Supernatural Beliefs, Unconscious Threat and Judgment Bias in Tibetan Buddhists

in Journal of Cognition and Culture
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Individuals who have been subtly reminded of death display heightened in-group favoritism, or “worldview defense.” Terror management theory argues (i) that death cues engender worldview defense via psychological mechanisms specifically evolved to suppress death anxiety, and (ii) that the core function of religiosity is to suppress death anxiety. Thus, terror management theory predicts that extremely religious individuals will not evince worldview defense. Here, two studies are presented in support of an alternative perspective. According to the unconscious vigilance hypothesis, subtly processed threats (which need not pertain to death) heighten sensitivity to affectively valenced stimuli (which need not pertain to cultural attitudes). From this perspective, religiosity mitigates the influence of mortality-salience only insofar as afterlife doctrines reduce the perceived threat posed by death. Tibetan Buddhism portrays death as a perilous gateway to rebirth rather than an end to suffering; faith in this doctrine should therefore not be expected to nullify mortality-salience effects. In Study 1, devout Tibetan Buddhists who were subtly reminded of death produced exaggerated aesthetic ratings unrelated to cultural worldviews. In Study 2, devout Tibetan Buddhists produced worldview defense following subliminal exposure to non-death cues of threat. The results demonstrate both the domain-generality of the process underlying worldview defense and the importance of religious doctrinal content in moderating mortality-salience effects.

Supernatural Beliefs, Unconscious Threat and Judgment Bias in Tibetan Buddhists

in Journal of Cognition and Culture



AdolphsR. Fear, faces, and the human amygdala Current Opinion in Neurobiology 2008 18 166 172

AdolphsR.RussellJ. A.TranelD. A role for the human amygdala in recognizing emotional arousal from unpleasant stimuli Psychological Science 1999 10 167 171

AndrewsP. A.GangestadS. W.MatthewsD. Adaptationism – how to carry out an exaptationist program Behavioral and Brain Sciences 2002 25 480 553

ArndtJ.GreenbergJ.PyszczynskiT.SolomonS. Subliminal exposure to death-related stimuli increases defense of the cultural worldview Psychological Science 8 1997a 379 385

ArndtJ.GreenbergJ.SolomonS.PyszczynskiT.SimonL. Suppression, accessibility of death-related thoughts, and cultural worldview defense: Exploring the psychodynamics of terror management Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1997b 73 5 18

ArndtJ.AllenJ. J.GreenbergJ. Traces of terror: Subliminal death primes and facial electromyographic indices of affect Motivation and Emotion 2001 25 253 277

BerridgeK. C. KahnemanD.DienerE.SchwarzN. Pleasure, pain, desire, and dread: Hidden core processes of emotion Well-being: The foundations of hedonic psychology 1999 New York, NY Russell Sage Foundation 525 557

BoyerP. Religion explained: The evolutionary origins of religious thought 2001 New York, NY Basic Books

BoyerP. Religious thought and behaviour as by-products of brain function Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2003 7 119 124

BussD. M.HaseltonM. G.ShackelfordT. K.BleskeA. L.WakefieldJ. C. Adaptations, exaptations, and spandrels American Psychologist 1998 53 533 548

ByrneD. The attraction paradigm 1971 San Diego, CA Academic Press

CoxC. R.GoldenbergJ. L.ArndtJ.PyszczynskiT. Mother’s milk: An existential perspective on negative reactions to breastfeeding Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2007 33 110 122

DarwinC. On the origin of species by means of natural selection or the preservation of favoured races in the struggle for life 1860 2nd edn. London John Murray

DavisM.WhalenP. J. The amygdala: Vigilance and emotion Molecular Psychiatry 2001 6 13 34

DechesneM.JanssenJ.van KnippenbergA. Defense and distancing as terror management strategies: The moderating role of need for structure and permeability of group boundaries Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2000 79 923 932

FinleyR. SurveyMonkey 2008 Portland, OR

FremantleF.TrungpaC. The Tibetan Book of the Dead: The Great Liberation through Hearing in the Bardo 1975 Shambhala, Boulder, CO

GoldenbergJ. L.PyszczynskiT.GreenbergJ.SolomonS.KluckB.CornwellR. I am not an animal: Mortality salience, disgust, and the denial of human creatureliness Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 2001 130 427 435

GoldenbergJ. L.HartJ.PyszczynskiT.WarnicaG. M.LandauM.Thomas L. Terror of the body: Death, neuroticism, and the flight from physical sensation Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2006 32 1264 1277

GossR. E.KlassD. Tibetan Buddhism and the resolution of grief: The Bardo-thodol for the dying and the grieving Death Studies 1997 21 377 395

GouldS. J.VrbaE. S. Exaptation – a missing term in the science of form Paleobiology 1982 8 4 15

GreenbergJ.PyszczynskiT.SolomonS.RosenblattA.VeederM.KirklandS.LyonD. Evidence for terror management II: The effects of mortality salience on reactions to those who threaten or bolster the cultural worldview Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1990 58 308 318

GreenbergJ.SimonL.Harmon-JonesE.SolomonS.PyszczynskiT.ChatelD. Testing alternative explanations for mortality effects: Terror management, value accessibility, or worrisome thoughts? European Journal of Social Psychology 1995 12 417 433

GreenbergJ.SolomonS.PyszczynskiT. Terror management theory of self-esteem and social behavior: Empirical assessments and conceptual refinements Advances in Experimental Social Psychology 1997 29 61 139

HaririA.BookheimerS. Y.MazziottaJ. A neural network for modulating the emotional response to faces Neuroreport 2000 11 43 48

HaririA.TessitoreA.MattayV.FeraF.WeinbergerD. The amygdala response to emotional stimuli: a comparison of faces and scenes Neuroimage 2002 17 317 323

HolbrookC.SousaP.Hahn-HolbrookJ. Unconscious vigilance: Worldview defense without adaptations for terror, coalition, or uncertainty management Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2011 101 451 466

InzlichtM.McGregorI.HirshJ. B.NashK. A. Neural markers of religious conviction Psychological Science 2009 20 385 392

JonasE.FischerP. Terror management and religion – Evidence that intrinsic religiousness mitigates worldview defense following mortality salience Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2006 91 553 567

KasserT.SheldonK. M. Of wealth and death: Materialism, mortality salience, and consumption behavior Psychological Science 2000 11 348 351

KeltnerD.LockeK. D.AudrainP. C. The influence of attributions on the relevance of negative emotions to personal satisfaction Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 1993 19 21 29

KirkR. E. Experimental design: Procedures for the behavioural sciences 1995 3rd edn. Brooks/Cole, Pacific Grove, CA

KirkpatrickL.NavarreteC. D. ‘Reports of my death have been greatly exaggerated’: A critique of terror management theory from an evolutionary perspective Psychological Inquiry 2006 17 288 298

LandauM. J.GreenbergJ.SolomonS.PyszczynskiT.MartensA. Windows into nothingness: Terror management, meaninglessness, and negative reactions to modern art Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2006 90 879 892

LandauM. J.SolomonS.PyszczynskiT.GreenbergJ. On the compatibility of terror management theory and perspectives on human evolution Evolutionary Psychology 2007 5 476 519

LiddellB.BrownK.KempA.BartonM.DasP.PedutoA.GordonE.WilliamsL. A direct brainstem-amygdala-cortical ‘alarm’ system for subliminal signals of fear NeuroImage 2005 24 235 243

LopezD. Prisoners of Shangri-la: Tibetan Buddhism and the West 1998 Chicago, IL University of Chicago Press

MatsumotoD.EkmanP. Japanese and Caucasian Facial Expressions of Emotion (JACFEE) and Neutral Faces (JACNeuF) 1988 San Francisco, 401 Parnassus Avenue, San Francisco, CA Human Interaction Laboratory, University of California [Slides]

McGregorI. Offensive defensiveness: Toward an integrative neuroscience of compensatory zeal after mortality salience, personal uncertainty, and other poignant self-threats Psychological Inquiry 2006 17 299 308

McGregorI.MarigoldD. C. Defensive zeal and the uncertain self: What makes you so sure? Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2003 85 838 852

McGregorI.ZannaM. P.HolmesJ. G.SpencerS. J. Compensatory conviction in the face of personal uncertainty: Going to extremes and being oneself Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2001 80 472 488

NavarreteC. D.FesslerD. M. Normative bias and adaptive challenges: A relational approach to coalitional psychology and a critique of terror management theory Journal of Evolutionary Psychology 2005 3 297 325

NavarreteC. D.KurzbanR.FesslerD. M.KirkpatrickL. Anxiety and intergroup bias: Terror-management or coalitional psychology? Group Processes and Intergroup Relations 2004 7 370 397

NorenzayanA.Dar-NimrodI.HansenI. G.ProulxT Mortality salience and religion: Divergent effects on the defense of cultural worldviews for the religious and the non-religious European Journal of Social Psychology 2009 39 101 113

PanatiC. The sacred origin of profound things: The stories behind the rites and rituals of the world’s religions 1996 New York, NY Penguin Books

PhamM. T. Emotion and rationality: A critical review and interpretation of empirical evidence Review of General Psychology 2007 11 155 178

PrinzJ. Gut reactions: A perceptual theory of emotion 2004 New York, NY Oxford University Press

ProulxT.HeineS. J. The case of the transmogrifying experimenter: Affirmation of moral schema following implicit change detection Psychological Science 2008 19 1294 1300

ProulxT.HeineS. J.VohsK. D. When is the unfamiliar The Uncanny? Meaning affirmation after exposure to absurdist literature, humor, and art Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2010 36 817 829

ProulxT.InzlichtM.Harmon-JonesE. Understanding all inconsistency compensation as a palliate response to violated expectations Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2012 16 285 291

PyszczynskiT.GreenbergJ.SolomonS. A dual-process model of defense against conscious and unconscious death-related thoughts: An extension of terror management theory Psychological Review 1999 106 835 845

RinpocheS. The Tibetan book of living and dying 1992 Harper, San Francisco, CA

RosenblattA.GreenbergJ.SolomonS.PyszczynskiT.LyonD. Evidence for terror management theory I: The effects of mortality salience on reactions to those who violate or uphold cultural values Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1989 57 681 690

RoutledgeC.ArndtJ.GoldenbergJ. L. A time to tan: Proximal and distal effects of mortality salience on sun exposure intentions Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2004 30 1347 1358

SamuelG. Civilized shamans: Buddhism in Tibetan societies 1993 Washington, DC Smithsonian Institute Press

SangayT. Tibetan death rituals of the dead Tibetan Medicine 1984 7 13 24

Shreve-NeigerA. K.EdelsteinB. A. Religion and anxiety: A critical review of the literature Clinical Psychology Review 2004 24 379 397

SchwarzN.CloreG. L. Mood, misattribution, and judgments of well-being: Informative and directive functions of affective states Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1983 45 513 523

SchwarzN.CloreG. L. HigginsE. T.KruglanskiA. W. Feelings and phenomenal experiences Social psychology: Handbook of basic principles 2007 2nd edn Guilford, New York, NY 385 407

SolomonS.GreenbergJ.PyszczynskiT. GreenbergJ.KooleS. L.PyszczynskiT. The cultural animal: Twenty years of terror management theory and research Handbook of experimental existential psychology 2004 Guilford, New York, NY 13 34

SolomonS.GreenbergJ.PyszczynskiT.CohenF.OgilvieD. SchallerM.NorenzayanA.HeineS.YamagishiT.KamedaT. Teach these souls to fly: Supernatural as human adaptation Evolution culture and the human mind 2010 New York, NY Psychology Press 99 118

ThornhillR. BockG.CardewG. The concept of an evolved adaptation Characterizing human psychological adaptations 1997 London CIBA Foundation 4 13

ThurmanR. A. E. The Tibetan book of the dead 1994 Bantam, New York, NY

ToobyJ.CosmidesL. BussD. M. Conceptual foundations of evolutionary psychology The handbook of evolutionary psychology 2005 Wiley, Hoboken, NJ 5 67

TracyJ. L.HartJ.MartensJ. P. Death and Science: The existential underpinnings of belief in intelligent design and discomfort with evolution 2011 PLoS ONE 6 e17349 doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0017349

van den BosK. Making sense of life: The existential self trying to deal with personal uncertainty Psychological Inquiry 2009 20 197 217

van den BosK.HamJ.LindE. A.SimonisM.van EssenW. J.RijpkemaM. Justice and the human alarm system: The impact of exclamation points and flashing lights on the justice judgment process Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 2008 44 201 219

WatsonD.ClarkL. A. Preliminary manual for the PANAS-X: Positive and negative affect schedule–expanded form 1991 Southern Methodist University Unpublished manuscript

WhalenP. J.RauchS. L.EtcoffN. L.McInerneyS. C.LeeM.JenikeM. A. Masked presentations of emotional facial expressions modulate amygdala activity without explicit knowledge Journal of Neuroscience 1998 18 411 418

WilliamsG. C. Adaptation and natural selection 1966 Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press

WinkielmanP.BerridgeK. C.WilbargerJ. L. Unconscious affective reactions to masked happy versus angry faces influence consumption behavior and judgments of value Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2005a 1 121 135

WinkielmanP.BerridgeK. C.WilbargerJ. L. BarrettL. F.NiedenthalP.WinkielmanP. Emotion, behavior, and conscious experience: Once more without feeling Emotion and consciousness 2005b New York, NY Guilford Press 335 362

WinkielmanP.KnutsonB.PaulusM. P.TrujilloJ. T. Affective influence on decisions: Moving towards the core mechanisms Review of General Psychology 2007 11 179 192

WismanA.GoldenbergJ. L. From the grave to the cradle: Evidence that mortality salience engenders a desire for offspring Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2005 89 46 61

WongE. China tightens security in Tibet New York Times 2009 9 March 2009 Available online at (accessed 28 July 2009).

WrightC. I.FischerH.WhalenP. J.McInerneyS.C.ShinL. M.RauchS. L. Differential prefrontal cortex and amygdala habituation to repeatedly presented emotional stimuli Neuroreport 2001 12 379 383


  • View in gallery
    Gender classifijication task. In Study 2, participants were primed with subliminal faces embedded within a gender classifijication task (modifijied from Winkielman et al., 2005a). Immediately following this task, participants rated the authors of a pair of essays about Tibetan culture.


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 40 40 22
Full Text Views 33 33 15
PDF Downloads 3 3 1
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0