Observations on the Blurring of the Religious and the Secular in a Japanese Urban Setting

in Journal of Religion in Japan
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Abstract

This paper presents some observations on how the borders between the religious and the secular are perceived, blurred and reinterpreted at the community level in Kyoto. These reflections are based mainly on my extended fieldwork in the city, where I participated in and took note of the activities of two chōnaikai (neighborhood associations). I also observed and examined events related to the Gion matsuri, which takes place in July and is one of the three main festivals in Japan. The neighborhood associations play a pivotal role in Kyoto’s community life, and the boundaries between the religious and the secular very often remain indistinct due to the ambiguous character of the chōnaikai. In this context, I analyze some of the religious activities within the chōnai, such as taking care of the small votive shrine dedicated to the bodhisattva Jizō, and events related to Shintō. With regard to local festivals, I explore religious and secular aspects of the Gion matsuri, an event that attracts crowds of visitors from all over Japan and abroad, which offers the opportunity to investigate the intermingling of religion and business, local government, culture and tourism.

Observations on the Blurring of the Religious and the Secular in a Japanese Urban Setting

in Journal of Religion in Japan

Sections

References

AmaToshimaro Why are the Japanese Non-Religious? 2005 Lanham University Press of America

AoyagiKiyotaka GhausAnsariNasP. “Viable Traditions in Urban Japan: Matsuri and Chonaikai Town-Talk: The Dynamics of Urban Anthropology 1983 Leiden Brill 96 111

AsahiShinbun朝日新聞 “(Gion Matsuri 09) Junkō anzen inoru, En no Gyōja yama (祇園祭09)巡行安全祈る、役行者山” 2009 7 17 28

AsahiShinbun朝日新聞 “Kyōto/Gion no maboroshi, yamahoko ato matsuri: ipponka de dai konzatsu, fukkatsu e chōshū ugoku “京都・祇園の幻、山鉾後祭―本化で大混雑、復活へ町衆動く” 2011 7 13 9

AsahiShinbun朝日新聞 “(Gion Matsuri 2011) Mori no miyako de konchikichin Gion bayashi, Sendai tanabata matsuri ni shucchō (祇園祭 2011) 杜の都でコンチキチン 祇園囃子、仙台七夕まつりに出張” 2011 8 7 35

AshkenaziMichael Matsuri: Festivals of a Japanese Town 1993 Honolulu University of Hawaii Press

Asia/Pacific Cultural Centre for UNESCO (ACCU) “Final Report of the International Partnership Programme for Safeguarding of Intangible Cultural Heritage 2009-10. 3rd Training Course for Safeguarding of Intangible Cultural Heritage.” 2009 Tokyo ACCU 17 http://www.accu.or.jp/ich/en/training/curriculum/third/pdf/2009-10TrainingCourseFinalReport.pdf (accessed 12 September 2011)

BestorTheodore C. “Tradition and Japanese Social Organization: Institutional Development in a Tokyo Neighborhood” Ethnology 1985 24 2 121 135

BestorTheodore C. Neighborhood Tokyo 1989 Stanford Stanford University Press

BodifordWilliam M. “Sōtō Zen in a Japanese Town: Field Notes on a Once-Every-Thirty-Three-Years Kannon Festival” Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 1994 21 1 3 36

BrumannChristoph “Outside the Glass Case: The Social Life of Urban Heritage in Kyoto” American Ethnologist 2009 36 2 276 299

ForfarDavid RogerGoodmanNearyIan “Individual Against the State? The Politics of Opposition to the Re-emergence of State Shintō” Case Studies on Human Rights in Japan 1996 London Routledge 245 276

FukamiShigeru深見茂氏 “Gion matsuri yamahoko gyōji no iji keishō no tame ni 祇園祭山鉾行事の維持継承のために.” [available in English. “Lecture 8: Activities for Maintaining and Succeeding Tradition of the Gion Festival Yamahoko Events.”Mukei bunka isan no shisutemu ni kansuru ichi nyūmon hen 無形文化遺産のシステムに関する一入門編 Introduction to Systems of Safeguarding ICH - UNESCO’s Convention and Law for the Protection of Cultural Properties in Japan]. 2008 1 25 Tokyo, Osaka, Kyoto ACCU http://www.accu.or.jp/ich/jp/training/curriculum/curriculum_8.html (accessed 2 September 2011)

Gion MatsuriYamahoko rengōkai祇園祭山鉾連合会 “Gienkin 1647man en, hisai bunkazai no shūfuku ni 義援金 1647 万円、被災文化財の修復に” Asahi Shinbun 2011 35 7.8.2011

Hinatani雛谷優 “‘Koto no kaze’ (113) fukkatsu naru ka yamahoko junkō ‘ato matsuri’ [rensai]” [古都の風] (113) 復活なるか山鉾巡行「後祭」(連載) Yomiuri Shinbun 読売新聞 2011 23 2011.07.24

HurNam-li Prayer and Play in Late Tokugawa Japan: Asakusa Sensōji and Edo Society 2000 Boston Harvard University Asia Center

ImamuraAnne E. Urban Japanese Housewives: At Home and in the Community 1987 Honolulu University of Hawaii Press

InoueNobutaka “A Festival with Anonymous Kami: The Kobe Matsuri” Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 1979 6 1-2 163 185

InoueNobutaka Basic Terms of Shinto 1997 http://www2.kokugakuin.ac.jp/ijcc/wp/bts/bts_o.html#o-tabisho (accessed 2 September 2011)

IshiiKenji “The Secularization of Religion in the City” Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 1986 13 2-3 193 209

IshiiKenji NoriyoshiTamaruReidDavid “Urbanization, Depopulation, and Religion” Religion in Japanese Culture: Where Living Traditions Meet a Changing World 1996 Tokyo, New York, London Kodansha International 156 170

IsomaeJun’ichi TimothyFitzgerald “The Formative Process of State Shinto in Relation to the Westernization of Japan: The Concept of ‘Religion’ and ‘Shinto’” Religion and the Secular: Historical and Colonial Formation 2007 London Equinox Publishing 93 101

KokuritsuKokkai Toshokan国立国会図書館 “The Constitution of Japan” 2003-2004 http://www.ndl.go.jp/constitution/e/etc/c01.html#s3 (accessed 10 September 2011).

KokuritsuKokkai Toshokan国立国会図書館 ItoMiyoji The Constitution of the Empire of Japan 2003-2004 http://www.ndl.go.jp/constitution/e/etc/c02.html#s2 (accessed 3 December 2011)

McMullinNeil “On Placating the God and Pacifying the Populace: The Case of the Gion ‘Goryō’ Cult” History of Religions 1988 27 3 270 293

NelsonJohn K. A Year in the Life of a Shinto Shrine 1996 Seattle and London University of Washington Press

OkamiRisa岡見理沙 “(Gion Matsuri 2011) Higashi Nihon dai shinsai no hisaichi fukkō inori yamabushi dokyō (祇園祭 2011) 東日本大震災の被災地復興祈り山伏読経” Asahi Shinbun 2011 25 17.7.2011

PlatvoetJan “The Definers Defined: Traditions in the Definition of Religion” Method & Theory in the Study of Religion 1990 2 2 180 212

PlatvoetJan JanPlatvoetMolendijkArie L. “To Define or not to Define: The Problem of the Definition of Religion” The Pragmatics of Defining Religion: Contexts Concepts and Contests 1999 Leiden Brill 245 265

ReaderIan “What Constitutes Religious Activity? (II)” Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 1991 8 4 373 376

ReaderIan “Ideology, Academic Inventions and Mystical Anthropology: Responding to Fitzgerald’s Errors and Misguided Polemics” Electronic Journal of Contemporary Japanese Studies 2004 http://www.japanesestudies.org.uk/discussionpapers/Reader.html (accessed 5 December 2011).

RoemerMichael K. “Ritual Participation and Social Support in a Major Japanese Festival” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 2007 46 2 185 200

SchnellScott The Rousing Drum: Ritual Practice in a Japanese Community 1999 Honolulu University of Hawaii Press

SteinerKurt Local Government in Japan 1965 Stanford Stanford University Press

SonodaMinoru “The Traditional Festival in Urban Society” Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 1975 2 2-3 103 136

UmemotoMayumi梅本真由美 “Meiji Jingū: 100 nen kōken sueta chinju no mori 明治神宮―100 年後見据えた鎮守の森” Asahi Shinbun 朝日新聞 2011 accessed 20 September 2011 30 15.1.2011:

WilliamsDuncan Ryūken The Other Side of Zen: A Social History of Sōtō Zen Buddhism in Tokugawa Japan 2009 Princeton Princeton University Press

YamadaPatricia “A Friend in Need: The Bodhisattva Jizō” Japanese Religions 1991 16 3 76 92

YomiuriShinbun読売新聞 “Buji o hōkoku 無事を奉告” 2011 08 01 24

9

In this regard see also Reader (1991) and the issue of whether or not inscribing ema is a religious activity. Moreover phenomena such as praying before the Jizō-dō or taking care of the votive shrine may make sense within the interpretative framework offered by Jan Platvoet who defines religion as a communication process between the “believers as empirical persons and putative ‘unseen beings’ whom the believers accept as real persons” (Platvoet 1999: 262). He speaks in this regard of “beings whose existence and activity cannot be verified or falsified but whom the believers believe to exist and to be active directly or indirectly in their lives and environment” (Platvoet 1990: 195). In this regard see for instance the suffix -san/-sama added to Jizō or Kannon which makes such “unseen beings” to some extent ‘real.’ In addition I would avoid speculating whether people actually think they are acting religiously when they ring the bell of a temple or a shrine or offer coins in order for us to decide whether or not these acts are religious. This approach is not only unnecessary for our analysis of religious phenomena in my view but also is not suitable to the work of scholars of religions who should investigate the observable world and not assess “non-perceptible realm(s)” (Platvoet 1990: 185).

26

For example in 2011during the first three days in January the Meiji Jingū in Tokyo was visited by 3.2 million people (see Umemoto 2011: 30). In Kyoto the most visited shrine is Fushimi Inari Taisha in the southern part of the city. These visits seem to involve in particular major shrines and do not necessarily mean that Shintō institutions are flourishing as Reader has also underlined (in this issue).

Figures

  • View in gallery
    Buddhist priest holding a religious function during Jizōbon in Kyoto (photo by author).
  • View in gallery
    The Yasaka Jinja o-tabisho on Shijō Street (photo by author).

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 27 27 12
Full Text Views 15 15 8
PDF Downloads 7 7 5
EPUB Downloads 1 1 0