Gout, Beasts, and Other Metaphorical Punishments in ap 11.226-231

in Mnemosyne
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

The reference to retributive gout in 11.229 serves as a semiotic hinge between two sets of interdependent poems in what may be a coherent Ammianic sequence (ap 11.226-231). Ammianos’ approval of gout as a just punishment in 11.229 establishes themes of retribution and somatic torment that are elaborated in 11.230-231, riddling epigrams that express the hope that their target will endure repeated execution on the cross (11.230) and then in the arena (11.231). The torturous executions hoped for in 11.230-231 are further contextualized by analogous references to mythic and fabulistic punishments in an adjacent set of poems by the same author (11.226-228). When these epigrams are considered in light of the retributive nature and metaphorical implications of gout, their wit and substance can be better appreciated.

Mnemosyne

A Journal of Classical Studies

References

AubretonR. Anthologie Grecque 1968 Paris

BartonT. Power and Knowledge: Astrology, Physiognomics, and Medicine under the Roman Empire 1994 Ann Arbor

BowersockG.W. Greek Sophists in the Roman Empire 1969 Oxford

CameronA. The Greek Anthology from Meleager to Planudes 1993 Oxford

ColemanK.M. M. Valerii Martialis Liber Spectaculorum 2006 Oxford

ClaussJ.J. An Acrostic in Vergil (Eclogues 1.5-8): The Chance that Mimics Choice? Aevum Antiquum 1997 10 267 287

FreisenbruchA. MorelloR.MorrisonA.D. Back to Fronto: Doctor and Patient in his Correspondence with an Emperor Ancient Letters Classical and Late Antique Epistolography 2007 Oxford 235 256

GarnseyP. Social Status and Legal Privilege in the Roman Empire 1970 Oxford

GleasonM.W. Making Men: Sophists and Self-Presentation in Ancient Rome 1995 Princeton

GourevitchD. NuttonV. Une maladie paradigmatique, la goutte Le triangle hippocratique dans le monde gréco-romain; le malade, sa maladie et son médecin 1984 Rome 217 247

GrilliA. Ennius podager rfic 1978 106 34 38

HengelM. Crucifixion in the Ancient World and the Folly of the Message of the Cross 1977 Philadelphia

HoltP. SegalE. Crucially Funny, or Tranio on the Couch: the Servus Callidus and Jokes About Torture Oxford Readings in Menander, Plautus, and Terence 2001 Oxford 127 137

HutchinsonG.O. Talking Books: Readings in Hellenistic and Roman Books of Poetry 2008 Oxford

KirsteinR. HarderM.A.RegtuitR.F.WakkerG.C. Companion Pieces in the Hellenistic Epigram Hellenistic Epigrams 2002 Paris 113 135

KrevansN. BingP.B.SteffenJ. The Arrangement of Epigrams in Collections Brill’s Companion to Hellenistic Epigram: Down to Philip 2007 Boston 131 147

KutzkoD. Catullus 69 and 71: Goat, Gout, and Venereal Disease cw 2008 101 4 443 452

KyleD.G. Spectacles of Death in Ancient Rome 1998 New York

LuzC. KwapiszJ.PetrainD.SzymanskiM. What Has It Got in Its Pocketses? The Muse at Play: Riddles and Wordplay in Greek and Latin Poetry 2013 Boston 83 99

MostG.W. HexterR.SeldenD. Disiecti membra poetae: the Rhetoric of Dismemberment in Neronian Poetry Innovations of Antiquity 1992 New York 391 419

NisbetG. A Sickness of Discourse: the Vanishing Syndrome of Leptosune G&R 2003a 50 2 191 205

NisbetG. Greek Epigram in the Roman Empire: Martial’s Forgotten Rivals 2003b Oxford

PittoreM. L’ironia negli epigrammi dell’Anthologia palatina: tra manipolazione linguistica e allusività 2004 Allesandria

PorterR.RousseauG.S. Gout: the Patrician Malady 1998 New Haven

PucciP. The Tragic Pharmakos of the Oedipus Rex Helios 1990 17 1 41 49

PufeB. Medizingeschichtliche Elemente in Epigrammen der Anthologia Graeca 1978 Erlangen-Nürnberg

RimellV. Martial’s Rome: Empire and the Ideology of Epigram 2008 Cambridge

SchulteH. Die Epigramme des Ammianos 2004 Trier

SwainS. Seeing the Face, Seeing the Soul: Polemon’s Physiognomy from Classical Antiquity to Medieval Islam 2007 Oxford

WhitehorneJ.E.G. Was Marcus Aurelius a Hypochondriac? Latomus 1977 36 413 421

WilkinsonK.W. New Epigrams of Palladas: a Fragmentary Papyrus Codex (P.Ctybr Inv. 4000) 2012

WilliamsG.W. Change and Decline: Roman Literature in the Early Empire 1978 Berkeley

2

Nisbet 2003b, 160 and 212 (“a punning skoptic vendetta”); cf. Swain (2007, 161 and n. 146) who accused Nisbet of having “pursued more of a vendetta against Polemon than Ammianus.” Philostratos includes several lurid anecdotes about Polemon’s gout (vs §532-533, 537, 543; with Gleason 1995, 21-54).

3

Gourevitch 1984, 236-241, 245-247; Porter and Rousseau 1998, 13-21; cf. Pseudo-Hedylus’ quip in 11.414 that ‘the daughter of limb-relaxing Bacchus and limb-relaxing Aphrodite is limb-‘relaxing’ Gout (ποδάγρα).’ Although ‘gout’ was a capacious category in antiquity, one whose core identification with atraumatic arthritic pain would encompass many discrete conditions in modern medical diagnostics, its literary depiction and its metaphorical implications were remarkably persistent and stable across time, space, genre, and language.

4

Williams 1978, 254-261. As Most (1992, 409-410) reminds us in his seminal discussion of dismemberment in Neronian and Flavian literature, “every represented torment of the human body implies a reflection on what it means to be a human being: and the more radical the former, the more urgent the latter.” On somatic obsessions during the Second Sophistic, see Bowersock 1969, 69-73; Whitehorne 1977 and esp. Freisenbruch 2007, who surveys the trivialized rhetoric of somatic anxiety in the correspondences of Fronto, Marcus Aurelius, and Aelius Aristides.

9

Porter and Rousseau 1998, 211-247.

15

Hengel 1977, 46-63 and 77-83. On crucifixion as a debasing punishment reserved for slaves, aliens, and other marginalized groups, see Cic. Verr. 2.5.14 and 162, Clu. 187; Val. Max. 8.4.2; and Suet. Dom. 10 (with Garnsey 1970, 124-127).

17

Holt 2001, 130-131; Coleman 2006, 91-92. Once reserved for non-citizens, crucifixion and other summa supplicia were inflicted on non-elite citizens beginning in the late second century ce (Garnsey 1970, 126-127).

23

Garnsey 1970, 124-126; see also Suet. Div. Cl. 14 and Ulpian Dig. 48.13.7.

27

Rimell 2009, 40.

28

Nisbet 2003b, 136; also mentioned as possibility by Kirstein 2002, 130. In extraordinary cases, those condemned ad bestias were subjected to forcible (and fatal) sexual assault by an animal (Coleman 2006, 62-65; e.g. Mart. Spect. 6 and Apul. Met. 10.34.3).

29

Hangel 1977, 31. Ammianos elsewhere displays an awareness of Roman discourse on contemporary themes: e.g. 11.97-98 which alludes to Nero’s Domus Aurea consuming all of Rome; cf. Mart. Spect 2, although the figure is so widespread that we need not assume a specific reference.

30

Coleman 2006, 92; e.g. in Martial Spect. 9, a Caledonian bear dispatches the criminal who plays the role of crucified Laureolus: nuda Caledonio sic uiscera praebuit urso / non falsa pendens in cruce Laureolus (3-4); cf. ciliv 9983a.

32

Krevans 2007, 135-136; poetic libri were often segmented by only a subtle paragraphos mark tucked unobtrusively beneath the first letters of each new poem—and this was often only added by a subsequent hand (Hutchinson 2008, 15–17). Latin libri tended to be substantially more distributed and “marked up” than their Greek counterparts (Hutchinson 2008, 22–23); cf. Martial’s purposeful segmentation of his Xenia and Apophoreta by tituli, which he claims will grant his wearied readers the editorial license to select individual poems while skipping others (13.8; 14.373-378).

33

Rimell 2009, 25.

35

Kyle 1998, 168.

41

Cameron 1993, 19-22 and 85.

42

Clauss (1997) appropriated Nabokov’s memorable description of aleatoric wordplay in “The Vane Sisters” for the title of his article on a Vergilian acrostic.

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 8 8 2
Full Text Views 6 6 6
PDF Downloads 0 0 0
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0