The Papal Bulls Dividing the Americas between Spain and Portugal: A Reappraisal
In: Journal of the History of International Law / Revue d'histoire du droit internationalSearch for other papers by Kent McNeil in
Current site
Google Scholar
Abstract
The papacy recently repudiated the doctrine of discovery that was relied upon by European nations when they colonized lands inhabited by Indigenous peoples. However, the Vatican did not repeal the papal bulls that authorized and provided canon law support for colonization of West Africa and the Americas by Portugal and Spain. This article examines these bulls and questions the Pope’s legal authority to issue them. It contends that the bulls bound only the Christian monarchs who accepted the Pope’s authority in this regard. They had no legal force insofar as the Indigenous peoples were concerned. Moreover, the historical record reveals that other colonizing European powers, such as France and England, rejected the validity of the bulls. In fact, Spain and Portugal acquired their overseas empires in the fifteen and sixteenth centuries, not by means of discovery or papal bulls, but by subduing Indigenous peoples and forcibly occupying their territories.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Alexandrowicz, Charles H. ‘Paulus Vladimiri and the Doctrine of the Coexistence of Christian and Non-Christian Countries’. British Yearbook of International Law 39 (1963), 441–448.
-
Bairoch de Sainte-Marie, Alice. ‘Les colonies françaises et le droit: Une approche globale, 1600–1750’. Études canadiennes 82 (2017), 87–119.
-
Baldwin, John W. The Government of Philip Augustus: Foundations of French Royal Power in the Middle Ages (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1986).
-
Batllori, Miguel. ‘The Papal Division of the World and Its Consequences’, in First Images of America: The Impact of the New World on the Old, ed. Fredi Chiappelli (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1976), 211–220.
-
Batson, Alexander. ‘Acquisitive Prescription in Early Modern International Law’. Journal of the History of International Law 24(4) (2022), 469–499.
-
Bellito, Christopher M. The General Councils: A History of the Twenty-One Church Councils from Nicea to Vatican II (New York: Paulist Press, 2002).
-
Biggar, H. P., ed. The Precursors of Cartier 1497–1534: A Collection of Documents relating to the Early History of the Dominion of Canada (Ottawa: Government Printing Bureau 1911), available at: https://www.heritage.nf.ca/articles/exploration/1496-cabot-patent.php (last accessed on 9 October 2024).
-
Biggar, H. P., ed. The Voyages of Jacques Cartier (Ottawa: Public Archives of Canada, 1924).
-
Biggar, H. P., ed. A Collection of Documents relating to Jacques Cartier and the Sieur de Roberval (Ottawa: Public Archives of Canada, 1930).
-
Blumenthal, Uta-Renate. The Investiture Controversy: Church and Monarchy from the Ninth to the Twelfth Century (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1988).
-
Borrows, John. ‘Sovereignty’s Alchemy: An Analysis of Delgamuukw v. British Columbia’. Osgoode Hall Law Journal 37(3) (1999), 537–596.
-
Borrows, John. Canada’s Indigenous Constitution (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2010).
-
Brooke, Z. N. ‘Pope Gregory VII’s Demand for Fealty from William the Conqueror’. English Historical Review 26(102) (1911), 225–238.
-
Brundage, James A. Medieval Canon Law and the Crusader (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1969).
-
Camden, William. The History of the Most Renowned and Victorious Princess Elizabeth, Late Queen of England (London: Printed by M. Flesher for R. Bentley, 4th ed. 1688 [1625]).
-
Castro, Daniel. Another Face of Empire: Bartolomé de las Casas, Indigenous Rights, and Ecclesiastical Imperialism (Durham: Duke University Press, 2007).
-
Coben, Lawrence A. ‘The Events that Led to the Treaty of Tordesillas’. Terrae Incognitae 47(2) (2015), 142–162.
-
Davenport, Frances Gardener. European Treaties bearing on the History of the United States and Its Dependencies (Washington, DC: Carnegie Institution of Washington, 1917).
-
Diffie, Bailey W. and George D. Winius. Foundations of the Portuguese Empire, 1415–1580 (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1977).
-
Disney, Anthony R. A History of Portugal and the Portuguese Empire, vol. 2 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009).
-
Ehrlich, Ludwik. Pisma wybrane Pawla Wlodkowica. Works of Paul Wladimiri: A Selection (Warszawa: Pax, 1968).
-
Fernández, Manuel Giménez. ‘Las Bulas Alejandrinas de 1493 Referentes a las Indias’. Anuario de estudios americanos 1 (1944), 171–430.
-
First Virginia Charter (Ipswich: Great Neck Publishing, 2017).
-
Folmer, Henry, Franco-Spanish Rivalry in North America, 1524–1763 (Glendale: Arthur H. Clark Co., 1953).
-
Gail, Marzieh. The Three Popes: An Account of the Great Schism when Rival Popes in Rome, Avignon, and Pisa Vied for the Rule of Christendom (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1969).
-
Gierke, Otto, Political Theories of the Middle Age (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1900).
-
Giry, A. Manuel de Diplomatique (Paris: Librairie Hachette, 1894).
-
Grotius, Hugo. De Jure Belli ac Pacis Libri Tres (1625), translated by Frank W. Kelsey (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1925).
-
Gwatkin, Henry Melvill. Church and State in England to the Death of Queen Anne (London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1917).
-
Higgins, A. Pearce. ‘International Law and the Outer World, 1450–1648’, in The Old Empire: From Beginnings to 1783, eds. J. Holland Rose, A. P. Newton and A. E. Benians (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1960), I, 183–206.
-
Hudson’s Bay Company. Charters, Statutes, Orders in Council, &c, Relating to the Hudson’s Bay Company (London: Hudson’s Bay Company, 1931).
-
Innocent IV, In quinque libros decretalium (Venice, 1578), in Commentaria doctissima in Quinque libros Decretalium (Turin: Apud haeredes Nicolae Beuilaquae, 1581).
-
Joint Statement of the Dicasteries for Culture and Education and for Promoting Integral Human Development on the ‘Doctrine of Discovery’ (30 March 2023), available at: https://press.vatican.va/content/salastampa/en/bollettino/pubblico/2023/03/30/230330b.html (last accessed on 9 October 2024).
-
Jotischky, Andrew. Crusading and the Crusader States (Harlow: Pearson Education Limited, 2004).
-
Kamen, Henry. How Spain Became a World Power, 1492–1763 (New York: Harper Collins, 2003).
-
Koskenniemi, Martti. To the Uttermost Parts of the Earth: Legal Imagination and International Power, 1300–1870 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2021).
-
La Chapelle, Baron de, ‘Jean Le Veneur et le Canada’. Nova Francia 6 (1931), 340.
-
La Roncière, Charles de. Histoire de la marine française, vol. 3 (Paris: Plon-Nourrit, 2nd ed. 1923).
-
La Roncière, Charles de. Jacques Cartier et la découverte de la Nouvelle-France (Paris: Librairie Plon, 1931).
-
Las Casas, Bartolomé de. Brevísima relación de la destrucción de las Indias, written 1532, published 1539, translation by Nigel Griffin, A Short Account of the Destruction of the Indies (London: Penguin Classics, 1992).
-
Lecler, Joseph. ‘La donation d’Alexandre VI: Le premier partage du monde’. Études: Revue catholique d’intérét général 237 (1938), 5–16, 195–208.
-
Lescarbot, Marc. The History of New France, translation of 3rd edn (1614) by W. I. Grant and H. P. Biggar (Toronto: Champlain Society, 1907).
-
Madigan, Kevin. Medieval Christianity: A New History (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2015).
-
Manhart, George Born. ‘The English Search for a Northwest Passage in the Time of Queen Elizabeth’, in Studies in English Commerce and Exploration in the Reign of Elizabeth (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1924).
-
Mathieu, Jacques. ‘L’héritage d’Adam 1000–1600’, in Histoire du Québec, ed. Jean Hamelin (St-Hyacinthe QC: Edisem, 1976), 59–88.
-
Mattingly, Garrett. ‘No Peace beyond What Line?’. Transactions of the Royal Historical Society 13 (1963), 145–162.
-
Maulde-la-Clavière, René de. La Diplomatie au Temps de Machiavel (Paris: Ernest Leroux, 1892).
-
McEwan, Gordon F. The Incas, New Perspectives (New York: W. W. Norton, 2006).
-
McHugh, Paul. Aboriginal Societies and the Common Law: A History of Sovereignty, Status, and Self-Determination (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2004).
-
McNeil, Kent. ‘The Doctrine of Discovery Reconsidered’. Osgoode Hall Law Journal 53(2) (2016), 699–728.
-
McNeil, Kent. ‘Sovereignty and Indigenous Peoples in North America’. University of California Davis Journal of International Law and Policy 22 (2016) 81–104.
-
McNeil, Kent. ‘An Overview of Political Authority in Medieval Europe: Empire, Papacy, and the Rights of Infidels’. History of Political Thought 41(2) (2020) 221–247.
-
McNeil, Kent. ‘L’émergence d’une monarchie française indépendante, 1100–1314: Le rejet de la suprématie papale’ (October 2020), available at: https://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/scholarly_works/2834/ (last accessed on 9 October 2024).
-
Miller, Robert J., Jacinta Ruru, Larissa Behrendt and Tracey Lindberg. Discovering Indigenous Lands: The Doctrine of Discovery in the English Colonies (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2010).
-
Miller, Robert J. ‘The Vatican Repudiates the International Law of Colonialism – Maybe?’, available at: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4437242 (last accessed on 9 October 2024).
-
Miller, Robert J., Lisa LeSage and Sebastián López Escarcena. ‘The International Law of Discovery, Indigenous Peoples, and Chile’. Nebraska Law Review 89(4) (2011) 819–884.
-
Miller, Robert J. and Micheline D’Angelis. ‘Brazil, Indigenous Peoples, and the International Law of Discovery’. Brooklyn Journal of International Law 37(1) (2011) 1–63.
-
Morrall, John B. Political Thought in Medieval Times (London: Hutchinson & Co., 1958, reprinted New York: Harper & Brothers, 1962).
-
Morrison, Karl Frederick, ed. The Investiture Controversy: Issues, Ideals, and Results (New York: Robert E. Krieger, 1978).
-
Muldoon, James, ed. The Expansion of Europe: The First Phase (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1977).
-
Muldoon, James. ‘Papal Responsibility for the Infidel: Another Look at Alexander VI’s Inter Caetera’. Catholic Historical Review 64(2) (1978) 168–184.
-
Muldoon, James. Popes, Lawyers, and Infidels: The Church and the Non-Christian World, 1250–1550 (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1979).
-
Navarette, D. Martin. Colecciónes de los viajes y descubrimientos que hicieron por mar los españoles (Madrid: La Imprenta National, 1837).
-
Newitt, Malyn. A History of Portuguese Overseas Expansion, 1400–1668 (Abingdon: Routledge, 2005).
-
Newton, A. P. ‘The Beginnings of English Colonization, 1569–1618’, in The Cambridge History of the British Empire, eds. J. Holland Rose, A. P. Newton and E. A. Benians (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1929), 55–92.
-
Nichols, Joshua Ben David. A Reconciliation without Recollection? An Investigation into the Foundations of Aboriginal Law (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2020).
-
Nowell, Charles E. ‘The Treaty of Tordesillas and the Diplomatic Background of American History’, in Greater America: Essays in Honor of Herbert Eugene Bolton (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1945), 1–18.
-
Nys, Ernest. Études de droit international et de droit politique (Bruxelles: Alfred Castaigne, 1896).
-
Pagden, Anthony. Lords of All the World: Ideologies of Empire in Spain, Britain and France, c.1500–c.1800 (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1995).
-
Pennington, Kenneth. The Prince and the Law, 1200–1600: Sovereignty and Rights in the Western Legal Tradition (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1993).
-
Probasco, Nathan J. Sir Humphrey Gilbert and the Elizabethan Expedition: Preparing for a Voyage (London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2020).
-
Quinn, David Beers, ed. The Roanoke Voyages, 1584–1590 (Abingdon: Routledge, 2016).
-
Report of the Committee appointed by the Council of Constance, Acta concilii constanciensis, ed. Heinrich Finke (Münster: Regensbergsche Buchhandlung, 1886–1928).
-
Robinson, Ian S. Authority and Resistance in the Investiture Contest: The Polemical Literature of the Late Eleventh Century (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1978).
-
Rose, J. Holland, ‘Sea Power, Part I: The Spirit of Adventure’, in The Cambridge History of the British Empire, vol. 1, eds. J. Holland Rose, A. P. Newton and E. A. Benians (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1929), 93–114.
-
Rubin, Alfred P. ‘International Law in the Age of Columbus’. Netherlands International Law Review 39(1) (1992), 5–35.
-
Russell, Frederick. The Just War in the Middle Ages (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1975).
-
Russell, Frederick. ‘Paulus Vladimiri’s Attack on the Just War: A Case Study in Legal Polemics’, in Authority and Power: Studies on Medieval Law and Government Presented to Walter Ullmann on His Seventieth Birthday, eds. Brian Tierney and Peter Linehan (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1980), 237–254.
-
Savelle, Max. The Origins of American Diplomacy: The International History of Angloamerica, 1492–1763 (New York: Macmillan, 1967).
-
Scott, William Henry. ‘Demythologizing the Papal Bull “Inter Caetera”’. Philippine Studies 35(3) (1987), 348–356.
-
Slattery, Brian. ‘French Claims in North America, 1500–59’. Canadian Historical Review 59(2) (1978), 139–169.
-
Smith, John Holland. The Great Schism 1378 (London: Hamish Hamilton, 1970).
-
Thomas, David Hurst. ‘The World as It Was’, in The Native Americans: An Illustrated History, eds. Betty Ballantine and Ian Ballantine (Atlanta: Turner Publishing Inc., 1993), 23–109.
-
Thomson, John A. F. Popes and Princes, 1417–1517: Politics and Polity in the Late Medieval Church (London: George Allen & Unwin, 1980).
-
Trudel, Marcel. Histoire de la Nouvelle-France, Les Vaines Tentatives 1524–1603 (Paris: Fides, 1963).
-
Ullmann, Walter. The Growth of Papal Government in the Middle Ages: A Study in the Ideological Relation of Clerical to Lay Power (London: Methuen & Co., 3rd ed. 1970).
-
Vander Linden, Herman. ‘Alexander VI and the Demarcation of the Maritime and Colonial Domains of Spain and Portugal, 1493–1494’. American Historical Review 22(1) (1916), 1–20.
-
Vattel, Emer de. The Law of Nations Or, Principles of the Law of Nature, Applied to the Conduct and Affairs of Nations and Sovereigns (1758), new ed. translated and edited by Joseph Chitty (London: Sweet & Sons, 1834).
-
Vitoria, Francisco de. De indis noviter inventis (1539), translated by John Pawley Bate, in Scott, James Brown, The Spanish Origins of International Law: Francisco de Vitoria and His Law of Nations (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1934), app. A.
-
Vladimiri, Paulus, Opinio Hostiensis, in Paulus Vladimiri and his Doctrine Concerning International Law and Politics, ed. Stanislaus F. Belch (The Hague: Mouton, 1965).
-
Wakelyn, Jon L., ed. America’s Founding Charters: Primary Documents of Colonial and Revolutionary Era Governance (Westport: Greenwood Press, 2006).
-
Walsh, Walter. England’s Fight with the Papacy: A Political History (London: James Nisbet & Co., 1912).
-
Wheaton, Henry. Elements of International Law, ed. Richard Henry Dana (Boston: Little, Brown, and Company, 8th ed. 1866), reproduction, George Grafton Wilson, ed. (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1936).
-
Williams, Robert A., Jr. The American Indian in Western Legal Thought: The Discourses of Conquest (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1990).
-
Williamson, James A. Maritime Enterprise, 1485–1558 (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1913).
-
Williamson, J. A. ‘England and the Opening of the Atlantic’, in The Cambridge History of the British Empire, eds. J. Holland Rose, A. P. Newton and E. A. Benians (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1929).
-
Wood, Charles T., ed. Philip the Fair and Boniface VIII: State vs. Papacy (New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston, 1967).
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 332 | 332 | 85 |
| Full Text Views | 24 | 24 | 5 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 115 | 115 | 12 |
The Papal Bulls Dividing the Americas between Spain and Portugal: A Reappraisal
In: Journal of the History of International Law / Revue d'histoire du droit internationalSearch for other papers by Kent McNeil in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Abstract
The papacy recently repudiated the doctrine of discovery that was relied upon by European nations when they colonized lands inhabited by Indigenous peoples. However, the Vatican did not repeal the papal bulls that authorized and provided canon law support for colonization of West Africa and the Americas by Portugal and Spain. This article examines these bulls and questions the Pope’s legal authority to issue them. It contends that the bulls bound only the Christian monarchs who accepted the Pope’s authority in this regard. They had no legal force insofar as the Indigenous peoples were concerned. Moreover, the historical record reveals that other colonizing European powers, such as France and England, rejected the validity of the bulls. In fact, Spain and Portugal acquired their overseas empires in the fifteen and sixteenth centuries, not by means of discovery or papal bulls, but by subduing Indigenous peoples and forcibly occupying their territories.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 332 | 332 | 85 |
| Full Text Views | 24 | 24 | 5 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 115 | 115 | 12 |