Religious in Form, Socialist in Content: Socialist Narratives and the Question of Civil Religion

in Journal of Religion in Europe
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Socialist narratives have a long history of being interpreted as religious in content and form. Scholars draw on concepts such as ‘political religion,’ ‘secular religion,’ and ‘civil religion’ to describe an alleged world-transcending quality of socialism. These concepts possess, however, normative implications since they often suggest a difference from ‘true’ or ‘real’ religion. The following article does not select a specific definition to confirm or repudiate the alleged character of socialism as a civil religion; nor will it suggest another term to describe this character more appropriately. Instead, it addresses the as-religion reflex evidenced in such acts of classification themselves by asking the question: what are the aesthetic conditions for a political system to be perceived as religious? By analysing various implementation strategies of the German Democratic Republic’s master narrative—captured in the motto “socialism will triumph”—this paper examines the narrative structures through which real socialism produced meaning. Literary-aesthetic analysis reveals that meaning and relevance were created through a carefully selected set of literary patterns. These patterns can induce the as-religion reflex even when the narrative content is considered to be secular. Reflections and analytical differentiations of form and content prove crucial to classifying narratives as expressions of civil religion.

Religious in Form, Socialist in Content: Socialist Narratives and the Question of Civil Religion

in Journal of Religion in Europe

Sections

References

BöhmeAnna KatharinaChallenging Englishness: Rebranding and Rewriting National Identity in Contemporary English Fiction” (PhD diss. Justus Liebig University Giessen2014). http://geb.uni-giessen.de/geb/volltexte/2014/10515/ (accessed 25 February 2016).

CasanovaJoséPublic Religions in the Modern World (Chicago: University of Chicago Press1994).

ClarkKaterinaThe Soviet Novel: History as Ritual (Chicago & London: University of Chicago Press1981).

ComtesseDagmarZivilreligion (Rousseau)” in: SchmidtThomas M. & PitschmannAnnette (eds.) Religion und Säkularisierung: Ein interdisziplinäres Handbuch (Stuttgart: J. B. Metzler2014) 7789.

de ManHendrikZur Psychologie des Sozialismus (Jena: Diederichs1927).

Deutsche Demokratische RepublikGesetz über das einheitliche sozialistische Bildungssystem” 25 February 1965. http://www.verfassungen.de/de/ddr/schulgesetz65.htm (accessed 23 December 2015).

DobrenkoEvgenySocialist Realism” in: DobrenkoEvgeny & BalinaMarina (eds.) The Cambridge Companion to Twentieth-century Russian Literature (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press2011) 97113.

EmmerichWolfgangKleine Literaturgeschichte der ddr (Berlin: AtV2000).

ErllAstridKollektives Gedächtnis und Erinnerungskulturen: Eine Einführung (Stuttgart & Weimar: J. B. Metzler2011).

ErllAstridMemory in Culture trans. by YoungSara B. (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan2011).

FeldtLauraThe Literary Aesthetics of Religious Narratives: Probing Literary-aesthetic Form and Sensory Effects in Exodus 7–11” in: GrieserAlexandra & JohnstonJay (eds.) The Sensory Sacred: Aesthetics as a Connective Concept (Berlin: Walter de Gruyter forthcoming).

FluckWinfriedWhy We Need Fiction: Reception Aesthetics, Literary Anthropology, Funktionsgeschichte” in: BiegerLaura & VoelzJohannes (eds.) Winfried Fluck: Romance with America? Essays on Culture Literature and American Studies (Heidelberg: Universitätsverlag Winter2009) 365384.

GrieserAlexandraAesthetics” in: SegalRobert & von StuckradKocku (eds.) Vocabulary for the Study of Religion (Leiden & Boston: Brill2016) vol. 11423.

GroysBorisUtopian Mass Culture” in: GroysBoris & HolleinMax (eds.) Traumfabrik Kommunismus: Die visuelle Kultur der Stalinzeit / Dream Factory Communism: The Visual Culture of the Stalin Era (Ostfildern-Ruit: Hatje Cantz2003) 2037.

GuskiAndreasSozialistischer Realismus und russische Avantgarde im historischen Kontext” in: PiechottaHans JoachimWuthenowRaph-Rainer & RothemannSabine (eds.) Formationen der literarischen Avantgarde vol. 2Die literarische Moderne in Europa (Opladen: Westdeutscher Verlag1994) 4052.

GutkinIrinaThe Cultural Origins of the Socialist Realist Aesthetic: 1890–1934 (Evanston: Northwestern University Press1999).

HaseThomasZivilreligion: Religionswissenschaftliche Überlegungen zu einem theoretischen Konzept am Beispiel der usa (Würzburg: Ergon2001).

HastedtReginaDie Tage mit Sepp Zach (Berlin: Verlag Tribüne1960).

HermanDavidNarrative Ways of Worldmaking” in: HeinenSandra & SommerRoy (eds.) Narratology in the Age of Cross-Disciplinary Narrative Research (Berlin & New York: de Gruyter2009) 7188.

IserWolfgangThe Act of Reading: A Theory of Aesthetic Response (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press1980).

IserWolfgangThe Fictive and the Imaginary: Charting Literary Anthropology (Baltimore & London: Johns Hopkins University Press1993).

JägerAndreaSozialistischer Realismus” in: OpitzMichael & HofmannMichael (eds.) Metzler Lexikon ddr-Literatur (Stuttgart: J. B. Metzler2009) 319322.

JamesWilliamThe Varieties of Religious Experience: A Study in Human Nature (London & New York: Routledge2004 [1902]).

KirschAnjaWeltanschauung als Erzählkultur: Zur Konstruktion von Religion und Sozialismus in Staatsübrgerkundeschulüchern der ddr (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht2016).

KnepperTimothyIneffability” in: SegalRobert A. & von StuckradKocku (eds.) Vocabulary for the Study of Religion (Leiden & Boston: Brill2015) vol. 2244245.

KochHansDie Ausbildung der ästhetisch-künstlerischen Erlebnisfähigkeit der sozialistischen PersönlichkeitPädagogik 28/2 (1973) 351357.

KorffGottfriedPersonenkult und Kultpersonen: Bemerkungen zu profanen ‘Heiligenverehrung’ im 20. Jahrhundert” in: KerberWalter (ed.) Personenkult und Heiligenverehrung (München: Kindt1997) 157183.

KrementsovNikolaiRevolutionary Experiments: The Quest for Immortality in Bolshevik Science and Fiction (Oxford: Oxford University Press2014).

KulaMarcinCommunism as ReligionTotalitarian Movements and Political Religions 6/3 (2005) 371381.

LachmannRenateMnemonic and Intertextual Aspects of Literature” in: ErllAstrid & NünningAnsgar (eds.) Cultural Memory Studies: An International and Interdisciplinary Handbook (Berlin & New York: de Gruyter2008) 301310.

LauerReinhardGeschichte der russischen Literatur: Von 1700 bis zur Gegenwart (Munich: Beck2000).

LaustsenCarsten B.Studying Politics and Religion: How to Distinguish Religious Politics, Civil Religion, Political Religion, and Political TheologyJournal of Religion in Europe 6/4 (2013) 428463.

LöwithKarlWeltgeschichte und Heilsgeschehen: Die theologischen Voraussetzungen der Geschichtsphilosophie (Stuttgart: Kohlhammer1961).

McCutcheonRussell T.The Discipline of Religion: Structure Meaning Rhetoric (New York & London: Routledge2003).

MünklerHerfriedAntifaschismus als Gründungsmythos der ddr: Abgrenzungsinstrument nach Westen und Herrschaftsmittel nach Innen” in: Konrad Adenauer Stiftung e.V. (ed.) Der Antifaschismus als Staatsdoktrin der ddr (St. Augustin & Berlin: Konrad Adenauer Stiftung2009) 3149.

NünningAnsgarMaking Events – Making Stories – Making Worlds: Ways of Worldmaking from a Narratological Point of View” in: NünningVeraNünningAnsgar & NeumannBirgit (eds.) Cultural Ways of Worldmaking: Media and Narrative (Berlin & New York: de Gruyter2010) 191214.

NünningAnsgarWie Erzählungen Kulturen erzeugen: Prämissen, Konzepte und Perspektiven für eine kulturwissenschaftliche Narratologie” in: StrohmaierAlexandra (ed.) Kultur – Wissen – Narration: Perspektiven transdisziplinärer Erzählforschung für die Kulturwissenschaften (Bielefeld: transcript2013) 1553.

RousseauJean-JacquesDu contrat social (Paris: Gallimard1964).

RyanMarie-LaureNarrative” in: HermanDavidJahnManfred & RyanMarie-Laure (eds.) Routledge Encyclopedia of Narrative Theory (London & New York: Routledge2010) 344348.

SatjukowSilke & GriesRainer (eds.) Sozialistische Helden: Eine Kulturgeschichte von Propagandafiguren in Osteuropa und der ddr (Berlin: Chr. Links2002).

SchiederRolfCivil Religion: Die religiöse Dimension politischer Kultur (Gütersloh: Gütersloher Verlagshaus1987).

SchmidtMirko F.Reportage” in: OpitzMichael & HofmannMichael (eds.) Metzler Lexikon ddr-Literatur (Stuttgart: J. B. Metzler2009) 275276.

SchmidtThomasVom Bürger zum Werktätigen: Die arbeiterliche Zivilreligion in der ddr ” in: GärtnerChristelPollackDetlef & Wohlrab-SahrMonika (eds.) Atheismus und religiöse Indifferenz (Opladen: Leske & Budrich2003) 315336.

SchwartzMatthiasDie Erfindung des Kosmos: Zur sowjetischen Science Fiction und populärwissenschaftlichen Publizistik vom Sputnikflug bis zum Ende der Tauwetterzeit (Frankfurt am Main: Peter Lang2003).

SeghersAnnaDas Siebte Kreuz: Ein Roman aus Hitlerdeutschland (Berlin: Aufbau2001 [1942]).

SontagSusanAgainst Interpretation” in: idem Against Interpretation and Other Essays (New York: Farrar, Strauss, & Giroux1966) 4–14.

StitesRichardRevolutionary Dreams: Utopian Vision and Experimental Life in the Russian Revolution (New York & Oxford: Oxford University Press1989).

StolzFritzVerstehens- und Wirkungsverweigerung als Merkmal religiöser Texte” in: Pezzoli-OlgiatiDaria (ed.) Fritz Stolz: Religion und Rekonstruktion; Ausgewählte Aufsätze (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht2004) 4561.

ThrowerJamesMarxism-Leninism as the Civil Religion of Soviet Society: God’s Commissar (Lewiston: E. Mellen Press1992).

VoegelinEricThe Political Religions” in: HenningsenManfred (ed.) Modernity Without Restraint vol. 5The Collected Works of Eric Voegelin (Columbia & London: University of Missouri Press2000) 1973.

VukovNikolaiSecular Rituals and Political Commemorations in the gdr, 1945–1956” in: PeperkampEsther & RajtarMałgorzata (eds.) Religion and the Secular in Eastern Germany 1945 to the Present (Leiden: Brill2010) 4160.

WhiteHaydenMetahistory: The Historical Imagination in Nineteenth-century Europe (Baltimore & London: Johns Hopkins University Press1973).

3

 See respectively Rolf SchiederCivil Religion: Die religiöse Dimension politischer Kultur (Gütersloh: Gütersloher Verlagshaus1987); Carsten Bagge Laustsen “Studying Politics and Religion: How to Distinguish Religious Politics Civil Religion Political Religion and Political Theology” Journal of Religion in Europe 6/4 (2013) 428–463 at 440. The latter author also discusses four different approaches to studying the entwinement of religion and politics.

4

Laustsen“Studying Politics and Religion” 440.

7

José CasanovaPublic Religions in the Modern World (Chicago: University of Chicago Press1994) 95; James Thrower Marxism-Leninism as the Civil Religion of Soviet Society: God’s Commissar (Lewiston: E. Mellen Press 1992); Thomas Schmidt “Vom Bürger zum Werktätigen: Die arbeiterliche Zivilreligion in der ddr” in: Christel Gärtner Detlef Pollack & Monika Wohlrab-Sahr (eds.) Atheismus und religiöse Indifferenz (Opladen: Leske & Budrich 2003) 315–336.

10

Laustsen“Studying Politics and Religion” 445.

12

Hendrik de ManZur Psychologie des Sozialismus (Jena: Diederichs1927) 94–95.

13

Marcin Kula“Communism as Religion,” Totalitarian Movements and Political Religions 6/3 (2005) 371–381 at 371–372.

17

Wolfgang IserThe Act of Reading: A Theory of Aesthetic Response (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press1980). As a theorist Iser is not interested in analysing actual readings of texts. Instead he proceeds from an ideal “implied reader.” His theory of aesthetic response (Wirkungstheorie) therefore differs from other reader-response theories (Rezeptionstheorien). A concise and informative overview of the historical conditions of reader-response theory is provided by Winfried Fluck “Why We Need Fiction: Reception Aesthetics Literary Anthropology Funktionsgeschichte” in: Laura Bieger & Johannes Voelz (eds.) Winfried Fluck: Romance with America? Essays on Culture Literature and American Studies (Heidelberg: Universitätsverlag Winter 2009) 365–384 especially 365–369.

29

Reinhard LauerGeschichte der russischen Literatur: Von 1700 bis zur Gegenwart (Munich: Beck2000) 665. The concept turned out differently in the various socialist countries. In East Germany socialist realism was enforced in the context of the Bitterfelder Weg a cultural and socio-political programme promoting the development of proletarian lay art. It was implemented through the political decision of the socialist party in 1958 and was explicitly supposed to contribute to the education of the people’s worldview. The basic idea of the programme—with its slogan “Put pen to paper miner!”—was a close contact between writers and workers. The artist was to participate in the production process to better understand the worker. The Bitterfelder Weg was primarily focussed on the depiction of everyday professional life and technical development. Initially successful the initiative failed after a few years. See Wolfgang Emmerich Kleine Literaturgeschichte der ddr (Berlin: AtV 2000) 129–130. However some influential writings resulted from the movement shaping the development of literature in the gdr toward socialist realism for instance Erik Neutsch’s Trace of Stones (1964) which was later made into a film starring the famous Manfred Krug and Brigitte Reimann’s Arrival in Daily Life (1961).

30

Irina GutkinThe Cultural Origins of the Socialist Realist Aesthetic: 1890–1934 (Evanston: Northwestern University Press1999) 51.

33

Dobrenko“Socialist Realism” 103.

35

Hayden WhiteMetahistory: The Historical Imagination in Nineteenth-century Europe (Baltimore & London: Johns Hopkins University Press1973) 150.

38

WhiteMetahistory152.

43

Groys“Utopian Mass Culture” 24. Sometimes the socialist players adopted this critique and translated it into a virtue. See Lauer Geschichte 681.

46

Regina HastedtDie Tage mit Sepp Zach (Berlin: Verlag Tribüne1960) 113. The source text states: “In den nächsten Wochen arbeitete ich wie nie zuvor und abends fiel ich wie tot ins Bett. Manchmal vor dem Einschlafen lauschte ich in mich hinein. Da war etwas Neues. Ich began die Kraft zu spüren von der Hennecke und seine Genossen immer faselten. Ich war fünfundvierzeig und dachte ich sei ausgewachsen. Und nun kam das über mich. So gewaltig so überwältigend daß ich nicht wußte wohin mit mir selbst. Da schlug ich dem Adolf einmal richtig auf die Schultern. Bis ich darüber sprechen konnte das dauerte noch Jahre. Aber unser Sein entwickelte sich schneller als das Bewußtsein.” Translation by author.

51

ClarkThe Soviet Novel10. Despite some variations in narrative settings or style (see Clark’s systematisation of basic novel types in ibid. 255–260) the working-class hero was an inherent part of Eastern European narrative cultures. See Silke Satjukow & Rainer Gries (eds.) Sozialistische Helden: Eine Kulturgeschichte von Propagandafiguren in Osteuropa und der ddr (Berlin: Chr. Links 2002). The anthology contains Soviet Czech Polish and Hungarian versions of the working class-hero narrative.

53

HastedtTage167–168.

57

GutkinCultural Origins38.

59

Dobrenko“Socialist Realism” 110.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 7 7 7
Full Text Views 5 5 5
PDF Downloads 2 2 2
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0