Young Children are Reality-Prone When Thinking about Stories

in Journal of Cognition and Culture
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Many parents and some researchers assume that young children are fantastical thinkers. We examined this assumption in the domain of reasoning about fictional stories. We presented 4-year-olds with realistic and fantastical stories and asked them how best to continue these stories: with ordinary events or with events that violate real-world causal laws. Children preferred the ordinary events for both types of stories (Experiment 1, n=42) while a comparison group of adults (n=68) continued stories based on their content. To ensure that children’s responses reflected their intuitions about stories per se, Experiment 2 (n=60) asked 4-year-olds to make the same choice between realistic and fantastical events, but in the context of figuring out an experimenter’s preferences or learning a new word. Here, children did not demonstrate an overall bias for the realistic events. These findings suggest that children are reality-prone in the context of fictional stories.



AmselE.TrionfiG.CampbellR. Reasoning about make-believe and hypothetical suppositions: Towards a theory of belief-contravening reasoning Cognitive Development 2005 20 545 575

BoergerE. A. ‘In fairy tales fairies can disappear’: Children’s reasoning about the characteristics of humans and fantasy figures British Journal of Developmental Psychology 2011 29 635 655

BourchierA.DavisA. Children’s understanding of the pretence-reality distinction: A review of current theory and evidence Developmental Science 2002 5 397 413

BoyerP. The naturalness of religious ideas: A cognitive theory of religion 1994 Berkeley, CA University of California Press

BrethertonI. BrethertonI. Representing the social world in symbolic play: Reality and fantasy Symbolic play: The development of social understanding 1984 New York, NY Academic Press 3 41

CookC.SobelD. M. Children’s beliefs about the fantasy/reality status of hypothesized machines Developmental Science 2011 14 1 8

DiasM. G.HarrisP. L. The effect of make believe play on deductive reasoning British Journal of Developmental Psychology 1988 6 207 221

FawcettC.MarksonL. Children reason about shared preferences Developmental Psychology 2010 46 299 309

GelmanS. A.MarkmanE. M. Categories and induction in young children Cognition 1986 23 183 209

GolombC.GalassoL. Make believe and reality: Explorations of the imaginary realm Developmental Psychology 1995 31 800 810

HarrisP. L. The work of the imagination 2000 Oxford Blackwell

HarrisP. L.BrownE.MarriotC.WhittalS.HarmerS. Monsters, ghosts, and witches: Testing the limits of the fantasy-reality distinction in young children Developmental Psychology 1991 9 105 123

JohnsonC. N.HarrisP. L. Magic: Special but not excluded British Journal of Developmental Psychology 1994 12 35 51

LandauB.SmithL. BJonesS. S. The importance of shape in early lexical learning Cognitive Development 1988 3 299 321

LewisD. Truth in fiction American Philosophical Quarterly 1978 15 37 46

MorisonP.GardnerH. Dragons and dinosaurs: The child’s capacity to differentiate fantasy from reality Child Development 1978 49 642 648

NelsonK.SeidmanS. BrethertonI. Playing with scripts Symbolic play: The development of social understanding 1984 New York, NY Academic Press 45 72

PhelpsK. E.WoolleyJ. D. The form and function of young children’s magical beliefs Developmental Psychology 1994 30 385 394

RepacholiB. M.GopnikA. Early reasoning about desires: Evidence from 14- and 18-month-olds Developmental Psychology 1997 33 12 21

RichertR. A.SmithE. I. Preschoolers’ quarantining of fantasy stories Child Development 2011 82 1106 1119

RichertR. A.ShawberA. B.HoffmanR. E.TaylorM. Learning from fantasy and real characters in preschool and kindergarten Journal of Cognition and Development 2009 10 41 66

RosengrenK.HicklingA. K. RosengrenK.JohnsonC. N.HarrisP. L. Metamorphosis and magic: The development of children’s thinking about possible events and plausible mechanisms Imagining the impossible 2000 Cambridge Cambridge University Press 75 98

RosengrenK.KalishC. W.HicklingA. K.GelmanS. A. Exploring the relation between preschool children s magical beliefs and causal thinking British Journal of Developmental Psychology 1994 12 69 82

RyanM.-L. Fiction, non-factuals, and the principle of minimal departure Poetics 1980 9 4 403 422

SamuelsA.TaylorM. Children’s ability to distinguish fantasy events from real-life events British Journal of Developmental Psychology 1994 12 417 427

ScarlettW. G.WolfD. When it’s only make-believe: The construction of a boundary between fantasy and reality in storytelling New Directions for Child Development 1979 6 29 40

SchankR. C.AbelsonR. P. Scripts, plans, goals and understanding 1977 Hillsdale, NJ Lawrence Erlbaum Associates

SchultC. A.WellmanH. M. Explaining human movements and actions: Children’s understanding of the limits of psychological explanation Cognition 1997 62 291 324

ScribnerS. Johnson-LairdP. N.WasonP. C. Modes of thinking and ways of speaking: culture and logic reconsidered Thinking: Readings in cognitive science 1977 New York, NY Cambridge University Press 483 500

SharonT.WoolleyJ. D. Do monsters dream? Young children’s understanding of the fantasy/reality distinction British Journal of Developmental Psychology 2004 22 293 310

ShtulmanA.CareyS. Improbable or impossible? How children reason about the possibility of extraordinary events Child Development 2007 78 1015 1032

SingerD. G.SingerJ. L. The house of make-believe: Children’s play and the developing imagination 1990 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press

SkolnickD.BloomP. What does Batman think about SpongeBob? Children’s understanding of the fantasy/fantasy distinction Cognition 2006 101 B9 B18

SobelD. M. Exploring the coherence of young children’s explanatory abilities: Evidence from generating counterfactuals British Journal of Developmental Psychology 2004 22 37 58

SobelD. M.MunroS. A. Domain generality and specificity in children’s causal inferences about ambiguous data Developmental Psychology 2009 45 511 524

SubbotskyE. V. Foundations of the mind: Children’s understanding of reality 1992 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press

SubbotskyE. V. Magical thinking in judgments of causation: Can anomalous phenomena affect ontological causal beliefs in children and adults? British Journal of Developmental Psychology 2004 22 123 152

TaylorM. Imaginary companions and the children who create them 1999 New York, NY Oxford University Press

WaltonK. L. Mimesis as make-believe 1990 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press

WeisbergD. S. TaylorM. Distinguishing imagination from reality The Oxford Handbook of the Development of Imagination 2013 New York, NY Oxford University Press 75 93

WeisbergD. S.GoodsteinJ. What belongs in a fictional world? Journal of Cognition and Culture 2009 9 69 78

WeisbergD. S.SobelD. M. Young children discriminate improbable from impossible events in fiction Cognitive Development 2012 12 90 98

WoolleyJ. D.CoxV. Development of beliefs about storybook reality Developmental Science 2007 10 681 693

WoolleyJ. D.BoergerE. A.MarkmanA. B. A visit from the Candy Witch: Factors influencing young children s belief in a novel fantastical being Developmental Science 2004 7 456 468


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 12 12 9
Full Text Views 6 6 6
PDF Downloads 0 0 0
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0