

WoodrumE.HobanT. Theology and religiosity effects on environmentalism Review of Religious Research 1994 35 3 193 206

WoodrumE.WolkomirM.J. Religious effects on environmentalism Sociological Spectrum 1997 17 2 223 234

Figures

  • Conceptualisation of the relationships of interpretation, theological stance and environmentalism
    View in gallery
  • Path diagram with standardised regression coefficients
    View in gallery

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 101 101 2
Full Text Views 4 4 4
PDF Downloads 2 2 2
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0