Mental Insanity in the Hippocratic Texts: A Pragmatic Perspective

in Mnemosyne
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

The terminology of insanity in the Hippocratic texts appears often confusing to the reader for its variety and ambiguity. Scholarship has dealt with this problematic group of words in different ways, attributing the phenomenon to accidents in the composition of early medical texts or their status as part of a developing technical language and fundamentally reducing them to synonymous. In this piece I propose to look at them not in a semantic perspective, but from the point of view of pragmatic linguistics. How does the grammar and position in which these words are used influence their effect within the individual narrative? How are nuances of emphasis and intensity expressed? How do aspects of subjectivity and chronology emerge through narrative strategies? Through a close reading of one illustrative passage from the patient cases of the Epidemics I attempt to extract further information about the use and meaning of early medical psychiatric vocabulary.

Mental Insanity in the Hippocratic Texts: A Pragmatic Perspective

in Mnemosyne

Sections

References

BakkerE.J. A Companion to the Ancient Greek Language 2010 Oxford

BakkerE.J. Pragmatics: Speech and Text 2010a 151 178 Bakker (ed.)

BattezzatoL. Linguistica e retorica della tragedia greca 2008 Roma

BenvenisteΕ. GiulianiM.V. La frase nominale Problemi di linguistica generale 2010 (1966) Milano 179 199 Problèmes de linguistique genérale

BerrettoniP. Il lessico tecnico del I e III libro delle Epidemie ippocratiche 1970 Annali della SNSP 39 27 106 217 311

BonannoM. L’allusione necessaria: ricerche intertestuali sulla poesia greca e latina 1990 Roma

CianiM. Psicosi e creatività nella scienza antica 1983 Venezia

ClarkeM. Bakker Semantics and Vocabulary 2010 160 182

ClassenJ. Beobachtungen über den homerischen Sprachgebrauch 1879 Frankfurt

CooperR. What is Wrong with the DSM? History of Psychiatry 2004 15 5 24

DeichgräberK. Die Epidemien und das Corpus Hippocraticum: Voruntersuchungen zu einer Geschichte der Koischen Ärzteschule 1933 Berlin

DeichgräberK. Die Patienten des Hippokrates: historisch-prosopographische Beiträge zu den Epidemien des Corpus Hippocraticum 1982 Mainz

Di BenedettoV. Il medico e la malattia 1986 Turin

van der EijkP. BakkerE.J. Towards a Rhetoric of Ancient Scientific Discourse. Some Formal Characteristics of Greek Medical and Philosophical Texts Grammar as Interpretation. Greek Literature in its Linguistic Contexts 1997 Leiden 77 129

van der EijkP. Diocles of Carystus 2000-2001 Leiden

van der EijkP. Medicine and Philosophy in Classical Antiquity 2005 Cambridge

EngeM. Psychische Erkrankungen bei Hippokrates Celsus und Aretaius 1991 Frankfurt

EntralgoP.L. The Therapy of the Word in Classical Antiquity 1970 New Haven

FögenT. Wissen Kommunikation und Selbstdarstellung. Zur Struktur und Charakteristik römischer Fachtexte der frühen Kaiserzeit 2009 München

FrancesA. A Warning Sign on the Road to DSM-V: Beware of its Unintended Consequence Psychiatric Times 2009 June 26

FrancesA. Good Grief The New York Times 2010 August 14

GraumannL.A. Die Krankengeschichten der Epidemienbücher des Corpus Hippocraticum 2000 Leipzig

HallidayM.A.K. WebsterJ. The Language of Science 2004 London

HarrisW.V. Mental Disorders in the Classical World 2013 Leiden

HellwegR. Stilistische Untersuchungen zu den Krankengeschichten der Epidemien Bücher I und III des Corpus Hippocraticum 1985 Bonn

HorstmanshoffM. The Ancient Physician: Craftsman or Scientist? Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences 1990 45 176 197

HorstmanshoffH.F.J.StolM.van TilburgC.R. Magic and Rationality in Ancient Eastern and Graeco-Roman Medicine 2004 Amsterdam

HughesJ.C. Harris If Only the Ancients Had Had DSM All Would Have Been Crystal Clear: Reflections on Diagnosis 2013 41 60

JonesW.H.S. Hippocrates 1923 Vol. I London

JouannaJ. Harris The Typology and Aetiology of Madness in Ancient Greek Medical and Philosophical Writing 2013 97 118

KutschenkoL.K. How to Make Sense of Broadly Applied Medical Classification Systems: Introducing Epistemic Hubs Hist. Phil. Life Sci. 2011a 33 583 602

KutschenkoL.K. In Quest of ‘Good’ Medical Classification Systems Medicine Studies 2011b 3 1 53 70 (2011)

LanataG. Linguaggio scientifico e linguaggio poetico. Note al lessico del De Morbo Sacro QUCC 1968 22 36

LangholfV. Horstmanshoff Structure and Genesis of Some Hippocratic Treatises 2004 219 275

LangslowD.R. Medical Latin in the Roman Empire 2000 Oxford

LanzaD. Lingua e discorso nell’Atene delle professioni 1968 Napoli

LeibbrandW.WettleyA. Der Wahnsinn. Geschichte der abendländischen Psychopathologie 1961 München

LevenK.H. Horstmanshoff At Times These Ancient Facts Seem to Lie before Me Like a Patient on a Hospital Bed - Retrospective Diagnosis and Ancient Medical History 2004 369 386

LichtenthaelerC. Neuer Kommentar zu den ersten zwölf Krankengeschichten im III Epidemienbuch 1994 Stuttgart

MartzavouP. ChaniotisA. Dream, Narrative, and the Construction of Hope in the ‘Healing Miracles’ of Epidauros Unveiling Emotions: Sources and Methods for the Study of Emotions in the Ancient Greek World 2012 Stuttgart 177 204

McDonaldG.C. Concepts and Treatments of Phrenitis in Ancient Medicine 2009 (PhD Thesis University of Newcastle)

MüriW. FlasharH. Melancholie und schwarze Galle Antike Medizin 1971 Darmstadt

PetridouG.ThumigerC. Approaches to the Patient in the Ancient World forthcoming 2015 Leiden

PigeaudJ. La follia nell’antichità Classica 1995 Bologna

PorterR. A Social History of Madness 1987 London

PorterR. Madness. A Brief History 2002 Oxford

SchironiF. Bakker Technical Languages: Science and Medicine 2010 338 354

SimonB. Harris Carving Nature at the Joints: the Dream of a Perfect Classification of Mental Illness 2013 27 40

SlingsS.R. Written and Spoken Language: an Exercise in the Pragmatics of the Greek Sentence CPh 1992 87 95 105

SlingsS.R. BakkerE.J. Figures of Speech and their Lookalikes. Two Further Exercises in the Pragmatics of the Greek Sentence Grammar as Interpretation 1997 Leiden 169 214

ThumigerC. Harris The Early Greek Medical Vocabulary of Insanity 2013 61 95

ThumigerC. PetridouThumiger Patient and Physician in the Epidemics Cases forthcoming 2015

JolyR.BylS. Hippocratis De Diaeta. CMG 2003 V 2 4 Berlin

KühleweinH. Epidemics III Hipp. Opera Omnia I Leipzig 1894 180 245

KühnK.G. Claudii Galeni Opera Omnia 1821-1833 Volume 7 Cambridge

LittréE. Œuvres completes d’Hippocrate 1839-1861 Paris

MewaldtJ. Galeni De Comate secundum Hippocratem. CMG 1915 V 9 2 Leipzig/Berlin

PolackH. Textkritische Untersuchungen zu der Hippokratischen Schrift Prorrhetikos I. 1976 Hamburg Diss. Hamburg 1954

WenkebachE. Galeni In Hippocratis Epidemiarum librum III commentaria III CMG 1936 V 10 1 2 Leipzig and Berlin

5

See Lanza 196894-96 and 117-118 Schironi 2008 340-341 on ‘families of words’ and their formation.

6

Bakker 2010a151. See also Slings 1992 95.

8

See Thumiger 201378-79 for data on the distribution of the occurrences of these terms.

9

Clarke 2010120.

11

See van der Eijk 2005124-125 for a survey.

13

See Lanza 196894-96 and 117-118 about the absence of these aspects in the Hippocratic language.

14

Schironi 2010338. See Lanza 1968 113-125; Berrettoni 1970 304-307 on the ‘intelligibility’ of the Hippocratic technical lexicon. See the introductory chapter in Langslow 2000 and Fögen 2009 9-25 for important remarks on the nature of ancient ‘technical’ literature and its language(s)—both focusing on Roman material but with methodological consideration reaching to include ancient technical texts more generally.

22

See Leven’s decisive criticism (2004).

27

Benveniste (2010) exposes the strangeness of a “verb of existing [which] of all verbs should have the privilege of being present in an enunciation in which it does not actually feature”. The verb ‘to be’ he adds later is “a verb like all the others” (188); we must “recover its full value and proper function in order to evaluate the distance between ‘nominal assertion’ and assertion which contains the verb ‘to be’” (189).

28

Benveniste 2010187 (here and below my translation).

29

Benveniste 2010192.

31

Cf. also Slings 199296-100; van der Eijk 1997 104 with n. 98 offering other possible explanations besides accidents of composition and transmission (although concentrating especially on ‘introductory’ nominatives of patients’ names at the beginning of a period). On the other hand Hellweg (1985 79) is characteristically impartial about “Nominal- und Verbalsätze”: no rationale behind the preference of one or the other can be detected in the texts in his view: “bei Untersuchung dieser Frage haben sich zwar keine starren Gesetzmäßigkeiten gefunden dennoch lassen diese Texte zuweilen eine gewisse Vorliebe für die eine oder andere Ausdrucksart erkennen”.

37

See Thumiger 201375.

40

Cf. Cooper 2004Frances 2009 and 2010 Simon 2013 and Hughes 2013 on taxonomic issues.

41

Cf. Porter 19878-38 for a strong argument in favour of the importance of narrative for the historian of ‘madness’; more generally ‘narrative-based medicine’ is gaining ground as a model of practice and inspiring a shift of perspectives also in the field of history of medicine (on these developments see Petridou and Thumiger (forthcoming) Introduction). For an example from a different but highly relevant context see Martzavou 2012 on the language and narrative of the emotions in the healing accounts of Epidauros.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 14 14 10
Full Text Views 26 26 25
PDF Downloads 6 6 6
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0