Reflections on the Status and Direction of Psychology: An External Historical Perspective

in Journal of Phenomenological Psychology
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Whenever one reads internal histories of psychology what is covered is the establishment of a lab by Wundt in 1879 as the initiating act and then the breakaway movements of the 20th Century are discussed: Behaviorism, Gestalt Theory, Psychoanalysis, and most recently the Cognitive revival. However, Aron Gurwitsch described a perspective noted by Cassirer and first developed by Malebranche, which dates the founding of psychology at the same time as that of physics in the 17th Century. This external perspective shows the dependency of psychology upon the concepts, methods and procedures of physics and the natural sciences in general up until the present time. Gurwitsch argues that this approach has blocked the growth of psychology and has assured its status as a minor science. He argued that the everyday Lifeworld achievements of subjectivity are the true subject matter of psychology and that a phenomenological approach to subjectivity could give psychology the authenticity it has been forever seeking but never finding as a naturalistic science. Some clarifying thoughts concerning this phenomenologically grounded psychology are offered, especially the role of desire. The assumption of an external perspective toward the history of psychology fostered the insights about psychology’s scientific role.

Reflections on the Status and Direction of Psychology: An External Historical Perspective

in Journal of Phenomenological Psychology



BerkeleyG. CalkinsM. W. Berkeley: Essay principles dialogues with selections from other writings 1929 New York Charles Scribner’s Sons (Original publications 1709–1732)

BoringE. G. A history of experimental psychology 1950 2nd Ed New York Appleton-Century-Crofts

BrockA. Psychology’s path to a mature science: An examination of the myths. Journal of Theoretical and Philosophical psychology 2011 31 250 257

CassirerE. 1911 Das Erkenntnisproblem in der Philosophie und Wissenschaft der neuren Zeit. I Berlin

DanzigerK. Does the history of psychology have a future? Theory and psychology 1994 4 467 484

EsperE. A A History of Psychology 1964 Philadelphia W. B. Saunders

GoertzenJ. R. Further problematizing the potential for a more unified experimental, scientific psychology: A comment on Mandler. Journal of Theoretical and Philosophical Psychology 2011 31 247 249

GoodallJ. Through a window: My thirty years with the chimpanzees of Gombe 1990 Boston Houghton Mifflin

GurwitschA. La Place de la Psychologie dans l’ensemble des sciences. Revue de Synthese 1934 VIII 169 185

GurwitschA. GurwitschA. The place of psychology in the system of the sciences. Studies in phenomenology and psychology 1966 Evanston Il. Northwestern University Press 56 68

JolleyN. Locke: His philosophical thought 1999 Oxford Oxford University Press (Original publications 1823)

KochS. Psychology cannot be a coherent science. Psychology Today 1969 3 14

KochS. ColeJ. K.ArnoldW. J. Language communities, search cells, and the psychological studies. Nebraska Symposium on motivation 1975: Conceptual foundations of psychology 1976 Lincoln, NE. University of Nebraska Press

LangeF. A. The history of materialism. 1925 London Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner (German original 1865)

Le RoyG. La psychologie de Condillac 1937 Paris Boivin et Cie (Condillac’s original publications 1798)

Lévi-StraussC. The Savage Mind 1966 Chicago IL University of Chicago Press (French original 1962)

MalebrancheN. LennonT. M.OlscampP. J. The search after truth 1980 Columbus, OH Ohio State University Press (French original 1674–75)

MandlerG. Crises and problems seen from experimental psychology. Journal of theoretical and Philosophical Psychology. 2011 31 240 246

SmithT. V.GreneM. Philosophers speak for themselves: from Descartes to Locke. 1957 Chicago University of Chicago Press (Original publication 1940)

van Lawick-GoodallJ.van LawickH. The shadow of a man 1971 Boston Houghton Mifflin Co.

WetterstenJ. R. The historiography of scientific psychology: A critical study. Journal of the history of the behavioral Sciences 1975 11 157 171

WoodbridgeF. Hobbes: Philosophy 1903 Minneapolis, MN The H.W. Wilson Co. (Original publication: 1640–1650)

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 19 19 14
Full Text Views 10 10 10
PDF Downloads 1 1 1
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0