Adult Male-to-Female Transsexualism

A Clinical Existential-Phenomenological Inquiry

in Journal of Phenomenological Psychology
No Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Male-to-female transsexualism manifests itself in the form of a discrepancy between the male sex assigned at birth and the subjective experience of belonging to the female gender, which in many cases also involves a somatic transition by cross-sex hormone treatment and genital surgery. Until now, no studies related to MtF transsexualism have been carried out within the framework of a phenomenological/existential approach. This paradigm would make it possible to better articulate the transsexual experience beyond the simplistic diagnostic criteria by which it is currently defined. In this study, I will reread MtF transsexualism in the light of Ludwig Binswanger’s theories on Mannerism and Jean Paul Sartre’s remarks on the self and the body. I will do this largely by focusing on first-hand accounts of the MtF transsexual’s experience, in other words from a first-person viewpoint. Finally, I will present some considerations on the meaning of psychological intervention in this field.

Adult Male-to-Female Transsexualism

A Clinical Existential-Phenomenological Inquiry

in Journal of Phenomenological Psychology

Sections

References

  • AhmedS. Queer Phenomenology: Orientation Objects Others 2006 Durham and London Duke University Press

  • AlmodovarP. ColliP.TomasinelliP. Tutto su mia madre 1999 Turin Einaudi

  • American Psychiatric Association (apa) Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders 1980 3rd ed. Washington, DC Author

  • American Psychiatric Association (apa) Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders 1987 3rd ed. Washington, DC Author

  • American Psychiatric Association (apa) Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders 1994 4th ed. Washington, DC Author

  • American Psychiatric Association (apa) Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders 2000 4th ed. Washington, DC Author

  • American Psychiatric Association (apa) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders 2013 Fifth Edition Washington, DC Author dsm-5

  • AntonC. Selfhood and Authenticity 2001 Albany, NY State University of New York Press

  • ArrojoJ. FlemingD. The constructedness of gender in the cinema of Almodòvar: a case study Formations: a 21st century media studies textbook 2000 Manchester Manchester University Press 260 263

  • AshworthP. The phenomenology of the lifeworld and social psychology Social Psychological Review 2003a Vol. 5 1 18 34

  • AshworthP. An approach to phenomenological psychology: the contingencies of the lifeworld Journal of Phenomenological Psychology 2003b Vol. 34 2 145 156

  • AshworthP. Seeing oneself as a carer in the activity of caring: Attending to the lifeworld of a person with Alzheimer’s disease International Journal of Qualitative Studies on Health and Well-being 2006 1 212 225

  • AshworthP. AshworthP.ChungM. C. Introduction to the place of phenomenological thinking in the history of psychology Phenomenology and Psychological Science: Historical and Philosophical Perspectives 2010 New York Springer 11 44

  • AshworthP.ChungM. C. AshworthP.ChungM. C. Conclusion: Phenomenology and Psychological Science Phenomenology and Psychological Science: Historical and Philosophical Perspectives 2010 New York Springer 197 205

  • BenjaminH. Transvestism and transsexualism International Journal of Sexology 1953 7 12 14

  • BenjaminH. The Transsexual Phenomenon 1966 New York The Julian Press, Inc. Publishers Retrieved March 14 2014 from http://www.mut23.de/texte/Harry%20Benjamin%20-%20The%20Transsexual%20Phenomenon.pdf. Copyright of the electronic edition by Symposium Publishing Düsseldorf 1999.

  • BillingsD. B.UrbanT. EkinsR.KingD. The Socio-Medical Construction of Transsexualism: An interpretation and critique Blending Genders: Social Aspects of Cross-dressing and Sex-changing 1996 London Routledge 99 117

  • BinswangerL. MendelW. M.LyonsJ. MayR.AngelE.EllenbergerH. F. The case of Ellen West: An Anthropological-Clinical Study Existence 2004 Lanham, Maryland Jason Aronson Book—Rowman & Littlefield Publishers 237 364 (Original work published 1944–1945 1957).

  • BinswangerL. AngelE. BroomeM. R.HarlandR.OwenG. S.StringarisA. The existential analysis school of thought The Maudsley Reader in Phenomenological Psychiatry 2012 Cambridge Cambridge University Press 117 130 (Original work published 1946)

  • BinswangerL. Grundformen und erkenntnis menschlischen Daseins 1953 2 ed. Zürich Max Niehans

  • BinswangerL. FilippiniE. Tre forme di esistenza mancata 1992a Milan SE (Original work published 1956)

  • BinswangerL. D’IppolitoB. M. La psichiatria come scienza dell’uomo 1992b Florence Ponte alle Grazie Editori (Original work published 1957)

  • BinswangerL. BorgnaE. Delirio: Antropoanalisi e Fenomenologia 1972 Venice Marsilio Editore (Original work published 1965)

  • BossM. Saba SardiF. Perversioni sessuali: significati e contenuti 1998 Milan La biblioteca di Vivarium (Original work published 1951)

  • CampbellJ. S. J. O.I’AnsonC. Beyond Gender Essentialism and the Social Construction of Gender: Redefining the Conception of Gender Through a Reinvestigation of Transgender Theory International Studies in Philosophy 2007 Vol. 39 1 19 30

  • CarmanT. DreyfusH. L.WrathallM. A. The Concept o Authenticity A Companion To Phenomenology and Existentialism 2009 Chichester, West Sussex, UK Blackwell Publishing, Ltd. 229 239

  • CharbonneauG. La présence maniérée: approche phénoménologique des maniérés L’art du comprendre 2001 10 74 85

  • ChilandC. SlotkinP. Transsexualism: illusion and reality 2003 Middletown—CT Wesleyan University Press (Original work published 1997)

  • CipollaA.RossiL.CardoneA. MorniroliA. La prostituzione transessuale Vite clandestine: frammenti racconti e altro sulla prostituzione e la tratta di esseri umani in provincia di Napoli 2010 Naples Gesco Edizioni 77 94

  • DrescherJ.Cohen-KettenisP.WinterS. Minding the body: Situating gender identity diagnoses in the icd-11 International Review of Psychiatry 2012 24 6 568 577

  • FoucaultM. GordonC. The Confession of the Flesh Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings 1972–1977 1977/1980 New York Pantheon Books 194 228

  • FrieR. Subjectivity and intersubjectivity in modern philosophy and psychoanalysis: A study of Sartre Binswanger Lacan and Habermas 1997 Boston Rowman & Littlefield

  • FrieR. Modernism or postmodernism? Binswanger, Sullivan and the problem of agency in contemporary psychoanalysis Contemporary Psychoanalysis 2002 38 534 573

  • FrieR. FrieR. Language and subjectivity: From Binswanger through Lacan Understanding experience: Psychotherapy and postmodernism 2003 London Routledge 154 182

  • FrieR. A hermeneutics of exploration: The interpretive turn from Binswanger to Gadamer Journal of Theoretical and Philosophical Psychology 2010 30 79 93

  • GhaemiS. N. Rediscovering existential psychotherapy: the contribution of Ludwig Binswanger American Journal of Psychotherapy 2001 55 1 51 64

  • GiorgiA.GiorgiB. SmithJ. A. Phenomenology Qualitative Psychology: A practical guide to research methods 2008 2nd edn London Sage

  • GiuffridaA. Nuove identita: il genere sessuale unico Psiche—Rivista di cultura psicoanalitica 2002 X 1 101 117

  • GoffmanE. The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life 1959 New York Anchor

  • HamburgerC.StürupG. K.Dahl-IversenE. Transvestism: Hormonal Psychiatric and Surgical Treatment Journal of American Medical Association 1953 152 30 391 396

  • HegelG. W. F. BaillieJ. B. The Phenomenology of Mind 1807 London Swan Sonnenschein & Co, Limited; New York The Macmillan Company. Retrieved February 9 2014 from http://archive.org/details/cu31924097557171.

  • HeideggerM. Sein und Zeit Jahrbuch fur Philosophie und phenomenologische Forschung 1927 VIII Halle Niemeyer 1 438

  • HerdtG. Third sex third gender: beyond sexual dimorphism in culture and history 1996 New York Zone Books

  • HeylensG.ElautEKreukelsB. P. C.PaapM. C. S.CerwenkaS.Richter-AppeltH Psychiatric characteristics in transsexual individuals multicentre study in four European countries British Journal of Psychiatry 2013 204 151 156

  • HusserlE. KerstenF. Ideas Pertaining to a Pure Phenomenology and to a Phenomenological Philosophy—First Book: General Introduction to a Pure Phenomenology 1982 The Hague Nijhoff (Original work published 1913)

  • KrausA. Existential a prioris and the phenomenology of schizophrenia Dialogues in Philosophy Mental and Neuro Sciences 2010 3 1 1 7

  • LangdridgeD. Phenomenological Psychology: Theory Research and Method 2007 Harlow – Essex – (England) Pearson Education Limited

  • LawrenceA. A.ZuckerK. J. HersenMBeidelD. C. Gender identity disorders Adult Psychopathology and Diagnosis 2012 Hoboken, N.J. John Wiley & Sons 601 635

  • LevA. I. Transgender Emergence—Therapeutic Guidelines for Working with Gender-Variant People and Their Families 2004 New York – London – Oxford The Haworth Clinical Practice Press

  • MacorattiG. FasolaC. Transessuali e transgender: la costruzione di un’identità negata L’identità: l’altro come coscienza di sé 2005 Turin Utet Libreria 143 58

  • MaldineyH. Penser l’homme et la folie 1991 Grenoble Jérôme Millon

  • MarcascianoP. Favolose narranti: Storie di transessuali 2008 Rome Manifestolibri

  • Mason-SchrockD. Transsexuals’ Narrative Contruction of the ‘True Self’ Social Psychology Quarterly 1996 59 3 176 192

  • MercaderP. L’illusion transsexuelle 1994 Paris Edition L’Hartmattan

  • MurphyA. V. DreyfusH. L.WrathallM. A. Sexuality A Companion to Phenomenology and Existentialism 2009 Oxford, UK Blackwell Publishing Ltd. 489 501

  • NeedlemanJ. BinswangerL. AngioniA.BantiG. Introduzione critica all’Antropoanalisi di Ludwig Binswanger Essere nel Mondo 1973 Rome Casa Editrice Astrolabio (Original work published 1963)

  • OwenI. R. LohmarD.BrudzinskaJ. The phenomenological psychology of gender: How trans-sexuality and intersexuality express the general case of self as a cultural object Founding psychoanalysis phenomenologically: Phenomenological theory of subjectivity and the psychoanalytical experience 2012 199 Dordrecht Springer Science & Business Media 199 212 Phaenomenologica

  • PrunasA.VitelliR.AgnelloF.CurtiE.FazzariP.GianniniF.HartmannD.BiniM. Defensive functioning in MtF and FtM transsexuals Comprehensive Psychiatry 2013 55 4 966 971

  • RecalcatiM. CappaF. L’immaginario, il simbolico e il reale Tracce di Immaginario 2008 Milan Mimesis Edizioni

  • RichardsC. Transsexualism and Existentialism Existential Analysis 2011 22 2 272 279

  • RicoeurP. SavageD. Freud and philosophy: An essay on interpretation 1970 New Haven Yale University Press (Original work published 1965)

  • RovattiP. A. La filosofia può curare? La consulenza filosofica in questione 2006 Milan Raffaello Cortina Editore

  • RubinH. Phenomenology as Method in Trans Studies glq: A Journal of Lesbian and Gay Studies 1998 4 2 263 281

  • RubinH. Self-Made Men: Identity and Embodiment among Transsexual Men 2003 Nashville Vanderbilt University Press

  • SalamonG. Assuming a Body: Transgender and Rhetorics of Materiality 2010 New York Chichester, West Sussex Columbia University Press

  • SalviniA. Transessualismo e riorganizzazione della rappresentazione narrativa di sé: un punto di vista clinico Rivista di Sessuologia 1999 23 3 257 268

  • SartreJ. P. BrownA. The Transcendence of the Ego: A sketch for a phenomenological description 2004 London and New York Routledge Retrieved March 14 2014 from http://cliffordglee.com/Site/EXSupplementalReadings_files/36578062–0415320682-Jean-Pau-Sartre-The-Transcendence-of-the-Ego-a-Sketch-for-a-Phenomenological-Description-Routledge.pdf. (Original work published 1937). 2004

  • SartreJ. P. WebberJ. The Imaginary: A phenomenological Psychology of the Imagination 2004 London and New York Routledge (Original work published 1940)

  • SartreJ. P. BarnesH. E. Being and Nothingness 1956 New York Philosophical Library (Original work published 1943)

  • SartreJ. P. BarnesH. Search for a Method 1958 New York Random House 1958 (Original work published 1957)

  • SartreJ. P. PavoliniC. L’idiota della famiglia 1977 Milan Il Saggiatore II Vol (Original work published 1971)

  • SchrockD. P.ReidL. L. Transsexuals’ Sexual Stories Archives of Sexual Behavior 2006 35 1 75 86

  • SpiegelbergH. Phenomenology in Psychology and Psychiatry 1972 Evanstone Northwestern University Press

  • StollerR. J. Sex and Gender 1968 New York Science House

  • StrykerS.WhittleS. The Transgender Studies Reader 2006 New York Routledge

  • TatossianA. Dalle LucheR.Di PiazzaG. La fenomenologia delle psicosi 2003 Rome Giovanni Fioriti Editore (Original work published 1979)

  • ViganòC. Psichiatria non psichiatria: la follia nella società che cambia 2009 Rome Borla Editore

  • VitelliR.BottoneM.SisciN.ValerioP. RiglianoP.GragliaM. L’identità transessuale tra storia e clinica: quale intervento per quale domanda Gay e Lesbiche in Psicoterapia 2006 Milan Raffaello Cortina Editore 281 322

  • VitelliR.RiccardiE. Gender identity disorder and attachment theory: The influence of the patient’s Internal Working Model on psychotherapeutic engagement and objective. A study undertaking using the Adult Attachment Interview International Journal of Transgenderism 2010 12 4 241 253

  • WeissG. Body Images: Embodiment as intercorporeality 1999 New York Routledge

  • WestphalC. Die konträre Sexualempfindung Archiv für Psychiatrie 1870 2 73 108

  • World Health Organization (who) The icd-10 classification of mental and behavioural disorders: clinical descriptions and diagnostic guidelines 1992 Geneva World Health Organization

  • WrathallM.MalpasJ. Heidegger Authenticity and Modernity: Essays in Honor of Hubert L. Dreyfus Volume 1 Cambridge, MA MIT Press

  • WunenburgerJ. J. ChioreV. L’immaginario 2008 Genoa Il Nuovo Melangolo

  • ZahaviD. Subjectivity and Selfhood: Investigating the First-Person Perspective 2005 Cambridge, MA MIT Press

  • ZimmermanM. E. WrathallM.MalpasJ. The End of Authentic Selfhood in the Postmodern Age? Heidegger Authenticity and Modernity: Essas in Honor of Hubert L. Dreyfus 2000 Volume 1 Cambridge, MA MIT Press 123 148

  • ZitoE.ValerioP. Genere: femminielli. Esplorazioni antropologiche e psicologiche 2013 Naples Libreria Dante e Descartes

  • ZuckerK. ValerioP.VitelliR.RomeoR.FazzariP. Il Disturbo dell’Identità di Genere in età evolutiva Figure dell’Identità di Genere: Uno sguardo tra psicologia clinica e discorso sociale 2013 Milan Franco Angeli Editore 17 33

  • ZuckerK. J.SpitzerR. L. Was the Gender Identity Disorder of Childhood diagnosis introduced into dsm-iii as a backdoor maneuver to replace homosexuality? A historical note Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy 2005 31 31 42

  • 3

    As Peter D. Ashworth (2010) pointed out some years ago here Sartre “was arguably following a line of thought due to Husserl” (p. 27) and in particular some considerations that Husserl (1913) made in his first book of his Ideas pertaining to a pure phenomenology and a phenomenological philosophy.

  • 16

    In Dan Zahavi’s theorization (2005) this could mean that we are referring here to the ‘person’ and not to the ‘Self’.

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 67 67 23
Full Text Views 190 190 36
PDF Downloads 8 8 2
EPUB Downloads 4 4 2