Distributive Justice and Distributed Obligations

in Journal of Moral Philosophy
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


Collectivities can have obligations beyond the aggregate of pre-existing obligations of their members. Certain such collective obligations distribute, i.e., become members’ obligations to do their fair share. In incremental good cases, i.e., those in which a member’s fair share would go part way toward fulfilling the collectivity’s obligation, each member has an unconditional obligation to contribute.

States are involuntary collectivities that bear moral obligations. Certain states, democratic legal states, are collectivities whose obligations can distribute. Many existing states are democratic legal states, but none satisfies more rigorous requirements of distributive justice. There, citizens who hold assets, in excess of what is just, bear a distributed duty to dedicate that excess toward correcting the injustice. It is an incremental good case not conditioned on the conformity of others who are also wealthier than justice allows, nor on the diligence of the state in meeting its obligations.

Distributive Justice and Distributed Obligations

in Journal of Moral Philosophy



Bennett A. (2014) Fair Play in: London Review of Books 36(12) 2930.

Bolton v. Stone [1951] ac 850 [1951] 1 All er 1078.

Buchanan Allen (2013) The Heart of Human RightsOxford.

Cohen G.A. (2000) Political Philosophy and Personal Behavior in: Cohen G.A. If You’re an Egalitarian How Come You’re So Rich? Cambridge ma.

Cohen G.A. (2008) Rescuing Justice and EqualityCambridgema.

Collins S. and Lawford-Smith H. (2016) Collectives’ and Individuals’ Obligations: a Parity Argument, in: Canadian Journal of Philosophy46(1) 3858.

Copp D. (2006) On the Agency of Certain Collective Entities in: Midwest Studies in Philosophy 30194221.

Crawford N.C. (2007) Individual and Collective Moral Responsibility for Systemic Military Atrocity in: Journal of Political Philosophy 15(2) 187212.

Darby D. and Branscombe N.R. (2014) Beyond the Sins of the Fathers: Responsibility for Inequality in: Midwest Studies In Philosophy 3812137.

Edmundson W.A. (2015) Ought We to Do What We Ought to Be Made to Do? in: Pavlakos G. and Rodriguez-Blanco V. eds. Practical Normativity. Essays on Reasons and Intentions in Law and Practical ReasonCambridge.

Fieldhouse A. (2013) A Review of the Economic Research on the Effects of Raising Ordinary Income Tax Rates: Higher Revenue, Unchanged Growth, and Uncertain but Potentially Large Reductions in the Growth of Inequality, in: Economic Policy Institute/The Century Foundation Issue Brief #353.

Gilbert M. (2006) Who’s to Blame? Collective Moral Responsibility and Its Implications for Group Members in: Midwest Studies in Philosophy 3094114.

Goodin R. (1996) The State as a Moral Agent in: Goodin R. Utilitarianism as a Public PhilosophyCambridge.

Held V. (1970) Can a Random Collection of Individuals Be Morally Responsible? in: The Journal of Philosophy 6747181.

Isaacs T. (2011) Collective Moral Responsibility in: Isaacs T. Moral Responsibility in Collective ContextsOxford5270.

Kant I. (1793/1996) Practical Philosophy Gregor M.J. (ed.) Cambridge.

Kutz C. (2001) Complicity: Ethics and Law for a Collective AgeCambridge.

Lawford-Smith H. (2012) The Feasibility of Collectives’ Actions in: Australasian Journal of Philosophy 90(3) 45367.

B. Leiter (2015) Why Marxism Still Does Not Need Normative Theory in: Analyse und Kritik 2015(37) 2350.

List C. (2006) The Discursive Dilemma and Public Reason, in: Ethics 116362402.

C. List and Pettit P. (2011) Group Agency: The Possibility Design and Status of Corporate AgentsOxford.

May L. (1987) The Morality of GroupsSouth Bendin.

Miller D. (2013) Taking up the Slack? Responsibility and Justice in Situations of Partial Compliance in: Miller D. Justice for Earthlings: Essays in Political PhilosophyCambridge20627.

Miller S. (2006) Collective Moral Responsibility: An Individualist Account in: Midwest Studies in Philosophy 3017693.

Murphy L.B. (1998) Institutions and the Demands of Justice in: Philosophy and Public Affairs 2725191.

Nagel T. (1981) Libertarianism without Foundations in: Paul J. (ed.) Reading Nozick Totowah nj.

Parrish J.M. (2009) Collective Responsibility and the State in: International Theory 111954.

Pasternak A. Sharing the Costs of Political Injustices in: Politics Philosophy & Economics 10(2) 188210.

Pettit P. (2007) Responsibility Incorporated in: Ethics 117(2) 171201.

Postema G. (1995) Morality in the First-Person Plural in: Law and Philosophy 143564.

Radzik L. (2001) Collective Responsibility and Duties to Respond in: Social Theory and Practice 27(3) 45571.

Rawls J. (1999a) A Theory of Justice Cambridge ma.

Rawls J. (1999b) The Law of PeoplesCambridgema.

Rawls J. (2001) Justice as Fairness: a RestatementCambridgema.

Sen A. (2011) The Idea of Justice Cambridge ma.

Shafer-Landau R. (1994) Vegetarianism, Causation, and Ethical Theory in: Public Affairs Quarterly 885100.

Shockley K. (2007) Programming Collective Control in: Journal of Social Philosophy 38(3) 44255.

Smilansky S. (2007) The Paradox of Beneficial Retirement in: Smilansky S. Ten Moral ParadoxesOxford.

Smiley M. (2010–11) From Moral Agency to Collective Wrongs: Re-thinking Collective Moral Responsibility in: Journal of Law and Policy 19171202.

Stilz A. (2011) Collective Responsibility and the State in: Journal of Political Philosophy 19190208.

Williams A. (1998) Incentives, Inequality, and Publicity in: Philosophy and Public Affairs 27(3) 22547.

Young I.M. (2011) Responsibility for JusticeOxford.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 68 68 22
Full Text Views 21 21 19
PDF Downloads 6 6 6
EPUB Downloads 2 2 2