A Dialogical Account of Deductive Reasoning as a Case Study for how Culture Shapes Cognition

in Journal of Cognition and Culture
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



In this paper, I discuss how certain social, cultural practices, namely different kinds of dialogical and argumentative practices, may influence how humans reason. I will focus particularly on deductive reasoning and address the question of whether deductive reasoning skills must be learned to be mastered, or whether they arise spontaneously in untrained reasoners. Based on a historically-informed dialogical reconceptualization of deductive reasoning, I will argue that deductive skills arise predominantly by means of specific training, schooling in particular. In a slogan, the main claim of the paper is: when it comes to deduction, we may say that ontogeny – the onset of deductive reasoning in an individual reasoner – to some extent recapitulates phylogeny – the historical emergence of the concept of deduction (in both cases, we are dealing with cultural phenomena). But I will also argue that some ‘mundane’ forms of dialogical interaction such as story-telling and adversarial betting may also cue untrained reasoners to perform closer to the deductive canons in experiments.

A Dialogical Account of Deductive Reasoning as a Case Study for how Culture Shapes Cognition

in Journal of Cognition and Culture



AdlerJ.RipsL. Reasoning: Studies of Human Inference and its Foundations 2008 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

BloorD. Knowledge and Social Imagery 1976 London Routledge

ByrneR. M. J. Suppressing valid inferences with conditionals Cognition 1989 31 1 83

CastelneracB.MarionM. PrimieroG.RahmanS. Arguing for inconsistency: Dialectical games in the academy Acts of Knowledge: History Philosophy and Logic 2009 London College Publications 45 84

ChemlaK. MancosuP. The interplay between proof and algorithm in 3rd century China: the operation as prescription of computation and the operation as argument Visualization Explanation and Reasoning Styles in Mathematics 2005 Amsterdam Springer 123 145

ColeM.GayJ.GlickJ. A.SharpD. W. The cultural context of learning and thinking 1971 New York, NY Basic Books

CounihanM. Looking for logic in all the wrong places: an investigation of language literacy and logic in reasoning 2008 Amsterdam ILLC-University of Amsterdam PhD dissertation

DiasM.HarrisP. L. The effect of make-believe play on deductive reasoning British Journal of Developmental Psychology 1988 6 207 221

DiasM.HarrisP. L. The influence of the imagination on reasoning by young children British Journal of Developmental Psychology 1990 8 305 318

DiasM.RoazziA.HarrisP. L. Reasoning from unfamiliar premises: A study with unschooled adults Psychological Science 2005 16 550 554

Dutilh NovaesC. The historical and philosophical origins of normativism Behavioral and Brain Sciences 2011 34 253 254

Dutilh NovaesC. Reassessing logical hylomorphism and the demarcation of logical constants Synthese 2012a 185 387 410

Dutilh NovaesC. Formal languages in logic – A philosophical and cognitive analysis 2012b Cambridge Cambridge University Press

ElqayamS.EvansJ. St.B. T. Subtracting “ought” from “is”: descriptivism versus normativism in the study of the human thinking Behavioral and Brain Sciences 2011 34 233 248

EvansJ. St.B. T. Bias in human reasoning: Causes and consequences 1989 Hillsdale, NJ Lawrence Erlbaum Associates

EvansJ. St.B. T. Logic and human reasoning: an assessment of the deduction paradigm Psychological Bulletin 2002 128 978 996

EvansJ. St.B. T. EvansJ. St.B. T.FrankishK. How many dual process theories do we need: One, two or many? In two minds: Dual processes and beyond 2008 Oxford Oxford University Press 31 54

EvansJ. St.B. T.BarstonJ.PollardP. On the conflict between logic and belief in syllogistic reasoning Memory and Cognition 1983 11 295 306

EvansJ. St.B. T.NewsteadS. E.AllenJ. L.PollardP. Debiasing by instruction: the case of belief-bias European Journal of Cognitive Psychology 1994 6 263 285

Evans-PritchardE. E. Witchcraft Oracles and Magic Among the Azande 1937 Oxford Oxford University Press

FrankishK. Dual-process and dual-system theories of reasoning Philosophy Compass 2010 5 914 926

FraserC. ZaltaE. School of names Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy 2009 available online at http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/school-names/

FraserC. ZaltaE. Mohist Canons Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy 2011 available online at http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/mohist-canons/

GreiffenhagenC.SharrockW. Logical relativism: logic, grammar, and arithmetic in cultural comparison Configurations 2006 14 275 301

HarmanG. Change in View Principles of Reasoning 1986 Cambridge, MA MIT Press

HarrisP. L. The work of the imagination 2000 New York, NY Wiley

HenrichJ.HeineS. J.NorenzayanA. The weirdest people in the world? Behavioral and Brain Sciences 2010 33 61 135

InhelderB.PiagetJ. The Growth of Logical Thinking from Childhood to Adolescence 1958 New York, NY Basic Books

Johnson-LairdP. AdlerJ.RipsL. Mental models and deductive reasoning Reasoning: Studies of Human Inference and its Foundations 2008 Cambridge Cambridge University Press 206 222

KlauerK. C.MuschJ.NaumerB. On belief bias in syllogistic reasoning Psychological Review 2000 107 852 884

KoonsR. ZaltaE. ‘Defeasible reasoning’ Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy 2009 available online at http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/defeasible-reasoning/

LloydG. E. R. OlsonD.TorranceN. Science in Antiquity: the Greek and Chinese cases and their relevance to the problem of culture and cognition Modes of Though: Explorations in Culture and Cognition 1996 Cambridge Cambridge University Press 15 33 Reprinted in Biagioli M. (Ed.) (1999). The Science Studies Reader. Routledge New York NY pp. 302-316 (page numbers refer to the 1999 reprint).

LuriaA. R. Cognitive Development: its social and cultural foundations 1976 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press

MercierH.SperberD. Why do humans reason? Arguments for an argumentative theory Behavioral and Brain Sciences 2011 34 57 74

MorrisA. K.SloutskyV. Understanding of logical necessity: developmental antecedents and cognitive consequences Child Development 1998 69 721 741

NetzR. The Shaping of Deduction in Greek Mathematics: A study in cognitive history 1999 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

OaksfordM. R.ChaterN. C. ElioR. Commonsense reasoning, logic and human rationality Common Sense Reasoning and Rationality 2002 Oxford Oxford University Press 174 214

OaksfordM. R.ChaterN. C. OaksfordM.ChaterN. C. Probability logic and the ‘Modus Ponens – Modus Tollens’ asymmetry The Probabilistic Mind: Prospects for Bayesian Cognitive Science 2008 Oxford Oxford University Press 97 120

PiagetJ. Sociological Studies 1995 London Routledge

ScribnerS. Johnson-LairdP. N.WasonP. C. Modes of thinking and ways of speaking: Culture and logic reconsidered Thinking: Readings in Cognitive Science 1977 New York, NY Cambridge University Press 483 500

ScribnerS.ColeM. The psychology of literacy 1981 Cambridge, MA. Harvard University Press

StanovichK. AdlerJ.RipsL. Individual differences in reasoning and the algorithmic/intentional level distinction in cognitive science Reasoning: Studies of Human Inference and its Foundations 2008 Cambridge Cambridge University Press 414 437

StenningK. Seeing Reason 2002 Oxford Oxford University Press

StenningK.van LambalgenM. Human Reasoning and Cognitive Science 2008 Cambridge MA MIT Press

TriplettT. Azande logic versus Western logic? British Journal of Philosophy of Science 1988 39 361 366

TverskyA.KahnemanD. Judgment under uncertainty: heuristics and biases Science 1974 185 1124 1131

VygotskyL. Mind in Society 1978 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press

WasonP. C. FossB. M. Reasoning New horizons in psychology 1966 Harmondsworth Penguin 135 151


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 32 32 19
Full Text Views 88 88 57
PDF Downloads 8 8 4
EPUB Downloads 2 2 2