Deconstructing Praise

Zosimus’ Conception of the Emperor Theodosius’ ἀνδρεία

in Mnemosyne
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

The purpose of this paper is to analyze the ethical and moral portrait of the emperor Theodosius in Zosimus’ New History. It is my working hypothesis that the historian subverted the rhetorical topics usually deployed in the basilikòs lógos to accommodate the emperor’s ethical portrayal to his religious and historiographical programme. In order to do so, Zosimus emptied the concept of ἀνδρεία from its philosophical and moral connotations.

Deconstructing Praise

Zosimus’ Conception of the Emperor Theodosius’ ἀνδρεία

in Mnemosyne

Sections

References

Attyah FlowerM. Theopompus of Chios. History and Rhetoric in the Fourth Century bc 1994 Oxford

Baker-BrianN.TougherS. Emperor and Author. The Writings of Julian the Apostate 2012 Cardiff

BaldiniA. Ricerche sulla storia di Eunapio di Sardi. Problemi di storiografia tardopagana 1984 Bologna

BerardoL. Struttura, lacune e struttura delle lacune nell’Ἱστορία νέα di Zosimo Athenaeum 1976 54 472 481

BouffartigueJ. L’empereur Julien et la culture de son temps 1992 Paris

BuckD. Eunapius of Sardis and Theodosius the Great Byzantion 1988 58 36 53

CameronA. The Imperial Pontifex HSPh 2007 103 341 384

Candau MorónJ.M. La perspectiva histórica de Zósimo Erytheia 1992 13 17 28

Cracco RugginiL. Pubblicistica e storiografia bizantine di fronte alla crisi dell’Impero Romano Athenaeum 1973 51 146 183

Cracco RugginiL. Zosimo, ossia il rovesciamento delle “Storie Ecclesiastiche” Augustinianum 1976 16 23 36

Cracco RugginiL. The Ecclesiastical Histories and the Pagan Historiography: Providence and Miracles Athenaeum 1977 55 107 126

DuvalY.-M. L’éloge de Théodose dans la ‘Cité de Dieu’ (V, 26, 1) RecAug 1966 4 135 179

ElmS. Sons of Hellenism Fathers of the Church: Emperor Julian Gregory of Nazianzus and the Vision of Rome 2012 Berkeley

Escribano PañoM.V. Tryphé y cristianismo en Zósimo. La representación tiránica de Teodosio Athenaeum 1998 86 526 539

GoffartW. The First Historian of Rome’s Fall ahr 1971 76 412 441

GreenT.M. Zosimus Orosius and their Traditions: Comparative Studies in Pagan and Christian Historiography 1981 Ann Arbor

HobbsA.H. Plato and the Hero: Courage Manliness and the Impersonal Good 2000 Cambridge

HumphriesM. Baker-BrianTougher The Tyrant’s Mask? Images of Good and Bad Rule in Julian’s Letter to the Athenians 2012 75 90

JonesM. Playing the Man: Performing Masculinities in the Ancient Greek Novels 2012 Oxford

KaegiW.E. Byzantium and the Decline of Rome 1968 Princeton

KindtB.HaeperenF. van Thesaurus Zosimi. Historia Nova 2008 Turnhout

KosterS. Die Invektive in der griechischen und römischen Literatur 1980 Meisenheim am Glan

LambW.R.M. Laches Protagoras Meno Euthydemus 1967 London

LiebeschuetzJ.H.W.G.HillC. Ambrose of Milan. Political Letters and Speeches 2005 Liverpool

MaravalP. Théodose le Grand (379-385): le pouvoir et la foi 2009 Paris

MartinA.CanivetP.BouffartigueJ. Histoire Ecclésiastique. Livres iii-v 2009 Paris

MazzarinoS. La fine del mondo antico 1959 Milan

McDonnellM. RosenSluiter Roman Men and Greek Virtue 2003 235 261

MehlA. Roman Historiography: an Introduction to its Basic Aspects and Development 2011 Chichester

MendelssohnL. Zosimi comitis et exadvocati fisci Historia Nova 1887 Leipzig

PaschoudF. GabbaE. Influences et échos des conceptions historiographiques de Polybe dans l’antiquité tardive Polybe: 9 exposés suivis de discussions 1974 Vandœuvres-Genève 303 344

PaschoudF. Cinq études sur Zosime 1975 Paris

PaschoudF. ChrysosE.K.SchwarczA. Zosime, Eunape et Olympiodore témoins des invasions barbares Das Reich und die Barbaren 1989 Wien 181 201

PaschoudF. ReggiG. L’Impero Romano cristiano visto da un pagano. La Storia Nuova di Zosimo Storici latini e greci di età imperiale 1993 Milano 189 204

PaschoudF. TejaR.Pérez GonzálezC. La figure de Théodose chez les historiens païens La Hispania de Teodosio 1997 Segovia 193 200

PaschoudF. Zosimus. Histoire Nouvelle 2000-2003 Paris

PaschoudF. Eunape Olympiodore Zosime. Scripta Minora 2006 Bari

PédechP. Trois historiens méconnus. Théopompe Duris Phylarque 1989 Paris

PernotL. La rhétorique de l’éloge dans le monde gréco-romain 1993 Paris

PetreZ. La pensée historique de Zosime StudClas 1965 7 263 272

Quiroga PuertasA.J. Julian’s Misopogon and the Subversion of Rhetoric AntTard 2009 17 127 135

RidleyR.T. Eunapius and Zosimus Helikon 1969-1970 9-10 574 593

RidleyR.T. Zosimus the Historian ByzZ 1972 65 277 302

RidleyR.T. Zosimus. New History 1982 Canberra

RinkerC.W. The Art of Censure: Classical ‘psogos’ Rhetoric 1979 Oklahoma

Rosen R.M.SluiterI. Andreia: Studies in Manliness and Courage in Classical Antiquity 2003 Leiden

ScavoneD.C. Zosimus and his Historical Models grbs 1970 11 57 67

SchmidW.T. The Socratic Conception of Courage HPhQ 1985 2 113 129

SchmidW.T. On Manly Courage: a Study of Plato’s Laches 1992 Carbondale

SluiterI.RosenR.M. RosenSluiter General Introduction 2003 6 8

SmithA. Baker-BrianTougher Julian’s Hymn to King Helios: the Economical Use of Complex Neoplatonic Concepts 2012 229 238

SpeckP. Understanding Byzantium: Studies in Byzantine Historical Sources 2003 Aldershot

VehO. Neue Geschichte 1990 Stuttgart

VlastosG. The Unity of the Virtues in the Protagoras RMeta 1972 25 415 458

WrightW.C. The Works of Emperor Julian 1913 London

3

Mendelssohn 1887xlviii: “tempora miscet loca ignorat res non conexas nectit nexasque divellit fabulas miraculaque persequitur ipsa re quae agebatur aut omissa aut obiter memorata”; Paschoud 2000-2003 lxxvii; Ridley 1982 xi; Cameron 2007 341. See also Kaegi 1968 101.

4

Paschoud 1993. On Zosimus’ New History as an attempt to counter the influence of the Christian Ecclesiastical Histories see Candau Morón 1992; Escribano Paño 1998 526-530. Paschoud (1975 215) considers this attempt as “la seule partie originale de l’enterprise de Zosime.” Green 1981 132-264; Mazzarino 1959 67-69. On Zosimus’ errors and inaccurate information see Berardo 1976; Ridley 1972 290-292 296-302. A nuanced opinion in Kaegi 1968 132-133.

6

Speck 2003263-279especially 263. An early defense of Zosimus was written by Johannes Löwenklau in the xvith century.

7

Goffart 1971419. On Zosimus’ sources see Green 1981 133-135; Ridley 1972 280-283.

8

Kindt and Haeperen 2008viii-x. See Speck 2003 265-276 for a defense of Zosimus’ work on the grounds of a deficient transmission of the historian’s work.

10

Escribano Paño 19981-5; Paschoud 2000-2003 xxxiii-xxxiv. On the hotly debated issue of his historical influences Scavone 1970. For Zosimus’ use of classical historiography see also Green 1981 135-136.

14

Cracco Ruggini 1977119-121; Mehl 2011 206-207; Paschoud 1975 1-23; Petre 1965; Ridley 1972 282-283.

16

Jones 201293.

23

Paschoud 1997199. In similar terms Eun. Fr. 61.

24

Quiroga 2009; Scavone 197059n. 9.

25

Paschoud 1993.

29

Pernot 1993157-158165-173. For a similar example see Polybius’s confrontation with Theopompus of Chios on the ethical portrait of Philip of Macedonia. Vid. Plb. 8.9-11. See also Attyah 1994 98-115; Pédech 1989 73-146.

30

Hobbs 20008-1079-80 83-86 130-136.

32

Translation taken from Lamb 1967. The context of this first definition is surveyed by Schmid 1985 114-115; Schmid 1992 96-104.

39

Translations taken from Wright 1913.

44

Paschoud 1989. On this topic see Eun. Fr. 59.

47

Goffart 1971418-419. Vid. also Cracco Ruggini 1973 166-167: “Ma d’altra parte in Zosimo . . . le considerazioni di ordine politico strategico militare finanziario ed economico hanno quasi sempre la meglio sulla interpretazione meramente religiosa.”

48

Goffart 1971414-417.

51

Cracco Ruggini 1976.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 14 14 4
Full Text Views 19 19 19
PDF Downloads 4 4 4
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0