What Made Sahar Scared?: Imaginary and Realistic Causes in Palestinian and American Children’s Concept for Fear

in Journal of Cognition and Culture
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


Young children associate fear with monsters, ghosts, and other imaginary creatures more than with real threats to safety, such as robbers or bullies – at least in Western societies. Cross-cultural studies are rare, are limited to older children, and have not asked if the role of the imagination extends to emotions other than fear. In this study, young Palestinian and American children (60 in each group, 3–7 years, age- and sex-matched) were asked to tell stories in which they generated a cause for fear as well as happiness, sadness, anger and surprise. Imaginary creatures were rarely cited as the cause of any emotion other than fear, but were cited frequently for fear by both Palestinians and Americans. There was also a cultural difference: Palestinians generated significantly fewer imaginary and more realistic causes for fear than did Americans. Thus, imaginary causes are a part of Palestinian children’s fear concept, but imaginary causes are not primary as they are for American children; for Palestinian children, realistic causes are primary in their fear concept.



BarrettH.C. BussD.M. Adaptations to predators and prey The handbook of evolutionary psychology 2005 Hoboken, NJ John Wiley and Sons 200 223

BauerD.H. An exploratory study of developmental changes in children’s fears Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 1976 17 69 74

BleulerE. RappaportD. Autistic thinking Organization and pathology of thought 1951 New York, NY Columbia University Press 199 437 (Originally published in 1912 as Das autistische Denken, Jahrbuch fϋr Psychoanalytische und Psychpathologische Forschungen 4, 1-39).

BoyerP.BergstromB. Threat-detection in child development: An evolutionary perspective Neuroscience and Behavioral Reviews 2011 35 1034 1041

BurkhardtK.LoxtonH.MurisP. Fears and fearfulness in South-African children Behaviour Change 2003 20 94 102

CamrasL.A.GrowC.RibordyS. Recognition of emotional expressions by abused children Journal of Clinical and Child Psychology 1983 12 325 328

DenhamA.ZollerD. ‘When my hamster died, I cried’: Preschoolers’ attributions of the causes of emotions Journal of Genetic Psychology 1991 152 371 373

ElbedourS.ShulmanS.KedemP. Children’s fears: Cultural and developmental perspectives Behaviour Research and Therapy 1997 35 491 496

FehrB.RussellJ.A. Concept of emotion viewed from a prototype perspective Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 1984 113 464 486

FlavellJ.H.FlavellE.R.GreenF.L. Young children’s knowledge about the apparent-real and pretend – real distinctions Developmental Psychology 1987 23 816 822

HallG.S. A study of fears American Journal of Psychology 1987 8 147 249

HarrisP. The work of the imagination 2000 Oxford Blackwell

HarrisP.BrownE.MarriottC.WhittallS.HarmerS. Monsters, ghosts and witches: Testing the limits of the fantasy-reality distinction in young children British Journal of Developmental Psychology 1991 9 105 123

IngmanI.OllendickT.AkandeA. Cross-cultural aspects of fears in African children and adolescents Behaviour Research and Therapy 1999 37 337 345

JersildA. BarkerR.G.KouninJ.S.WrightH.F. Study of children’s fears Child Behavior and Development 1943 New York, NY McGraw Hill 329 344

LeslieA.M. Pretending and believing Cognition 1994 50 211 238

MaduewesiE. Nigerian elementary children’s interests and concerns Alberta Journal of Educational Research 1982 28 204 211

PiagetJ. The origins of intelligence in children 1952 New York, NY International Universities Press

PiagetJ. Play, dreams, and imitation in childhood 1962 New York, NY W.W. Norton

RussellJ.A. SaarniC.HarrisP.L. Culture, scripts, and children’s understanding of emotion Children’s understanding of emotion 1989 Cambridge Cambridge University Press 293 318

SamuelsA.TaylorM. Children’s ability to distinguish fantasy events from real-life events British Journal of Developmental Psychology 1994 12 417 427

SayfanL.LagattutaK. Grownups are not afraid of scary stuff, but kids are: Young children’s and adults’ understanding of children’s, infants’, and adults’ fears Child Development 2008 79 821 835

SayfanL.LagattutaK. Scaring the monster away: What children know about managing fears of real and imaginary creatures Child Development 2009 80 1756 1774

StrayerJ. Children’s attributions regarding the situational determinants of emotion in self and others Developmental Psychology 1986 22 649 654

TaylorM.CartwrightB.CarlsonS. A developmental investigation of children’s imaginary companions Developmental Psychology 1993 29 276 285

VandewieleM. Fears of Senegalese secondary school students The Journal of Interdisciplinary and Applied Psychology 1981 107 281 287

WellmanH.EstesD. Early understanding of mental entities: A reexamination of childhood realism Child Development 1986 57 910 923

WidenS.C.RussellJ.A. LewisM.Haviland-JonesJ.M. Young children’s understanding of other’s emotions Handbook of emotions 2008 New York, NY Guilford 348 363

WoolleyJ.D.PhelpsK.E. Young children’s practical reasoning about imagination British Journal of Development Psychology 1994 12 53 67


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 10 10 6
Full Text Views 7 7 7
PDF Downloads 0 0 0
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0