Reasoning and Culture in a Historical Perspective
In: Journal of Cognition and CultureNeedham Research Institute 8 Sylvester Road, Cambridge CB3 9AF UK
Search for other papers by G. E. R. Lloyd in
Current site
Google Scholar
Summary
After a preliminary discussion of some of the problems of the nature of reason and argument and the difficulties of investigating them, this paper uses the rich evidence from ancient civilisations, Greece and China especially, to explore the relationship between reasoning and culture. While argument and persuasion are evidently widespread in all human populations, the modalities they take may differ depending on the differing pragmatic circumstances in which they are conducted – the audiences and interlocutors in question and the aims of persuasion. Those circumstances may give rise to different modes of argument and styles of reasoning. While Chinese persuaders typically target rulers or those in authority, some Greek ones had to try to persuade a general public who, in some situations, decided the issue by taking a vote. That, it is argued, may help to explain the main way in which Greek arguments were distinctive when compared with those we find in other ancient civilisations. The suggestion is that the axiomatic-deductive mode of argument that was developed by some Greek philosophers and mathematicians was a reaction against what were perceived as the merely persuasive modes cultivated by orators, sophists and politicians in the context of public debate.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Adler J. E. & Rips L. J. Reasoning: Studies of Human Inference and its Foundations 2008 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Barkow J. H. , Cosmides L. & Tooby J. The Adapted Mind: Evolutionary Psychology and the Generation of Culture 1992 Oxford Oxford University Press
-
Baron-Cohen S. The Essential Difference: Men, Women and the Extreme Male Brain 2003 London
-
Billig M. Arguing and Thinking 1996 2nd edn. Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Bloom A. The Linguistic Shaping of Thought. A Study in the Impact of Language in Thinking in China and the West 1981 Hillsdale, NJ. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
-
Burnyeat M. F. Furley D. J. & Nehamas A. Enthymeme: Aristotle on the logic of persuasion Aristotle’s Rhetoric: Philosophical Essays 1994 Princeton, NJ. Princeton University Press 3 55
-
Byrne R. W. & Whiten A. Machiavellian Intelligence 1988 Oxford Clarendon Press
-
Carruthers P. Language, Thought and Consciousness 1996 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Chomsky N. Language and Mind 2006 3rd edn. Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Cooper W. The Evolution of Reason 2001 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Cosmides L. & Tooby J. Barkow J. , Cosmides L. & Tooby J. Cognitive Adaptations for Social Exchange The Adapted Mind: Evolutionary psychology and the generation of culture 1992 New York, NY. Oxford University Press 163 228
-
Cullen C. Major J. S. A Chinese Eratosthenes of the Flat Earth Heaven and Earth in Early Han Thought 1993 Albany, NY. State University of New York Press 269 290
-
Dascal M. The study of controversies and the theory and history of science Science in Context 1998 11 147 154
-
Dascal M. & Chang H.-L. Traditions of Controversy 2007 Amsterdam John Benjamins
-
Daston L. & Mitman G. Thinking with Animals 2005 New York, NY. Columbia University Press
-
Dunbar R. I. M. The Social Brain Hypothesis Evolutionary Anthropology 1996 6 178 190
-
Dupré J. Humans and Other Animals 2002 Oxford Clarendon Press
-
Evans J. St. B.T. Bias in Human Reasoning 1989 Erlbaum, Hove
-
Gigerenzer G. & Goldstein D. G. Reasoning the fast and frugal way: Models of bounded rationality Psychological Review 1996 103 650 669
-
Gigerenzer G. & Todd P. M. Simple Heuristics That Make Us Smart 1999 Oxford Oxford University Press
-
Gluckman M. The Judicial Process among the Barotse of Northern Rhodesia 1967 2nd edn. Manchester Manchester University Press
-
Goody J. The Domestication of the Savage Mind 1977 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Graham A. C. Later Mohist Logic, Ethics and Science 1978 London School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London
-
Graham A. C. Disputers of the Tao 1989 La Salle, IL. Open Court
-
Griffin D. R. Animal Thinking 1984 Cambridge, MA. Harvard University Press
-
Griffin D. R. Animal Minds 1992 Chicago, IL. Chicago University Press
-
Hacking I. The Emergence of Probability 1975 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Hacking I. “Style” for Historians and Philosophers Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 1992 23 178 199
-
Hacking I. Scientific Reason 2009 Taipei National Taiwan University Press
-
Hacking I. ‘Language, Truth and Reason’ 30 years later Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 2012 43 599 609
-
Harbsmeier C. Science and Civilisation in China vii/1, Language and Logic 1998 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Harman G. Change in View: Principles of Reasoning 1986 Cambridge MA. MIT Press
-
Henrich J. , Heine S. & Norenzayan A. The weirdest people in the world Behavioral and Brain Sciences 2010 33 61 83
-
Holyoak K. J. & Morrison R. G. The Cambridge Handbook of Thinking and Reasoning 2005 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Holyoak K. J. & Thagard P. Mental Leaps: Analogy in Creative Thought 1995 Cambridge, MA. MIT Press
-
Hsu E. Pulse Diagnosis in Early Chinese Medicine: The Telling Touch 2010 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Humphrey N. K. Bateson P. P. G. & Hinde R. A. The social function of intellect Growing Points in Ethology 1976 Cambridge Cambridge University Press 303 317
-
Humphrey N. K. A History of the Mind 1992 London Chatto and Windus
-
Humphrey N. K. Soul Dust 2011 Quercus, London
-
Ierodiakonou K. Ancient thought experiments: A First Approach Ancient Philosophy 2005 25 125 140
-
Jackendoff R. How language helps us think Pragmatics and Cognition 1996 4 1 34
-
Jaynes J. The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind 1976 Boston, MA. Houghton Mifflin
-
Johnson-Laird P. N. How We Reason 2006 Oxford Oxford University Press
-
Johnston I. The Mozi 2010 Hong Kong Chinese University Press
-
Kahneman D. Thinking Fast and Slow 2011 London Allen Lane
-
Kahneman D. , Slovic P. & Tversky A. Judgement under Uncertainty 1982 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Knoblock J. Xunzi: A Translation and Study of the Complete Works 1988-1994 Stanford, CA. Stanford University Press 3 volumes
-
Knoblock J. & Riegel J. The Annals of Lü Buwei 2000 Stanford, CA. Stanford University Press
-
Kroeber A. L. & Kluckhohn C. Culture: A critical review of concepts and definitions 1952 Cambridge MA Peabody Museum of American Archeology and Ethnology 47
-
Kuhn D. The Skills of Argument 1991 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Kuper A. Culture: The Anthropologists’ Account 1999 Cambridge, MA. Harvard University Press
-
Levinson S. C. & Jaisson P. Evolution and Culture 2006 Cambridge, MA. MIT Press
-
Lévi-Strauss C. The Savage Mind 1966 Weidenfeld and Nicolson, London (trans. of La Pensée sauvage, Plon, Paris 1962)
-
Lévy-Bruhl L. Primitive Mentality 1923 New York, NY. George Allen and Unwin (trans. L. A. Clare of La Mentalité primitive, Felix Alcan, Paris 1922)
-
Lloyd G. E. R. Polarity and Analogy 1966 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Lloyd G. E. R. The Revolutions of Wisdom 1987 Berkeley University of California Press
-
Lloyd G. E. R. Demystifying Mentalities 1990 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Lloyd G. E. R. Adversaries and Authorities 1996a Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Lloyd G. E. R. Aristotelian Explorations 1996b Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Lloyd G. E. R. Ancient Worlds, Modern Reflections 2004 Oxford Oxford University Press
-
Lloyd G. E. R. The institutions of censure: China, Greece and the modern world Quaderni di Storia 2005 62 7 52
-
Lloyd G. E. R. Cognitive Variations 2007a Oxford Oxford University Press
-
Lloyd G. E. R. Scott D. The wife of Philinus, or the Doctors’ Dilemma: Medical Signs and Cases and Non-deductive Inference Maieusis 2007b Oxford Oxford University Press 335 350
-
Long A. A. & Sedley D. N. The Hellenistic Philosophers 1987 Cambridge Cambridge University Press 2 volumes
-
Luria A. R. Cognitive Development: Its Cultural and Social Foundations 1976 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press
-
Major J. S. Heaven and Earth in Early Han Thought 1993 Albany, NY State University of New York Press
-
Matilal B. K. Epistemology, Logic and Grammar in Indian Philosophical Analysis 1971 Mouton, The Hague Janua linguarum series minor III
-
Matilal B. K. Logic, Language and Reality 1985 Delhi Matilal Banarsidaa
-
Matilal B. K. The Character of Logic in India 1998 Albany, NY State University of New York Press
-
McGilchrist I. The Master and his Emissary: The Divided Brain and the Making of the Western World 2009 New Haven, CT Yale University Press
-
Mercier H. On the universality of argumentative reasoning Journal of Cognition and Culture 2011 11 85 113
-
Mercier H. & Sperber D. Why do humans reason? Arguments for an argumentative theory Behavioral and Brain Sciences 2011 34 57 74
-
Nickerson R. S. Confirmation Bias: A ubiquitous phenomenon in many guises Review of General Psychology 1998 2 175 220
-
Nisbett R. E. The Geography of Thought: How Asians and Westerners Think Differently . . . and Why 2003 New York, NY The Free Press
-
Sperber D. , Cara F. & Girotto V. ‘Relevance theory explains the selection task’ Cognition 1995 57 31 95
-
Tooby J. & Cosmides L. Evolutionary psychology and the generation of culture: part I, theoretical considerations Ethology and Sociobiology 1989 10 29 49
-
Tooby J. & Cosmides L. Universals of human nature Journal of Personality 1990 58 17 67
-
Tooby J. & Cosmides L. Barkow J. H. , Cosmides L. & Tooby J. The psychological foundations of culture The Adapted Mind: Evolutionary Psychology and the Generation of Culture 1992 Oxford Oxford University Press 19 136
-
Tversky A. & Kahneman D. Kahneman D. , Slovic P. & Tversky A. Judgement under uncertainty: heuristics and biases Judgement under Uncertainty 1982 Cambridge Cambridge University Press 3 20
-
Vygotsky L. Thought and Language 1986 Cambridge, MA MIT Press
-
Wagner R. The Invention of Culture 1975 Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ
-
Wason P. C. Foss B. M. Reasoning New Horizons in Psychology I 1966 Penguin, Harmondsworth
-
Wason P. C. & Johnson-Laird P. N. Psychology of Reasoning: Structure and Content 1972 Batsford, London
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 586 | 111 | 9 |
| Full Text Views | 174 | 22 | 0 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 132 | 40 | 0 |
Reasoning and Culture in a Historical Perspective
In: Journal of Cognition and CultureNeedham Research Institute 8 Sylvester Road, Cambridge CB3 9AF UK
Search for other papers by G. E. R. Lloyd in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Summary
After a preliminary discussion of some of the problems of the nature of reason and argument and the difficulties of investigating them, this paper uses the rich evidence from ancient civilisations, Greece and China especially, to explore the relationship between reasoning and culture. While argument and persuasion are evidently widespread in all human populations, the modalities they take may differ depending on the differing pragmatic circumstances in which they are conducted – the audiences and interlocutors in question and the aims of persuasion. Those circumstances may give rise to different modes of argument and styles of reasoning. While Chinese persuaders typically target rulers or those in authority, some Greek ones had to try to persuade a general public who, in some situations, decided the issue by taking a vote. That, it is argued, may help to explain the main way in which Greek arguments were distinctive when compared with those we find in other ancient civilisations. The suggestion is that the axiomatic-deductive mode of argument that was developed by some Greek philosophers and mathematicians was a reaction against what were perceived as the merely persuasive modes cultivated by orators, sophists and politicians in the context of public debate.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 586 | 111 | 9 |
| Full Text Views | 174 | 22 | 0 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 132 | 40 | 0 |