Gender Violence and the Price of Virginity: Theory and Evidence of Incomplete Marriage Contracts
In: Journal of Religion and DemographySearch for other papers by Daniel L. Chen in
Current site
Google Scholar
Abstract
This paper builds and tests a model of marriage as an incomplete contract that arises from asymmetric virginity premiums and examines whether this can lead to social inefficiencies. Contrary to the efficient households hypothesis, women cannot prevent being appropriated by men once they enter marriage if they command lower marriage market opportunities upon divorce. Because men cannot or do not commit to compensating women for their lower ex post marriage market opportunities, marriage is an incomplete contract. Men may seek to lower women’s ex ante “market wages” in order to induce entry into joint production. Inefficient or abusive marriages are less likely to separate. Equalizing virginity premiums may reduce domestic and non-domestic violence.
Female circumcision and prices women pay doctors to appear virgin before marriage in many countries suggest asymmetric virginity premiums continue to exist. Evidence from China and the US suggest asymmetric virginity premiums persist over economic development. Asymmetric virginity premiums are strongly positively correlated with female but not male virginity premiums. I use variation in religious upbringing to help estimate the effect of virginity premiums on gender violence in the US. The OLS relationship between virginity premiums and female reports of forced sex may be biased downwards if shame is associated with abuse and this shame is greater for women with higher virginity premiums. But the OLS relationship for males might not be biased downwards. Asymmetric virginity premiums are positively correlated with men forcing sex on women and paying women for sex. The model complements a growing empirical literature on inefficient households and human rights abuses, visible manifestations of female appropriability across time and space.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Aizer, Anna and Pedra Bo (2004), “Love, Hate and Murder: Commitment Devices in Violent Relationships,” Brown University mimeo.
-
Altman, Lawrence. (2004), “Study Finds that Teenage Virginity Pledges Are Rarely Kept,” New York Times, March 10.
-
Aries, P. and Georges Duby. (1992), A History of Private Life, Vol 1–5, Harvard University Press.
-
Assessoria Especial Das Delegacias De Defesa Da Mulher Do Estado De São Paulo, General Statistics, 1989.
-
Bearman, Peter S. and Hannah Bruckner (2001), “Promising the Future: Virginity Pledges and First Intercourse,” American Journal of Sociology, 106(4), 859–912.
-
Becker, Gary. (1991), A Treatise on the Family, Harvard University Press.
-
Bedard, K. and O. Deschenes (2003), “Sex Preferences, Marital Dissolution, and the Economic Status of Women.” Unpublished working paper 6–03, University of California-Santa Barbara, Santa Barbara.
-
Bernheim, Douglas, Carman, K., Kotlikoff, L J, and Novarro, N. (2004), “How Do Widowhood and Divorce Affect Economic-Well Being? Evidence from the Health and Retirement Survey,” Stanford University mimeo.
-
Bernstein, Nina (2004), “More Teenagers are Striving for Restraint,” New York Times, March 7.
-
Bloch, Francis and Vijayendra Rao, ”Terror as Bargaining Instrument: A Case-Study of Dowry Violence in Rural India,” American Economic Review, September 2002.
-
Botticini, M. and A. Siow, (2002), “Why Dowries”, American Economic Review.
-
Bowlus, Audra J. and Shannon N. Seitz (2002), “Domestic Violence, Employment and Divorce,” Queen’s University mimeo.
-
Caballero, R. and M. Hammour (1998), “The Macroeconomics of Specificity,” Journal of Political Economy 106(4), 724–767.
-
Chen, Daniel L. (2004), “Club Goods and Group Identity: Evidence from Islamic Resurgence During the Indonesian Financial Crisis,” University of Chicago mimeo.
-
Chen, Daniel L. (2004), “Does Religious Intensity Cause Social Violence?” University of Chicago mimeo.
-
Chiappori, Pierre A. and Yoram Weiss (2003), “Marriage Contracts and Divorce: an Equilibrium Analysis,” University of Chicago mimeo.
-
Choi, Sue Yeon (1998), “Restoring Virginity,” Berkeley Medical Journal.
-
Connolly, Ceci. “Texas Teaches Abstinence, With Mixed Grades,” Washington Post.
-
Constable, Pamela (2003), “Beset Afghan Girls’ Schools,” Washington Post, September 8.
-
Crittenden, Ann (2001), The Price of Motherhood: Why the Most Important Job in the World is Still the Least Valued. Metropolitan Books.
-
Denizet-Lewis, Benoit (2004), “Friends, Friends With Benefits and the Benefits of the Local Mall,” New York Times, May 30.
-
Drumm, Rene D., M. Popescu, J. Wrenn, and D. McBride (2004), “Abuse Issues in a Conservative Christian Denomination: How Similar are Congregants in Diverse Regions?” Andrews University mimeo.
-
Duby, Georges and Michelle Perrot eds. (1994), A History of Women, Vol 1–5, Harvard University Press.
-
Duflo, Esther and Chris Udry (2003), “Intrahousehold Resource Allocation in Cote D’Ivoire: Social Norms, Separate Accounts and Consumption Choices,” Yale University Economic Growth Center Discussion Paper No. 857.
-
Edlund, Lena, (1999), “Son preference, sex ratios, and marriage patterns”, Journal of Political Economy.
-
Epstein, H. “The Fidelity Fix” New York Times, June 13, 2004
-
Epstein, Louis M. (1973), The Jewish People: The Jewish Marriage Contract. Arno Press, New York.
-
Evans, Thomas. (2004), “Religion and Charitable Giving,” University of Illinois mimeo.
-
Feng, W., & Wang, F. (2001). One Quarter of Humanity: Malthusian Mythology and Chinese Realities, 1700–2000. Harvard University Press.
-
Field, Erica (2004), “The Consequences of Early Marriage in Bangladesh,” Harvard University mimeo.
-
Filkins, Dexter (2003), “‘Honor Killings’ Defy Turkish Efforts to End Them,” New York Times, July 13.
-
Fisman, Raymond, Sheena Iyengar, Emir Kamenica, and Itamar Simonson, (2004), “Searching for a Mate: Theory and Experimental Evidence,” Columbia University mimeo.
-
French, Howard W. (2003), “Victims Say Japan Ignores Sex Crimes Committed by Teachers,” New York Times.
-
Glaeser, Edward L., and Bruce I. Sacerdote, (2008), “Education and religion.” Journal of Human Capital 2.2: 188–215.
-
Goody, Jack ed. (1973), Character of Kinship, Cambridge University Press.
-
Goody, Jack (1983), The Development of Family and Marriage in Europe, Cambridge University Press.
-
Goody, Jack (1976), Production and Reproduction, Cambridge University Press.
-
Heise, L., Pitanguy, J., & Germain, A. (1994). Violence Against Women: The Hidden Health Burden. World Bank discussion papers, 255.
-
Holden, Karen and Smock, Pamela J. (1991), “The Economic Costs of Marital Dissolution: Why do Women Bear a Disproportionate Cost?” Annual Review of Sociology, 1991, 17: 51–78.
-
Hotchkiss, J. and M. Melinda Pitts (2003), “At What Level of Labor-Market Intermittency are Women Penalized?” American Economic Review.
-
Kahn, Joseph and J. Yardley (2004), “Amid China’s Boom, No Helping Hand for Young Qingming,” New York Times, August 1.
-
Kandela, Peter (1996), “Egypt’s Trade in Hymen Repair,” Lancet, Vol 347, No 9015.
-
Kew, Melissa (2004), “Unwanted Sexual Activity Among Married Women in Urban China,” University of Chicago mimeo.
-
Kristof, Nicholas D. (2004), “Beaten Afghan Brides,” New York Times, October 6.
-
Kristof, Nicholas D. (2004), “Sentenced to be Raped,” New York Times, September 29.
-
Lakhani, Arif (2004), “The Price of Honor,” South Asian Journal, Harvard University.
-
Laumann, Edward O., John H. Gagnon, Robert T. Michael, and Stuart Michaels (1994), The Social Organization of Sexuality in the United States. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
-
Laumann, Edward O., Steven Ellingson, Jenna Mahay, Anthony Paik, and Yoosik Youm. (2004), The Sexual Organization of the City. University of Chicago Press.
-
Laumann, E. O., Michael, R. T., Michaels, S., & Gagnon, J. H. (2000). Sex, Love, and Health: Private Choices and Public Policies.
-
Michael, Robert T., John H. Gagnon, Edward O. Laumann, and Gina Kolata. (1995), Sex in America: A Definitive Survey. Boston: Little, Brown.
-
Nicolo, Antonio and Piero Tedeschi (2003), “Incomplete Contracts as Strategic Device: Applications to Nuptial and Partnership Agreements,” U of Padua mimeo.
-
Nussbaum, Martha (1996), “Double Moral Standards?” Boston Review.
-
Onishi, Norimitsu (2003), “Divorce in South Korea: Striking a New Attitude,” New York Times, September 21.
-
Oriang, Lucy (2003), “It’s a Craze We’re Going Through,” Daily Nation on the Web, The East African, November 21.
-
Pan, Philip. “Forbidden Love Challenges Rules in China,” Washington Post Foreign Service.
-
Pezzini, Slvia (2003), “The Effect of Women’s Rights on Women’s Welfare: Evidence from a Natural Experiment,” LSE mimeo.
-
Posner, Richard (1992), Sex and Reason, Harvard University Press.
-
Rangel, Marcos (2004), “Alimony Rights and Intra-Household Allocation of Resources: Evidence from Brazil,” UCLA mimeo.
-
Rasul, Imran (2004), “Household Bargaining over Fertility: Theory and Evidence from Malaysia,” University of Chicago mimeo.
-
Rhode, Deborah L. (1999), Speaking of Sex: The Denial of Gender Inequality. Harvard University Press.
-
Rubinger, Maria, et. al., Crimes Contra A Mulher, Introduction.
-
Scheffler, Mark (2004), “So, How’s Your Sex Life?” Chicago Tribune Magazine, November 14, 2004.
-
Seattle Times, http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/news/nation-world/html98/honr06_20000706.html.
-
Segal, Ilya (1999), “Complexity and Renegotiation: A Foundation for Incomplete Contracts,” Review of Economic Studies, 66, 57–82.
-
Silverman, Jay (2001), “Dating Violence Against Adolescent Girls and Associated Substance Use, Unhealthy Weight Control, Sexual Risk Behavior, Pregnancy, and Suicidality,” Journal of the American Medical Association.
-
Stevenson, Betsey and J. Wolfers (2003), “Til Death Do Us Part: The Effects of Divorce Laws on Suicide, Domestic Violence and Intimate Homicide,” NBER Working Paper 10175.
-
Waite, Linda (2000), The Case for Marriage, Doubleday.
-
Women’s Rights Project (Human Rights Watch). (1998). The Human Rights Watch Global Report on Women’s Human Rights. Oxford University Press.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 894 | 457 | 88 |
| Full Text Views | 234 | 5 | 2 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 266 | 10 | 5 |
Gender Violence and the Price of Virginity: Theory and Evidence of Incomplete Marriage Contracts
In: Journal of Religion and DemographySearch for other papers by Daniel L. Chen in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Abstract
This paper builds and tests a model of marriage as an incomplete contract that arises from asymmetric virginity premiums and examines whether this can lead to social inefficiencies. Contrary to the efficient households hypothesis, women cannot prevent being appropriated by men once they enter marriage if they command lower marriage market opportunities upon divorce. Because men cannot or do not commit to compensating women for their lower ex post marriage market opportunities, marriage is an incomplete contract. Men may seek to lower women’s ex ante “market wages” in order to induce entry into joint production. Inefficient or abusive marriages are less likely to separate. Equalizing virginity premiums may reduce domestic and non-domestic violence.
Female circumcision and prices women pay doctors to appear virgin before marriage in many countries suggest asymmetric virginity premiums continue to exist. Evidence from China and the US suggest asymmetric virginity premiums persist over economic development. Asymmetric virginity premiums are strongly positively correlated with female but not male virginity premiums. I use variation in religious upbringing to help estimate the effect of virginity premiums on gender violence in the US. The OLS relationship between virginity premiums and female reports of forced sex may be biased downwards if shame is associated with abuse and this shame is greater for women with higher virginity premiums. But the OLS relationship for males might not be biased downwards. Asymmetric virginity premiums are positively correlated with men forcing sex on women and paying women for sex. The model complements a growing empirical literature on inefficient households and human rights abuses, visible manifestations of female appropriability across time and space.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 894 | 457 | 88 |
| Full Text Views | 234 | 5 | 2 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 266 | 10 | 5 |
