Establishing Personal Identity in Reincarnation: Minds and Bodies Reconsidered

in Journal of Cognition and Culture
No Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


Little is known about how the minds and bodies of reincarnated agents are represented. In three studies, participants decided which individual, out of multiple contenders, was most likely to be the reincarnation of a deceased person, based upon a single matching feature between the deceased and each of the candidates. While most participants endorsed reincarnation as entailing a new body, they reasoned that candidates with a similar physical mark (e.g., a mole) or a similar episodic autobiographical memory to the deceased, when alive, were more likely than candidates with other physical or psychological based similarities to be the reincarnation of the deceased. As predicted, by increasing the distinctiveness of a matching physical mark and an episodic autobiographical memory, while holding others constant, likelihood judgments for the candidate with the similar distinctive physical mark were significantly higher than candidates with non-distinctive physical marks, but differences between the distinct and general episodic autobiographical memory condition did not reach statistical significance. These findings support the claim that we intuitively represent reincarnated agents as psychologically determined but physically embodied, and that different assumptions underpin the use of physical and psychological features to establish identity in reincarnation contexts.

Establishing Personal Identity in Reincarnation: Minds and Bodies Reconsidered

in Journal of Cognition and Culture



AddisR.D.TippettL.J. Memory of myself: autobiographical memory and identity in Alzheimer’s disease Memory 2004 12 56 74

AndersenS.M.ColeS.W. “Do I know you?” The role of significant others in general social perception Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1990 59 384 399

AndersenS.M.GlassmanN.S.ChenS. Transference in social perception: the role of chronic accessibility in significant-other representations Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1995 59 384 399

AshfordS.TimmsN. What Europe thinks: A study of Western European values 1992 London Dartmouth Publishing

AstituR.HarrisP.L. Understanding mortality and the life of the ancestors in rural Madagascar Cognitive Science 2008 32 713 740

Baron-CohenS. Theory of mind and autism: a fifteen year review International Review of Mental Retardation 2000 23 169 204

BaillargeonR. Infants’ physical world Current Directions in Psychological Science 2004 13 89 94

BarrettJ.L. Theological correctness: cognitive constraint and the study of religion Method and Theory in the Study of Religion 1999 37 608 619

BarrettJ.L. Exploring the natural foundations of religion Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2000 4 29 34

BarrettJ.L. Epidemiological and nativist accounts in the cognitive study of culture: a commentary on Pyysiäinen’s innate fear of Bering’s ghosts Journal of Cognition and Culture 2003 3 226 232

BarrettH.C.BehneT. Children’s understanding of death as the cessation of agency: a test using sleep versus death Cognition 2005 2 93 108

BarrettJ.L.KeilF.C. Anthropomorphism and God concepts: Conceptualizing a non-natural entity Cognitive Psychology 1996 31 219 247

BastianM. NewellS. Irregular visitors: Narratives about ogbaanje (spirit children) in Southern Nigerian popular writing Readings in African popular fiction 2002 Bloomington, IN Indiana University Press 59 66

BellC. The religion of Tibet 1931 London The Clarendon Press

BeringJ.M. Intuitive conceptions of dead agent’s minds: The natural foundations of afterlife beliefs as a phenomenological boundary Journal of Cognition and Culture 2002 2 262 308

BeringJ.M.BjorklundD.F. The natural emergence of reasoning about the afterlife as a developmental regularity Developmental Psychology 2004 40 217 233

BlokS.NewmanG.RipsL.J. AhnW.-k.GoldstoneR.L.LoveB.C.MarkmanA.B.WolffP. Individuals and their concepts Categorization inside and outside the lab 2005 Washington, DC American Psychological Association 127 149

BloomP. Descartes’ baby: How child development explains what makes us human 2004 London William Heinemann

BloomP.GelmanS.A. Psychological essentialism in selecting the 14th Dalai Lama Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2008 12 243

BoyerP. Religion explained: The human instincts that fashion gods spirits and ancestors 2001 New York, NY Basic Books

BoyerP. Are ghost concepts “intuitive,” “endemic” and “innate” Journal of Cognition and Culture 2003 3 233 243

CohenE. The mind possessed 2007 New York, NY Oxford University Press

CohenE.BarrettJ. When minds migrate: Conceptualizing spirit possession Journal of Cognition and Culture 2008 8 23 48

CohenE.BurdettE.KnightN.BarrettJ. Cross‐cultural similarities and differences in person‐body reasoning: experimental evidence from the United Kingdom and Brazilian Amazon Cognitive Science 2011 35 1282 1304

CorriveauK.H.PasquiniE.S.HarrisP.L. “If it’s in your mind, it’s in your knowledge”: children’s developing anatomy of identity Cognitive Development 2005 20 321 340

GottliebA. The afterlife is where we come from: The culture of infancy in West Africa 2004 Chicago, Il University of Chicago Press

CreiderJ.T. Two lives: My spirit and I 1986 Northampton, MA Interlink Publishing

DennettD.C. The intentional stance 1989 Cambridge MA MIT Press

EdelmannJ.BernetW. Setting criteria for ideal reincarnation research Journal of Consciousness Studies 2007 14 92 101

FiskeS.T.TaylorS.E. Social cognition 1991 New York, NY McGraw-Hill

Gallup cnn usa Today Poll 2005 (retrieved 9 July 2013) June 16 2005. Available online at

GallupG.ProctorW. Adventures in immortality 1982 New York, NY McGraw-Hill

GelmanS. The essential child: Origins of essentialism in everyday thought 2005 Oxford Oxford University Press

GobbiniA.I.LeibenluftE.SantiagoN.HaxbyJ.V. Social and emotional attachment in the neural representation of faces Neuroimage 2004 22 1628 1635

GopnikA.MeltzoffA.N.KuhlP.K. The scientist in the crib: Minds brains and how children learn 1999 New York, NY William Morrow

GottfriedG.M.GelmanS.A.SchultzJ. Children’s understanding of the brain: From early essentialism to biological theory Cognitive Development 1999 14 147 174

GottliebA. The afterlife is where we come from 2004 Chicago, Il University of Chicago Press

GuthrieS.E. Faces in the clouds: A new theory of religion 1993 New York, NY Oxford University Press

GutheilG.RosengrenK.S. A rose by any other name: preschoolers’ understanding of individual identity across name and appearance changes British Journal of Developmental Psychology 1996 14 477 498

HallD.G.LeeS.C.BélangerJ. Children’s use of syntactic cues to learn proper names and count nouns Developmental Psychology 2001 37 298 307

HaraldssonE. Popular psychology, belief in life after death and reincarnation in the Nordic countries, Western and Eastern Europe Nordic Psychology 2006 58 171 180

HaseltonM.G.BussD. Error management theory: a new perspective on biases in cross-sex mind reading Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2000 78 81 91

HaseltonM.G.NettleD. The paranoid optimist: An integrative evolutionary model of cognitive biases Personality and Social Psychology Review 2006 10 47 66

HaslamN.BastianB.BissettM. Essentialist beliefs about personality Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2004 30 1661 1673

HicklingA.K.GelmanS. How does your garden grow? Evidence of an early conception of plants as biological kinds Child Development 1995 66 856 876

HindeR.A. Why gods persist: A scientific approach to religion 2009 London Taylor and Francis

HirschfeldL.A. Do children have a theory of race? Cognition 1995 54 209 252

HodgeM. Descartes’ mistake: how afterlife beliefs challenge the assumption that humans are intuitive Cartesian substance dualists Journal of Cognition and Culture 2008 8 387 415

JohnsonC.N. If you had my brain, where would I be? Children’s understanding of the brain and identity Cognitive Psychology 1990 37 28 59

JohnsonC.N.WellmanH.M. Children’s developing conceptions of the mind and brain Child Development 1982 53 222 234

KleinS.NicholsS. Memory and the Sense of Personal Identity Mind 2012 121 677 702

KleinS.GermanT.CosmidesL.GabrielR. A theory of autobiographical memory: Necessary components and disorders resulting from their loss Social Cognition 2004 22 460 490

LeslieA.M. HirschfeldL.A.GelmanS.A. ToMM, To By,Agency: core architecture domain specificity Mapping the Mind: Domain specificity in cognition and culture 1994 Cambridge Cambridge University Press 119 148

LeveroniC.L.SeidenbergM.MayerM.R.MeadL.A.BinderJ.B.RaoS.M. Neural systems underlying the recognition of familiar and newly learned faces Journal of Neuroscience 2000 20 878 886

MacdonaldC. Varieties of things: Foundations of contemporary metaphysics 2008 New York, NY Wiley

MalleB.F. How the mind explains behavior: Folk explanations meaning and social interaction 2004 Cambridge, MA MIT Press

MalleB.F.MosesL.J.BaldwinD.A. Intentions and intentionality: foundations of social cognition 2001 Cambridge, MA MIT Press

MatlockJ. Of names and signs: reincarnation, inheritance, and social structure on the Northwest Coast Anthropology of Consciousness 1990 1 9 18

MeltzoffA.N.MooreM.K. BermudezJ.L.EilanN.MarcelA. Infants’ understanding of people and things: From body imitation to folk psychology The Body and Self 1995 Cambridge, MA Bradford Books 43 69

MillsA.MatlockJ. Amerindian Rebirth: Reincarnation beliefs among North American Indians and Inuit 1994 London University of Toronto Press

NicholsS. Do children think of the Self as the soul? (Commentary on Jesse Bering) Behavioral and Brain Sciences 2006 24 481 482

ObeyesekereG. Imagining karma: Ethical transformation in Amerindian Buddhist and Greek rebirth 2002 London University of California Press

OluwoleS.B. OluwoleS.B. Reincarnation: An issue in African philosophy? In Witchcraft reincarnation and the god head 1992 Lagos Excel Publishers 40 44

OrubuA.O. OrubuA.O. The hereafter in African traditional religions African Traditional Religion 2002 Benin City Institute of Education, University of Benin 116 133

OronaC.J. Temporality and identity loss due to Alzheimer’s disease Social Science and Medicine 1990 30 1247 1256

ParfitD. Reasons and persons 1984 Oxford Oxford University Press

PerryJ. Personal identity 1975 Berekely, CA University of California Press

PyysiäinenI On the ‘innateness’ of religion: a comment on Bering Journal of Cognition and Culture 2003 3 218 225

PyysiäinenI Intuitive and explicit in religious thought Journal of Cognition and Culture 2004 4 123 150

ReidT. BrookesD.R. Essays on the intellectual powers of man 1785 University Park, PA Pennsylvania State University Press

RichertR.A.HarrisP.L. The ghost in my body: children’s developing concept of the soul Journal of Cognition and Culture 2006 6 409 427

RoazziM.NyhofM.JohnsonC. Mind, Soul and Spirit: Conceptions of immaterial identity in different cultures International Journal for the Psychology of Religion 2013 23 75 86

RonchJ.L. Mourning and grief in late life Alzheimer’s dementia: revisiting the vanishing self American Journal of Alzheimer’s Disease and Other Dementias 1996 11 25 28

RosengrenK.S.GelmanS.A.KalishC.W.McCormickM. As time goes by: children’s early understanding of growth in animals Child Development 1991 62 1302 1320

SerpellJ.A. The domestic dog: its evolution, behaviour and interactions with people Applied Animal Behaviour Science 1996 47 49 69

ShahN.J.MarshallJ.C.ZafirisO.SchwabA.ZilesK.MarkowitschH.J.FinkG.R. The neural correlates of person familiarity: a functional magnetic resonance imaging study with clinical implications Brain 2001 24 804 815

ShoemakerS.SwinbourneR. Personal identity 1984 Oxford Blackwell

SloneJ. Theological Incorrectness: Why Religious People Believe What They Shouldn’t 2007 Oxford Oxford University Press

SorrentinoC.M. Children and adults represent proper names as referring to unique individuals Developmental Science 2001 4 399 407

StevensonI. Children who remember previous lives: A question of reincarnation 1991 Jefferson, NC MacFarland

ThalbourneM.A. Varieties of belief in life after death: a factor analytic study Journal of the American Society for Psychical Research 1996 90 268 291

TulvingE. TulvingE.DonaldsonW. Episodic and semantic memory Organization of memory 1972 New York, NY Academic Press 381 402

WalterT. Reincarnation, modernity and identity Sociology 2001 35 1 38

WhiteC.SousaP.BerniunasR. Psychological essentialism in selecting the 14th Dalai Lama: an alternative account Journal of Cognition and Culture 2014 14 157 158


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 79 79 23
Full Text Views 138 138 61
PDF Downloads 11 11 0
EPUB Downloads 2 2 0