A Response to the Attempted Critique of the Scientific Phenomenological Method

in Journal of Phenomenological Psychology
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


Recently, a book (details are given below) was published, the sole purpose of which was to discourage researchers from using the scientific phenomenological method. The author (Paley, 1997; 1998; 2000) had previously been critical of nurses who had used the scientific phenomenological method but in the new book he goes after the originators of different methods of scientific phenomenological research and attempts to criticize them severely. In this review I defend only the scientific phenomenological method that is strictly based upon the thought of Edmund Husserl. Given the entirely negative project of only critiquing phenomenologically grounded scientific research, one would expect the author to be sensitive to the cautions historians and philosophers of science speak about when one attempts to criticize concepts and procedures that belong to a different research community. Paley, an empiricist, uses empirical criteria to criticize phenomenological work.

Moreover, given the entirely negative project of critiquing phenomenologically grounded scientific research one would expect the author to be knowledgeable about phenomenology and the innovative research practices used by a new research community. However, (1) the author has only a thin, superficial understanding of phenomenology (e.g., it is not a technology; Paley, 2017, 109). One gets the impression that he only reads phenomenology in order to critique it. He displays an outsider’s understanding of it which means that his criticisms of it are faulty because he does not know how to think and dwell within the phenomenological framework; (2) he does not understand “discovery-oriented” research and he keeps judging such research according to criteria from the “context of verification” perspective which are the wrong criteria for “discovery-oriented” research; (3) he denigrates and reduces nursing research strategies because he interprets them to be based on pragmatic motivations only. He does not even grant that nurses can have authentic scientific motivations for seeking phenomenologically based methods; (4) he uses unfair rhetorical strategies in the sense that he uses strategies himself that he criticizes when others use them. The review below documents what has been summarized here.

A Response to the Attempted Critique of the Scientific Phenomenological Method

in Journal of Phenomenological Psychology



BinetA., 'La peur chez les enfants' (1895) 2 Année Psychologique: 223-254.

BrentanoF.RancurelloA.TerrellD.B.McAlisterL.L., Psychology from an empirical standpoint, (Humanities Press, New York 1973) (German original 1874)..

BrentanoF.MüllerB., Descriptive psychology, (Routledge, New York 2006) (German original 1982)..

CattellJ. McK, 'Psychometrische Untersuchungen' (1886) 3 Philosophical Studies: 305452-336492.

CrottyM., Phenomenology and nursing research, (Churchill Livingstone, Melbourne 1996).

DiltheyW., 'Ideas concerning a descriptive and analytic psychology', in R.M. Zaner and K.L. Hughes (eds), Descriptive psychology and historical understanding, (Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague 1977) (German original 1894)..

FeyerabendP., Against method, (N.J. Humanities Press, Atlantic Highlands 1975).

GiorgiA., 'Phenomenology and experimental psychology i' (1965) 5 Review of Existential Psychology and Psychiatry: 228-238.

GiorgiA., 'Phenomenology and experimental psychology ii' (1966) 6 Review of Existential Psychology and Psychiatry: 37-50.

GiorgiA., Psychology as a human science: A phenomenologically based approach, (Harper & Row, New York 1970).

GiorgiA., 'The “Context of Discovery/Context of Verification” Distinction and Descriptive Human Science' (1986) 17 Journal of Phenomenological Psychology: 151-166.

GiorgiA., 'The Status of Husserlian Phenomenology in Nursing Research' (2000) 2000(14) Scandinavian Journal of Caring Science: 3-10.

GiorgiA., 'Concerning the Application of Phenomenology to Nursing Research' (2000a) 14 Scandinavian Journal of Caring Science: 11-31.

GiorgiA., The descriptive phenomenological method in psychology: A modified Husserlian approach, (Duquesne University Press, Pittsburgh PA 2009).

GiorgiA., 'Phenomenology and the Practice of Science' (2010) 21(1) Existential Analysis: 3-22.

GiorgiA., 'ipa and Science: A Response to Jonathan Smith' (2011) 42 Journal of Phenomenological Psychology: 195-216.

HansonN.R., Patterns of discovery, (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1965).

HeideggerM., Being and time, (Harper and Row, New York 1962) (German original 1927)..

HopkinsB.C., The philosophy of Husserl, (Mc-Gill-Queen’s University Press, Montreal 2010).

HumphreyG., Thinking: An introduction to its experimental psychology, (John Wiley & sons, New York 1963).

HusserlE.LauerQ., 'Philosophy as a Rigorous Science', in Q. Lauer (ed), Phenomenology and the crisis of Philosophy, (Harper Torch Books, New York 1965) 71-148 (German original 1911)..

HusserlE.FindlayJ., Logical investigations. Two volumes, (Humanities Press, New York 1970) (German original 1900)..

HusserlE.CarrD., The crisis of European sciences and transcendental phenomenology, (Northwestern University Press, Evanston IL 1970a) (German original 1954)..

HusserlE.ScanlonJ., Phenomenological psychology: Lectures Summer Semester; 1925, (Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague 1977) (German original 1962)..

HusserlE.PalmerR.E., '“Phenomenology” Edmund Husserl’s Article for the Encyclopedia Britannica (1927)' (1981) Husserl: Shorter works Notre Dame in & Brighton England. The University of Notre Dame Press & Harvester Press. (German original written 1927; first published 1962)..

HusserlE.KerstenF., Ideas pertaining to a pure phenomenology and to a phenomenological philosophy. First book, (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, The Hague 1983) (German original 1913)..

HusserlE.RojcewiczR.SchuwerA., Ideas pertaining to a pure phenomenology and to a phenomenological philosophy: Second Book, (Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht 1989) (German Original 1952)..

KockelmansJ., Phenomenological psychology: The Dutch school, (M. Nijhoff, Dordrecht 1987).

KraussL.M., 'The Universe: ‘The Important Stuff is Invisible’' (2016) Vol. LXIII(4) The New York Review of Books, March.

KuhnT., The structure of scientific revolutions, (University of Chicago Press, Chicago IL 1962).

KuhnT., 'Second Thoughts on Paradigms', in T. Kuhn (ed), The essential tension, (University of Chicago Press, Chicago IL 1977) 293-319.

KuhnT., The structure of scientific revolutions, (University of Chicago Press, Chicago 2012).

LakatosI., J. Worral and G Currie (eds), The methodology of scientific research programmes, (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1978).

LeveringB.van ManenM., 'Phenomenological anthropology in the Netherlands and Flanders', in T. Tymeniecka (ed), Phenomenology world-wide, (Kluwer Press, Dordrecht 2002) 274-286.

LinschotenJ., Idolen van de psycholoog, (Bijleveld, Utrecht 1964).

LumengJ.C.PatilN.BlassE.M., 'Social influences on formula intake via suckling in 7 to 14 week-old-infants' (2007) 49(4) Developmental psychobiology: 351-361.

MaxwellJ.A., 'Designing a Qualitative Study', in L. Bickman and D.J. Rog (eds), Handbook of Applied Social Research Methods, (Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks CA 1998) 69-100.

Merleau-PontyM.SmithC., Phenomenology of perception, (Humanities Press, New York 1962) (French original 1945)..

MohantyJ.N., Edmund Husserl’s theory of meaning, (M. Nijhoff, The Hague 1969).

NorlykA.HarderI., 'What Makes a Phenomenological Study Phenomenological? An Analysis of Peer-Reviewed Empirical Nursing Studies' (2010) 20(3) Advancing Qualitative Methods: 420-431.

PaleyJ., 'Husserl, Phenomenology and Nursing' (1997) 26 Journal of Advanced Nursing: 187-193.

PaleyJ., 'Misinterpretive phenomenology: Heidegger, ontology and nursing research' (1998) 27(4) Journal of Advanced Nursing: 817-824.

PaleyJ., 'Against Meaning' (2000) 1 Nursing Philosophy: 109-120.

PaleyJ., 'Phenomenology as Rhetoric' (2005) 12(2) Nursing Inquiry: 106-116.

PaleyJ., 'Heidegger, Lived Experience and Method' (2014) 70(7) Journal of Advanced nursing: 1520-1531.

PaleyJ., Phenomenology as Qualitative research: A Critical Analysis of Meaning Attribution, (Routledge, London 2017).

S.P. Parker (ed), McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific and Technical Terms, (McGraw-Hill Inc., New York 1994).

PopperK., The logic of scientific discovery, (Hutchinson & Co., London 1959).

PopperK., Conjectures and refutations: The growth of scientific knowledge, (Routledge & Kegan Paul, London 1963).

ReichenbachH., Experience and prediction, (University of Chicago Press, Chicago IL 1961) (Original Publication 1938)..

SartreJ-P.BarnesH, Being and nothingness, (Philosophical Library, New York 1956) (French original 1943)..

ScanlonJ.ScanlonJ., 'Translator’s Introduction', in Edmund Husserl: Phenomenological psychology: Lectures Summer semester; 1925, (Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague 1977) (German original 1962)..

SchützA., M. Natanson (ed), Collected papers I, (Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague 1962) (Papers originally published in various journals 1942–55)..

SpiegelbergH., 'Phenomenology through vicarious experience', in E. Straus (ed), Phenomenology: Pure and applied, (Duquesne University Press, Pittsburgh PA 1964) 105-126.

SpiegelbergH., K. Schuhmann (ed), The phenomenological movement, (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, The Hague 1982).

SpiegelbergH., 'Putting ourselves into the place of others: Toward a phenomenology of imagining self-transposal', in H. Spiegelberg (ed), Steppingstones toward an ethics for fellow-existers: Essays 1944–1983, (Martinus Nijhoff, Dordrecht 1986) 99-104.

ToulminS., Foresight and understanding, (Harper & Row, New York 1961).

Van ManenM., 'The Utrecht School: A Phenomenological Experiment in Educational Theorizing' (1979) 10(No. 1) The Journal of educational policy studies.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 54 54 36
Full Text Views 23 23 23
PDF Downloads 2 2 2
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0