Language Defies Logic? Naming Practices Trump Logical Consistency for Indonesian Adults

in Journal of Cognition and Culture
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


In English, ‘animal’ applies to humans and non-human animals, but in Indonesian, the word (‘hewan’) does not apply to humans. Previous research has shown that English-speaking children were more likely than Indonesian-speaking children to agree that mammals are animals (age 6) and humans are mammals (age 9). As adults, Indonesian speakers accepted these statements, but denied that humans are animals. Thus, adults’ judgments were intransitive. In the present work, Indonesian-speaking children and adults were asked to revisit their judgments about biological categories following exposure to three-dimensional objects as an analog for class-inclusion relationships. The results were striking: While most of the children changed their judgments after the analogical prompt to agree that humans are mammals and humans are animals, the adults stayed with their initial judgments that were collectively illogical but consistent with their naming practice. These results suggest a complex interplay between naming, logical thinking and development.

Language Defies Logic? Naming Practices Trump Logical Consistency for Indonesian Adults

in Journal of Cognition and Culture



AnggoroF. K. A mammal that is not an animal? Naming and the animal concept in English and Indonesian speakers Journal of Cognition and Culture 2012 12 31 48

AnggoroF. K.MedinD. L.WaxmanS. R. Language and experience influence children’s biological induction Journal of Cognition and Culture 2010 10 171 187

AnggoroF. K.WaxmanS. R.MedinD. L. Naming practices and the acquisition of key biological concepts: Evidence from English and Indonesian Psychological Science 2008 19 314 319

BacksheiderA.ShatzM.GelmanS. Preschoolers’ ability to distinguish living kinds as a function of regrowth Child Development 1993 64 1242 1257

ColeyJ. D. The human animal: Developmental changes in judgments of taxonomic and psychological similarity among humans and other animals Cognition Brain Behavior 2007 11 733 756

HamptonJ. A. A demonstration of intransitivity in natural categories Cognition 1982 12 151 164

HatanoG.SieglerR. S.RichardsD. D.InagakiK.StavyR.WaxN. The development of biological knowledge: A multi-national study Cognitive Development 1993 8 47 62

HerrmannP.WaxmanS. R.MedinD. L. Anthropocentrism is not the first step in children’s reasoning about the natural world Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2010 107 9979 9984

HerrmannP.MedinD. L.WaxmanS. R. When humans become animals: Development of the animal category in early childhood Cognition 2012 122 74 79

InagakiK.HatanoG. Young children’s recognition of commonalities between animals and plants Child Development 1996 67 2823 2840

JohnsonK.MervisC.BosterJ. Developmental changes within the structure of the mammal domain Developmental Psychology 1992 28 74 83

LeddonE. M.WaxmanS. R.MedinD. L. Unmasking “alive:” Children’s appreciation of a concept linking all living things Journal of Cognition and Development 2008 9 461 473

LeddonE.WaxmanS. R.MedinD. L.BangM.WashinawatokK. G.HayesM.Bryant One animal among many? Children’s understanding of the relation between humans and nonhuman animals Psychology of Culture 2012 Hauppauge, NY Nova Science Publishers 105 126

OpferJ. E.SieglerR. S. Revisiting the living things concept: A microgenetic study of conceptual change in basic biology Cognitive Psychology 2004 49 301 332

RandallR. A. How tall is a taxonomic tree? Some evidence for dwarfism American Ethnologist 1976 3 543 553

SpringerK.KeilF. On the development of biologically specific beliefs: The case of inheritance Child Development 1989 60 637 648

TavernaA.WaxmanS.MedinD.PeraltaO. Core-folkbiological concepts: New evidence from Wichí children and adults Journal of Cognition and Culture 2012 12 339 358

VosniadouS.BrewerW. F. Mental models of the earth: A study of conceptual change in childhood Cognitive Psychology 1992 24 535 585


Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 24 24 10
Full Text Views 10 10 10
PDF Downloads 2 2 2
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0