The Threat to “Un-Moderate”: Moroccan Islamists and the Arab Spring

in Middle East Law and Governance
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Across the Islamic world, Islamist groups have chosen to join popular protests stemming from the 2011 Arab Spring. In Morocco, however, an exception emerged. The country’s main Islamist opposition political party – the Justice and Development Party (hizb al-a’dala wa al-tanmia) – declined invitations to join demonstrations organized by the February 20th Movement for Change. Under what conditions do Islamist movements support Arab Spring uprisings? Why did the PJD choose to stay outside these protests demanding greater reform? The PJD, some scholars argue, did not support Arab Spring unrest because it is a co-opted Islamist movement. In contrast, I argue that the PJD refused to join the protests because it thought it could leverage them to its advantage. By threatening the Moroccan regime to leave formal party politics for the street, the Islamist party used the unrest to increase its bargaining power, sideline its rivals, and win its policy demands. This threat to “un-moderate” empowered the PJD to get what it wanted from the regime during the Arab Spring.

The Threat to “Un-Moderate”: Moroccan Islamists and the Arab Spring

in Middle East Law and Governance

Sections

References

2)

Scott Shane“Islamist Group is Poised to Be Power in Egypt, But its Intentions are Unclear,” New York TimesFebruary 4 2011 8.

3)

Robert Worth“Jordanians Go to Polls Under Cloud of a Boycott,” New York TimesNovember 10 2010 14.

4)

Ethan Bronner“Jordan Faces a Rising Tide of Unrest, but few Expect a Revolt,” New York TimesFebruary 5 2011 8.

5)

Mark Vilensky“Tunisia’s Prime Minister Calls it a Day,” New York Times Magazinehttp://nymag.com/daily/intel/2011/02/tunisia_1.html

11)

Ellen LustStructuring Conflict in the Arab World: Incumbents Opponents and Institutions (New York: Cambridge University Press2005) 38-60.

12)

Thierre Fabre“Roi du Maroc et du Business,” Challengesissue 303 May 31 2012 60-61.

16)

John EntelisIslam Democracy and the State in North Africa (Bloomington: Indiana University Press1997) 53.

18)

Lust 2005. Ibid. 59-60.

20)

Russell E. Lucas“Monarchical Authoritarianism: Survival and Political Liberalization in a Middle Eastern Regime Type,” International Journal of Middle East Studies1 (February 2004) 108.

22)

Jason Brownlee“The Muslim Brothers: Egypt’s Most Influential Pressure Group,” History Compass (May 2010) 425-427.

23)

Kurt Weyland“The Arab Spring: Why the Surprising Similarities with the Revolutionary Wave of 1848?” Perspectives on Politics10:04 (December 2012) 2.

26)

Carrie Rosefsky Wickham“Strategy and Learning in the Formation of Egypt’s Wasat Party,” Comparative Politics36 (2004) 211-214.

27)

Jillian SchwedlerFaith in Moderation (New York: Cambridge University Press2006).

28)

Michaelle BrowersPolitical Ideology in the Arab World: Accommodation and Transformation (New York: Cambridge University Press2009).

29)

Mohammed HafezWhy Muslims Rebel (New York: Lynne Rienner Publishers2003).

32)

James D. Morrow“Alliances: Why Write Them Down?” Annual Review of Political Science 3 (2000): 78-79. Also: James D. Morrow “Alliances and Asymmetry” American Journal of Political Science 35 (1991) 904-933.

34)

Willis 1999Ibid. 46.

37)

Bilal Talidi 2008a. Ibid. 119-121

38)

Abdelilah Benkiraneal-harakat al-islamiyya wa ishkaaliat al-manhaj (Casablanca: al-najah al-jadid Publishers1999) 29

39)

Saadeddine Othmani“fi al-syiaasa al-shara’ia” al-fourqaan (1986): 2.

40)

Fred Halliday“Tunisia’s Uncertain Future,” Middle East Report 163 (1990): 26.

43)

Michael Willis“Morocco’s Islamists and the Legislative Elections of 2002: The Strange Case of the Party that Did Not Want to Win,” Mediterranean Politics 9 (2004): 60-63.

46)

Yatim et. al. 2006. Ibid. 34-35.

47)

In the 1990sthe regime tapped Khatib to host secret peace negotiations at his home between an advisor of Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin and Hamas leader Khalid Mashil. See: Sabah “Laqa tarikhi bayna mustashaar yitzhak rabin wa khalid mishal bibayt khatib” July 16 2012 1.

48)

According to Ellen Lust (2005) we could consider this a transition from outside to inside the regime’s structure of contestation (pp. 38-48).

49)

Amr Hamzawy“Party for Justice and Development in Morocco: Participation and Its Discontents,” Carnegie Papers 93 (2008): 20.

51)

Abdelgan Belout“Benkirane yataras al-moutamir al-jahoui al-thaani lihizb al-adala wa al-tanmia,” at-Tajdid965 July 5 2004 1.

53)

Eva Wegner and Miquel Pellicer“The Moroccan Justice and Development Party in Local Government: Do Islamists Govern Differently?” Robert Schuman Centre For Advanced Studies (2009): 17-18. Andrew Watrous “Islamist Participation in Alliance-Building at the Sub-National Level in Morocco” Fulbright Moroccan Studies Symposium Presentation (2010).

62)

Farid Boussaid“The Rise of the PAM in Morocco: Trampling the Political Scene or Stumbling into it?” Mediterranean Politics 14 (2009). Kevin Köhler “All the King’s Men: The Emergence of the Authenticity and Modernity Party (PAM) in Morocco” IPRIS Maghreb Review 6 (2010): 1-2.

63)

Mustapha Sehimi“La Grande Peur,” Maroc Hebdo InternationalFebruary 24 2011 21.

64)

Reda Dalil“Les Fous du Phosphate,” Le TempsJuly 23 2011 19-21.

65)

Younes Adam“Mouvement du 20 Février: Qui Tire les Ficelles?,” PuceFebruary 25 2011 32.

69)

Mustapha Sehimi“Coup de Force Islamiste,” MarocHebdoMay 27 2011 22-27.

70)

Abdelhaq Balshakr“Hal thaabat harkat 20 Febriaar fi tanjarat ‘al’adl wa al-Ihsan?” Akhbaar al-yom488 July 5 2011 1.

71)

Mohammed Jaabouk“Le trouble jeu de Mohamed Fizazi,” Le SoirJuly 26 2011.

72)

Ismail Rouhi“al-adala wa al-tanmia biman’a shabibatihi min al-mushaarika fi masirat al-ahd,” as-Sabahissue 3377 February 20 2011 1.

73)

Reda Dalil“Benkirane l’omniprésent,” Le TempsMarch 12 2011 32.

76)

Ismail Rouhi Ibid. February 20 20111.

77)

Abdelhaq Balshakr“Jama’a al-Moatasim…min al-sijin ila al-qasar,” Akhbar al-yom372 February 19-20 2011 1.

81)

Aziz al-Hiwar“Raisouni yadou ila al-thoura wa al-kharouj ‘an al-hakim al-mustabideen,” al-MassaeNovember 16 2011 1. http://www.almassae.press.ma/print/34781

82)

Ahmed Raissouni“qadiyat al-sahra al-maghrabia wa al-wajib al-islamyi,” at-Tajdid2526 December 5 2011 7.

85)

Mohammed Bouharid“hal yamhou moatassim maqoula ‘al-ayaadi al-beida’ lilislamiyeen?,” jaridat al-oulaJanuary 23-28 2011 12-13

92)

Halima Abrook“Daoudi: itha faaza al-PAM fi al-intikhabaat al-muqbala kulunaa gadi nawaliuo harakat a’shreen febrier,” Akhbar al-yomissue 1432 July 13 2011 20.

94)

Younis Miskeen“Benkirane yuhadid biltasouit bi”la” ala al-dustour al-jadid,” Ahkbaar al-yomissue 464 June 7 2011: 2.

95)

Adaad Adil al-Karmousi“Mutalib al-Islamiyeen fi al-mayzaan,” Maghreb al-YomFebruary 18-24 2011 12-13.

99)

Rachid Baha“Ramid: itha lam natban al-malakia al-barlamaania sankoun khalf al-jamhouriyeen,” Sabahissue 3404 March 23 2011 1.

100)

Saadedine Othmani interview“Rahabnaa ‘aoudat al-shabaab ila al-ihtihaam bilshan al-’am,” al-mashadApril 1-7 2011 25.

102)

John WaterburyCommander of the Faithful: The Moroccan Political Elite (New York: Columbia University Press1970).

103)

Reda Dalil“Pourquoi a-t-il fallu qu’il parle?” Le TempsJuly 2 2011 29.

106)

Tniouni“Carnet,” TelQuelJune 18-24 2011 16.

108)

Younis Miskeen Ibid. 2011.

109)

Mohcine Lourhzal“2012: l’analyse de Lahcen Daoudi,” Le TempsJanuary 1 2011 32.

110)

Mohammed Nafaa“Interview: Lahcen Daoudi, président du groupe PJD à la Chambre des représentants,” Le ReporterOctober 6 2011 19.

111)

Mohammed Nafaa“Il ne Faut pas que les Escobar reviennent!” Le ReporterJuly 6 2011 12.

112)

Sadik Boukuzoual“Ramid: naqtarah ishraaf al-qadaa ‘ala al-intikhabaat,” Sabah March 31 2011 1.

114)

Sanae Taleb“98.7% de Oui,” PuceJuly 8-14 2011 30.

116)

Mohammed Nafaa“Je maintiens que je suis pessimiste!” Le ReporterOctober 6 2011 17.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 15 15 7
Full Text Views 5 5 5
PDF Downloads 2 2 2
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0